For years , America has been debating the use of the term "Redskin" by Washington's NFL team, the Washington Redskins.
Though the NFL says they're listening , nothing has been done. But with this ad, the NCAI has put a human face on the story
and shows exactly why the term "Redskin" is so problematic, in compressing an entire people's rich and varied identity into
one stereotype.
Even though the term "Native American" has its own issues of blanket categorization, it's at least used cautiously and with
the knowledge, if even tacit, that this group of people can be somewhat identified by their long-standing relationship to the
continent. Redskin, however, is simply a terrible slur. It reduces these groups to the color of their skin (in a very racist way)
and lumps everyone together with no thought to their heritage or history.
Despite almost constant pressure, Washington Redskins owner Dan Snyder has repeatedly said he has no plans to change
the team's name . In a letter to fans, Snyder wrote that the team name "was, and continues to be, a badge of honor. ... I've listened
carefully to the commentary and perspectives on all sides, and I respect the feelings of those who are offended by the team name.
But I hope such individuals also try to respect what the name means, not only for all of us in the extended Washington Redskins family, but among Native Americans too."
Basically, Snyder has heard the complaints, but he doesn't care.
A number of other major sports teams have questionable names — the Kansas City Chiefs (NFL), the Atlanta Braves (MLB), Cleveland
Indians (MLB), Edmonton Eskimos (CFL), Chicago Blackhawks (NHL) — and for one reason or another, they're mostly Native
American slurs. While some might argue that naming a team after Native Americans is a way to honor their courage and strength,
the use of these slurs is nothing more than capitalizing on a relatively defenseless group of people that have been marginalized in
America for centuries.

Could not do a darn thing with the formatting - copied it verbatim though, so all ya gotta do is click.
This is one powerful message - from us, the "Invisible People".
As I started to watch I could feel my heart beat pick up. This overwhelming feeling of honor I felt for these people, these first Americans, our native sons and daughters. To see their own pride in their eyes and then to see how there are struggles that remain. The message at the end was simplistic BUT powerful. I don't think its too much to ask that a people be allowed dignity and pride for one’s heritage without mockery.
This ad is beautiful, and powerful.
It's too bad the Nations can't come together with enough money to buy ad space for a Super Bowl stage show featuring some of them performing traditional dances,.. things of this nature, with drums, wind pipes, traditional fast-paced chants. A well put together appearance would wipe anyone else off the map and bring Indians to the forefront of the nation's conscience.
We need to come off the reservations and into the media to gain support.
It is a powerful video.
Snyder has refused to meet with any number of Indian leaders. He's pretty much a coward, but keeps insisting that the name is ''honoring'' us. Perhaps I could come up with a name that would honor him from his heritage.
Don't think "Dipshit" would honor anybody - maybe???
As with gay the word might have changed meanings over the years. I always thought of it as honoring them and after doing some research I see the majority of Americans feel the same.
Dean, you didn't do enough research..The majority of Americans that feel the same were not Indian. If your insulting someone why would they give a crap, it isn't them that being insulted.
Another point, it seems very arrogant for non Indians to tell an Indian what is insulting to them and what isn't.
BTW, the way the meaning of it hasn't changed in 200 years.
An afro, tall shield, spear, hoops through the nose and ears, wearing a loin cloth - a Zulu warrior - fierce, proud, dangerous. Let's call the team "Ni**ers" in honor of all the blacks from Africa.
Workable?
There are a lot more white people than Indians. So it is true that most people view it as an honor. Just like the confederate flag one can choose to see it positive or negative. Being a glass is half full guy I see the good in these symbols.
1st,
I watched the video with great interest and attention. It was quite compelling. I hope it ultimately contributes to the success of the movement to get this done finally.
I have an unrelated question for you.
I've taken note of the great number of tribes that still hold to their roots. My question is: Does the Indian nation coalesce at any juncture? When seeking to gain influence, to all the tribes get together and pool their strength to push in the same direction? When they seek to make change, do they do so with all participating with one voice?
I'll give it a shot Krish,
The first thing to understand is that each nation has their own language/customs/culture. So issues can affect one tribe and not another.
In the case of the name, and other issues the nations unite under National Council of American Indians (NCAI). There are also regional groups that band together to be heard. Some of these alliances have been there for hundreds of years.
That's my take on it.
This is a bit off topic but I've attended several Native Nations events for work. Within the last 5 years they've started hosting a Native American Health Care Conference. Last year it was in Albuquerque. It's a small venue but it's growing.
I don't think it's off topic at all Pj. Yes, those organizations help because we take it back to the tribe/nation to "PayIt4ward" to see if the impact can/will be productive/positive. If not, the tribe/nation will let you know that the "ideas" you're bringing in from the outside are not workable without the tribal/nation culture.
