There was much hubbub in late 2012 when President Obama made four recess appointments during a short recess between two pro-forma sessions of the Senate in January of that year.
The case later went to the Supreme Court and the maneuver was ruled to be unconstitutional.
The key in the 2014 Supreme Court decision regarding the president’s appointments to the National Labor Relations Board over the three-day break was that the justices found the executive branch determined what it interpreted as a recess.
But Justice Stephen Breyer wrote in the majority opinion that under the Constitution “the Senate is in session when it says it is.”
Obama said Saturday night that he would submit an appointment to the Senate, as part of his constitutional obligation, but “in due time.”
But now we have a completely different set of parliamentary circumstances. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., has indicated that he thinks that the nomination of a new justice should wait until the election of the next president.
This window is open next week and this week only.
In short: Both bodies of Congress are operating in the perfect parliamentary status in which a recess appointment would be

Go for it.
Actually I don't think any of this matters much. Why? Because even if Obama nominates someone in time, and no matter who he nominates-- the Republicans won't even take up the matter-- let alone approve the nomination.
So nothing will be done until after the election.
And then the odds are that Pres. HR Clinton's win will sweep in a lot of Democrats to Congress. The the Dem. controlled Senate will finally approve Obama's nomination-- or if none, they will approve someone Hillary nominates.
(There's no way Bernie can win the nomination-- look at NH. And Americans as a whole don't like extremists-- or nutcases).
Holy cow from USDA to homeland security his appointments have been terrible.
And Trump or Cruz would make better appointments, 96?
It won't happen.
I hope that it does happen, Cerenkov.
We don't operate under a Parliamentary system. In this situation, Robert's Rules of Order are not applicable.
" In this situation, Robert's Rules of Order are not applicable.".
Of course not-- he left the site long ago!
(Although when speaking of entities such as Robert, what is meant by the term "order" is open to debate).
You do realize that a Recess Appointment only lasts until the end of the Senate Term. And for it to remain, the appointment has to be submitted in normal fashion. So a recess appointment right now would have a Justice sitting on the court only temporarily.
Of course it's a temp position Bruce. The republicans want Obama to hold off on naming a nominee until after the elections. That is pure BS on their part. Their stance has nothing to do with what is best for the country or the American people. It's simply to hope they win the presidential election and get to appoint a conservative justice. Simple as that.
Name the nominee and let congress do their thing. If they want to play the BS game then he should use the recess appointment procedure.
OH Jesus Fucking Christ! Now it's what's best for the country? Was it what was best for the country when the Dems stalled Reagan's choices for the court for 18 months? Cry me a fucking river. It's all fucking politics, until it's your party on the short end of the stick, then it's the "good of the country". My ass.
I'm not sure what Jesus Christ has to do with this, Bruce. Is he the final arbitrator on the SCOTUS? And how your ass got involved in this is a great question.
Speaking of crying a river, the republicans seem to be doing that right now. Let Obama nominate a justice and they can stall all they want. I don't believe they have the balls to do anything but ''cry a river''.
But that's not what you're calling for here Kavika. You're calling for Obama to make a Recess Appointment.
What I'm calling for Bruce, is for the republicans to cut the BS and either approve or not approve a nominee. If they continue to babble about waiting until there is a new president, than Obama should use a recess appointment, and we could watch Cruz et al heads explode.
". It's simply to hope they win the presidential election and get to appoint a conservative justice."
Which may be a really stupid move on their part. Their egos are so inflated that they are sure they will win the election. (After they've gone out of their way to alienate the Hispanic vote, the Black vote, the woman's vote..and probably a few others). And after every day becoming more and more extreme-- and more and more ridiculous. Buffoons on steroids. Why should Bernie & Hillary even bother to attack them, they're doing the job all by themselves. They are a laughingstock-- and that stock price is going down. What if our current Democratic president is followed by ..another Dem. president-- only this time with a Democratic Senate? DUH! Stuck on Stupid Republicans are!!!
problem with the recess appointment? I think it was found out all they need is to come in call for order in the senate , then adjorn for the day and they are not in recess, I seem to remember that tactic used, and the court agreed the senate is in recess when the senate says they are , not when the president says they are.
Recess appointment is not applicable for a SCOTUS position, but have been used for other judicial vacancies. Recess appointments to the judiciary have generated significant concern because unconfirmed judges lack the life tenure and guaranteed salary required by Article III.
It doesn't matter whether President Obama's nomination is confirmed or not but he does have a responsibility to the American people to put forth a nominee and the Senate has a responsibility to do what we elected and pay them to do. In this case they need to deliberate and vote on the President's nominee.
This chicken shit position of waiting is nothing more than skirting their responsibilities. They can just vote NO but they need to do their fucking job!
Anyone that defends the Senate for not doing their job is NOT putting their country first but their political party. I don't give a shit what was done in the past. There are many things we did in the past that we no longer do so that argument is weak.
