╌>

The surprisingly uncomplicated racist history of the Confederate flag

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pat-wilson  •  11 years ago  •  36 comments

The surprisingly uncomplicated racist history of the Confederate flag

http://theweek.com/articles/562004/surprisingly-uncomplicated-racist-history-confederate-flag

The flag has no meaning "regardless" of politics, or above politics; its heritage is not exempt from history. Anyone can interpret anything any way they want, but if they claim historical sanction for their interpretation, then they'd best be accurate. And in that sense, history is clear: There is no revolutionary cause associated with the flag, other than the right for Southern states to determine how best to subjugate black people and to perpetuate slavery.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  pat wilson    11 years ago

It should not be controversial to say that people should not spend their days mourning relatives they never knew from a war that ended 150 years ago, especially if that feeling is so paramount that it outweighs the sense of brotherhood they might feel toward fellow humans who are alive, and for whom the flag's presence and endorsement by the government is the personification of the evil of white supremacy.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Simple enough.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

And the reason for ANOTHER one of these articles is ?????????

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  pat wilson    11 years ago

It's a response, period.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Makes perfect sense. Was used during the Civil War as a battle flag, a war fought by the Confederacy to keep slavery alive. To keep the right to the buying and selling and owning of Black human beings. Then was used briefly to commemorate soldiers who had fought in said war at funerals. Then put away for many, many decades until Strom Thurman (who had a Black Mistress and child) decided it would be the perfect symbol to say "Fuck You!" to the Civil Rights movement that sought equality between the races (and a few religions) and has only been used to say "Fuck You!" to equality between the White Race and every other Race (and a few religions) ever since. Is not the Confederate Flag. Is not a symbol of the heritage of the Civil war and would have faded away into retaliative obscurity in some museums if Strom Thurmond had not revived it to say "Fuck You!" to the beginnings of Civil Rights Movement (and a few religions) and that has been it's main use ever since. