MSNBC's Chris Matthews Appears Perplexed by Actual Tolerance
“You're not driving me into some ditch here, Chris,” stated John Kasich to Chris Matthews on Thursday evening, after being badgered with repeated questions about his position on gay marriage.
Matthews started his interrogation by asking Kasich what he thought about the topic since, according to Matthews, there were a lot of Republicans in New York who are not socially conservative. Kasich responded by saying he believed in traditional marriage between a man and woman, but there needed to be a balance: “There is a conflict to some degree between people practicing their deeply held religious beliefs, which they have a right to do, and the issue of discrimination against somebody that they think is doing something inappropriate. That has to be balanced.”
It did not seem like Matthews found that answer to be satisfactory since the host ratcheted up the attacks. “Do you tolerate same sex marriage?… Do you tolerate it,” Matthews pressured. Kasich defended himself by pointing out the fact that he attended a gay wedding and the couple knew how he felt. This ability to both attend a gay wedding while still believing in traditional marriage perplexed the ultra-liberal Matthews.
Matthews then tried to railroad Kasich by asking what a gay couple should do if they loved each other. The presidential candidate said they should continue to love each other and went on to explain how he tolerates gay marriage. “I’m also a believer that if I don't like what somebody is doing, I have a couple of things I can do. I can tolerate it. I can say something. Or I have another thing I can do. I can pray for a person. That’s another thing I can do. Okay so, you're not driving me into some ditch here, Chris.”
Chris Matthews, a man who takes every chance he can to paint Republicans as bigots, could not wrap his head around a Republican tolerating something they didn’t believe in. “But the fact that you would go to a gay wedding and help celebrate it with people and you would say “I believe in traditional marriage.” I don’t—I still don't get your exact position.” The pair soon moved on to another topic.
Contrary to popular belief on the left, it’s possible for someone to not agree with something and still tolerate its existence, like a difference of opinion.
Transcript below:
AD FEEDBACK
MSNBC
Kasich Town Hall
April 14, 2016
7:27:45 – 7:30: 45 PM Eastern
CHRIS MATTHEWS: But a lot of women may be fiscally conservative like you. They may be worried about taxes like you, and they're conservative, except on these social issues. They are pro-choice in many cases, because in the end –
JOHN KASICH: That's divided, okay.
MATTHEWS: It's divided but a lot of republican women are pro-choice, in this state I can tell you. And there are a lot of women who say, “you know, I’m straight, I'm married to my husband, I'm happy, that’s a traditional marriage, but the fact that two guys or two women get married doesn't affect me any.” What’s your view on those subjects?
KASICH: Well you know, I support traditional marriage.
MATTHEWS: What’s that mean?
KASICH: Between a man and a woman.
MATTHEWS: Yeah, well I know that. But—
KASICH: Let me finish.
MATTHEWS: [Inaudible] What-- exclusively to them?
KASICH: No, I’ve said the court has ruled and we're not going pass any laws now. It's in place. See, there is an issue here, though, that I keep wading into, people ask me.
Look, Chris, we have -- there is a conflict to some degree between people practicing their deeply held religious beliefs,…
MATTHEWS: Sure.
KASICH: …which they have a right to do,…
MATTHEWS: I agree.
KASICH: …and the issue of discrimination against somebody that they think is doing something inappropriate. That has to be balanced. And what I've tried to argue is everybody just take a breath. And let's just try to understand one another a little better and be more tolerant, because once you write a law, then they-- you keep rewriting the laws. Because you never get this right.
MATTHEWS: Do you tolerate same sex marriage?
KASICH: Yeah, I’m not going to—yes.
MATTHEWS: Do you tolerate it?
KASICH: I went to one!
MATTHEWS: I know you did.
KASICH: Yeah, I don't think it's right. And the wedding that I went to, they know I don't agree with them.
MATTHEWS: What should gay people do, who love each other?
KASICH: What should they do?
MATTHEWS: If they love each other, what should they do?
KASICH: Well, they should love one another, that’s the end of it.
