╌>

Court's Overreach On Same-Sex Marriage Jars Democracy

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  23 comments

Court's Overreach On Same-Sex Marriage Jars Democracy
A divided Supreme Court leaned left in voting 5-4 to legalize same-sex marriage across the nation. APA divided Supreme Court leaned left in voting 5-4 to legalize same-sex marriage across the nation. AP View Enlarged ImageJustice: Not surprisingly, the Supreme Court's decision to make same-sex marriage the law of the land left gay rights groups and their supporters overjoyed. But this wasn't about gay rights; it was again about judicial overreach.Is there no corner of human thought or behavior that the U.S. Supreme Court doesn't believe it can control by legislating from the bench?Can the nine justices who sit on our nation's highest court simply mandate that all discussion on such contentious topics such as gay marriage be now and forever closed?Do five men and women believe they can rewrite traditions dating back thousands of years with a few strokes of their mighty pens?Apparently so. So much for our democracy."The limitation of marriage to opposite-sex couples may long have seemed natural and just, but its inconsistency with the central meaning of the fundamental right to marry is now manifest," the majority wrote in its 5-4 Obergefell v. Hodges opinion, which says that the 14th Amendment includes the right for same-sex couples to get hitched.That word "manifest" is key. It means that, for all intents and purposes, the court has spoken on this issue. No more discussion allowed. President Obama piped up with his own opinion: "We are all more free."Sorry, Mr. President, but we aren't. The court's 5-4 decision was wrong, and not because it gave gays the right to marry. The fact is, before this ruling, 37 states already had some kind of law making gay marriage legal. This had always been an issue for the states. Now, no dissent. What happened to the 10th Amendment?They took a serious social issue, one that states, religious institutions and individuals were grappling with successfully, and said, instead of democracy, there is now only one opinion: the court's. So much for freedom of religion. So much for freedom of speech.Or, as Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in his dissent, "Aside from undermining the political processes that protect our liberty, the decision threatens the religious liberty our nation has long sought to protect."Thomas reminds us that marriage isn't merely a civil institution but a religious one as well. Indeed, throughout history, the civil institution largely existed to validate, strengthen and protect the religious institution.Now the federal government will instruct religions what to do and whom they must allow to be married and under what conditions. A clash is inevitable.Justice Samuel Alito made plain that the decision "will be exploited by those who are determined to stamp out every vestige of dissent." Those who continue to believe gay marriage is wrong, he added, "will risk being labeled as bigots and treated as such by governments, employers and schools."Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/062615-759348-supreme-court-granted-rights-to-one-group-took-rights-away-from-everyone-else.htm#ixzz3eF1iaIHZ Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

The dynamic of our constitutional system is that individuals need not await legislative action before asserting a fundamental right. The Nations courts are open to injured individuals who come to them to vindicate their own direct, personal stake in our basic charter. An individual can invoke a right to constitutional protection when he or she is harmed, even if the broader public disagrees and even if the legislature refuses to act. The idea of the Constitution was to withdraw certain subjects from the vicissitudes of political controversy, to place them beyond the reach of majorities and officials and to establish them as legal principles to be applied by the courts.

Often well-written dissents provide future deciders with the rationale forover-rulinga decision. Thomas (the court can't bestow dignity on you; you must do that for yourself even if you are a slave) and Scalia (you don't need the restriction of marriage; just be a good hippie) took the opportunity ofthisdecision to "wax philosophical" instead of applying Constitutional principles such as the oneexpressed,by Thomas, above. The principle applied by the court was simply to extend the equal protection of marriage laws to those excluded from them.

 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

The precedent a conservative should perhaps bemoreconcerned about (because of its application in such issues as birth control and abortion) is the following:

The fundamental liberties protected by the Fourteenth Amendments Due Process Clause extend to certainpersonal choicescentral toindividual dignity and autonomy, includingintimate choicesdefining personal identity and beliefs.

It recognizes that some choices aretoo private and too personalto be effectively compelled by legislation (no matter any interest of the government in doing so).

 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

You are free (the government protects your right) toproselytize, eventocounselyour gay friends, against gay marriage, as long as you don't expectthe governmentto support your cause bydenyingequal rights to anyone.

The reason the "free exercise of religion" protections are in the same Constitutional amendment as the "free speech and assembly" one is that religion is freedom ofthought, belief or idea. If you are religiously opposed to same-sex marriage (or birth control, or abortion) your remedy is in your freedom to influencethe choiceof those considering it, not in mandating their behavior using legislation.

Keep your sacraments out of the government and the government will stay out of your sacraments.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Nothing says democracy like "you two consenting adult lovers can enjoy all the benefits of marriage, but you two can't."
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Or you three can't.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Apparently not.
 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

Or you three can't.

Should the government extend marriage to three people, the protection of that law will extend equally to gay partners. For the time being, the laws werenot changed, but the existing laws were simply applied equally.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Don't waste your time explaining - conservatives equate same sex relations with everything from child rape to sheep rape.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Nice exaggeration and ad hominem. I exoected no better. Bestiality and pedophilia do not involve informed consent. Plural marriage does. Same sex marriage arguments apply to adult plural marriages equally. After all, gay people were always allowed to marry the opposite sex.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Plural marriage has about as much to do with same sex marriage as raping sheep. You know this, but it doesn't stop you from making the comparison anyways.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
By your logic, the concept marriage itself is a slippery slope.What do you think about your neighbor's bedroom preferences with his wife? How does it feel that your marriage to your wife is exactly equal to his marriage to his wife, even though she performs oral sex on him and he performs anal sex on her?
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Why are you changing the subject of our dialogue?

"It's the slippery slope from one abomination and abnormal behavior being condoned by the regime to allowing more evil behavior as allowed private choices."

By "abomination and abnormal behavior", I assume you are talking about things gay people do, like blowjobs and anal sex, right? Truth is, when you allow a heterosexual couple to get married, you are almost always letting a person who has had a penis in their mouth into your club, and in a certain percentage of them you are allowing practitioners of anal sex into your club. Marriage is a slippery slope.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
You just don't want to admit to the validy of my comment. Heterosexuals engage in the exact same behaviors that you consider immoral and deviant, and you have no problem with them getting married. That is hardly a meaningless derailment.
 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

What the hell are same-sex marriage jars and what do they have to do with democracy? Personally, I prefer Mason jars for canning purposes, but hey, that's just me.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Don't you just love it when one person can decide how 315,000,00 people have to live. Unfortunately the Supreme court has no power to do what they have done. That right is left to the states according to the Constitution, but what is the Constitution these days?

I wouldn't have been happy if the results have been exactly opposite since it's not their place to do it either way. Precedence has eliminated one more paragraph in the Constitution.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Where the hell was your line of thinking when Citizens United passed 5-4. If I recall you were singing the praises of that decision. Now honestly, between the two decisions, which one has more impact on American citizens now and into the future? I can hardly wait to hear your answer and defense of your position.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
No, America would be less great if either heterosexuals or homosexuals were denied the rights and privileges that come with marriage. It just got better.
 
 

Who is online







70 visitors