SCOTUS Decisions - Lethal Injection, Redistricting and EPA Regulation
SCOTUS decisions on key cases have been issued -
Supreme Court Refuses to Ban Lethal Injection Drug
The Supreme Court refused Monday to limit states' use of a controversial execution method that opponents have likened to being burned alive.
The court's conservative majority said lethal injection remains the most humane method of execution. During oral arguments in April, they had blamed opponents for exacerbating a shortage of drugs that has forced some states to experiment with less reliable alternatives.
Justice Samuel Alito wrote the decision for the court. All four liberal justices dissented vehemently, and two of them said the entire death penalty likely is unconstitutional.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2015/06/29/supreme-court-lethal-injection/28648145/
Supreme Court Allows Commissions to Draw Congressional Districts
The Supreme Court ruled Monday that states can try to remove partisan politics from the process of drawing political maps.
The decision was a victory for the proponents of independent commissions and a blow for state lawmakers who did not want to be drawn out of the process.
Voters in seven states -- Arizona, California, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, New Jersey and Washington have turned to such commissions in an effort to reduce political "gerrymandering," the map-drawing method that leads to districts easily won by Democrats or Republicans.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2015/06/29/supreme-court-arizona-congress-maps/27400015/
High Court Strikes Down Power Plant Regulations
A narrowly divided Supreme Court struck down federal clean air regulations Monday on coal- and oil-fired power plants that have been on the drawing board for a quarter century.
The 5-4 ruling blocks the Environmental Protection Agency from jump-starting new rules designed to reduce the amount of dangerous mercury and other toxins that pollute the nation's air, at an unknown net cost to power plants and consumers.
It was a major defeat for the Obama administration, which had been on a roll at the high court on environmental matters lately. It was a victory for a coalition of 20 states, along with major electric utilities and coal producers.
The decision was written by Justice Antonin Scalia, with the other four conservative justices agreeing. Justice Elena Kagan wrote a dissent for the four more liberal justices.
At issue was whether the EPA should have considered costs after Congress directed it to take any "appropriate and necessary" action to regulate power plants. The challengers argued that "appropriate" must take cost estimates into account, but the agency did not do so.
While the estimated annual cost of $9.6 billion is not widely disputed, the cost-benefit ratio is. Opponents said the benefits are as low as $4 million a year. Proponents said when all secondary pollutants are considered, they're as high as $90 billion.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2015/06/29/supreme-court-clean-air/28366777/

A busy day for the Nine Wise Ones on the Potomac!
I'm good with their decisions on Lethal Injection and Redistricting, but disappointed on the EPA decision.
All in all, not a bad day.
FLY
The political factions of the nation will see the decisions in much the same light I imagine, except many disagree with the EPA decision will also disagree with the lethal injection decision.
Thanks for the feedback
jennilee
Many see the two issues as distinctly separate, at least I do.
For instance I support the death penalty and a woman's right to choose to have an abortion, even though I have personal reservations about abortion in my own mind.
Cerenkov
I support the death penalty, when guilt is proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
No reasonable person denies that there are flaws in the death penalty process, e.g. there needs to be some reasonable limit to the appeals process (say ten years from date of conviction), there needs to be an automatic and thorough appeal process that is automatic regarding any procedurals flaws and competent counsel issues.
Let the condemned decide, if they cannot or refuse, then the government decides.
Nothing could be worse than allowing unfettered campaign contributions to flow. The districts are only for determining Red or Blue. Flip a coin.
Environmental laws have been rendered inefficacious, by socialindifference and corporate greed, since the seventies. That movement is long time gone. Ironically, the Pope sees it that way too.
O M
Let the condemned decide what? Whether to be executed or how thy are executed? And why should let them decide?
I think you misunderstand the point of the redistricting commissions rather then the party in power doing this, it is will at least to a degree lessen the political impact of redistricting decisions at least in theory.
Many laws and regulations are inefficacious for a variety of reasons - do you think the EPA decision was good or bad?
By the way thanks for feedback and perspective
How they are executed. Gary Gilmore chose the firing squad. No discussion on that method, eh? BANG, he gone.
I know what it means. I could care less how the dogs fight over the scraps. Changing boundaries on a map will never benefit theconstituency. Politics is not about the people.
Anytime pollution standards are relaxed, or in this instance, not reducing these toxins, people will suffer. Suffering is bad. Just ask an asthmatic or someone suffering from mercury poisoning. There are thousands of toxins which are ingested by people every day. New ones are hitting the markets daily and they are totally unregulated. While this decision isdisappointing, it is but a drop in thetoxic bucket we call home.
Of course the coal fired plants are not the only source of those toxins as I am sure you will agree, the scope of this decision is fairly narrow.
Some states have statutes that allow condemned inmates to choose execution method, that is a matter for the states - not the SCOTUS
We will have to agree to disagree on the redistricting decision
Thanks again for all the feedback
Cost has to be a serious consideration.
The Supreme Court ruled Monday that states can try to remove partisan politics from the process of drawing political maps.
The decision was a victory for the proponents of independent commissions and a blow for state lawmakers who did not want to be drawn out of the process.
One of their best decisions of the day. A bi-partisan commissions to draw Congressional districts is much better then the rampant gerrymandering of states who allow their legislatures draw them in their own favor.
Maybe not, if you can show me how "redistricting" a map helps actual constituents in the within the area redrawn.
I can see your point on execution as a state issue. The scotus should decide the areas where states don't or won't make the choices. The chinese use a firing squad. They also use injection. They have one of the highest rates of execution in the world, literally pro's.
However, if there is strong scientific evidence that lethal injection is somehow more or less humane, I'm in. Yet what can be more inhumane than choking at the end of a rope, multiple rounds shredding your heart, electrical overload or the gas chamber?
The humane or inhumane criteria cannot be proven IMO. Cause you have to die to know the answer. And what could be more inhumane than being revived to know the answer?
O M
I am saying that the bipartisan commissions doing the redistricting is an improvement over redistricting being done by the part in power as a "spoils of war" action.
There is a better chance of fair marking of district lines under the commissions than by a partisan legislature.
I'm with you, Fly!
It is disappointing to hear that no measures will be taken to clean up the air, but I can also see that they needed to take the cost effectiveness into consideration. However, what price can one put on someone's health, and how can anyone calculate the cost savings for doing the right thing?
Living in KY as I do, about all we have are coal fired power plants... We also have high rates per capita of respiratory illnesses, etc. A correlation?
The restrictions of this decision on the EPA does not mean
Maybe not as strict or as severe as some think are needed, but certainly not stopping the process. We all tend to overreact to SCOTUS decisions, legislation or executive actions based on where we view the decision from politically.
A reduction (though some think elimination) of carbon emissions is certainly needed, but there needs to be logic and reason behind the path to those goals. But we must not let slowing down the process become stopping the process
pat
I agree
T G D
Totally agree, though I fear that deals will still be made on the bipartisan commissions based on the politics rather than the populace
Here is the latest survey from Gallup on what people think about capital punishment
And some anecdotal input on the SCPTUS decision