╌>

Big blow to Republicans and Scott Walker: 'Right to Work' ruled unconstitutional

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  10 years ago  •  12 comments

Big blow to Republicans and Scott Walker: 'Right to Work' ruled unconstitutional

When Scott Walker came into office, he claimed that he had no interest in trying to get “Right to Work” laws passed. Unfortunately for the people of Wisconsin, Scott Walker is a liar and a terrible person.

In fact, he and his fellow Republican legislators introduced an ALEC inspired written bill making Wisconsin a Right to Work state. Since the bill was signed into law, Wisconsin’s workforce has diminished by at least 10,000. Wisconsin is hemorrhaging jobs because Right to Work laws don’t have anything to do with generating living wage jobs, or much in the way of real work, at all. Three unions filed lawsuits against the bill, arguing that the law posed an unconstitutional seizure of union property, and on Friday they received some good news:

Dane County Circuit Judge William Foust agreed. He said the law amounts to the government taking union funds without compensation since under the law they must represent people who don't pay dues. That presents an existential threat to unions, Foust wrote.

"While (union) losses today could be characterized by some as minor, they are not isolated and the impact of (the law) over time is threatening to the unions' very economic viability," he wrote.

This judgement, calling the law unconstitutional on the grounds that it is an “existential threat,” could have some far-reaching ramifications in the many Republican-backed legislatures that really want to put the screws to the working folk of this country. The importance of this ruling also means that there will be further appeals.

Attorney General Brad Schimel promised to appeal the decision and said he was confident it would not stand, noting that no similar law has been struck down in any other state. Schimel, also a Republican, has not decided whether to seek an immediate suspension of the ruling while the appeal is pending, spokesman Johnny Koremenos said.

"We are confident Wisconsin's freedom-to-work law is constitutional and will ultimately be upheld," Walker wrote on Twitter.

Because nothing says leadership like a tweet about your unconstitutional law that is helping to drown your state’s economy. For further discussion go to jpmassar’s diary on this news here.

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2016/04/12/1514205/-Big-blow-to-Republicans-and-Scott-Walker-Right-to-Work-ruled-unconstitutional?detail=email&link_id=3&can_id=c58da4fbb96453573464f49525080008&source=email-major-porn-distributor-delivers-blow-to-north-carolinas-viewing-pleasure&email_referrer=major-porn-distributor-delivers-blow-to-north-carolinas-viewing-pleasure&email_subject=major-porn-distributor-delivers-blow-to-north-carolinas-viewing-pleasure


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    10 years ago

Cry me a river One-Percenters.

If there's an appeal (which is likely) and it is struck down, you'll have to deal with the "injustice" of charging individuals for services from which they benefit directly … but think they should receive gratis.

Think of it as "reality".

I'm willing to have an actual discussion on this … I wonder if it's possible.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    10 years ago

I'm a Manager and I supervise bargaining unit employees so I cannot be represented by the Union.  I still pay dues.  I pay them because as a woman I would most likely not have reached the level that I have without the Union.  I have had several bad Union employees and because I've always worked with the Union and included them in meetings and treated my employees fairly, the Union has ALWAYS backed me when I've had to reprimand one of my employees.  They've sat down in the meetings and succinctly gone through the employee's job description, repeating the task and asking the employee directly "You can do that, can't you?"  Right now I'm working with the Union to reassign one of my employees because they are not capable of performing their current job. 

Not every Union is this accommodating and I can understand how some Unions have created the stereotype that many think of when they hear "Union".  It's dangerous to get rid of workers rights.  It's a tricky balance because there are some Unions that don't always practice or conduct themselves in the spirit of what the Union is supposed to represent.  It should be a unit that both the supervisor and employee can use in order to get the best out of both.

This law, "The right to work law" is specifically for the purpose of crippling the voice of the worker and for giving employers free rein.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

This law, "The right to work law" is specifically for the purpose of crippling the voice of the worker and for giving employers free rein.

And that's the sole reason; the others are bogus.

I represented employees in the way you described; when a client of mine was properly the subject of an adverse action, in the presence of management or its designee, I would apprise the employee of his job description responsibilities and hoped the employee would so acknowledge and promise not to repeat an indiscretion going forward.

There were times when my representation meant assuring due process was followed.

And when management failed to dot the "i's" and cross the "t's" -- I got it on the record and put the handwriting on the wall, that if the case went to arbitration, management would have legal fees to pay … FOR A LOSS!

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago

AH posted this four days ago... Here....

I fully commented on it there from a legal standpoint. (IMHO)

But to simply reiterate, a county circuit judge will certainly have this decision overturned on appeal, I doubt it will arrive at the SC before the lower appellate courts overturn it.

County circuit judges do not have the authority to issue opinion judgments from the bench. They are limited to follow black letter law, subject to appeal.

It will be overturned and remanded to comply with the current law. Think of this as a political stunt by a judge that now sits solidly in the liberal political camp, especially in an election year.

