Police-State Attorneys General Cheered By Left, May Be Sued By Right
With recent brazen attacks on free speech and property rights, certain leftwing state attorneys general are perhaps better called “police-state attorneys general.” While their abuse of power to investigate conservative speech to silence it is applauded by their comrades on the left, they are likely to spawn a cottage industry of aggressive conservative litigators specializing in what are called Section 1983 lawsuits.
California Attorney General Kamala Harris sent 11 agents to raid the home of filmmaker David Daleiden, who exposed Planned Parenthood’s selling of baby parts. The alleged violation constituting probable cause to invade Mr. Daleiden’s home was that he falsified a driver’s license.
Pro-life protesters gathered recently to demand that Harris resign. Over at the Los Angeles Times, Robin Abcarian writes, “Abortion foes want Kamala Harris to resign – for doing her job.”
Doing her job? How many home invasions are done by Kamala Harris – or any state attorney general, for that matter – over a falsified driver’s license? Abcarian and the LA Times would assuredly be calling for the head of a Republican AG who raided homes of illegal aliens under such pretenses.
The phrase, “a man’s home is his castle,” dates back to before the founding of America, reflecting a near-sacrosanct core of one of the greatest protections of liberty and property rights we have. The Fourth Amendment is the single-most important protection against a police state because it is designed to prevent what is otherwise criminal trespass on private property by the government. It also prevents larceny by the government – the taking of our papers and effects, or what comedian George Carlin called our “stuff” – without consent or legal justification.
Daleiden said the agents took his computer that had unreleased footage and even his phone. While some like Ms. Abcarian are cheerleading for Harris, the left’s grand defenders of the media’s First and Fourth Amendment rights have been conspicuously silent. So much for principles.
Harris was also recently exposed for other civil rights abuses in a lawsuit by Americans for Prosperity Foundation. In what appears to be a violation of the law of the land protecting private association expressed in the landmark case NAACP v. Alabama, Harris is demanding that charities disclose to her their top donors listed on a confidential federal tax return schedule. Federal tax law provides civil and even criminal penalties for both federal and state officials who inspect or disclose that confidential federal tax return information without express authorization under the tax code.
Not only does it appear that Ms. Harris acquired and inspected this information without legal authorization under federal law, her office made publicly available the names and addresses of donors to over 1,700 charities. There are felony penalties for government officials who disclose such information.
Ms. Harris is not alone among state attorneys general in her police-state approach to “doing her job.” She has joined nearly 20 others in an investigation of ExxonMobil about its speech and publication about climate change. Leftwingers such as Robert Kennedy, Jr., Bill Nye the “Science Guy,” and a host of taxpayer-funded university professors such as Jagadish Shukla actually want “climate-change deniers” to go to jail.
The Wall Street Journal reported that some of these state attorneys general gathered with a dozen leftist activists “committed to prevent the fossil fuel industry from crossing the red lines for a just and livable planet.” In January at the Manhattan headquarters of the Rockefeller Family Foundation on scenic Riverside Drive they hatched a plan to use RICO lawsuits against climate-hysteria skeptics.
The attorneys general then held a press conference announcing they would “creatively” and “aggressively” use the powers of their offices for their policy response on climate change. Virgin Islands AG Claude Walker even pledged to do something “transformational.” Previously a lawyer within a host of federal agencies, Walker obviously isn’t lacking hubris.
After several AGs launched investigations of Exxon under the pretext of their state law enforcement powers, Walker issued a judge-less administrative subpoena to free-market think tank Competitive Enterprise Institute for its research, op-eds, speeches, and publications about climate change.
A federal statute, Section 1983 of U.S. Code Title 42, authorizes lawsuits against these officials personally. The pertinent parts read:
“Every person who, under color of any statute, ordinance, regulation, custom, or usage, of any State or Territory or the District of Columbia, subjects, or causes to be subjected, any citizen of the United States or other person within the jurisdiction thereof to the deprivation of any rights, privileges, or immunities secured by the Constitution and laws, shall be liable to the party injured in an action at law, suit in equity, or other proper proceeding for redress … .”
