╌>

Save Us from the Tyranny of 'Settled' Science

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  10 years ago  •  28 comments

Save Us from the Tyranny of 'Settled' Science
In classrooms across the country, high school students are taught the scientific method. It consists of constructing a doubtful hypothesis and designing a series of experiments to test the hypothesis with the observable facts. After a number of tests prove positive. The student can then take the facts and reach a conclusion. When a conclusion is constantly verified, it is enshrined in what might be called “established” science.

There is a second kind of science that uses methods very different from those of “established” science. In fact, this science, if indeed it might be called such, uses the exact opposite method. It consists of constructing a conclusion and then testing that conclusion with a hypothesis that is repeated over and over again using doubtful data to back it up.



The “logic” of this particular scientific method is that the truth of the conclusion is determined by the number of times the hypothesis is affirmed. With enough repetition, even the data starts to take on the appearance of the truth. The secret is to get as many people and media as possible to parrot the great discovery. At a certain point, the conclusion can be enshrined in a special pantheon that might be called “settled” science, and woe betide any “denier” who dare question it.

Like its cousin “settled” law, “settled” science can be useful even outside its field. It can be employed to silence opposition, impose laws and promote political agendas. It respects no rank or positions. August researchers and famous professors can be toppled from their positions if they express the slightest doubts about a “settled” position. Even the strongest evidence is ignored with disdain and disbelief. Meanwhile the hypothesis mantra is just repeated over and over again.

“Settled” science cases abound in today’s politically-correct times. The most obvious one is the dogma of “global warming.” Many old-school scientists have suffered persecution for calling into question the faulty computer models and fudged data associated with this doctrine. They have even shown that the globe is not warming. Flexible “settled” scientists immediately tweaked the hypothesis to speak of “climate change,” and thus cover both sides.

But facts have never been an obstacle to “settled science” promoters who simply dismiss facts and those who bring them up. Climate Statistics Prof. Caleb Rossiter, for example, found his fellowship 'terminated' after his Wall Street Journal op-ed declaring “the left wants to stop industrialization -- even if the hypothesis of catastrophic, man-made global warming is false.” In another case, a well-loved and respected doctor who specializes in studies about sexual-risk behaviors has just been expelled from an important medical center in Massachusetts after he raised legitimate evidence-based concerns over the center’s decision to endorse the homosexual lifestyle.

A highly qualified scientist in California found scientific evidence that questioned a dogma of evolutionary thought and was fired after publishing his finding in a peer-reviewed journal. These and so many other cases fill the news and intimidate those who seek the truth.

However, there are those rare times when “settled” science runs into trouble and it becomes too obvious that the conclusions are wrong and indefensible. That is the beauty of “settled” science; it can be easily reversed by merely ceasing to repeat the hypothesis. The loud choruses that yesterday blasted forth the “settled” message, today become eerily silent. It is as if the embarrassing conclusion never existed.

An example of this is the “settled” science of peak oil. For decades, “settled” scientists have repeated the hypothesis that oil production will soon reach its peak and humanity will sink into the darkness of an age without fossil fuels.

The only problem is no one told the oil industry. Over the last decade, oil producers have found so much oil that most people agree there are supplies for decades and decades. The evidence can be seen at every gas pump: there is too much oil around, not too little. And so not much is heard from the peak oilers these days. But that is another beauty of “settled” science; the mantra chanters of one conclusion can easily transition to another mantra without any loss of reputation.

The phenomenon of “settled” science is a sad reflection of the frenetic intemperance of these times. The desire to be free from any moral restraint has reached such a point that even the most exacting and absolute sciences must be sacrificed to the tyranny of human passions. Even reality itself must be altered to conform to the agendas of the liberal establishment.



Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2016/01/save_us_from_the_tyranny_of_settled_science.html#ixzz3xRyEwoFC
Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

There is no "settled science". Newton's laws had to be revised once relativistic effects were understood.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    10 years ago

Anyone can dispute "settled science" if he's willing to pay the public price for such heresy ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

The “logic” of this particular scientific method is that the truth of the conclusion is determined by the number of times the hypothesis is affirmed. With enough repetition, even the data starts to take on the appearance of the truth. 

And that statement shows a fundamental misunderstanding of "science."

Science proceeds in an environment of objectivity which, in one way is manifested by its willingness and protocol of re-examining its own conclusions and laws.

This unlike the dogmas of religionists who claim to "take on faith" that which they fail to understand and fail to openly acknowledge that which they fail to understand!

Unlike religion (and politics), science doesn't go to war … I mean actual combative, violent war … nor does it coerce or guilt trip or propagandize … it tests and re-tests and re-THINKS its conclusions.

The science-deniers and faux-"experts" will piss on every postulate, theory or scientific law that does not fit their ideology or politics … frequently cutting off their proverbial noses in a rush to deny an individual or entity its due … for no other reason than to spite and manifest their mean-spirits.

