Controversial bill aims to privatize air-traffic control
Controversial bill aims to privatize air-traffic control
Bart Jansen , USA TODAY 6:01 p.m. EST February 3, 2016
WASHINGTON — A controversial proposal that puts the nation's air traffic controls into private hands burst on to the legislative scene Wednesday, pitting pilots against many airlines and the people who manage the skies.
The legislation, opposed by powerful lawmakers in both parties, drew unusual support from the air traffic controllers' union, which says the growing inefficiencies, dated equipment and unstable funding call for a drastic response.
Rep. Bill Shuster, R-Pa., chairman of the Transportation Committee, who proposed the change said it would insulate the air traffic control system from the funding whims of Congress, which, during a 2013 budget fight, shut down the government and furloughed air traffic controllers.
Shuster says the air traffic control system under the FAA is safe, but "incredibly inefficient."
The problems, he said, "will only get worse as passenger levels grow and as the FAA falls further behind in modernizing the system."
Lawmakers and various air traffic controller organization have proposed privatization at least eight times over the past 40 years.
This time, National Air Traffic Controllers Association backed the proposal.
The opposition, however, lined up even before Schuster introduced the legislation. House Appropriations Chairman Hal Rogers, R-Ky., and the top Democrat, Nita Lowey of New York, said in a letter Monday to House Speaker Paul Ryan that such a move give the public less leverage to influence how the system operations.
Senate Appropriations Chairman Thad Cochran, R-Miss., and the top Democrat, Barbara Mikulski of Maryland, in a Jan. 27 letter said privatization would mean "less oversight and less accountability."
Criticism came Wednesday from the Air Line Pilots Association, a union representing 52,000 pilots, which fears airlines would shoulder the costs of air-traffic control rather than spreading the costs among all aircraft.
Shuster’s proposal kicks off the debate on broader legislation to renew FAA policy that expires in March. Pilot training, airport fees and drone regulations will also be up for discussion.
The 273-page bill includes provisions that:
• Require airlines to refund baggage fees for bags delayed more than 24 hours on domestic flights.
• Ban the use of cell phones for in-flight voice calls on scheduled passenger flights.
• Authorize the Transportation Department to establish a smartphone application for consumer complaints.
• Require large and medium airports to provide private rooms in every terminal for nursing mothers.
• Require airlines to notify families, before tickets are booked, if family members are assigned seats that
aren't together.
Privatizing air-traffic control in the U.S. has been proposed in the past, but never adopted. Dozens of other countries have privatized their air-traffic systems, but lingering questions focus on whether the private system adopted in Canada, for example, would work in the much larger and more complex U.S. airspace.
Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx and FAA Administrator Michael Huerta have remained neutral to discuss the proposal with lawmakers.
“In the U.S., we have probably the most complicated airspace in the world,” Foxx told a roundtable of reporters Tuesday. “It isn’t a non-starter for that reason. I just have to see what people are actually proposing before I can weigh in on any proposal one way or the other. If I were a reflexive 'no' on this, I would say so.”
Other issues deal with how the government could delegate the power to the private group to collect its funding.
The corporation would be governed by an 11-member board, including the chief executive officer, two members named by the transportation secretary, four named by airlines, two from the general-aviation community, one from the controllers’ union and one from the pilots’ union. Shuster envisions a three-year transition from the government to the corporation.
The industry group Airlines for America, which represents most of the major airlines, contends that current airline taxes and fees of about $13 billion per year would cover the $10 billion cost of operating the air-traffic control system. But the carriers say they are not trying to reduce their costs in direct government spending.
When Shuster's committee votes on the bill Feb. 11, the top Democrat, Rep. Peter DeFazio of Oregon, said he would propose an amendment to keep controllers within FAA while guaranteeing funding for the system by dedicating aviation fees to the organization rather than leaving it subject to annual congressional spending decisions. DeFazio expects appropriators to oppose his measure, too.
DeFazio argues moving controllers would disrupt progress that's been made to upgrade equipment and create chaos for the six-year life of the legislation. Debate over the proposal could delay FAA legislation, he warned.
"It's potentially going to be held up indefinitely because of a controversy over privatizing the air-traffic organization," DeFazio said.
Airline executives from American, Southwest and JetBlue say that a private corporation governed by representatives of the aviation industry could move faster than FAA to upgrade equipment and adopt more efficient flight paths.
The group Airlines for America estimates that unnecessary flight delays cost the country $30 billion per year that could be avoided through making the system more efficient.
"A more efficient system with proper governance, funding and accountability will bolster our nation's first-rate safety record and result in more choice, more direct trips, lower fuel consumption, reduced emissions and fewer flight delays," said Nicholas Calio, the group's CEO.
Delta Air Lines is a notable exception. Delta’s senior vice president for flight operations, Capt. Steve Dickson, says privatizing air-traffic control won’t reduce heavy traffic in the Northeast and could distract from current efforts to ease congestion.
A Delta study projected that traveler costs would rise 20% to 29%, based on higher fees charged during the first six years of privatization in Canada and the United Kingdom. Delta CEO Richard Anderson called the proposal "unnecessary and unwise" in a Tuesday letter to Shuster.
Key Democrats question whether the government can give the power to collect taxes and fees without a constitutional amendment. Shuster said the corporation would collect user fees from the industry, while nine government taxes that are now collected could be abolished.
DeFazio said the bill calls for the corporation's board to propose its user fees and airline routes, which could be reviewed by the transportation secretary for 45 days, which he argued would be cumbersome and would lead to "significant ticket-price increases." DeFazio also said airlines would dominate the board.
"The same people who today determine your baggage costs would determine what you would pay to use the air-traffic control system," DeFazio said. "I don't think that gives consumers a lot of confidence."
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2016/02/03/controversial-bill-proposes-privatize-air-traffic-control/79745638/

DeFazio said the bill calls for the corporation's board to propose its user fees and airline routes, which could be reviewed by the transportation secretary for 45 days, which he argued would be cumbersome and would lead to "significant ticket-price increases." DeFazio also said airlines would dominate the board.
"The same people who today determine your baggage costs would determine what you would pay to use the air-traffic control system," DeFazio said. "I don't think that gives consumers a lot of confidence."
Shuster says the air traffic control system under the FAA is safe, but "incredibly inefficient."
I have to wonder how efficiency is measured for the air traffic system . Is it based on the number of personnel needed ?
Good question, Petey.
I would add a question about equipment updating. I have often read that ATC gear is downright antiquated... but I have not seen any good explanations for "why". Really old gear is expensive to maintain, so I would imagine that whoever has to pay those costs would like to update. Why doesn't it happen? Does anyone know?