MATTHEWS: But not get married?
Tell the Truth 2016
KASICH: I've given you the answer. I believe in traditional marriage. I've accepted the court ruling.
MATTHEWS: I know, I’m just asking.
KASICH: So wait, here is the thing. There could be an effort to pass a constitutional amendment. I'm not for doing it. I'm for moving on.
MATTHEWS: Yeah.
KASICH: You know what? I'm also—I’m also a believer that if I don't like what somebody is doing, I have a couple of things I can do. I can tolerate it. I can say something. Or I have another thing I can do. I can pray for a person. That’s another thing I can do. Okay so, you're not driving me into some ditch here, Chris.
MATTHEWS: No, I'm not trying to.
KASICH: You’re not going to.
MATTHEWS: I’m not trying to. Let me ask you about—Ditches are usually selected by the candidates.
KASICH: Yeah. It is. It is. [Laughter]
MATTHEWS: Because I think it was interesting that you would go to a gay -- this isn't my special field of interest. But the fact that you would go to a gay wedding and help celebrate it with people and you would say “I believe in traditional marriage.” I don’t—I still don't get your exact position. Would you like to change the law? http://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/nb/nicholas-fondacaro/2016/04/14/chris-matthews-perplexed-actual-tolerance
Matthews started his interrogation by asking Kasich what he thought about the topic since, according to Matthews, there were a lot of Republicans in New York who are not socially conservative. Kasich responded by saying he believed in traditional marriage between a man and woman, but there needed to be a balance: “There is a conflict to some degree between people practicing their deeply held religious beliefs, which they have a right to do, and the issue of discrimination against somebody that they think is doing something inappropriate. That has to be balanced.”
It did not seem like Matthews found that answer to be satisfactory since the host ratcheted up the attacks. “Do you tolerate same sex marriage?… Do you tolerate it,” Matthews pressured. Kasich defended himself by pointing out the fact that he attended a gay wedding and the couple knew how he felt. This ability to both attend a gay wedding while still believing in traditional marriage perplexed the ultra-liberal Matthews.
Matthews then tried to railroad Kasich by asking what a gay couple should do if they loved each other. The presidential candidate said they should continue to love each other and went on to explain how he tolerates gay marriage. “I’m also a believer that if I don't like what somebody is doing, I have a couple of things I can do. I can tolerate it. I can say something. Or I have another thing I can do. I can pray for a person. That’s another thing I can do. Okay so, you're not driving me into some ditch here, Chris.”
Chris Matthews, a man who takes every chance he can to paint Republicans as bigots, could not wrap his head around a Republican tolerating something they didn’t believe in. “But the fact that you would go to a gay wedding and help celebrate it with people and you would say “I believe in traditional marriage.” I don’t—I still don't get your exact position.” The pair soon moved on to another topic.
Contrary to popular belief on the left, it’s possible for someone to not agree with something and still tolerate its existence, like a difference of opinion.
Transcript below:
AD FEEDBACK
MSNBC
Kasich Town Hall
April 14, 2016
7:27:45 – 7:30: 45 PM Eastern
CHRIS MATTHEWS: But a lot of women may be fiscally conservative like you. They may be worried about taxes like you, and they're conservative, except on these social issues. They are pro-choice in many cases, because in the end –
JOHN KASICH: That's divided, okay.
MATTHEWS: It's divided but a lot of republican women are pro-choice, in this state I can tell you. And there are a lot of women who say, “you know, I’m straight, I'm married to my husband, I'm happy, that’s a traditional marriage, but the fact that two guys or two women get married doesn't affect me any.” What’s your view on those subjects?
KASICH: Well you know, I support traditional marriage.
MATTHEWS: What’s that mean?
KASICH: Between a man and a woman.
MATTHEWS: Yeah, well I know that. But—
KASICH: Let me finish.
MATTHEWS: [Inaudible] What-- exclusively to them?
KASICH: No, I’ve said the court has ruled and we're not going pass any laws now. It's in place. See, there is an issue here, though, that I keep wading into, people ask me.