These police-state attorneys general are infringing on rights of free speech and overstepping their bounds in violation of the 4th Amendment prohibiting unreasonable searches and seizures, all for viewpoint discrimination, which is disagreement with the message conveyed. Discovery in lawsuits against these police-state attorneys general will likely uncover more violations of the law than just their constitutional violations. http://www.cnsnews.com/commentary/mark-fitzgibbons/police-state-attorneys-general-cheered-left-may-be-sued-right
California Attorney General Kamala Harris sent 11 agents to raid the home of filmmaker David Daleiden, who exposed Planned Parenthood’s selling of baby parts. The alleged violation constituting probable cause to invade Mr. Daleiden’s home was that he falsified a driver’s license.
Pro-life protesters gathered recently to demand that Harris resign. Over at the Los Angeles Times, Robin Abcarian writes, “Abortion foes want Kamala Harris to resign – for doing her job.”
Doing her job? How many home invasions are done by Kamala Harris – or any state attorney general, for that matter – over a falsified driver’s license? Abcarian and the LA Times would assuredly be calling for the head of a Republican AG who raided homes of illegal aliens under such pretenses.
The phrase, “a man’s home is his castle,” dates back to before the founding of America, reflecting a near-sacrosanct core of one of the greatest protections of liberty and property rights we have. The Fourth Amendment is the single-most important protection against a police state because it is designed to prevent what is otherwise criminal trespass on private property by the government. It also prevents larceny by the government – the taking of our papers and effects, or what comedian George Carlin called our “stuff” – without consent or legal justification.
Daleiden said the agents took his computer that had unreleased footage and even his phone. While some like Ms. Abcarian are cheerleading for Harris, the left’s grand defenders of the media’s First and Fourth Amendment rights have been conspicuously silent. So much for principles.
Harris was also recently exposed for other civil rights abuses in a lawsuit by Americans for Prosperity Foundation. In what appears to be a violation of the law of the land protecting private association expressed in the landmark case NAACP v. Alabama, Harris is demanding that charities disclose to her their top donors listed on a confidential federal tax return schedule. Federal tax law provides civil and even criminal penalties for both federal and state officials who inspect or disclose that confidential federal tax return information without express authorization under the tax code.
Not only does it appear that Ms. Harris acquired and inspected this information without legal authorization under federal law, her office made publicly available the names and addresses of donors to over 1,700 charities. There are felony penalties for government officials who disclose such information.
Ms. Harris is not alone among state attorneys general in her police-state approach to “doing her job.” She has joined nearly 20 others in an investigation of ExxonMobil about its speech and publication about climate change. Leftwingers such as Robert Kennedy, Jr., Bill Nye the “Science Guy,” and a host of taxpayer-funded university professors such as Jagadish Shukla actually want “climate-change deniers” to go to jail.
The Wall Street Journal reported that some of these state attorneys general gathered with a dozen leftist activists “committed to prevent the fossil fuel industry from crossing the red lines for a just and livable planet.” In January at the Manhattan headquarters of the Rockefeller Family Foundation on scenic Riverside Drive they hatched a plan to use RICO lawsuits against climate-hysteria skeptics.
The attorneys general then held a press conference announcing they would “creatively” and “aggressively” use the powers of their offices for their policy response on climate change. Virgin Islands AG Claude Walker even pledged to do something “transformational.” Previously a lawyer within a host of federal agencies, Walker obviously isn’t lacking hubris.
After several AGs launched investigations of Exxon under the pretext of their state law enforcement powers, Walker issued a judge-less administrative subpoena to free-market think tank Competitive Enterprise Institute for its research, op-eds, speeches, and publications about climate change.
A federal statute, Section 1983 of U.S. Code Title 42, authorizes lawsuits against these officials personally. The pertinent parts read:
“Every person who, under color of any statute, ordinance, regulation, custom, or usage, of any State or Territory or the District of Columbia, subjects, or causes to be subjected, any citizen of the United States or other person within the jurisdiction thereof to the deprivation of any rights, privileges, or immunities secured by the Constitution and laws, shall be liable to the party injured in an action at law, suit in equity, or other proper proceeding for redress … .”
These police-state attorneys general are infringing on rights of free speech and overstepping their bounds in violation of the 4th Amendment prohibiting unreasonable searches and seizures, all for viewpoint discrimination, which is disagreement with the message conveyed. Discovery in lawsuits against these police-state attorneys general will likely uncover more violations of the law than just their constitutional violations. http://www.cnsnews.com/commentary/mark-fitzgibbons/police-state-attorneys-general-cheered-left-may-be-sued-right
Tags
Who is online
97 visitors

California Attorney General Kamala Harris
She's going to make a great Senator from California! I'm voting for her!