Why The Center Matters For 2016
Op Ed by Mack McLarty
The recent headline of a Wall Street Journal/NBC poll seemed to confirm a trending theme in American politics: "Liberals Make Big Comeback in 2015." The story cited polling data showing that 26% of registered voters identify themselves as liberal, up from 23% a year earlier. Conservatives, by contrast, fell to 33% from 37%.
Newsworthy findings, no doubt. But missing from the headline and buried in the numbers was the identity of the largest group of voters found in the polls: those calling themselves moderates. According to the polling analysis by the Journal and NBC News, they've ticked up to 38% of the electorate.
The invisible center
We're now in the season of the invisible center. Media coverage of the early phase of the 2016 presidential race is focused on pressures pushing candidates to the margins. In this narrative, the Democratic Party is leaning left while the GOP field is running right. Incentives to mobilize the base, motivate big money and craft a strong message (and write eye-catching articles) have emphasized competition for the pole positions.
Will these trends hold up over the next 15 months? It's too early to tell. But it would be a mistake to count out the center as a relevant force. First, despite the headlines, the presidential race includes candidates on both sides , including the Democratic front-runner , with records of moderate positions and histories of bipartisan cooperation.
Getting things done
More importantly, the next president, regardless of the outcome, will inherit an inescapable lesson from Washington's current dysfunction: While it's possible to win elections at the extremes, whether in Congress or in presidential primaries, you can't govern from there. A successful campaign strategy, in other words, may not be the same as a successful strategy for governing.
There is a strong case to be made that restoring effective national government is the single most important challenge facing the country. The inability in Washington to get things done has had a devastating ripple effect. It has cost the economy an estimated one percent of GDP, and two million jobs since 2010. It has deepened divisions at home and weakened our national security. It has left old problems unaddressed -- see infrastructure, immigration, education, debt and deficits -- and opportunities unrealized.
Ideological polarization is so closely linked to hapless governance that, to borrow from the wisdom of Geico, "Everybody knows that." Most Americans certainly do. In a recent poll from George Washington University, about 60% of both Democrats and Republicans said they preferred a candidate who would "be the most effective at getting things done in Washington" as opposed to one "whose views most closely match (their) own."
Striking a balance of interests
How can a vital center contribute to better government? Traditionally, the center is where principles and pragmatism have met to solve problems, from budget stand-offs to policy on civil rights, energy and arms control. Solutions to complex issues often involve picking the best ideas from column A and column B. This is the case with immigration reform, for example, which requires border security (column A) and a path to legal status for the undocumented (column B). So too with addressing economic inequality, which calls for growth in private enterprise as well as effective government programs.
A key feature of the center is an ability to strike a balance between competing beliefs and interests. While this kind of exercise has become as rare in Washington as a solar eclipse, you can find it happening frequently in state capitals. Many states are facing difficult and divisive budget choices. Yet in places like Arizona, with a Republican governor, and California, with the ageless Jerry Brown, a Democrat, bipartisan deals have won out. Gov. Brown's job approval has soared to 64%, the highest of his tenure.
The center provides space for discussion, argument, and principled compromise on major issues. Not surprisingly, these traits are also the ingredients for a healthier and more constructive tone in politics. Rather than pitting opponents against each other in an unrealistic game of winner-take-all, the center encourages respect and cooperation. Who wants to take on climate change, the problem of declining middle class incomes, or global security with partial, absolutist positions? The prospects for success would be low.
The center in 2016
Every presidential candidate will be asked over the next months to describe how she or he will "get things done in Washington." With the official launches of their campaigns over the last week, Hillary Clinton and Jeb Bush each proposed a vision not just for addressing the country's problems, but for fixing Washington. Other candidates, and more to come in the days ahead, have done the same. Our current predicament shows that inflexible ideological formulas will make it more difficult to do either.
Many Democratic or Republican voters are among the roughly 43% of Americans who identify themselves "independents." Like many moderates, these voters don't claim to have all the answers -- that's part of their appeal. And a reason they should be heard during the campaign season and deserve a strong voice in Washington.
Mack McLarty was White House Chief of Staff and Special Envoy for the Americas in the Clinton Administration. He is Chairman of McLarty Associates and McLarty Companies.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2015/06/25/the-center-in-election-2016/29237641/

The middle matters in 2016
Now that is good to know and perhaps a harbinger of changes in how Washington works, or maybe not if history is any indicator of the future.
There was an article in the NYT a couple weeks ago about in which HRC's campaign manager talked about how things have changed since 1992, when the independent voter was the target of campaigns. Now they don't care.Mack McClarty is very much a person of the 90s. He's a dinosaur.
She would do much better to adopt the 1992 strategy. She is not a liberal and every time she opens her mouth to spout liberal rhetoric that she has shown in the past that she does not agree with, she simply shows her hypocrisy. Running a centrist campaign is her best hope. Democrats are already going to vote for her no matter what, she'd be better served trying to butter up Independent moderates.
Sean
Well thanks for your perspective
It seems to me that whether things change in Washington in the short term or not, that no one gets elected president without significant support from the "middle"
Interesting that someone is a "dinosaur" and "out-of-touch" because they advocate for the necessity of collaborative government being in the best interest of the country.
that no one gets elected president without significant support from the "middle"
Mitt Romney would beg to differ. He dominated the "independent" vote in 2012, but missed his targets among "conservative" voters, which is why he lost. Obama exceeded his targets among the liberal base. He won. Conservatives didn't like Romney and McCain. Liberals weren't excited by Kerry. They all lost. It's why Jeb Bush has no chance of winning the election, even if he wins a divided primary. Conservatives will sit at home.
Unless you have a crazy set of circumstances as in 2008, the side that energizes its base will almost certainly win.
Interesting that someone is a "dinosaur" and "out-of-touch" because they advocate for the necessity of collaborative government being in the best interest.
The truth on the ground doesn't really care about how things "should" be. I'm talking about the reality of the next campaign, not tooth fairy wishes.
In 2016, moderates don't matter. Actual swing voters are incredibly rare and it makes more sense to focus on voters likely to support a given candidate and get them to vote. Both parties will follow the strategy.
Sean
Your view on the matter is noted as is that of Mack McClarty, who has some experience in the matter, I guess we will see next year.
There is a difference between independents and moderates, the group referenced in the article is the moderates, which can be democrats, republicans or independents.
Chucky
I agree but HRC would say "What difference does it make?"