Look, Chris, we have -- there is a conflict to some degree between people practicing their deeply held religious beliefs,…
MATTHEWS: Sure.
KASICH: …which they have a right to do,…
MATTHEWS: I agree.
KASICH: …and the issue of discrimination against somebody that they think is doing something inappropriate. That has to be balanced. And what I've tried to argue is everybody just take a breath. And let's just try to understand one another a little better and be more tolerant, because once you write a law, then they-- you keep rewriting the laws. Because you never get this right.
MATTHEWS: Do you tolerate same sex marriage?
KASICH: Yeah, I’m not going to—yes.
MATTHEWS: Do you tolerate it?
KASICH: I went to one!
MATTHEWS: I know you did.
KASICH: Yeah, I don't think it's right. And the wedding that I went to, they know I don't agree with them.
MATTHEWS: What should gay people do, who love each other?
KASICH: What should they do?
MATTHEWS: If they love each other, what should they do?
KASICH: Well, they should love one another, that’s the end of it.
MATTHEWS: But not get married?
Tell the Truth 2016
KASICH: I've given you the answer. I believe in traditional marriage. I've accepted the court ruling.
MATTHEWS: I know, I’m just asking.
KASICH: So wait, here is the thing. There could be an effort to pass a constitutional amendment. I'm not for doing it. I'm for moving on.
MATTHEWS: Yeah.
KASICH: You know what? I'm also—I’m also a believer that if I don't like what somebody is doing, I have a couple of things I can do. I can tolerate it. I can say something. Or I have another thing I can do. I can pray for a person. That’s another thing I can do. Okay so, you're not driving me into some ditch here, Chris.
MATTHEWS: No, I'm not trying to.
KASICH: You’re not going to.
MATTHEWS: I’m not trying to. Let me ask you about—Ditches are usually selected by the candidates.
KASICH: Yeah. It is. It is. [Laughter]
MATTHEWS: Because I think it was interesting that you would go to a gay -- this isn't my special field of interest. But the fact that you would go to a gay wedding and help celebrate it with people and you would say “I believe in traditional marriage.” I don’t—I still don't get your exact position. Would you like to change the law? http://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/nb/nicholas-fondacaro/2016/04/14/chris-matthews-perplexed-actual-tolerance

North Carolina CONSERVATIVES passed a law making it impossible for gay and lesbian individuals to sue for "discrimination".
The shit-for-brains who came up with that piece of crap call it "protecting RELIGIOUS FREEDOM"!
Really?
What if the next time a Jew or Muslim is denied EQUAL PROTECTION UNDER THE LAW IN NORTH CAROLINA, he or she finds he can't bring suit because a Christian store owner "justified" the act of discrimination as one of "religious freedom".
"I DON'T SERVE JEWS BECAUSE THEY DON'T ACCEPT CHRIST AS THE MESSIAH"!
"I DON'T SERVE GAYS BECAUSE THEY DON'T FOLLOW CERTAIN TENETS OF CHRISTIANITY"!
Is that your idea of "tolerance" XX?
Don't duck this with your emoticon, childish cop outs … give me a specific response.
North Carolina allows Jews in their state? Wow! Has anyone told the right wing Christians yet?
North Carolina allows Jews in their state?
Well, The Vatican just did -- so why not North Carolina?
Just days before the New York primary, Bernie Sanders traveled today from New York City to Rome to attended a conference hosted by the Vatican on the urgency of building a “moral economy.”
During his remarks, the Brooklyn-born Jewish senator quoted the teachings of Pope Francis several times, noting what the pontiff has said about the idolatry of money and needing to create an economy that distributes wealth more evenly to all working families.
That's true, but I don't think Pope Francis is an Evangelical Pope.
On a side note, I like this Pope. He's a breath of fresh air the Catholic church really needs.
I hope you don't mind if I chime in here.....
