American Exceptionalism — How's It Fared In Obama Years?
American Exceptionalism — How's It Fared In Obama Years?
BY MICHAEL BARONE
President Barack Obama extols his record at his final State of the Union address to Congress in Washington last Tuesday, Jan. 12, 2016. (AP... View Enlarged Image
In his final State of the Union speech, Barack Obama made at least a few bows toward the idea that America is an exceptional nation, an idea he once derided by saying, "I believe in American exceptionalism, just as I suspect that the Brits believe in British exceptionalism and the Greeks believe in Greek exceptionalism." We remain exceptional, he said Tuesday, as the strongest nation militarily and because we're doing better economically than most others.
But overall, has America become less exceptional in Obama's seven years? Yale law professor Peter Schuck addresses that question in National Affairs, using as a benchmark "Understanding America," a 2008 book he co-edited with the late political scientist James Q. Wilson.
America, Schuck summarized, is "unique on a whole host of fronts" because it's "decentralized, diverse, competitive, contentious." These factors have contributed to the astonishing success of a republic that started off with 3.9 million people in 1789 and has 321 million today.
One way we are exceptional is that we have a Constitution that divides power among three branches. Obama has gathered more power in the executive: passing ObamaCare by legislative legerdemain, shutting down the coal industry by dubious regulations, attempting to legalize illegal immigrants by executive order, though the most recent attempt was ruled illegal by federal courts. This trend toward prime ministerial government didn't start in 2009. But Obama has extended it further than ever.
In other ways, Obama has not changed what is unfortunate about American politics. We tend to have relatively low voter turnout, and it's declined during his years. And U.S. politics and government remain relatively decentralized, with different states going their own ways.
Although Obama was re-elected with 51% of the vote, most Americans have Republican governors and state legislatures. Most rejected what parts of ObamaCare they could and, even as Obama touts gun control, every state now allows law-abiding citizens permits to carry concealed weapons.
On education, America has become less centralized, sloughing off George W. Bush's bipartisan education accountability law and increasingly rejecting Obama-supported Common Core.
Harvard economist Benjamin Friedman ascribes America's exceptional economic success to its businesses' flexibility and competitiveness, its largely unregulated and flexible labor markets and its soundly regulated financial institutions. On this score, critics have grounds for saying Obama policies have made the nation less exceptional — and less productive. Certainly financial regulation proved less sound than thought shortly after Friedman wrote, but it's not clear Obama's Dodd-Frank Act improved it.
Michael Barone
Michael Barone
Big banks' market share has increased; bank loaning has not entirely rebounded.
Entrepreneurship and new business formation this century has been lagging previous levels, an acceleration of a pre-Obama trend.
Friedman noted also that Americans tend to work more than people in other advanced countries. But our distinctiveness there has declined since 2009. American workforce participation remains at the lowest levels since the 1970s, even after several years of 2% economic growth. Disability rolls have skyrocketed, and young people have gotten a slower start on their working lives than in past generations.
Schuck notes, accurately, that American social mobility has for many years not been exceptionally high, as many have assumed. But many Americans think it's declining. Overall, the case for the exceptionalism of our economy seems increasingly to be based more on other nations' weak economies than on the strength of our own.
What about diversity? Immigration continues, though at lower levels compared with the 1982-2007 period, and immigration from Mexico, our largest source of immigrants then, has tailed off to zero since the 2008 financial crisis.
Despite Islamist terrorist attacks and despite Obama's warnings against anti-Muslim prejudice, there's little sign of anti-immigrant violence. What's changed is public acquiescence in legalizing illegal immigrants — perhaps a response to Obama's arguably illegal attempts to do so.
Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-viewpoint/011516-790201-michael-barone-how-has-american-exceptionalism-fared-under-obama.htm#ixzz3xMmtA5WW
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
BY MICHAEL BARONE
President Barack Obama extols his record at his final State of the Union address to Congress in Washington last Tuesday, Jan. 12, 2016. (AP... View Enlarged Image
In his final State of the Union speech, Barack Obama made at least a few bows toward the idea that America is an exceptional nation, an idea he once derided by saying, "I believe in American exceptionalism, just as I suspect that the Brits believe in British exceptionalism and the Greeks believe in Greek exceptionalism." We remain exceptional, he said Tuesday, as the strongest nation militarily and because we're doing better economically than most others.
But overall, has America become less exceptional in Obama's seven years? Yale law professor Peter Schuck addresses that question in National Affairs, using as a benchmark "Understanding America," a 2008 book he co-edited with the late political scientist James Q. Wilson.
America, Schuck summarized, is "unique on a whole host of fronts" because it's "decentralized, diverse, competitive, contentious." These factors have contributed to the astonishing success of a republic that started off with 3.9 million people in 1789 and has 321 million today.
One way we are exceptional is that we have a Constitution that divides power among three branches. Obama has gathered more power in the executive: passing ObamaCare by legislative legerdemain, shutting down the coal industry by dubious regulations, attempting to legalize illegal immigrants by executive order, though the most recent attempt was ruled illegal by federal courts. This trend toward prime ministerial government didn't start in 2009. But Obama has extended it further than ever.
In other ways, Obama has not changed what is unfortunate about American politics. We tend to have relatively low voter turnout, and it's declined during his years. And U.S. politics and government remain relatively decentralized, with different states going their own ways.
Although Obama was re-elected with 51% of the vote, most Americans have Republican governors and state legislatures. Most rejected what parts of ObamaCare they could and, even as Obama touts gun control, every state now allows law-abiding citizens permits to carry concealed weapons.
On education, America has become less centralized, sloughing off George W. Bush's bipartisan education accountability law and increasingly rejecting Obama-supported Common Core.
Harvard economist Benjamin Friedman ascribes America's exceptional economic success to its businesses' flexibility and competitiveness, its largely unregulated and flexible labor markets and its soundly regulated financial institutions. On this score, critics have grounds for saying Obama policies have made the nation less exceptional — and less productive. Certainly financial regulation proved less sound than thought shortly after Friedman wrote, but it's not clear Obama's Dodd-Frank Act improved it.
Michael Barone
Michael Barone
Big banks' market share has increased; bank loaning has not entirely rebounded.
Entrepreneurship and new business formation this century has been lagging previous levels, an acceleration of a pre-Obama trend.
Friedman noted also that Americans tend to work more than people in other advanced countries. But our distinctiveness there has declined since 2009. American workforce participation remains at the lowest levels since the 1970s, even after several years of 2% economic growth. Disability rolls have skyrocketed, and young people have gotten a slower start on their working lives than in past generations.
Schuck notes, accurately, that American social mobility has for many years not been exceptionally high, as many have assumed. But many Americans think it's declining. Overall, the case for the exceptionalism of our economy seems increasingly to be based more on other nations' weak economies than on the strength of our own.
What about diversity? Immigration continues, though at lower levels compared with the 1982-2007 period, and immigration from Mexico, our largest source of immigrants then, has tailed off to zero since the 2008 financial crisis.
Despite Islamist terrorist attacks and despite Obama's warnings against anti-Muslim prejudice, there's little sign of anti-immigrant violence. What's changed is public acquiescence in legalizing illegal immigrants — perhaps a response to Obama's arguably illegal attempts to do so.
Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials-viewpoint/011516-790201-michael-barone-how-has-american-exceptionalism-fared-under-obama.htm#ixzz3xMmtA5WW
Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
