╌>

This is how Hillary Clinton gets the coverage she wants

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  10 years ago  •  1 comments

This is how Hillary Clinton gets the coverage she wants

Hillary Clinton’s supporters  often argue   that mainstream   political reporters  are incapable of covering her positively—or even fairly. While it may be true that the political press doesn’t always write exactly what Clinton would like, emails recently obtained by Gawker offer a case study in how her prodigious and sophisticated press operation manipulates reporters into amplifying her desired message—in this case, down to the very word that  The Atlantic ’s Marc Ambinder used to describe an important policy speech.

The emails in question , which were exchanged by Ambinder, then  serving as  The  Atlantic ’s politics editor , and Philippe Reines, Clinton’s notoriously combative spokesman and consigliere, turned up thanks to a Freedom of Information Act request we filed in 2012 (and which we are currently suing the State Department  over). The same request previously revealed that Politico’s chief White House correspondent, Mike Allen,  promised to deliver  positive coverage of Chelsea Clinton, and, in a separate exchange, permitted Reines to ghost-write an item about the State Department  for Politico’s Playbook newsletter. Ambinder’s emails with Reines demonstrate the same kind of transactional reporting, albeit to a much more legible degree: In them, you can see Reines “blackmailing” Ambinder into describing a Clinton speech as “muscular” in exchange for early access to the transcript. In other words, Ambinder outsourced his editorial judgment about the speech to a member of Clinton’s own staff.

On the morning of July 15, 2009, Ambinder  sent Reines a blank email  with the subject line, “Do you have a copy of HRC’s speech to share?” His question concerned a speech Clinton  planned to give later that day  at the Washington, D.C. office of the Council on Foreign Relations, an influential think tank. Three minutes after Ambinder’s initial email, Reines replied with three words: “on two conditions.” After Ambinder responded with “ok,” Reines sent him a list of those conditions:

 


From:  [Philippe Reines]
Sent:  Wednesday, July 15 2009 10:06 AM
To:  Ambinder, Marc
Subject:  Re: Do you have a copy of HRC’s speech to share?

3 [conditions] actually

1) You in your own voice describe them as “muscular”

2) You note that a look at the CFR seating plan shows that all the envoys — from Holbrooke to Mitchell to Ross — will be arrayed in front of her, which in your own clever way you can say certainly not a coincidence and meant to convey something

3) You don’t say you were blackmailed!


One minute later, Ambinder responded:


From:  Ambinder, Marc
Sent:  Wednesday, July 15, 2009 10:07 AM
To:  Philippe Reines
Subject:  RE: Do you have a copy of HRC’s speech to share?

got it


Ambinder made good on his word. The opening paragraph of the article he wrote later that day, under the headline “ Hillary Clinton’s ‘Smart Power’ Breaks Through ,” precisely followed Reines’ instructions:


When you think of President Obama’s foreign policy, think of Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. That’s the message behind a muscular  speech that Clinton is set to deliver today to the Council on Foreign Relations. The staging gives a clue to its purpose:  seated in front of Clinton , subordinate to Clinton, in the first row, will be  three potentially rival power centers: envoys Richard Holbrooke and George Mitchell, and National Security Council senior director Dennis Ross .


Based on other emails released in the same batch we received, Ambinder’s warm feelings toward Clinton may have made him uniquely susceptible to Reines’ editing suggestions. On July 26, 2009,  he wrote to Reines  to congratulate his boss about her appearance on  Meet the Press :


From:  Ambinder, Marc
Sent:  Sunday, July 26, 2009 12:05 PM
To:  Philippe Reines
Subject:  she kicked A

on MTP


On  November 29, 2010 , he sent along another congratulatory note, apparently in regard to a press conference Clinton  had held that day  to address the publication of thousands of State Department cables by WikiLeaks:


From:  Ambinder, Marc
Sent:  Monday, November 29, 2010 12:05 PM
To:  Philippe Reines
Subject:  This is an awesome presser...

She is PITCH f#$*& PERFECT on this stuff.