I'm Fed Gov so our participation is purely for disseminating information on products we regulate for health purposes so consumers can make educated decisions. We also advocate for participation in clinical trials because products affect sub populations differently. One of our sister Agencies I believe did a study back in 2003 on lessons learned while developing Clinical Trials Education for Native Americans. It's very difficult gaining the trust of the Native American communities but quite understandable.
Pj, this meme pretty much covers it.
Thank you Kavika,
I'm not Krish, but I've been called worse.
The reason for my question is this:
It's not quite the same in the Jewish world, but there are a number of denominations. Political affiliation further complicates the landscape, but there is much that we Jews do not agree on. I find it an obstacle to our potential strength.
Do you have these obstacles in the A-I world? Could you be stronger as a group if not for your internal disagreements, or do you essentially gain consensus and run with it?
LOL, sorry Jonathan,
1st post I believe answers your question. To add a bit to it, yes there are internal disagreements within the tribes, but a voice isn't put forth without the majority agreement of the tribe.
Yes, in a way it is a problem when trying to have one voice on a situation, like the Jewish people we have many thoughts/positions on situations. The one thing that there is little disagreement on is the term ''R*dskin''...
What I found interesting is that the polls taken that show approval of the name are polls of non Indians. When a poll was taken of Indian over 85% what the name changed and consider it a racial slur.
Another poll that was interesting was one taken of Washington fans, where the majority thought the name was fine, but of that group 70% said they would never call an Indian a R*dskin to their face. That, pretty much let's you know what the name really means.
No problem.
Personally, it never occurred to me that it was a slur. I don't think I've used the term other than to refer to the team.
It sounds like there are enough issues that unite, rather than divide.
I think that there will be a change in the team name in the next couple of years. I hate to sound jaded, but the change would bring the team an incredible amount of licensing revenue from all the new team shwag they'd be selling to the fans and interested party. It's a large money making opportunity, for sure. I'm not sure that they'll be doing it out of the kindness of their hearts, though.
Snyder's refusal to change the name is really puzzling. Being Jewish one would think that he would totally understand slurs of a group of people.
Your correct in that a name change would bring a lot of new revenue to the team. But Snyder isn't going to change the name out of respect for a race of people.
Kavika - money trumps anything, religion, heritage, even a mother. You've heard the term "he'd sell his own mother". Snyder believes that as long as he gives money towards Native American causes that he will eventually win them over. You hear some say that it must be okay because the Native American's are taking his money. Well.....I'd take his money too but that doesn't mean my principals have changed. It just means he's stupid enough to give me money.
I've heard fans don't want the name changed but if it's going to be happen they would rather it just be "Washington" period.
Actually Pj, his Native American Foundation has run into most tribes refusing his money or offer of money.
I'm not surprised. Of course, I don't know too much on the subject except what it put out there for publicity purposes.
But Snyder isn't going to change the name out of respect for a race of people.
Do you think Israel vacated Gaza out of respect for the Palestinians?
Jonathan, no they probably didn't, but I'm not sure what that has to do with this situation. Care to explain it please.
I'll keep it as short as possible, as it is off-topic to a great degree. Israel vacated Gaza as a no-strings-attached concession. They asked for nothing in return, in the hope that they'd get something. It wasn't out of respect. It was out of the hope that by making the first move, they'd get a reciprocal positive move. It wasn't out of respect; it was a new approach to a survival tactic.
You can see how well that worked.
The analogy is that Snyder won't do anything out of respect, but expects something in return.
I don't believe that Snyder will do it either way, IMO. The only way he will change the name is if he is forced to. Washington D.C. will not let him built a new stadium there until the name is changed. Will it work, I don't know.
Snyder has fought it at every turn, including suing those that have taken him to court.
His track record fits quite well with the prior owner of the team. An avowed racist.
Here is an interesting link that you may enjoy.
Also there are many Indian tribes that have contact with Israel, and have visited and support the Israel cause.
WWW Virtual Library - American Indians
Index of Native American Organizations on the Internet
Tribes, for the most part, are very autonomous - no one shares outside without the tribes total approval. Tribes are also sovereign nations - they like to control their own destinies/fates - and working with others is not a cultural initiative because of the many years of lack of trust or not being able to trust others. The trust thing can/usually a regional/local issue that goes back hundreds of years - or at the total loss of lands, rights, culture, traditions, heritage brought on by the European stream.
At issue with the Indian Organizations is, as stated above, don't want interference in how to operate/run/develop/grant tribal freedoms to others outside the tribe - as is being done by the U. S. government.