What makes this Supreme Court different from other Supreme Courts? (opinion)
Heres what last weeks U.S. Supreme Court decisions signify: Old America has conceded to the New America.
The New America is the coalition that came to power with President Barack Obama in 2008 and gave him the winning majority. Its a coalition of groups marginalized for most of U.S. history: racial and religious minorities, immigrants, young people, gays, single mothers, working women and unchurched Americans who claim no religious affiliation.
What holds the coalition together is a commitment to diversity and inclusion. Precisely the values the Supreme Court affirmed with its Obamacare decision on Thursday and its gay-marriage ruling on Friday. We finally declared, Obama said , that in America, healthcare is not a privilege for a few but a right for all. Thats inclusion.
Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia testifies before a House Judiciary Subcommittee hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington, May 20, 2010. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is trying to rally the New America behind her candidacy for president. She tweeted the word HISTORY in rainbow colors last week to signify the rainbow coalition.
The Old America capitulated. But not without protest. Justice Antonin Scalia offered this scathing dissent : If I ever joined an opinion for the court that began: The Constitution promises liberty to all within its reach, a liberty that includes certain specific rights that allow persons . . . to define and express their identity, I would hide my head in a bag.
Scalia was expressing contempt for identity politics. Identity politics is at the core of the New America.
The Supreme Court has always been a lagging indicator of political change. It was designed that way. The House of Representatives is the branch of government most sensitive to popular sentiment. Its members are elected every two years. The president is elected every four years. Senators are more insulated. Theyre elected for six years.
Justice James C. McReynolds, who sat on the Supreme Court from 1914 to 1941, was a vehement and determined opponent of President Franklin D. Roosevelts New Deal policies. Courtesy of Library of Congress
Supreme Court justices serve for life. They are not elected, and they cant be recalled. Thats supposed to insulate them from popular pressure. Of course, politics has a lot to do with how justices are nominated and confirmed. But its the politics of long ago. Two current justices (Anthony Kennedy and Scalia) were nominated by President Ronald Reagan in the 1980s. Another, Clarence Thomas, was chosen by President George H.W. Bush in 1991. Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer were picked by President Bill Clinton in the early 1990s.
Altogether, five justices were chosen by Republican presidents and four by Democratic presidents. The Democratic justices picked up one Republican vote on the same-sex marriage decision (Kennedy) and two Republican votes on the health-care decision (Kennedy and Chief Justice John Roberts Jr.). With those rulings, the Republican-majority court granted legitimacy to the New America.
The decisions are being met with resistance, of course. Thats always the case with controversial Supreme Court decisions racial integration in 1954, abortion in 1973. The Republican Party has become a resistance movement determined to disempower the New America. Which raises the stakes enormously for the 2016 election.
Obama was not entirely accurate when he said the court defined healthcare as a right. In its 2012 decision upholding the Affordable Care Act, the court stated that it was not granting any constitutional right to healthcare. It ruled that healthcare is a benefit. The benefit was granted by Congress and the president, and it can be taken away by Congress and the president. Just not by this president.
The leader of the ultraconservative Club for Growth said, Its now up to Congress . . . to repeal Obamacare, and Congress should continue to do so until there is a president who is willing to sign that repeal. All the contenders for the Republican presidential nomination have promised to do exactly that. Repeal can happen if one of them wins the election because then Republicans will almost certainly retain control of Congress. Former Florida Governor Jeb Bush, for example, vowed to repeal and replace this flawed law if he succeeds Obama in the White House.
The White House is illuminated in rainbow colors after the historic Supreme Court ruling legalize gay marriage, in Washington, June 26, 2015. REUTERS/Gary Cameron
Resistance to the same-sex marriage ruling will be more difficult because the court did declare it a constitutional right. Conservatives are now rallying to the cause of religious freedom by arguing that Americans should not be forced to violate their religious convictions by accepting same-sex marriage.