The emails quoted above are particularly remarkable given Ambinder’s understanding of Clinton’s press strategy, as he articulated in a column for  The Week  last year. Predicting how Clinton’s widely documented aversion to reporters would play out in the 2016 presidential race, Ambinder wrote , “The Clinton campaign will use the press instrumentally. ... Good news for us, though: The reporters covering Clinton are going to find ways to draw her out anyway, because they’re really good, they’ll give her no quarter, and they’ll provide a good source of accountability tension [ sic ]   until Walker (or whomever) emerges from the maelstrom.”

When asked for comment about his correspondence with Reines, Ambinder wrote in an email to Gawker, “I don’t remember much about anything, but I do remember once writing about how powerful FOIA is, especially as a mechanism to hold everyone in power, even journalists, accountable.” When asked to elaborate, he followed up with a longer message:


Philippe and I generally spoke on the phone and followed up by email. The exchange is probably at best an incomplete record of what went down. That said, the transactional nature of such interactions always gave me the willies.... Since I can’t remember the exact exchange I can’t really muster up a defense of the art, and frankly, I don’t really want to. I will say this: whatever happened here reflects my own decisions, and no one else’s.


In a subsequent phone exchange, Ambinder added:


It made me uncomfortable then, and it makes me uncomfortable today. And when I look at that email record, it is a reminder to me of why I moved away from all that.  The Atlantic , to their credit, never pushed me to do that, to turn into a scoop factory. In the fullness of time, any journalist or writer who is confronted by the prospect, or gets in the situation where their journalism begins to feel transactional, should listen to their gut feeling and push away from that.

Being scrupulous at all times will not help you get all the scoops, but it will help you sleep at night. At no point at  The Atlantic  did I ever feel the pressure to make transactional journalism the norm.


Ambinder emphasized that the emails did not capture the totality of his communication with Reines, and said they were not indicative of his normal reporting techniques. When asked if the exchange was typical of the magazine’s reporting and editing process, a spokesperson for  The Atlantic  told Gawker: “No, this is not typical, and it goes against our standards.”

Reines didn’t respond when we asked if he engaged in similar transactions with other reporters covering the State Department. But on the day of his trade with Ambinder, at least one other journalist used Reines’ preferred adjective—“muscular”—to describe the speech at the Council on Foreign Relations. That  reporter was none other than Mike Allen of Politico :

This Is How Hillary Clinton Gets the Coverage She Wants

Allen even took note of the seating arrangement, just as Reines had requested of Ambinder:


A look at the CFR’s guest seating chart shows that arrayed in the front row will be top members of her team — the envoys she has called her “force multipliers”: Richard Holbrooke, George Mitchell, Dennis Ross, Philip Goldberg and Stephen Bosworth.


We can’t say for sure that Reines implored Allen to describe Clinton’s speech as “muscular” and emphasize where particular audience members were seated, but that kind of request would hardly be out of the ordinary. As we noted above, Allen allowed Reines to ghost-write an item for his Playbook newsletter; and, in the course of attempting to secure an interview with Chelsea Clinton, told Reines he was prepared to submit interview questions to Clinton’s team in advance for their approval.

Allen referred our questions to Politico’s spokesperson, who told Gawker via email: “Mike’s preview of this speech includes multiple ‘aides say’ qualifiers and is transparent in that it’s based on ‘prepared remarks’ and a ‘seating chart.’” (If Allen and Reines did indeed email about Clinton’s speech, however, we expect to receive a copy of their correspondence in a subsequent batch as the State Department continues to process our request.)

In any case, Reines’ strategy worked out nicely. For an article aggregating Allen’s piece,  New York  magazine quoted his use of “muscular” in the headline, and  even commissioned an illustration of Clinton wearing the arms of a body builder.

http://gawker.com/this-is-how-hillary-clinton-gets-the-coverage-she-wants-1758019058

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    10 years ago

Politico, supposedly one of the best sources of mainstream political analysis, even let Clinton staff author a piece under the byline of one it's star journalists.

 

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot
afrayedknot


83 visitors