Homeowner Who Fatally Shot Robbery Suspect Could Face Charges
LINK to video :
http://news.yahoo.com/video/homeowner-fatally-shot-robbery-suspect-194025284.html
The victim of an armed robbery in his home could face criminal charges. The homeowner shot and killed a man Sunday morning who came into his home. The Jefferson County Sheriff`s Office and the Jefferson County District Attorney`s Office are weighing the evidence in deciding whether charges are appropriate

First comment :
This is a controversial case with a tricky decision by the prosecutors : Do they prosecute the robbery victim who suffered a home invasion and armed robbery because he killed the man who was now stealing his car ? What do you think ?
I didn't watch the video but I found a different article. I see no need to charge the homeowner. He was defending his home from career criminals.
As I understand the prosecutors decision he is saying that the danger was passed because the robbers has already left his premises . He untied himself and found them escaping by stealing his car . BTW , feel free to post a link to the written article ...
Thanks for the link ...
I just don't like watching videos on my phone.
I understand the argument but I don't support it.
There is one less criminal out there and I consider that a good thing. In my opinion, the homeowner should definitely not be charged. Unfortunately, the law is written a specific way to ensure that no one can "claim" self defense and use it as a cover up for murder. If the homeowner must be charged according to the law then I think the courts should use it's discretion to drop all charges based on the evidence. I've heard there have been several situations where people are being robbed related to Craig's list advertisements. There seems to be a trend starting here.
This is going to be a tricky decision either way . Fortunately there were no blacks involved [to my knowledge ] . At least we won't be hearing from "black lives matter" ...
The police and the courts will need to evaluate the evidence and determine if charges are warranted. It is hard for us to learn of all the details in matters like these when we decide to determine guilt or innocence in the court of public opinion.
That being said..... given what is known now, I see no reason to bring charges against the homeowner.
I am pretty much in agreement with what you said . Thanks for stating your case .
I agree and common sense dictates he shouldn't be charged but the criminal defense attorney consulted for the story explained that based on where the shooting occurred it wouldn’t fall under the definition of self-defense. It will be interesting to see how the courts react.
The consensus seems to be everyone supporting the victim except for one person supporting the home invaders.
hahahahaha - You're terrible. I almost spit my coffee out laughing and I'm sure you didn't mean it to be funny.
I'm pretty sure Blue isn't against the homeowner but taking a position of what the law allows. I was also conflicted because I don't want others to think they can arbitrarily shoot and claim self defense. It seems unreasonable that the homeowner would be charged in this situation but it is the law. I'm hoping the courts do the right thing and dismiss any charges.
Here is an update to this incident . The homeowner who shot the robber/kidnapper was exonerated .
Anthony Mott Not Charged for Killing Robber Who Responded to Craigslist Ad
The thief got what he deserved. No charges.