╌>

Everyone Said Fiorina Lied About Planned P’hood At GOP Debate- Then THIS Video Was Just Released…

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  3 comments

Everyone Said Fiorina Lied About Planned P’hood At GOP Debate- Then THIS Video Was Just Released…
The Center for Bio-Ethical Reform has released the source video which became a point of controversy surrounding a claim made by Carly Fiorina at the second Republican debate.As reported by Western Journalism, one of the most memorable moments of the debate at the Reagan Library was when Fiorina prosecuted Planned Parenthood for its alleged trafficking in aborted babies body parts.AdvertisementAs regards Planned Parenthood, anyone who has watched this videotape, I dare Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama to watch these tapes. Watch a fully formed fetus on the table, its heart beating, its legs kicking, while someone says we have to keep it alive to harvest its brain, she said. This is about the character of our nation.Fiorinas highly charged and effective attack against Planned Parenthood elicited an almost immediate response from certain media outlets, included some Breitbart characterized as the lying fact-checkers. Many stated that the video Fiorina referenced does not exist.What the candidate does describe is the eyewitness testimony of a woman named Holly ODonnell, who worked in Planned Parenthood facilities as a tissue procurement specialist. She recounts what Fiorina described. To depict the incident ODonnell discussses, the Center for Medical Progress (CMP) used 10 seconds of footage of an aborted baby with its legs kicking and heart beating obtained from the Center for Bio-Ethical Reform (CBR). In the CMP video, the footage is clearly marked as being from CBR, so there was no attempt to deceive.CBR released the full source video on Tuesday, titled Carly Fiorina was right, to prove the baby used to illustrate ODonnells narration was aborted and was still showing the signs of life described.The founder of CBR, Gregg Cunningham, told Fox News on Tuesday: We have incontestably laid to rest the question of whether this is an authentic abortion because we show the abortion.

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    11 years ago

Oh man, just give it up all ready. She lied and all these attempts to, after the fact, put lipstick on that pig of a lie are fooling no one.

Times

Cunningham says he is confident the procedure was an abortion, and not a miscarriage, owing to the lack of medical treatment offered to the fetus. He said he estimated the age of the fetus at about 17 and a half weeks. It is unimaginably more horrifying than the clip that we licensed for CMP to use and that Carly Fiorina made reference to in the debate, Cunningham said.

UPDATE: Hours after the publication of the video, several medical experts raised questions about whether the video showed an abortion or a miscarriage. Current medical guidelines do not call for resuscitation of a fetus at 17 and a half weeks. For a fuller discussion of the accepted medical practice

From the Times update ;

But medical experts who reviewed the video are not so sure. Its possible it could be an abortion and it could be a miscarriage, said Jeffrey Perlman, a neonatologist at Weill Cornell Medical College, after watching the extremely graphic footage on YouTube.

But three leading neonatal doctors and an obstetrician who has studied premature births interviewed by TIME on Tuesday said that medical guidelines do not indicate a need for resuscitating a fetus born so young .

Paul Holtrop, a neonatologist at Beaumont Health System in Michigan, who has published research on the survival rates for infants who have been resuscitated as early as 22 weeks, agreed that doctors would not attempt to intubate or ventilate a baby born at such an early gestational stage. Nobody would resuscitate a baby at 17 and a half weeks, he said. The future is a certain death.

Perlman, who co-chaired a report for the American Academy of Pediatrics on the guidelines for resuscitating infants after birth, also said there would be no expectation of medical care. The lower edge of viability is approximately 23 weeks, Perlman explained. Fetal heart rate is present from very early on. If you deliver and you have a heartbeat that is not inconsistent with a miscarriage.

Jennifer Gunter, an obstetrician who wrote a book, The Preemie Primer, a guide for parents about premature birth, agreed. If you resuscitate before 22 weeks, its because you thought the fetus was older, she said. The survival odds are so dismal.

John Kattwinkel, a professor emeritus of pediatrics at the University of Virginia, who co-chaired the Academy of Pediatrics report with Perlman, also said there is nothing that can be done for a fetus at 17 weeks, though like Holtrop he said he had not seen the video. There is nothing that the medical team should do to prolong the babys clearly non-viable life, he wrote in an email. Fetuses will move and kick and have an audible heartbeat from midway through the first trimester, as any woman who has carried a baby in her uterus knows. And those activities will continue for a time if the fetus is born alive. But no one has ever saved the extrauterine life of a 17 week fetus. We have been able to move the threshold down to 23 weeks in some cases, and some will argue that 22 weeks may rarely be possible . But the chance of survival below that gestation is simply so remote that application of aggressive neonatal resuscitation and intensive care would be not only futile, but cruel.

She lied about what she said she saw in the original films.

Choice denying groups then try to go back in time and make up new films then say, "See this must be what she was talking about", when that just can not be true.

Now this latest yahoo is saying his graphics must be of an abortion because, " no medical help was rendered", while the experts say that's just shit for proof of anything.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I agree. Give it up and get on to something else. The tape that Carly described does not exist. The anti-abortion people have had weeks to prove that it does and they haven't, because they can. You're becoming a one note song and you're off pitch to boot.

And then this tape comes along, which shows an early miscarriage (though the right to life people saying it's an abortion) of a 17 1/2 week old fetus. There is no amount of resuscitation that could magically give that fetus life at that stage of development. Even IF it really is an abortion, then at 17 and a half weeks it is 100% legal under Roe V Wade. No crime was committed and it has nothing at all to do with what Carly says she saw AND heard. Her lie, that she is ticking by, even though it is shown over and over again, is a child's equivalent of someone putting their hands over the ears, closing their eyes and screaming "I can't hear you!" over and over and over again, while stomping their feet a temper tantrum worthy of a five year old. That's not the childishly ignorant reaction you want in a CEO or in a President. No wonder she was fired and no one wants to hire her for anything again. Certainly not for President.

 
 

Who is online







95 visitors