╌>

This College President Rejected the Loony Demands of His Students

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pj  •  10 years ago  •  5 comments

This College President Rejected the Loony Demands of His Students

This College President Rejected the Loony Demands of His Students

By Andrew Kloster | February 1, 2016 | 5:21 PM EST

 

In the wake of incidents smacking of mob rule at the University of Missouri and Yale , some college administrators are waking up.

Students attend college to be educated, not to play “social justice warrior.” So when students disrupt the educational mission of colleges, they should be appropriately disciplined. Whether it was at the University of Missouri or at Yale or elsewhere, in 2015, we saw university administrators respond to student-led disruption in a tepid fashion.

Minding the Campus, a publication that follows higher education, handed out “Worst College President of 2015″ awards , and the common thread was that administrators at the “honored” institutions all submitted to prevailing politically correct orthodoxy rather than standing up for the educational mission of their institutions.

But this month, we have a light in the darkness. Marvin Krislov, president of Oberlin College (not exactly a conservative bastion), has rejected the 50-point, 14-page list of demands presented by a handful of student activists . The list of demands was presented in mid-December, and it was a doozy, mixing left-wing insults (“labor exploitation”; Oberlin was “built” upon the “soil” of a “white supremacist, patriarchal, capitalist system”) with unacceptable and even contradictory demands (demanding various hirings, firings, racial quotas, and other spoils).

Now, it took over a month for the Oberlin president to respond. Such a delay could evince some trepidation, but it could also be pragmatic—attempting to demonstrate that concerns were taken seriously before being rejected. (Or, of course, it could be an ordinary response timeline, given the winter break.)

And yet, Krislov’s response is worth a read .

It’s true that it bends over backwards to explain how “[s]ome of the challenges outlined in the [list of demands] resonate with me and many members of our community.” This is, perhaps, too gentle by half.

But it also excoriates the list for including “deeply troubling” demands and “personal attacks on a number of faculty and staff members.” And the response also sets the president apart as a voice of authority when it notes that “our” calling is to provide “our” students with a “broad-based, in-depth education.” Indeed, this use of language appropriately sets educator and student on different levels. One teaches, and the other learns. It is the faculty that is responsible for “scholarship, research, musicianship, artistry, advising, and mentoring[.]”

Viewed through this lens, the list of demands is doubly concerning. As Krislov explicitly states, the demands represent an unacceptable departure from Oberlin’s academic model (the standard model of most American colleges).

Left implied is the concern that the demands represent a troubling presumptuousness by the consumer of education, whose avenues for disagreement with university administration are generally internal, not external. Students may vote with their pocketbook, may choose to donate or not, and may seek to become a member of the academy.

Acceptance into an undergraduate class confers no rights of radical critique: Colleges are supposed to be places of learning, insulated from this sort of “class consciousness.”

Unfortunately, many college administrators across the country have lost sight of education as a mission and have instead focused on collective “dialogue” and hyphenated learning. While Oberlin College’s stiff arm to an unreasonable list of demands is welcome, it does not represent a new direction, nor does it necessarily represent a movement. But perhaps it provides hope to other educators that their day will come.

Andrew R. Kloster is a legal fellow in the Edwin Meese III Center for Legal and Judicial Studies at The Heritage Foundation, focusing on civil rights, the role of the federal courts and other constitutional issues.

http://cnsnews.com/commentary/andrew-kloster/college-president-rejected-loony-demands-his-students


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   seeder  PJ    10 years ago

Acceptance into an undergraduate class confers no rights of radical critique: Colleges are supposed to be places of learning, insulated from this sort of “class consciousness.”

Unfortunately, many college administrators across the country have lost sight of education as a mission and have instead focused on collective “dialogue” and hyphenated learning.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    10 years ago

I automatically have my doubts about anyone who gets praise from the Heritage Foundation... 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

Thanks for sharing the close minded "I'm afraid of anything not sanctioned by far left red meat sites" perspective. Get some air in your bubble, soon.  

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

by far left red meat sites 

Sean... This is a great demonstration of you makin' stuff up... Of you ignoring reality in favor of a preconception that you just pulled from a dark and smelly place. 

I post quite a bit... and almost never from dingbat sites. That is simple fact; you can easily verify it.

But that would require you to take an interest in reality , rather than your own fantasies. I don't see that happening.

     Party      Party      Party

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   seeder  PJ  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

It's good to be cautious of where information is coming from, I agree.  For me, I think the school needed to show back bone.  I'm not a fan of people demanding certain rights while stepping all over other people's rights.  And frankly, I don't think I'd react very well if someone handed me a list of ultimatums demanding they be met otherwise they will in essence hold everyone's education hostage.  It will be interesting to see how this situation develops. 

 
 

Who is online

Snuffy
evilone


97 visitors