Don't buy into the DailyKoz's hyperbole.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

As an individual and not from a legal standpoint, do you think this is a good law?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Mac knows I'm not a fan of unions. (at least what they are today) So, from my political position what Wisconsin has done is good law. I also know that Wisconsin has been a very hotly contested state politically as a few years back it went through a political switch over from Democrat dominated to Republican dominated and despite every attempt by the Democrats to prevent it or switch it back, the voters have rejected them.

Those voters I suspect are also workers.

We also get a lot of misinformation from both sides the Republican side saying that it is so much better economically in the state afterward and the Democrats are claiming that it isn't. And they both have their experts and statistics and charts that all go to prove their individual positions.

Politically, I would be on the opposite side as Mac. with no resolution so we do not discuss it on a political basis. Legally I can discuss, and if I was wildly wrong Mac would be informing me of such quickly and we would discuss it amicably.

Socially, I think it is wrong headed in the way it is done, but that is the libertarian in me.

So count me as a wait and see opinion, both sides have their good and bad points in this. What I really think is both sides need to adjust their positions to take into account the realities of today.

But good luck getting either side to agree to that.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

As an individual and not from a legal standpoint, do you think this is a good law?

Please see my comment in response to NWM.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

It will be overturned and remanded to comply with the current law. Think of this as a political stunt by a judge that now sits solidly in the liberal political camp, especially in an election year.

If it's challenged on the basis of Constitutionality, I can see it going all the way to the SCOTUS.

To compel an entity to perform services while denying that entity fair compensation is something of a philosophical reciprocal equivalent of "taxation without representation" … that is, "representation without taxation."

I'd like anyone on this board to let me know if/when they will work gratis in any situation other than a charitable or emergency setting. Further, I'd like anyone on this board to tell me why they should receive goods and services without compensating the provider(s) … again, the exceptions being charitable or emergency circumstances.

I challenge any individual on this board who currently is a represented BUT NON-UNION-MEMBER employee (a labor, not a management individual) in a right-to-work state, to voluntarily decline ON PRINCIPLE, any/all UNION-NEGOTIATED wages/benefits/safety conditions, and then stipulate in writing, his permission for his employer to arbitrarily set those conditions regarding his employment.

Please ADDRESS THESE SPECIFICS which are the basis of my position.

As a subject for open philosophical discussion, I offer the following … and ask again why any individual or entity should be compelled under the law, to provide a service without compensation evenly assessed on all the recipients?

THIS MUST BE THE BASIS OF YOUR ARGUMENT BE IT PRO or CON to the question.

Involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  A. Macarthur   10 years ago

If it's challenged on the basis of Constitutionality, I can see it going all the way to the SCOTUS.

That is the issue Mac, as I understand it the issue was never raised in the case in chief as a constitutional issue by the plaintiff. The judge used his constitutional opinion of the law to decide the case. The only way this makes it to the State SC is if the appellate courts follow the trial courts path. Which you know as well as I is specifically barred on many levels. Which from what I can find out is the case here, the Judge applied an impermissible opinion to decide the case it's appealable on it's face and overturnable as a matter of law.

AS far as the other parameters in the question, I don't rise to the qualified level needed to respond.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    10 years ago

I'm going to further split some hairs here …

Besides the U.S. Supreme Court, other proponents of right-to-work laws also point to the  Constitution  and the right to  freedom of association .

They argue that workers should both be free to join unions or to refrain, and thus, sometimes refer to non-right-to-work states as "forced unionism" states. These proponents argue that by being forced into a collective bargain, what the majoritarian unions call a fair share of collective bargaining costs is actually "financial coercion and a violation of  freedom of choice ."

An opponent to the union bargain is forced to "financially support an organization they did not vote for, in order to receive monopoly representation they have no choice over." [14]

_____________________________________________________________________________

Then let such a "represented-with-no-choice individual" bring suit as a token-claimant CONTENDING A "CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT" TO REFUSE REPRESENTATION AND CORRESPONDINGLY-WON BENEFITS, AND, IN GOING FORWARD, BE GIVEN THE RIGHT TO NEGOTIATE SEPARATE AND APART FROM ANY/ALL COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENTS.

What if such an individual had to testify under oath as to why he/she was unwilling, in conjunction with viewing "fair share" as "unconstitutional," to state unequivocally as to why she hasn't simply sued for total disassociation with the union, etc. in question?

It is one thing to do, as some California teachers have done, to try to avoid paying a "fair share" claiming First Amendment violations, BUT, QUITE ANOTHER TO SUE FOR THE RIGHT TO BE NON-REPRESENTED. 

What if a given bargaining agent sued to cut the "fair share" folks loose … 

What if any provider of goods or services declined to provide either in the absence of agreement by the recipients to pay? OH! ISN'T THAT THE WAY IT WORKS IN REALITY?

Go figure.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

It's a liberal county judge. It's meaningless. It's just like the time the county judge  ruled his public sector union reforms were unconstitutional. 

The Wisconsin Supreme Court will overturn this ruling too. 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

It's a liberal county judge. It's meaningless. It's just like the time the county judge  ruled his public sector union reforms were unconstitutional. 

The Wisconsin Supreme Court will overturn this ruling too. 

We'll see; you may be correct … on the other hand … there are other strategies.

 
 

Who is online






92 visitors