╌>

Ayatollah Roberts and His Sharia Council

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  12 comments

Ayatollah Roberts and His Sharia Council

In the matter of the so-called Affordable Care Act, the Supreme Court ruled that the law must not say what it in fact does say because it would be better if it were not to say what it says and were to say something else instead. In the matter of same-sex marriage, the Supreme Court rules that the law must say what it does not say because it would be better if it were to say what it does not say instead of what it says. Which is to say, the Supreme Court has firmly established that it does not matter what the law says or does not say what matters is what they want.

That texts may be imaginatively interpreted to any end is not news The devil can cite Scripture for his purpose, as William Shakespeare observed in The Merchant of Venice. The legendary constitutional scholar Barack Obama failed to notice, until the day before yesterday, that the Constitution mandates the legalization of homosexual marriage from sea to shining sea, but, to be fair, that is an easy provision to overlook, even for a mind as keen as Barack Obamas, since the Constitution does not say one word about marriage, much less about the state-level codification of homosexual couplings being a fundamental federal right.

Jiggery-pokery is putting it generously.

But scriptural interpretation is a funny business. I grew up on the edges of some wildly entertaining fundamentalist circles in West Texas, and I very much enjoyed hearing mail-order theologians explain how, sometime between turning water into wine at that famous wedding and pouring out a round for the guys at the Last Supper, Jesus very subtly declared alcohol verboten. Put any given text on the rack, and you can prove Ronald Coases dictum: If you torture the evidence enough, it will confess to anything.

Constitutional torture is an art, and Chief Justice John Roberts has emerged as its Andy Warhol: an impresario who will put his name on anything. It is uncomfortable to think about, but our Supreme Court functions in much the same way as Irans Guardian Council: It is a supralegislative body of purported scholars, distinguished by ceremonial black robes, that imaginatively applies ancient doctrines conscious of the present needs and the issues of the day, as the ayatollahs over there and over here both put it, deciding discovering! what is mandatory and what is forbidden as the shifting currents of politics dictate. The main difference is that the Iranians take their sharia rather more seriously than we take our constitutional law: John Robertss opinion in Burwell wasnt just wrong wrong can be forgiven it was embarrassing, craven, and intellectually indefensible. Antonin Scalia was right to let him have it with both barrels, but hed do better to resign from the Supreme Court it is difficult to see how an honorable man could be associated with it.

The idea that lurking in the penumbras of our 18th-century Constitution is a fundamental national right to gay marriage is simply preposterous. It is not there. The gentlemen who wrote the Constitution did not get around to enfranchising women or abolishing slavery, but they snuck in a constitutional right to gay marriage that weve somehow overlooked for 228 years or so: No mentally functional adult, regardless of his views on gay marriage, should be expected to pretend that that is true.

I am in favor of arranging the laws to permit gay couples to arrange their domestic affairs in whatever way they see fit, and to have those affairs blessed by whatever authorities are inclined to bless them: Episcopalian church, Sams Club, Taylor Swift, Grand Mystic Royal Order of the Nobles of the Ali Baba Temple of the Shrine its a free country, Sunshine. Unlike Barack Obama, I did not arrive at my views on same-sex affairs recently and at a moment of political convenience. But, that being said, the idea that lurking in the penumbras of our 18th-century Constitution is a fundamental national right to gay marriage is simply preposterous. It is not there. It is a fiction, and, just like the Harry Potter novels, the fact that it is very, very popular does not mean that it is not fiction.

The ranks of the Right are filled with a splendid array of gifted and erudite lawyers with unshakeable commitment to the rule of law. Many of them are my friends and colleagues. But their arguments always leave me a little bit cold. We can debate all day about how many Angels in America can have their first dance on the head of Anthony Kennedys pen, but we know that the Courts liberals are going to vote one way, that some of its conservatives will probably vote another, and that John Roberts and Anthony Kennedy will, if the goblins in their heads are sufficiently insistent, ratify whatever Starbucks-customer consensus exists for 80 miles on either side of Interstate 95. That the chief justice went one way on health care and another on marriage tells us nothing at all about the law or the Constitution: It tells us about John Roberts.