Several states have already passed laws allowing public officials to refuse to authorize same-sex marriages if it offends their religious convictions. Some have passed laws allowing businesses to refuse services to gay couples on the same grounds. Thats discrimination. We already saw a strong blowback from business when Indiana tried to pass a religious freedom law.
Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker , who is a strong favorite of many conservatives, said, The only alternative left for the American people is to support an amendment to the U.S. Constitution. That will never happen when nearly two-thirds of Americans have come to favor same-sex marriage.
The backlash brings to mind an old Arab proverb: Dogs bark, and the caravan moves on. The dogs are barking. But this caravan is moving on.
Tags
Who is online
67 visitors

I found this an interesting analysis of past and the current supreme court. I can't say I agree with everything, but worth reading.
Hal
That is the best and most accurate explanation ofhow "we the people" critique the Supreme Court (and in fact other government organizations).
When they decide as we like "parties and parades", but we disagree with a decision "protests, vitriolic harangues and character assassinations."
Hal,
The perfect description of how SCOTUS is viewed.
Good article FLY.
Nicely done Hal!
Identity politics is at the core of the New America.
Here, the author is correct. That's been the goal of the Democratic party for 40 years. No one is an American anymore. They are black or gay or a woman or a transvestite plumber first and foremost. Their primary allegiance is to their group. It's why the term "melting pot" which was once the highest aspiration of the former American ideal, is now hate speech on liberal controlled college campuses. God forbid an immigrant identify with the country where he lives.
Ask the Roman legions how they fared once they were made up of men who identified with their local tribes rather than Rome. Identity politics do not end well.
Obama was not entirely accurate when he said the court defined healthcare as a right.
"Not entirely accurate" is a Democrat spinning for a lie. Obama's a lawyer, he's knows the Court said nothing of the sort. Kudos to this Democrat for at least pointing out his lie.
Of course, nobody expects honesty from President "If you like your health care plan, you can keep it." Nor did anyone blink an eye when Justice Kagan who testified in 2009 that "There is no federal constitutional right to same-sex marriage."miraculouslyfound this same right last week. Not one commentator I came across from either end of the political spectrum thought there was a chance in hell Kagan was honest or would vote consistently with her prior testimony. She's a liberal justice. Her lies are expected.
That's how we end up where we are today. Not a single rational person believed itpossiblethat any of the fourdemocrats would faithfullyinterprettheConstitutionin line with Kagan's prior testimony. It would be unthinkable. The four aren't actual justices, they are just votes. They vote in line with their party to get the outcome they want. The law isirrelevantto the process.
Resistance to the same-sex marriage ruling will be more difficult because the court did declare it a constitutional right.
Once upon a time, in an intellectually honest America where theConstitutionactually meant something, rights werenot "discovered" by judges after hundreds of years. Five judges didn't wake up one day and didn't miraculously find that slavery wasunconstitutional, or that woman had the right to vote. No, they went ahead andamended theConstitutionbecause they believed that rights had to beenumeratedin the document tobeguaranteed. If a right can be "discovered" it can just as easily be taken away, should five justices have a different policy preference.
TheConstitutionis really an ingenious document, it's too bad we aredeterminedto throw it overboard in favor ofanunrestrained all powerful superjudiciary whose power is essentially unlimited.Rewritea statute ?Sure. Invent new "fundamental" rights? Why not? When the country was a republic, issues like gay marriage could be solved one of two ways. Let popular willmanifestitselfthrough statelaws and on the local level, which has been happening for the last few years, or change theConstitutionitself through an amendment (see slavery). No longer. Issues are removed from the people's hands and are decided by the preferences of 5 unelected justices.
This is how Republics lose their legitimacy and collapse. When citizens feel they have no say in the issues that are important to them, they stop feelingallegianceto a government.
Have a really difficult time understanding how the below translates into - The Constitution promises liberty to all within its reach, a liberty that includes certain specific rights that allow persons . . . to define and express their identity,
THIS is what the Constitution promises - "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America."
Kennedy needs to go back to Cali where his style/modicum of justice is well-accepted.