╌>

(Science Friday) How often are commercial flights landed using autopilot?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  flynavy1  •  10 years ago  •  8 comments

(Science Friday) How often are commercial flights landed using autopilot?

(Jim Richards, Test Pilot)

I can answer from my experience as an Airbus 320 Captain, but procedures differ both by airline and by aircraft type. 

To answer one of your questions directly, no, they are not used often.  I personally have used it for about 10-20 landings total in the 10 years I've been flying the A320.  I don't know a single pilot who would prefer to perform an autoland to landing his/herself.  What's more, the autoland system tends to land more "firmly" than a pilot can.  Don't get me wrong -- the system works extremely well, it just doesn't land softly most of the time.

When I do use it (and in my experience this is true of my colleagues as well), it's because I'm required to due to low visibility, and in those situtations I'm very happy I have it.  Visibility is essentially the only factor (i.e. not snow, rain, wind, etc) that drives the decision to autoland.  In fact, other than visibility, there are more restrictions with respect to an autoland than there are for a manual landing.  For example, the runway must not be contaminated by snow or standing water, and the maximum crosswind allowed is significantly lower.

All that said, the statement that "The only case where an 'Auto Land' feature would have any value is one where there is no qualified pilot to land the plane" is incorrect.  Autoland has great value in that it allows aircraft to land in visibility that is too low to land manually (fog, generally), and as such gets a good bit of usage at major airports on foggy mornings.  It's also technically correct, but misleading to say that it's "against the rules to land when visibility is below certain limits."  Again, this varies by airline and aircraft, but at my airline we are certified to autoland all the way down to 600 feet RVR (essentially visibility down the runway), but that figure is derived more from the ability to safely taxi after landing than it is for the landing itself.  In fact, we have no requirement to see the runway environment during the landing.  At 100 feet above the runway (called an "Alert Height") we do a last assessment that our systems are working normally, and then continue to the landing if they are.  For a manual landing, the rule is complex, but essentially we need to have 1/2 mile of visibility.  So any time the visibility is between 1/2 mile and 600 feet, we're able to land automatically when we otherwise couldn't have.

Back to the original question though -- if you're a passenger, you've just landed, and you're wondering whether the landing was performed by the autopilot, it probably wasn't unless it's very foggy outside.

https://www.quora.com/How-often-are-commercial-flights-landed-using-autopilot


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

The reason I seeded this was because of my current work regarding autonomous vehicles, and former experience with hands off carrier landings with the US Navy.  Just yesterday I was on a flight into Munich, with poor visibility, and a high cross wind.  The landing was very controlled, and the touchdown quite smooth.  On exiting the aircraft I asked the pilot if he made use of autoland, and he acknowledged that he indeed did make use of those systems to put us on the ground.

Given the quality of the landing vs the conditions, you wonder how well the plane would be landed under good conditions with autoland?  I know that carrier pilots despise landing using ACLS, and justifiably so.  Their ability to get back on a pitching deck in all weather is a perishable skill if not practiced regularly, and damage to the ACLS from battle is a very real possibility.   Somehow I find it ironic that commercial pilots make use of autoland only in the worst flight conditions.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

Back in 1973 I flew home to Grand Rapids Michigan from Wichita Falls Texas for Christmas leave. Everything was fine until I got to the leg from Chicago to GR. That part was handled by a small airline that doesn't exist any longer called Republic Airlines. We had one stop between Chicago and GR in Benton Harbor. It looked like we were flying in milk from the snow, but the pilot tried it anyway. It was an old twin propeller aircraft of the kind that the bottom was lower then the front considerably when sitting on the ground and you had to walk up and down steps to board. It was just my luck to be sitting next to a retired Navy pilot who kept telling me all of the way down that it was going to be a very bad landing and what he thought the pilot should be doing, but wasn't. He was right. I couldn't even see the ground when we touched down and the plane slid back and forth, almost sideways, down the whole length of the runway. It was amazing to me that the pilot was able to keep it on the runway. After we unloaded  few passengers I thought he was going to cancel the hop over to GR, but he said we were going to try it anyway. I was ordering scotch on the rocks like crazy before the landing and on the ground and they were not objecting to how many I was having. Still the pilot managed to get back to the runway an in what seemed to take forever, got the plane back off the ground and we made it to GR where is was much clearer. I don't think he could really see hardly a thing landing or taking off. To tell the truth, I enjoyed every second of the excitement of it.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

A few years ago I came across theses videos which represent the difficulties of getting back upon a pitching deck.  For reference, the tolerance for a successful approach to trap on a carrier is +/-5' in most cases for a level deck.  Now add heavy seas, and that tolerance gets even smaller.  Landing on hard runways does not have these constraints.

Short version of pitching deck landings:

Long version with the added difficulty of night time operations:

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

Interesting article FLY. I'm much more secure jumping out of a perfectly good airplane then landing in one. But that's just me. Laugh

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

I screamed my liver out on the jumps I had to make to get my wings!  You can only imagine what happened in my flight suit. 

Jumping out of a perfectly functioning aircraft is NOT a natural act!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Many of my jumps could have been much easier if the damn pilot could have found the DZ.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

I have to admit, I've seen some navigators that couldn't find their plate with a fork......

 
 

Who is online



104 visitors