And that is the problem. Asked what he thought about Western civilization, Mohandas K. Gandhi supposedly quipped that he thought it would be a good idea. Conservatives, if were being honest, might say the same about the rule of law. It would be a good idea, at least an interesting experiment. For the moment, though, theres only power, the men who have it, and the things they do with it.

Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/420406/john-roberts-decision-kevin-d-williamson


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

he idea that lurking in the penumbras of our 18th-century Constitution is a fundamental national right to gay marriage is simply preposterous. It is not there. The gentlemen who wrote the Constitution did not get around to enfranchising women or abolishing slavery, but they snuck in a constitutional right to gay marriage that weve somehow overlooked for 228 years or so: No mentally functional adult, regardless of his views on gay marriage, should be expected to pretend that that is true.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Hail the Caliphate.
 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

The Supreme Court is not a Sophomore "bull session" and the Court does not normallypontificateon issues unless anadversary proceedingis brought before it, in which one party sues the other for damages it has suffered (no "what ifs"). The Court is then able to rule on claims of the litigants, while at the same time deciding on the Constitutional issue raised. No laws of Congress can be overturned unless they are first challenged, usually in lower courts, and a constitutional issue raised.

In the Burwell case the court upheld the Executive's interpretation that the law meant healthcare subsidieswould apply in all states regardless of whether the states set up their own exchanges or not.

In theObergefellcase, they interpreted the 14th Amendment, that equal protection of the law applies to all civil marriage ceremonies, as it did when it was challenged in Loving v Virginia.

The dynamic of our constitutional system is that individuals need not await legislative action before asserting a fundamental right. The Nations courts are open to injured individuals who come to them to vindicate their own direct, personal stake in our basic charter. An individual can invoke a right to constitutional protection when he or she is harmed, even if the broader public disagrees and even if the legislature refuses to act. The idea of the Constitution was to withdraw certain subjects from the vicissitudes of political controversy, to place them beyond the reach of majorities and officials and to establish them as legal principles to be applied by the courts.

Often well-written dissents provide future deciders with the rationale forover-rulinga decision. Thomas (the court can't bestow dignity on you; you must do that for yourself even if you are a slave) and Scalia (you don't need the restriction of marriage; just be a good hippie) took the opportunity ofthisdecision to "wax philosophical" instead of applying Constitutional principles such as the oneexpressed,by Thomas, above. The principle applied by the court was simply to extend the equal protection of marriage laws to those excluded from them.

 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

The precedent a conservative should perhaps bemoreconcerned about (because of its application in such issues as birth control and abortion) is the following:

The fundamental liberties protected by the Fourteenth Amendments Due Process Clause extend to certainpersonal choicescentral toindividual dignity and autonomy, includingintimate choicesdefining personal identity and beliefs.

It recognizes that some choices aretoo private and too personalto be effectively compelled by legislation (no matter any interest of the government in doing so).

 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

The court returned the power to the people and their churches. The onus is back on them to influence what is essentially a verypersonal and intimate choicecentral toindividual dignity and autonomy (a choice which probably does not belong in the government).

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Your grasp on the article resembles Justice Kennedy's understanding of the Constitution. You just project whatever meaning you want on it, regardless.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

No. The issue, if you understand the article or any of the dissents, is not about some favored policy. It's about the very foundation of our jurisprudence. These decisions aren't rooted in the law, their just about imposing favored outcomes.

Of course conservatives should be worried. Justice Kennedy and his imaginary Constitution can do whatever he wants. The vague, meaningless prose he uses as the basis of his decision opens the door for the Court to do anything to any piece of law or the Constitution itself.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

The principle applied by the court was simply to extend the equal protection of marriage laws to those excluded from them


If you believe that, you really, really really, did not understand the dissents. That's a staggeringly terrible summary of the arguements. I hope its out of ignorance rather than done to intentionallymislead.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Is there a slippery slope going on in SCOTUS decisions about marriage ? I think it is unavoidable . There has already been a decision made about polygamy :

The next inevitable step would be group marriage containing an unspecified number of both males & females and no indication at all about sexual preferences .

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

And John, you honestly know nothing about constitutional law nor how legal dissent/concurrence works.

Not a slam - just a comment.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    11 years ago

Citizens United from the mullahs too? Allahu akbar( )

 
 

Who is online




devangelical


82 visitors