The zeal-without-knowledge folk are among the most dangerous in that they are easily aroused, easily accusative, easily led and misled by those who pander to their needed delusions.

 NOTE: DEGREE IN BIOLOGY SPECIALIZING IN LIMNOLOGY, FRESH-WATER ICHTHYOLOGY and related fields. 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

NOTE: DEGREE IN BIOLOGY

Does not make you a scientist nor to think like one .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

NOTE: DEGREE IN BIOLOGY

Does not make you a scientist nor to think like one .

The usual from Petey; contributing nothing but a critique of someone who does.

WTF degrees have you earned? 

What in your vast store of knowledge and expertise "makes a scientist" and/or an individual who thinks like one?

Ever do a population study of brook and brown trout in a high energy stream … age to weight/length ratios, male to female ratio, insect population assessment … larval, nymphs, emerging adults … stomach syphoning of brook and brown trout to determine presence of invertebrates in the ecosystem …

But I'll defer to your ever-predictable talk-downs and await your explanation as to what makes a scientist and how to think like one.

I posted my resume so as to separate myself from the bullshit artists with ideological agendas … 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I'll defer to your ever-predictable talk-downs and await your explanation as to what makes a scientist and how to think like one.

That is an huge topic . We haven't the space or the communication skills to deal with it adequately . However , I suggest you go to my home page and look at several of the pieces I've presented . Several are topics of a scientific nature . But you seem to avoid what I do like the plague . Considering that you discuss like you're innumerate I guess that's not surprising . Would you like an example of some of your comments that led me to that impression ?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

But you seem to avoid what I do like the plague . Considering that you discuss like you're innumerate I guess that's not surprising . Would you like an example of some of your comments that led me to that impression ?

Your favorite new word manages to slide in when you have nothing of substance to contribute.

I posted a specific response to rather naive commentary on the scientific method … and you chose to comment on the note I left at the bottom of that response, a note stating the background that qualified offer a reasonable rebuttal.

You didn't address the content … and did your usual, namely, leaving a snarky, somewhat insulting personal smack down.

Damned right I avoid your discussions; that would be going out of my way to invite more smack downs.

If/when you stop the kind of non-rebuttal-attack-the-messenger-but-avoid-addressing-the-message comments, I'll be happy to go to all of your articles, agree or disagree in SPECIFIC REGARD TO YOUR CONTENT.

You're likely a bright, well-educated guy … but are quick to accuse or imply that all who take positions you don't like … are underlings.

Show civility and specificity and we likely will have some interesting conversations.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

but are quick to accuse or imply that all who take positions you don't like … are underlings.

I find that someone whose recent experience is that of a union rep should consider that the kind of obfuscation that job entails will suffer an effect on his abilities to think logically and scientifically . Some of your phrasing makes me doubt you have any use for logic at all ...

From your previous comment :

This unlike the dogmas of religionists who claim to "take on faith" that which they fail to understand and fail to openly acknowledge that which they fail to understand!

This includes those whose ideological bias is so strong they avoid being objective inevitably . One doesn't have to be a "religionists" to end up in that hole .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

I find that someone whose recent experience is that of a union rep should consider that the kind of obfuscation that job entails will suffer an effect on his abilities to think logically and scientifically . Some of your phrasing makes me doubt you have any use for logic at all ...

Another load … you don't know shit about what my job entailed … all you appear to know is how to fake your way to, but not ever making it all the way to … viability.

Your the "man behind the curtain" who demands the "witches broom" as pre-payment for an implied reward … but who, when he gets it, changes the deal because he can't deliver the goods.

I earned 6 figures annually (not bad for an enumerate, huh) to write, negotiate and enforce contracts and represent working people many of whom, from time-to-time, would otherwise have been fucked (literally on occasions, and figuratively with frequency) by management … with no recourse.

Still, that's none of your f'n business and the quote of yours (in blue) is the crap you throw when you can't join the conversation with substantive content.

Other than that …

I'm just proud to be a part of this all (that's sarcasm BTW) … the intellectual challenges being presented by those with nothing to say and who say it nevertheless, the cerebral giants who pull their thumbs out of their butts long enough to turn them downward … it gives new meaning to the term re-BUTT-al.

And still, while a few of you must think I hate you … I don't … I feel badly for those who have reached adulthood but who can't usually seem to put a complicated thought into more than adolescent terms … or gestures.

Too bad … your loss … and mine. Once past the bullshit character flaws, I really would be interested to have a conversation or two.

Good night.

