An Oklahoma court has stunned local prosecutors with a declaration that state law doesn’t criminalize oral sex with a victim who is completely unconscious.
The ruling, a unanimous decision by the state’s criminal appeals court, is sparking outrage among critics who say the judicial system was engaged in victim-blaming and buying outdated notions about rape.
But legal experts and victims’ advocates said they viewed the ruling as a sign of something larger: the troubling gaps that still exist between the nation’s patchwork of laws and evolving ideas about rape and consent.
The case involved allegations that a 17-year-old boy assaulted a girl, 16, after volunteering to give her a ride home. The two had been drinking in a Tulsa park with a group of friends when it became clear that the girl was badly intoxicated. Witnesses recalled that she had to be carried into the defendant’s car. Another boy, who briefly rode in the car, recalled her coming in and out of consciousness.
The boy later brought the girl to her grandmother’s house. Still unconscious, the girl was taken to a hospital, where a test put her blood alcohol content above .34. She awoke as staff were conducting a sexual assault examination.
Tests would later confirm that the young man’s DNA was found on the back of her leg and around her mouth. The boy claimed to investigators that the girl had consented to performing oral sex. The girl said she didn’t have any memories after leaving the park. Tulsa County prosecutors charged the young man with forcible oral sodomy.
But the trial judge dismissed the case. And the appeals court ruling , on 24 March, affirmed that prosecutors could not apply the law to a victim who was incapacitated by alcohol.
“Forcible sodomy cannot occur where a victim is so intoxicated as to be completely unconscious at the time of the sexual act of oral copulation,” the decision read. Its reasoning, the court said, was that the statute listed several circumstances that constitute force, and yet was silent on incapacitation due to the victim drinking alcohol. “We will not, in order to justify prosecution of a person for an offense, enlarge a statute beyond the fair meaning of its language.”
Benjamin Fu, the Tulsa County district attorney leading the case, said the ruling had him “completely gobsmacked”.
“The plain meaning of forcible oral sodomy, of using force, includes taking advantage of a victim who was too intoxicated to consent,” Fu said. “I don’t believe that anybody, until that day, believed that the state of the law was that this kind of conduct was ambiguous, much less legal. And I don’t think the law was a loophole until the court decided it was.” To focus on why the victim was unable to consent, he continued, puts the victim at fault.
But several legal experts declined to fault the appeals court, saying instead that the ruling should be a wake-up call for legislators to update Oklahoma’s laws.
Michelle Anderson, the dean of the CUNY School of Law who has written extensively about rape law, called the ruling “appropriate” but the law “archaic”.
“This is a call for the legislature to change the statute, which is entirely out of step with what other states have done in this area and what Oklahoma should do,” she said. “It creates a huge loophole for sexual abuse that makes no sense.”
Jennifer Gentile Long, who leads a group, AEquitas, that guides prosecutors in sexual and domestic violence cases, agreed. She said the Oklahoma law was an example of a gulf that still exists in some places between the law and evolving notions around consent and sexual agency.
Oklahoma has a separate rape statute that protects victims who were too intoxicated to consent to vaginal or anal intercourse, Long noted. But “there are still gaps in the ways laws are written that allow some cases to fall through the cracks,” she said. “This case” – because it did not involve vaginal rape but an oral violation – “seems to be one of them”.
In the wake of the ruling, Fu has said he will push for lawmakers to change the code. Many states have engaged in a broad overhaul of their rape laws in recent years, Anderson said, part of a movement to fall in line with the modern understanding of rape.
“There is a recognition that social mores have changed, that the law should now try to protect sexual autonomy as opposed to sexual morality,” she said. Often, the law changes after an outcry over unpopular court rulings.
The Oklahoma appeals court declined to make the ruling a precedent. But Fu said he has learned that other defendants are nevertheless making the same argument in other parts of Oklahoma to avoid charges.
The defendant’s attorney, Shannon McMurray, was not available for comment. She told Oklahoma Watch, which was first to report the ruling , that prosecutors were clearly in the wrong to charge the young man with forcible sodomy, and not a lesser crime of unwanted touching.
“There was absolutely no evidence of force or him doing anything to make this girl give him oral sex,” McMurray said, “other than she was too intoxicated to consent.”
http://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/apr/27/oral-sex-rape-ruling-tulsa-oklahoma-alcohol-consent?utm_source=esp&utm_medium=Email&utm_campaign=GU+Today+USA+-+Version+CB+header&utm_term=169483&subid=14230036&CMP=ema_565

You have got to be kidding me! It's OK in OK to rape a woman who is too drunk to consent or is passed out completely, just as long as you rape her in the mouth! The defendant's own attorney doesn't seem to get it! "There was absolutely no evidence of force or him doing anything to make this girl give him oral sex,” McMurray said, “other than she was too intoxicated to consent.” What in the hell part of " too intoxicated to consent." does this idiot and this idiotic court not get? If she's too drunk to consent or is passed out. it is ALWAYS RAPE! ALWAYS!
This is when a gun would come in handy.
If he had used force, it would have been illegal under OK law because forcible oral sodomy is illegal, but he didn't use force, he just used her when she was passed out! In their thinking, since she was passed out he didn't have to use force, so the oral sodomy he did to her was not illegal. What kind of twisted thinking is that?
I agree. Daddy needs to go pay a visit to this kid and have a "talk" with the boy to set him straight!
NOW THAT was very 1950's of them.....
But unfortunately, the law needs to be revised. From an absolute legal statuary standpoint, he didn't break the law they charged him with. I'm sure that they re-charged him under a law he did break.
Sometimes it takes just such an occurrence to get a legislative body to fix it's past failings to act.
In no way does this excuse the boy and the advantage he took with the young lady.
And if she was my Daughter, the young man would find that his persona could be bent, if not exactly in the same manner in which he bent my daughter, a manner in which the point would be driven home in a way to permanently brand the lesson in his brain I'm sure. (never had occasion to effect such a lesson plan in my life thank god)
This is not the 50's anymore and although I'm a strong believer in being responsible for self, there are things you just DON'T DO as a gentleman. And this young man was seriously lacking in that department.
Lechery is not permissible in society.....
His lawyer slipped him through a legal technicality that I am sure the state legislature is going to plug up. He got away with it. The next one won't. The law, as currently written, would allow a man to take advantage of a mentally disabled women or girl because he just talked her into it and didn't force her, even though she didn't have the mental capability of understanding what was happening and of making a decision to consent. Though maybe OK does have a separate law for that? One would hope so.
Were she my daughter the young man would certainly find out from me personally that a young man does not act like that without consequences. In the small town in the rural area where I grew up there may be a few fathers who may want to have words all at the same time with the young man too to set an example for others. Nothing serious you understand. Just to make sure he really understands the error of his ways and does not repeat his actions.
Bill Cosby should feel good about this development ...
As long as he only raped women orally in OK. I wonder how many other states have laws like this?
I'm unclear on who brought the charges. Was it the girl, or the state? While it is clearly wrong to perform sex acts on someone who is unconscious, I'd like to know if it was the girl's idea to press charges. Sixteen year olds frequently engage in sexual behavior. If that's where this date was headed in the first place, because both of them were on board with it but then she got too drunk, I could see her possibly not wanting to press charges. Is this a case of the state knows best so they're going to press charges even if the 16 yr old is against it? I can't tell from the article.