Via: community • 10 years ago • 4 comments
Their fundamental difference boils down to this: Sanders thinks a tax hike is necessary to fund a government-run Medicare-for-all program that would be cheaper than what Americans currently spend on insurance premiums. Clinton thinks those taxes would be more expensive.
It's a bizarre line of attack from Clinton that reeks of desperation. She needs to scare democratic voters and claiming Sanders' will take away Democrat's health care might work with low information democratic voters. But. she is badly distorting Sanders' proposal. She's insinuating that Sander's plan would take away healthcare from people, which is simply false.
On the other hand, her argument that Sander's plan will cost vast amounts of money is completely accurate, although reality doesn't play well in the Democratic primary. There's a reason Sanders won't discuss how much his plan would cost or how he would pay for it.
Clinton has reasons to be worried, perhaps even desperate. She has the emailgate thingy (whether there's anything to it or not is irrelevant, it has become an issue her campaign must deal with), an uptick in Sanders financial support as well as closing in on her poll numbers, and Hillary attempting to shake her well deserved image as an establishment candidate. She has to do something, and scaring folks is relatively easy.
As far as reality in planning for health care, I myself am unsure just how this would play out best. I mean the differences in premiums since the ACA became law, and the outlay by employers is steep. We are just starting to see the effects in both financial cost, as well as improved health care.
I found it hilarious that Clinton brought this point up...
"There is no way that can be paid for without raising taxes on the middle class. The arithmetic just doesn't add up," Clinton said Tuesday in Iowa. "I don't think that is the right way to go."
...because it is the American Middle Class that is funding the majority of the ACA now as is. She is hurting herself by bringing up the cost of healthcare to the Middle Class. Through taxes that go towards health care, and increasingly extravagant premiums, the Middle Class is funding America's new health care law. How much would it actually cost to have a single payer system? I dunno.
Single payer died in Vermont because it was found to be too expensive. It's a good thing that they recognized it and admitted it rather than force it on the taxpayers.
Unlike Sanders, Clinton would keep Obamacare, but would introduce new measures to lower Americans' health care costs .
It's a bizarre line of attack from Clinton that reeks of desperation. She needs to scare democratic voters and claiming Sanders' will take away Democrat's health care might work with low information democratic voters. But. she is badly distorting Sanders' proposal. She's insinuating that Sander's plan would take away healthcare from people, which is simply false.
On the other hand, her argument that Sander's plan will cost vast amounts of money is completely accurate, although reality doesn't play well in the Democratic primary. There's a reason Sanders won't discuss how much his plan would cost or how he would pay for it.
Clinton has reasons to be worried, perhaps even desperate. She has the emailgate thingy (whether there's anything to it or not is irrelevant, it has become an issue her campaign must deal with), an uptick in Sanders financial support as well as closing in on her poll numbers, and Hillary attempting to shake her well deserved image as an establishment candidate. She has to do something, and scaring folks is relatively easy.
As far as reality in planning for health care, I myself am unsure just how this would play out best. I mean the differences in premiums since the ACA became law, and the outlay by employers is steep. We are just starting to see the effects in both financial cost, as well as improved health care.
I found it hilarious that Clinton brought this point up...
"There is no way that can be paid for without raising taxes on the middle class. The arithmetic just doesn't add up," Clinton said Tuesday in Iowa. "I don't think that is the right way to go."
...because it is the American Middle Class that is funding the majority of the ACA now as is. She is hurting herself by bringing up the cost of healthcare to the Middle Class. Through taxes that go towards health care, and increasingly extravagant premiums, the Middle Class is funding America's new health care law. How much would it actually cost to have a single payer system? I dunno.
Single payer died in Vermont because it was found to be too expensive. It's a good thing that they recognized it and admitted it rather than force it on the taxpayers.