 

 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I earned 6 figures annually

That goes a long way toward making MY point . It shows a level of involvement in your job that had NOTHING to do with science . And maybe little to do with logic either . Spin doctors make lots of moolah but they are not about being logical ... often the exact opposite . Obfuscation is something you excel at . I have seen that from your commentary on NT . But your claim about being scientific in your thinking does not appear borne out by your commentary ...

the cerebral giants who pull their thumbs out of their butts long enough to turn them downward

Just  to "rebut" that point , you are the one who is afraid to show up on my threads . I don't think you are capable of proving anything about what I've done ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

the cerebral giants who pull their thumbs out of their butts long enough to turn them downward

Just  to "rebut" that point , you are the one who is afraid to show up on my threads . I don't think you are capable of proving anything about what I've done 

One more time, Petey,

Damned right I avoid your threads; that would be going out of my way to invite more smack downs.

If/when you stop the kind of non-rebuttal-attack-the-messenger-but-avoid-addressing-the-message comments, I'll be happy to go to all of your articles, agree or disagree in SPECIFIC REGARD TO YOUR CONTENT.

You're likely a bright, well-educated guy … but are quick to accuse or imply that all who take positions you don't like … are underlings.

Show civility and specificity and we likely will have some interesting conversations.

I earned 6 figures annually

That goes a long way toward making MY point . It shows a level of involvement in your job that had NOTHING to do with science .

It's simply fascinating how everything that everybody writes "goes a long way toward making YOUR point." We just all fall into your side of the argument no matter what.

I had a number of jobs, Petey … employee contracts, newspaper editor-in-chief, published author, BIOLOGIST, professional photographer, digital artist, advance degree in Fine Art, educator, technology consultant … so forgive me for the diversity … but to make it easier for you, if/when a thread deals with science, think of me as the guy doing vertebrate and invertebrate population studies on high energy streams (oh shit! that entails statistical compilations … and here I am a friggin' enumerate!). 

Just address content and not what you may or may not know about my qualifications, abilities or lack thereof … let's discuss the particulars of the subject before the forum.

If you assure me that you can proceed in that manner, I'll be happy to read what you've done, praise it, disagree with it or claim "neutrality".

If you can't promise that, it would be masochistic to go to one of your threads knowing that you'll do what you're wont to do when you cannot rebut content-with-content … talk down, smack down and be the "Man Behind the Curtain."

That's my last, best negotiated offer.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I suggest we talk about something other than science . Or at least talk in general about what features make for good science . That would be my offer .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

I suggest we talk about something other than science . Or at least talk in general about what features make for good science . That would be my offer .

I will talk about anything you like, Petey and as long as we can be mutually respectful, where we agree I will acknowledge that and where we disagree, I will do so specifically and respectfully.

Does that work?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I find talking about heated topics with you just adds more heat . That's why I would like to discuss the issue of what characteristics make for good science in general . Once some agreement is reached about that [if any] only then should specific science topics be introduced .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

I find talking about heated topics with you just adds more heat . That's why I would like to discuss the issue of what characteristics make for good science in general . Once some agreement is reached about that [if any] only then should specific science topics be introduced .

We can agree to avoid commenting directly to one another in threads that are "heated". I don't enjoy having acrimonious words with you. 

If you want to discuss any topic … your choice … post an article and I'll join it. If it's out-of-my-league and I don't feel qualified to discuss it, I'll either bypass it and/or, indicate by way of a comment, that it's over my head.

What's most important to me is that we can agree, or, when we disagree, we do so respectfully.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

It may take a while before I can assemble an article about what makes for a properly done study . But if you are the only one interested , it hardly seems worth the effort ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

It may take a while before I can assemble an article about what makes for a properly done study . But if you are the only one interested , it hardly seems worth the effort ...

Well then let's just agree to be mutually respectful of one another and let the discussions come as they will.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

So what exactly makes one a scientist? Yes, yes, I know, many former (and present) scientists had no degree. But please elucidate your position.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Steve Ott   10 years ago

So what exactly makes one a scientist? Yes, yes, I know, many former (and present) scientists had no degree. But please elucidate your position.

Steve,

Who are you asking? If it's me, I will give you a thoughtful answer some time tomorrow.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I was asking Petey. Apparently he believes a degree does not make one a scientist. 

My best guess would be that you and I have fairly close ideas as to what makes a scientist.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Steve Ott   10 years ago

Steve ,

IDK how to answer that exact question . I was merely referring to the process of doing science rather than the characteristics of those doing the work . However , with the lack of attention to the details of the process these days  perhaps that is the better question to ask . It seems there is too much politicking going on in the science community and too little data analyzing ...

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

I often got into trouble in high school and college by questioning my professors. At least in the area of teaching, it was dangerous to be presumptive and question what was taught. It only made me think that perhaps they didn't actually "study" their chosen field. 

It seems, unfortunately, the the "zeal without knowledge" folk are now within in the ranks of scientists. I find it all very dis-heartening.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Steve Ott   10 years ago

I think the issue is more about politics than zeal . Science takes a lot of funding . The process involved with funding is a tortuous path even at best ...

 
 

Who is online



Tacos!


111 visitors