I think that requesting the President to hold off on appointing a successor is a mistake on the part of the Senate. They should, instead, be making all kinds of Presidential noises about the President appointing the best person for the job and then (since they have a clear majority in the Senate) seeing to it that all of his choices are rejected immediately. The end result would be the same and it would sound better in the media. Those right wing guys have never learned how to dissemble properly, they approach things like a bull in a china shop. The way they are doing it, they invite folks like you to accuse them of not doing their job, when they actually are doing their job by placing the candidates on hold. A candidate under filibuster is being rejected as being so obviously unfit that a hearing isn't even necessary.
We have paid both branches a hell of a lot of money for them to accomplish absolutely nothing for 7 years.
Actually Pj, they have accomplished a great deal. They have kept idiotic schemes that would destroy the country from being passed or implemented. After all, someone has to be the adult and tell the children that the candy they want will be bad for them in the long run.
Ttga - I don't think I understand your point and I don't want to assume and be inaccurate. Are you saying you approve of the job that both the Republicans and Democrats have done?
Are you saying you approve of the job that both the Republicans and Democrats have done?
Pj, as far as I know, very few Democrats have tried to stop the runaway spending that has occurred over the past twenty years or so (actually closer to fifty years). Those that have done so certainly have my approval. Unfortunately, all too many Republicans have also decided to cater to the demands of those who want unending Bread and Circuses and who have a sense of unlimited entitlement just because they happened to be born. Those Republicans most certainly do not have my approval. The unlimited spending demanded by voters will destroy this nation (in fact, that process is already well under way). Anyone who blocks it should be applauded.
Ttga - I think I'm kinda in shock right now. It sounds like you're advocating for a coup d'é·tat. You believe that a group of people should decide what happens to all of America because they've decided they don't trust the citizens to make the right choices? You think we should just toss away the Constitution and everything our ancestors fought for?
Hint : they were elected to do that.
You think we should just toss away the Constitution and everything our ancestors fought for?
Pj, the Constitution has been tossed away already, not only during the Obama Administration but long before that (as far back as the Johnson Administration). Nothing I have advocated is unconstitutional. It's not a coup de'tat; it's simply the accretion of power through the votes of adults who do not think of themselves as entitled to be supported by everyone else. Most people know that you can't borrow your way out of debt (you will go bankrupt if you try). Those same people, however, think that it's just fine for the Government to do it, if it has what looks like a benefit for them; and that the Government will never go bankrupt. They haven't looked at Greece, mostly because they don't want to hear things that would cut off their gravy train. (Gotta go, dinner).
Enjoy you meal! :o)
It was great. Desert was brownies with cherry pie filling and whipped cream. Heart attack on a plate, but very good.
Yum Yum - sounds delish. I had plain ole ice cream. :0(
You believe that a group of people should decide what happens to all of America because they've decided they don't trust the citizens to make the right choices?
Pj,
I missed the implications of this part earlier. You do realize, don't you, that this is exactly the rationale for passing Obamacare.
Happy Monday Ttga. We are bracing for some poor weather in my area today so I'm settling in for a lazy day.
Yes, I understand the point you are trying to make with the ACA and how it was voted in without support from the other side. First, let me be clear on my position. I don't think it's appropriate for any branch of government to refuse to bring issues forward for debate or to be voted on. So, I understand your point but the difference is that the ACA was debated and it was voted on. Now, we can debate whether its honorable to pass something without representation or support from the other side but the rules are clear on what is required to pass a bill and both sides have more or less taken advantage of the voting requirements when it's benefited their agendas. To be obstructive and to announce up front that you aren't even going to consider, debate, or vote on something to me is very telling of the character and honor of the ones obstructing but I digress. I think it's dangerous to allow a faction of our society to make decisions for our country without support of the people through their representatives and to circumvent the rules and processes in order to enact those decisions.
My concern is with the process not the issue, if that makes sense. If the people want to change how to vote laws in then that's a debate we can have and vote on but to give carte blanche to a group because they've decided they know what's best for America is not what our country is about. There are plenty of other countries where that happens and I don't think that's working out very well for their citizens. We cannot pervert our processes and rules because we don't like what the other side is doing. It's painful sometimes and frustrating but we make changes through votes.
Whew....I think I got carried away. lol
My suggestion for improving Citizens United : Along with the media blitz it should include who paid for the message .
I guess that's a start. Happy Valentine's day Petey!
I left a response on your V Day thread :
Petey! You're naughty..........I LIKE it
You're off topic !
On 2nd thought, there are many labor and Obamacare measures that will stand without a majority opinion, plus the fact that the cases where Scalia expressed (even wrote an opinion and voted) will mean nothing because a SCOTUS opinion is not legal until it's officially handed down, that it might do The President of the United States Of America and the American people good. Barack Hussein Obama, should NOT to try to appoint someone right away that the conservatives might like and vote their way. Four to four decisions let the lower court decision stand and that's good for liberals many times in many upcoming decisions.
Then again you never know what you'll get. Ronald Reagen (the 2nd worst President in modern history after W (who at least didn't sell weapons systems to terrorists)) appointed Sandra Day O'Connor and she turned out to be a real friend of the common people.
Let Mitch O'Connell try to stall and hope that a President Trump with nominate Judge Judy to complete the joke and embarrassment of our electoral system to the rest of the world.
I nominate William Jefferson Clinton.