╌>

(Opinion) How Donald Trump has already shaken U.S. relations with friends a foes

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  flynavy1  •  10 years ago  •  5 comments

(Opinion) How Donald Trump has already shaken U.S. relations with friends a foes

Donald Trump says he doesn’t care what the world thinks of him. The whole world.

Has any presidential candidate ever exhibited such boorishness? Does it matter?

Bad manners are the antithesis of diplomacy. They weaken international coalitions essential to physical security. But then, Trump discounts the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and key bilateral treaties with U.S. allies in Asia and Latin America.

 

Bad manners also undermine economic security. Trump advocates the same beggar-thy-neighbor tariffs that deepened the Great Depression in the 1930s and sparked World War Two.

Strangest of all, Trump delights in offending. This would also make it hard for him to sustain friendships or cooperation with allies that are as proud of their independence — and as sensitive to slight — as Washington is.

Trump demeans Mexico by threatening to build a wall along its border with the United States. He offends France by faulting it for the Charlie Hebdo and concert-hall massacres. He scoffs at Germany’s “ insane ” Syrian immigration policy and affronts Britain by smearing critics there as panderers. He scorns Japanese and Chinese trade policies as rip-offs, and insults all Muslims, a third of the world’s population , by proposing to bar them from the United States.

Foreign nations have not accepted Trump’s disdain with the humility of losers on his reality TV show, The Apprentice . British Prime Minister David Cameron calls the New York real estate developer “ divisive, unhelpful and quite simply wrong .” The French ambassador to the United States dubs Trump a “ vulture ” whose tweet about the brutal Charlie Hebdo attack lacked “human decency.” Many more see Trump as a threat to peace.

If global warming, global terrorism and global economic uncertainty didn’t exist, this might not matter. That’s not today’s world, however. Trump’s contempt feeds enmities that threaten Americans and poisons friendships upon which Washington relies.

 

The institutions that the United States helped build after World War Two are what have kept us from World War Three: the United Nations, the World Trade Organization, NATO and many more. The Great Recession of 2008 did not evolve into another Great Depression because, unlike in the 1930s, central banks around the world pulled together to prevent economic collapse. Without the grease of goodwill, the machinery of cooperation freezes.

Some commentators liken Trump to President Andrew Jackson, a populist who also stoked public anger and invited mobs with muddy boots into the White House. But in foreign relations, the analogy doesn’t hold. In 1828, the year Jackson won the presidency, there was no telegraph, telephone, television or Internet to speed news. Jackson offered no commentary on foreign affairs and no one would have known — or cared — if he had. As a young, weak country, the United States then had few speaking lines on the world stage.

Former Republican presidential nominee Barry M. Goldwater is the better comparison. Like Trump, the Arizona senator brashly wooed controversy. “ Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice ,” he declared at the 1964 Republican National Convention. Goldwater voted against the Civil Rights Act of 1964, opposed mandatory Social Security contributions and commended the extreme right-wing John Birch Society. In foreign affairs, Goldwater praised atomic “brinksmanship,” suggested that NATO’s commander be authorized to use nuclear weapons and advocated “bombing the living hell” out of Vietnam. He rejected peaceful coexistence with the Soviet Union.

In the tightly interconnected world of the 1960s, when the United States aspired to effective leadership of the “Free World,” the Goldwater nomination set alarm bells clanging globally.

 

Soviet premier Nikita Khrushchev called the Goldwater candidacy “a strange phenomena.” A more forthright commentator said Russians “feel they must be on their guard more than ever.”

Allies were blunter. A West German newspaper editorialized that Goldwater would “be more dangerous for world peace than Mao Zedong.” A British editorial warned that if Goldwater tried “to put his policies into effect, the whole Western alliance could be undermined.” One French newspaper commented that the senator sent “cold chills up your back.”