Bakers shouldn't have to bake a cake for certain other people if they have objections to certain other peoples religious beliefs, sexual habits or co-habitations. And this objection is based upon their (the bakers) personal religious beliefs, sexual habits or co-habitations.
So this implies two things,
So if this is the actual case, it should hold that such practice is done in a wide variety of services.
Religious Hospitals for instance, is there any that are advocating that gay people not be treated when they need treatment? Refusing to treat (provide services) to gay people?
Not if they wish to remain a hospital.
Auto Repair Services? do they refuse to repair gay peoples autos when they need such? None that I have ever seen.
Real Estate Offices? Not if they wish to remain in the property sales business.
Catholic community services? do they refuse serving gay people?
Church Food Banks, do they turn away the hungry gay person?
Baking a cake for hire is a service. The act of baking the cake may be an art, but selling it for profit is a service provided to those who can pay for it.
AND under the law cannot be restricted by religious belief.
NOW if they decide to become the church's baker and bake their cakes sponsored by the church for a religious ceremony devoted to the church, they may have an argument they can win.
But once they distribute their service to anyone outside the church, they then haven't a legal leg to stand on.
Besides being morally wrong. Whatever happened to the christian belief of taking the morally high road?
Can anyone answer that for me?
Anyone wish to share a bagel?
Baking a cake for hire is a service. The act of baking the cake may be an art, but selling it for profit is a service provided to those who can pay for it.
And at that point the cake becomes not as much a work of art, as much as a product. I can't find anything wrong with your argument.
I guess Kassich thinks that if he prays for the gays who aren't allowed to be married, then God will somehow save them from hospital visitation rules, and will magically make their taxes work out better than if they filed a joint return, and maybe God will even let the males get pregnant so that they won't be turned down by the adoption agency.
My suggestion to candidates running for office : If prodded to answer questions about tiny minorities say that it is not an important issue to the majority of voters .
EEK, don't say THAT... Say something else that is kind and concerned!!!
My suggestion to candidates running for office : If prodded to answer questions about tiny minorities say that it is not an important issue to the majority of voters .
I think what most of them do is look at what their pollsters tell them. Then they say things that they think will gain them more support than it will lose them. (If they take a strong stand on an issue, it will please a lot of votrs, but also alienate some other group). So they play politics, although some are more sincere than others.
Liberals don't understand tolerance. If I am an atheist, it doesn't mean I want to attack religious people. But, to a liberal, it does...
Liberals don't understand tolerance. If I am an atheist, it doesn't mean I want to attack religious people. But, to a liberal, it does...
Another "tolerant" conservative who knows the minds and hearts of all of whom he stereotypes.
In case you aren't aware : your comment is intolerant, cannot possibly be based on an accurate, systematic accounting, and … is an example of an …
Hit a nerve, did I? I'm not surprised. Thanks for the pedantic reply though; it amused me.
Hit a nerve, did I? I'm not surprised. Thanks for the pedantic reply though; it amused me.
Yes! Ridiculous generalizations posited as irrefutable truth is indeed un-nerving!
Amusement in this case = Whistling passed the grave yard.
Hmm... over-generalization or a simple opinion? Maybe you are too quick to jump to judgment? I hope we can learn something from this exchange.
I agree. But let's not go overboard criticizing Amac.
I agree. But let's not go overboard criticizing Amac.
When one makes it ad hominem … he's lost the argument.
Then you have list every argument you've engaged in here.
If I am an atheist, it doesn't mean I want to attack religious people.
I think that's a bit of an over-generalization. Some do, some don't.
And similarly, if someone is a religious person-- it doesn't necessarily mean they want to attack Atheists!
Yes, that's correct. I wish that attitude was more prevalent.
I think that's a bit of an over-generalization. Some do, some don't.
I would tend to agree with that. To some atheists believing in a god is almost as insulting as being an atheist is to a person of faith. Most of the time I don't care. I think most people would just prefer to be left alone.
Well said.
Liberals don't understand tolerance.
I'm a liberal and very tolerant. So are my friends on the right center and fellow liberals. Otherwise they wouldn't remain my friends.