WHY HIGH TAXES DON’T CURE POVERTY
The rising popularity of Bernie Sanders shows, among other things, that a significant number of Americans believe his claim that higher taxes would benefit all Americans, and the poorest especially.
But Sanders is peddling a dangerous delusion. Reality does not bear out his economic theory. To find out why, we need only look at the impact of high-tax liberalism on global poverty. Take Europe. According to the CIA’s Factbook (globally recognized as a reliable analytical tool), the poverty rate is around 15 percent in the United States, Britain and Germany. However, the comparative tax rates in Britain and Germany far exceed those of the United States. More relevant, taxes on higher incomes are considerably higher across Europe. This raises a difficult question for European socialists: why, after years of expansive government, have they failed to confront poverty?
The reason, in part, is punitive tax rates only push wealth to alternate lower-tax locations (thus denying investment in communities that need it most). In this sense, the liberal obsession with higher taxation is an intellectual stick-man against poverty. It offers an emotional veil for a serious problem. Those who have experienced liberal orthodoxy know this truth all too well.
Look at the Vietnamese people today. Although the Communist regime remains strikingly authoritarian, the Vietnamese are now the most fervent supporters of their nation’s emerging capitalism. They know that broadening opportunity and economic growth empower all of a society’s citizens: rich, middle-income, and poor alike.
This raises a difficult question for European socialists: why, after years of expansive government, have they failed to confront poverty?
But another reason why high taxes don’t cure poverty is in their transfer of power from individuals to government. This poses three distinct problems. First, government is decidedly inefficient and ineffective in its allocation of resources towards the social good. As I noted recently in regards to Chicago, liberal mismanagement of public services is catastrophic for those at the bottom of the economic ladder. The same is true for middle-class communities, as northern Virginia residents learned this weekend.
Second, wealthy individuals tend to invest their capital in long-term economic investments. Whether this is investment in start-up companies, or stock markets, or in an existing business, the application of wealth in pursuit of a profit serves to benefit others. It means jobs, efficiency, and beneficial entrepreneurial development (think of ride sharing firms, for example).
Third, and most importantly, high taxes necessarily flow into the expansion of government. Where taxes are high, the private sector shrinks. And the consequences of this shrinking are variably witnessed in Europe’s economic stagnation and in the failed state of Venezuela.
Ultimately, fighting poverty demands more intellectually rigorous ideas in place of “tax the rich” platitudes. As studies past and present have found, the key to defeating poverty is education reform: that great equalizer of social mobility. But we must also improve lower-income access to tangible capital, enable capital flows, expand affordable health care, and restore fiscal solvency in government. http://opportunitylives.com/why-high-taxes-dont-cure-poverty/
But Sanders is peddling a dangerous delusion. Reality does not bear out his economic theory. To find out why, we need only look at the impact of high-tax liberalism on global poverty. Take Europe. According to the CIA’s Factbook (globally recognized as a reliable analytical tool), the poverty rate is around 15 percent in the United States, Britain and Germany. However, the comparative tax rates in Britain and Germany far exceed those of the United States. More relevant, taxes on higher incomes are considerably higher across Europe. This raises a difficult question for European socialists: why, after years of expansive government, have they failed to confront poverty?
The reason, in part, is punitive tax rates only push wealth to alternate lower-tax locations (thus denying investment in communities that need it most). In this sense, the liberal obsession with higher taxation is an intellectual stick-man against poverty. It offers an emotional veil for a serious problem. Those who have experienced liberal orthodoxy know this truth all too well.
Look at the Vietnamese people today. Although the Communist regime remains strikingly authoritarian, the Vietnamese are now the most fervent supporters of their nation’s emerging capitalism. They know that broadening opportunity and economic growth empower all of a society’s citizens: rich, middle-income, and poor alike.
This raises a difficult question for European socialists: why, after years of expansive government, have they failed to confront poverty?
But another reason why high taxes don’t cure poverty is in their transfer of power from individuals to government. This poses three distinct problems. First, government is decidedly inefficient and ineffective in its allocation of resources towards the social good. As I noted recently in regards to Chicago, liberal mismanagement of public services is catastrophic for those at the bottom of the economic ladder. The same is true for middle-class communities, as northern Virginia residents learned this weekend.
Second, wealthy individuals tend to invest their capital in long-term economic investments. Whether this is investment in start-up companies, or stock markets, or in an existing business, the application of wealth in pursuit of a profit serves to benefit others. It means jobs, efficiency, and beneficial entrepreneurial development (think of ride sharing firms, for example).
Third, and most importantly, high taxes necessarily flow into the expansion of government. Where taxes are high, the private sector shrinks. And the consequences of this shrinking are variably witnessed in Europe’s economic stagnation and in the failed state of Venezuela.
Ultimately, fighting poverty demands more intellectually rigorous ideas in place of “tax the rich” platitudes. As studies past and present have found, the key to defeating poverty is education reform: that great equalizer of social mobility. But we must also improve lower-income access to tangible capital, enable capital flows, expand affordable health care, and restore fiscal solvency in government. http://opportunitylives.com/why-high-taxes-dont-cure-poverty/

The premise in the headline is flawed fundamentally; it is not "high" taxes (across the board) that can impact poverty, rather A TAX SYSTEM THAT IS FAIR AND NOT RIGGED TO BENEFIT THE WEALTHY AT THE EXPENSE OF THE POOR AND MIDDLE CLASS!
