The Two-Tiered Recovery
The April jobs report continued the saga of a two-tiered labor market recovery. The economy added 160,000 jobs and the unemployment rate remained at 5 percent. Revisions to the previous two moths amounted to 19,000 fewer jobs than originally reported. With this report, total employment is now 5.4 million above the previous peak and up just over 14 million from the employment recession low.
But the broad numbers may not paint a true picture of the employment landscape. The biggest complaint is that overall wage growth has been unimpressive. In April, average hourly wages increased by 0.3 percent, nudging up the annual increase to 2.5 percent. Given the impressive number of jobs added, most analysts have been promising that wage growth would soon follow, but annual wage growth has remained between 2 and 2.5 percent for the past few years, below the near-3 percent seen in previous expansions.
It’s not supposed to work this way. If employers are having a hard time filling positions, and workers are more willing to jump ship, wages should be rising faster. However, according to economist Joel Naroff, “No matter how tight the market may be, companies are still willing to go without new hires and limit pay increases.”
It may be that the labor market is not quite as healthy as the top line measures indicate. In addition to the 2.1 million Americans who have been out of work for more than six months, the number of workers who work part-time but would rather be full-time remains at a still-elevated 6 million. According to research from the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, the high numbers of “part-time for economic reasons” is a contributing factor to limiting wage growth.
Steve Murphy of Capital Economics also notes that there has been a surge of low paying jobs in sectors like retail and leisure, while “at the same time, employment in higher-paid sectors such as manufacturing and mining has fallen back sharply. More generally, there has been a sharp deterioration in the quality of jobs created.”
Career coach Connie Thanasoulis-Cerrachio , co-founder of SixFigureStart® says her on-the-ground-interaction with employers and candidates echoes that sentiment: “We see a tale of two [labor] markets – strong candidates have a great market. Mediocre ones are still have a hard time.” What makes a strong candidate? It helps if those seeking jobs are looking in the hot industries that are hiring, like technology, healthcare, accounting, marketing/data analytics as well as the non-profit world, which Thanasoulis-Cerrachio says is “ booming ”.
What appears to be happening is that workers in the high growth fields can demand higher wages, but the vast majority of workers either don’t feel like they have bargaining power or have made a different kind of adjustment: if the boss can’t pay me more, maybe I will work a little less. This could be part of the reason why worker productivity has dropped off. According to the Labor Department , in the recent 2007-2015 period, annual labor productivity has slowed significantly to 1.2 percent, the worst period since the late-1970s to mid-1980s. Naroff says the downshift is understandable because “until workers have reasons to work harder (i.e., greater compensation), they will find ways not to work harder.”
Of course, with corporate earnings set to drop for a third consecutive quarter, companies are unwilling to take the first step to incentivize their workforces. This strange game of chicken is unlikely to continue for too much longer. Unfortunately, there is probably an equal probability that we see a downshift in the economy, which would spur workers to step it up; and an uptick, which would force companies to pay more.
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/april-jobs-report-two-tiered-recovery-jill-schlesinger

A look at the economic recovery, largely without political bias.
That is a refreshing way to look at the most serious issue facing the country.
Some key points I took away from the article (in no particular order)
According to research from the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, the high numbers of “part-time for economic reasons” is a contributing factor to limiting wage growth.
there has been a surge of low paying jobs in sectors like retail and leisure, while “at the same time, employment in higher-paid sectors such as manufacturing and mining has fallen back sharply.
in the recent 2007-2015 period, annual labor productivity has slowed significantly to 1.2 percent, the worst period since the late-1970s to mid-1980s
annual wage growth has remained between 2 and 2.5 percent for the past few years, below the near-3 percent seen in previous expansions.
“until workers have reasons to work harder (i.e., greater compensation), they will find ways not to work harder.” Brilliant.
Dean
Well at least you got something out of what you read
Pretty honest piece Robert.
It touches on the point of the shift towards service jobs away from more traditional higher paying jobs that were once found in manufacturing.
It also outlines the point related to worker productivity. Workers in all types of employment now consider themselves to be disposable commodities with respect to their employers. The lack of loyalty ends up costing employers right at the bottom line.
Lastly I think across the board, companies have stopped looking at innovation and productivity gains and have kept a more watchful eye on the feelings of their investors and shareholders. Proof in this are the requirements of shorter terms for ROI of capital expenditures. At one time capital investments would have been approved for an ROI of even as much as 30 months. Today, you're lucky to get 12 months for a major investment.
Our economy has changed since the late 1980s, and not for the better.
FLY
Good point
I agree that declining employee loyalty to employers is not unexpected and a detriment to efficient operations, but that is also a two-edged sword as in recent decades job-hopping has become the norm rather than long term employment which was the standard in past generations.
Loyalty is a two way street.
The lack of longer term investment in R&D and capital improvements is also unarguable, but it can be paralleled with lower return on investment for dollars invested, which is why many companies are consolidating ownership (stock buy backs) and holding large amounts of cash on the books.
Any type of corporate tax reform (and we need some) must include more incentives for investment and higher costs (taxes) for cash holdings of corporations - these two simple changes would spur investment in my view.
As always I appreciate your feedback.