╌>

Here’s one way the GOP might cave in the Supreme Court fight

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  10 years ago  •  18 comments

Here’s one way the GOP might cave in the Supreme Court fight

February 25

So Nevada Governor Brian Sandoval, a Republican, has pulled his name from consideration to replace Antonin Scalia on the Supreme Court. The floating of Sandoval was probably never more than an elaborate trolling exercise aimed at Republicans, but it served as a reminder that, before long, there actually will be a nominee, which will shift the political dynamic. Senate Republicans, of course, continue to vow that this nominee won’t get any hearing, no matter who it is.

But here’s one scenario in which it might be hard for Republicans to sustain that posture.

Let’s fast forward three weeks, to mid-March.

A new Quinnipiac poll today found Donald Trump leading Marco Rubio by 44-28 among likely GOP primary voters in Florida. A second poll today found it much closer, at 34-27, but it is now at least possible that Trump could defeat Rubio in his home state on March 15th, which would seem to put him well on his way to winning the nomination. Even if Trump loses Florida, it’s plausible he could still amass a near-insurmountable delegate advantage by then .

In three weeks, Obama will have picked his nominee. CNN has a short-list of possible picks right here ; it seems likely that he or she will be thoroughly within the legal mainstream — someone such as Sri Srinivasan, who is “ considered a moderate ,” has been praised by Republicans, and was confirmed to the D.C. Circuit by a 97-0 vote. The White House almost certainly does not think Republicans can maintain their no-action posture for too long, so Obama might nominate a moderate on the off chance that he or she might actually get through, allowing him to further shape the Court.

So in three weeks, though this is anything but assured, Trump could be the presumed nominee. If so, all heck will be breaking loose in the GOP asylum, which will be looking more out of control than ever. And Obama will have picked his choice for the Court. Are Republicans really going to continue to refuse to give any hearings to, or even meet with, a moderate Supreme Court nominee at that point?

Maybe. But remember, Republicans themselves worry that if Trump is the nominee, they will be at dire risk of losing the Senate and the White House . That chatter will be a lot louder if Trump looks like he’s got an insurmountable delegate lead. That in turn will give rise to the obvious next question: should Republicans really risk not confirming Obama’s nominee, if it could mean that President Hillary Clinton — her nomination could also look more likely in three weeks — will get to pick Scalia’s replacement, with the help of a Democratic Senate? (If you want more on the various permutations in that scenario, go here .)

Now, it’s possible that even if things do go in this direction, Republicans could continue refusing to hold any hearings, because — as they themselves have revealed — they calculate that so doing could draw more attention to the nominee, making it harder still to oppose that person. But this posture might — might — get tougher once there’s a specific nominee. Combine the media coverage of that nominee’s life story and qualifications with wall-to-wall attention to Trump tightening his grip on the nomination, and reporters might begin asking vulnerable Republican Senators who are up for reelection in Obama states: You really won’t give any hearing to Obama’s nominee, but you’d gladly give a full hearing to President Trump’s pick to replace Scalia, instead?

Obviously they wouldn’t directly answer that question. But the point is that not considering Obama’s nominee at all could become a lot harder to sustain, if and when maximum Trump crazy breaks out.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/plum-line/wp/2016/02/25/heres-one-way-the-gop-might-cave-in-the-supreme-court-fight/?wpmm=1&wpisrc=nl_popns

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    10 years ago

I think that when the President actually appoints a real person, the Senate will be under unbearable pressure to at lest hold a committee hearing or look like partisan hacks in the November election, perhaps costing them the Senate.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago

Your thinking that the nomination of a person has any bearing on what the Senate chooses to do. in reality, it doesn't.

The two portions of this are entirely separate. Millard Fillmore went through three nominations before the senate decided to wait for the incoming president to nominate one who they confirmed. Wasn't Fillmore's fault, his first nominee withdrew after the committee hearings and was told he would be confirmed. Why is a mystery.

The second was an outright rejection, and the third was tabled as too close to the presidential succession. (democrat congress with an incoming democrat president)

The whole process took two years.

The process should run and if they wish to kill his nominee then do it.

It's been done before.

Eventually a nominee will be nominated and confirmed, but that is up to the Senate on how long that will take.

The election isn't going to change that.

Any nominee right now is going to be a purely political nominee, appointed for political reasons and will represent a president and senate that is willing to play politics with the running of this country. which the citizens are used to now after the last seven years.

This is a tempest in a teapot. Neither side gives one hot damn about the damage they can be causing.

And given that truth, the best course just might be to wait a while. Waiting would be in the best interests of the democrats cause it would keep the nomination in question during an election year. Keeping the Supreme court in the discussion adn deflecting some of the attention being paid to the current administrations horrible policies. (if that is even possible) Rushing off to get someone nominated plays right into the republicans hands. as they have been winning elections for seven years now running against anything and everything Obama and the democrats have done said they were going to do, or even hinted at doing. At this nomination, by a lame duck president, is going to be one more thing they can use to build opposition.

(If I was being considered, I would withdraw also, just not worth the political hailstorm that will be throw at any one this president nominates)

That is a track record that cannot be ignored.

If your an honest political analyst.

This is an ANTI-Establishment election, the Democrats (and current president along with the slightly leading candidate) are the establishment in power right now.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

It may well be an anti-establishment election, but there are a lot of establishment GOP Senators up for re-election this year, so this Supreme Court nomination will be made an issue by everyone of their opponent. It's going to have a big impact on the Senate races and outcomes.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

ok.....

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Actually I think the court would improve with the appointment of a moderate.  We seemingly have a 4 conservative to 4 liberal group right now.  Wouldn't it be best to have a moderate that could be capable of voting either way? 

Of course neither side would go for that.......