… punitive tax rates only push wealth to alternate lower-tax locations (thus denying investment in communities that need it most). In this sense, the liberal obsession with higher taxation is an intellectual stick-man against poverty. It offers an emotional veil for a serious problem. Those who have experienced liberal orthodoxy know this truth all too well.
"Punitive" is an editorialized term in this "argument" … it's used in place of "fair". The reason impoverished communities don't receive the investment needed to lift them out of poverty is due to the generally low wages of its residents, who consequently cannot participate significantly as consumers.
And then there's the outsourcing … the corporate practitioners of which claim that "high taxes drive them to leave." That's pure B.S. -- while on paper their tax rates are high, in reality, many corporations pay NO FEDERAL TAXES AT ALL WHILE SIMULTANEOUSLY RECEIVING GOVERNMENT SUBSIDIES.
The game is rigged!
[CHART] U.S. Corporations That Pay No Taxes
The top 25% pay 70% of income taxes. How much do you want to confiscate? 90%?
The top 25% pay 70% of income taxes. How much do you want to confiscate? 90%?
You need to see this in perspective … otherwise, that phenomenon has no contextual relevance.
According to PolitiFact and others, in 2011 the 400 wealthiest Americans "have more wealth than half of all Americans combined
So you are not interested in taxing income . Instead you want to confiscate wealth ... Got it .
So you are not interested in taxing income . Instead you want to confiscate wealth ... Got it .
No you don't "got it".
The über wealthy pay more in taxes because they pay on greater amounts of income ... but they pay a much lower effective rate/percentage of their income than do middle class workers; that's because of the tax loopholes they enjoy via bought legislatiion.
Don't put words in my mouth and then criticize me based on your words … followed by your declaration of "got it."
When unfairness is the reason a particular segment of a particular system is "successful" it's a rigged system.
In the 1950s and 1960s, when the economy was booming, the wealthiest Americans paid a top income tax rate of 91% . Today, the top rate is 43.4%. The richest 1% pay an effective federal income tax rate of 24.7% in 2014; someone making an average of $75,000 is paying a 19.7% rate.
BUT …
But new data out this spring from the IRS gives us a closer look of how the income tax works at the pinnacle of the income distribution -- not just the top 1 percent, or even the top 0.1 percent, but among the rarified realm of the 0.01 and even the 0.001 percent. Those latter two categories are new in the IRS report this year, reflecting a growing public interest in the ultra-wealthy and their effects on the economy.
The IRS found that as you go from being merely wealthy (the 1 percent) to super-duper wealthy (the 0.001 percent), your average federal income tax rate actually goes down . In other words, the progressivity of the federal income tax starts to fall apart at the upper reaches of the income distribution. Take a look.
Platitudes and erroneous conclusions are not valid rebuttals ... They're zeal without knowledge blather.
Discuss what I state not the misrepresented rewrite!
That goes for all of you who don't actually rebut the information I take the time and effort to post in order to rebut yours!
IN SUMMARY … THE GAME IS RIGGED WHEN THOSE WHO HAVE MORE GET TO KEEP MORE (A GREATER PERCENTAGE OF) BECAUSE THEY CAN BUY THE SYSTEM BY BUYING THE LEGISLATORS WHO CONTROL THE SYSTEM!
The game is not rigged. Success is rewarded. That's why we have so many people trying to come here. It's natural fir those who are not successful to look for scapegoats and bogeymen.
The game is not rigged. Success is rewarded. That's why we have so many people trying to come here. It's natural fir those who are not successful to look for scapegoats and bogeymen.
The "game" is also rigged in places from which those trying to come here originate … the standard of living here is better due to social services but life in poverty is still no picnic.
The value of your money, interest rates for loans, availability of jobs, and the rate of home foreclosures are all decided by a small group of elite private bankers who run the Federal Reserve. Contrary to common belief, the Federal Reserve – the Central Bank in the U.S. – is not a government agency. It’s privately owned and operated.
The GAME IS INDEED RIGGED.
"Success" is a nebulous term.
For example …
Over the past decade, the companies that make up the S&P 500 have spent an astounding 54 percent of profits on stock buybacks. Last year alone, U.S. corporations spent about $700 billion, or roughly 4 percent of GDP, to prop up their share prices by repurchasing their own stock….
It is mathematically impossible to make the public- and private-sector investments necessary to sustain America’s global economic competitiveness while flushing away 4 percent of GDP year after year.
For example, Americans pay more for pharmaceuticals than do the citizens of any other developed nation.
That’s partly because it’s perfectly legal in the U.S. (but not in most other nations) for the makers of branded drugs to pay the makers of generic drugs to delay introducing cheaper unbranded equivalents, after patents on the brands have expired.
This costs you and me an estimated $3.5 billion a year – a hidden upward redistribution of our incomes to Pfizer, Merck, and other big proprietary drug companies, their executives, and major shareholders.
We also pay more for Internet service than do the inhabitants of any other developed nation.
I could post examples all night.
Interesting I hope the S&P companies spend a lot more this year on buybacks because last year was a losing year and the S&P ended down six percent for the year.