President Lyndon B. Johnson welcomed Goldwater’s challenge. He knew the Arizona extremist would be easier to defeat than anyone else the Republicans could nominate. Johnson’s campaign ran the infamous “ Daisy” commercial — a little girl counts flower petals as she plucks them, which turns into the countdown for an atomic bomb explosion over her head. “These are the stakes,” Johnson intoned.

Goldwater lost. Since then, no candidate has prompted such overt international controversy. Normally, foreign leaders refrain from commenting on U.S. elections, given that they hope to cooperate with whoever is selected.

Goldwater developed a more centrist position over time. Today, he would fit somewhere between Mitt Romney and Senator Rand Paul (R-Ky.) in the GOP. Had he been elected, his policies might have become more sensible than his rhetoric.

The same could be true of Trump, who pledges to be reasonable in office. But Goldwater refrained from ad hominem attacks on nationalities, religions and individuals. The New Yorker has trumped the Arizonan. He has already weakened confidence in, and increased fear of, America. Rebuilding trust will complicate the foreign policy goals he has begun to articulate, including the reform of important institutions and agreements .

If elected, Trump would face animosity whichever border he crossed. Half a million Britons have already signed a petition to ban him . Trump would most likely face long odds in negotiating with foreign leaders, having already flaunted his disrespect.

Average citizens might find themselves similarly disadvantaged. The president is the face of the nation, freely chosen to represent all Americans. Trump’s election would likely place every American serving or traveling abroad in the uncomfortable position of explaining why we picked someone who disses so many.

Perhaps more important, America’s greatest successes have resulted from its ability to inspire. Since 1776, the United States has made democracy look inviting and capitalism attractive. The world has become more stable as a result. Arrogance dims the nation’s appeal as a model, and undermines faith in humanity’s common future.

A remarkable image from the 20th century was the photograph of Earth taken by American astronauts on the moon. It revealed a beautiful blue marble in the immensity of space — and reminded all peoples that the planet isn’t really that big. Getting along is important to security and prosperity.

 

Remarkably, Trump just doesn’t care.

http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2016/03/29/how-donald-trump-has-already-shaken-u-s-relations-with-friends-a-foes/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

A remarkable image from the 20th century was the photograph of Earth taken by American astronauts on the moon. It revealed a beautiful blue marble in the immensity of space — and reminded all peoples that the planet isn’t really that big. Getting along is important to security and prosperity.

Remarkably, Trump just doesn’t care.  (Nor do his supporters which is just as damaging!)

Trump is doing tremendous damage with regards to foreign relations around the globe..... and he is nothing more than a candidate at this point.  To disregard the opinions of the rest of the world places the US, it's citizens, and it's businesses at a disadvantage, and in some cases, danger of attack.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

I love the comparison to Goldwater and the are many similarities, such as isolationism and not caring about the opinions of or cooperation of our allies. Or even their survival. Trump claims "America First" when what he really means is "America Only" and according to right wing Communist Max Boot when it comes to foreign affairs is not only ignorant, but aggressively so. We can not have an isolationist in the White House in today's complicated world. It would bring disaster for us and the rest of our allies, who Trump apparently doesn't care if they survive or drown.

And the most absurd part about Trump being an isolationist is not that that is his plan or ideology, but rather because he is too ignorant, too stupid, to try to learn about foreign policy and Americas place in the world and it's continued operations toward peace and conflict. In short he wants to be an isolationist because he is not smart enough to be anything else. He hasn't the drive or intelligence or desire to be a world leader and that is what we have to have!

Electing Trump would be electing a foreign policy and world policy moron who doesn't even want to try to learn!

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

Trump, NOW wanting to be president is for many of the wrong reasons. 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago

It's is best I stay out of the conversation.

All I can say is I disagree.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Say what you feel my friend.  You and I share and exchange both similar and opposing views all the time.  I don't want that to change as I think it sets a good example around these parts.

 
 

Who is online



Dismayed Patriot


108 visitors