Supreme Court to Hear Challenge to Union Fees
The Supreme Court on Tuesday agreed to decide whether public-sector unions may require workers who are not members to help pay for collective bargaining. A ruling against them could deal a severe blow to organized labor.
The case, Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association, No. 14-915, was brought by California teachers who said that being compelled to pay union fees to subsidize activities they disagreed with violated their First Amendment rights.
Limiting the power of public unions has long been a goal of conservative groups, and they welcomed Tuesdays development.
The question of whether teachers and other government employees can be required to subsidize the speech of a union they do not support as a condition of working for their own government is now squarely before the court, Mark Mix, president of the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation, said in a written statement.
Union leaders expressed alarm at the courts decision to consider the issue.
The Supreme Court is revisiting decisions that have made it possible for people to stick together for a voice at work and in their communities decisions that have stood for more than 35 years and that have allowed people to work together for better public services and vibrant communities, Lily Eskelsen Garca, president of the National Education Association, and other union officials said in a statement.
The challengers said that some collective bargaining with a government employer amounts to lobbying and that forcing them to pay for those activities violates their First Amendment rights.
This is a challenge to the largest regime of state-compelled speech for public employees in the nation, the teachers wrote in a brief urging the justices to hear their case. They are represented by Michael A. Carvin, the lead lawyer in the recent challenge to nationwide tax subsidies under the Affordable Care Act. The court allowed the subsidies in a 6-to-3 decision last week.
The Supreme Court will hear arguments in the case in its next term, which begins in October. The ruling could affect millions of government workers, but is unlikely to have a direct impact on unionized employees of private businesses.
Under California law, public employees who choose not to join unions must pay a fair share service fee, also known as an agency fee, typically equivalent to members dues. The fees, the law says, are meant to pay for collective bargaining activities, including the cost of lobbying activities.
Kamala D. Harris, Californias attorney general, defended the fees in a brief urging the justices not to hear the case.
Mandatory agency fees ensure that all employees in a particular bargaining unit pay a fair share of the cost of the representation, she wrote. They prevent the unfairness and conflict that could arise were only part of the work force to support representation activities that, by law, must advance and protect the interests of every employee.
Agency fees for nonmembers typically consume roughly 2 percent of a new teachers salary, the teachers wrote in their brief. These fees sometimes increase regardless of whether there is an increase in teacher pay. The total amount of annual dues often exceeds $1,000 per teacher.
The teachers acknowledged that nonmembers who ask are entitled to a refund of fees used by the union for purely political activities. The amount of the refund received by nonmembers who successfully opt out each year is generally around $350 to $400, their brief said. They argued that the Supreme Court should at a minimum require that nonmembers should have to opt in before they are charged for such activities.
But the teachers broader claim was that collective bargaining is itself a political activity when the employer is the government.
In this era of broken municipal budgets and a national crisis in public education, the teachers wrote, it is difficult to imagine more politically charged issues than how much money cash-strapped local governments should devote to public employees, or what policies public schools should adopt to best educate children. Yet California compels petitioners to fund a very specific point of view on these pressing public questions.
Nor is California alone, they said. More than 20 other states compel millions of public employees to pay hundreds of millions of dollars to public-employee unions regardless of whether those unions advocate policies the employees support or, indeed, regardless of whether the policies even benefit those employees.
read more at
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/01/us/supreme-court-to-hear-challenge-to-union-fees.html?partner=rss&emc=rss
Tags
Who is online
67 visitors

Another politically charged case before the SCOTUS.
The question seems simple, "Should non-members be required to pay fees to a union?", but it is much more complicated than it sounds and the consequences of the decision will be significant in several ways.