Happy Friday All.

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

We have four moderates now. {chuckle} two liberals and two conservatives. We also have two hardliners from each side also.

What we don't have (and lost with Scalia's death) is a constitutional originalist.

WE have always had at least one on the court until now. Somehow I don't suspect the constitution will have a voice on the highest court in the land anymore.

And we will be worse off for it.

And happy Friday to you too brother!

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

No we don't have a Constitutional orientalist, but I don't think we need one. The Constitution is a living, breathing and changing thing and we need a Justice that understands that. It's not carved in rock and I believe the Founding Fathers intended it to be flexible and change and advance with the changing time. We need a moderate.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

When you can change the constitution to mean anything you want it to on a whim, can you still say you have a constitution?

The founders were against constitutional interpretation, wrote extensively about the evils of changing it without great pause.

It is why they mandated a process for changing it requiring a super super majority of not only congress but the American people.

And political forces since the beginning have been trying to side step that supermajority requirement ever since. Thomas Jefferson wrote that the constitution is to be interpreted by the meanings in common usage at the time it was written. Otherwise we will lose the ideals that created it. Being classically educated they were well aware of how language meanings change over time. But the ideals contained in it don't and it shouldn't be changed based upon language.

You need a justice that understands this very important point, otherwise, you have a constitution that means only what those nine people says it does. Then you can fundamentally change the nation on the political whims of less than three millionths of the nations population. The ruling body becomes the Supreme Court, A junta passing down edicts, and the other two branches become operatives doing nothing but applying mandates from the nine wise men.

Not a good situation. Predicted by the Founders as something that could happen if we weren't careful. Look like we are there.

The constitution as an ideal must grow and change I agree with the ideal, but the document, if it must change should only be done by a majority of the people.

Not nine men appointed politically for life.

It is not a living document.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Well I'm afraid we're going to have to agree to disagree. I believe it is a living document that must be interpreted in light of the times cases come before the court.

Impasse?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Quote:

I believe it is a ****** document that must be interpreted in light of the times.....

Remove one word and this is a statement I can agree with as long as the original meanings of the words as written are brought forth to today.

I'm not denying that the constitution must change with the times. Neither do the founders.

But the words "Living Document" are a subterfuge used as justification to disguise a rational for a shortcut to changing it other than the intended way.

Every argument concerning and in support of a "Living Document" classification for the constitution makes an argument for rapid change as our societies political whims change. The Founders designed the process to prevent this.

I would choose to go with their wisdom. I choose to give them the benefit of the doubt on this cause they were right in so many other areas that they are considered enlightenment geniuses. And the document they created, with it's imperfections, is still the closest man has ever came to creating a truly free nation.

There has been only one president that ever came close to that level of genius, Abraham Lincoln.

I daresay we will never see another.

I agree to an Impasse, but the impasse is actually over one ideologies belief's that the constitution should be easily changed to suit current societal situations, and the other sides belief's that it shouldn't be easy to change cause doing so destroys the foundation of the society altogether.

I'm on the side that thinks it shouldn't be easy to change.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I agree to an Impasse

Agreed.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Kennedy and Roberts have frequently been the deciding vote with the 4 liberal block. I don't think one of the four liberals has ever joined 4 conservative to make a 5-4 majority, certainly not in a high profile case. There votes are never in doubt. 

With Scalia's loss, the Court has 4 liberals, 2 conservatives and 2 moderates who lean conservative. 

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Sean, your breakdown agrees with mine except for the steepness of political angle leanings. you lean a lot more right than I do.

I'm sure there are some liberals here that would say the exact same thing from the other perspective.

Four conservatives, two moderates and two liberals.

Scalia was considered a hard core conservative by liberals, but (after reviewing his decision history) actually 65% of the time he agreed with the liberal interpretation of issues. The real issue the liberals had with Scalia is that he was a originalist. Scalia would've struck down Roe v Wade, not cause the outcome was wrong, (in fact he made many statements that not legalizing abortions was a societal crime) He vehemently disagreed with the right to privacy created to support a blanket authorization of all abortions of any type for any reason.

Liberals in their zeal to vilify anyone against Roe v Wade, fail to mention that Scalia was an abortion rights supporter. If they acknowledge that, then they have to accept that some limits to abortion are both morally right and lawful.

That is something they will never do, they got a blanket gift from the Supreme Court and will die excusing/defending it. They also know that such gift will only last as long as they maintain a split court. Once the balance shifts one more seat in either direction, the fight is on.

I delve a bit more deeply into such things than most.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Can you identify a single case where one of the liberal moderates broke ranks and provided a decisive vote to the "conservative" side? Being a moderate would entail siding with the other wing of the court on a divisive issue, on occasion. 

It's very easy to identify major cases where Kennedy and Roberts were  swing votes that sided with liberals.

 

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

I only need one.

DC vs Heller.

The four dissenting justices dissented on two grounds: long standing precedent (under US v Miller) and militia requirements.

two of those four justices readily accepted the individual rights interpretation without question and based their dissent on other factors rather than the laws in question did not violate the right to bear arms.

Souter and Ginsberg. (their agreement on the individual right did not overcome the governments right to regulate)

NOTE: Scalia agreed that the government has the right to regulate, but the individual right of a law abiding citizen to own, carry and use a firearm (specifically handguns) cannot be infringed by that regulation.

They signed on to the dissents, (their overriding political belief) but agree with the individual right.

This is why even the ultra liberal 7th circuit (Illinois) struck down Chicago's bans on handguns. And the liberal 9th circuit (west coast) struck down most of California's bans on open carry. (citing both Heller and McDonald) The unconstitutionality of bans is based on the individual right. (which was a 7-2 decision although unstated)

 
 

Who is online





103 visitors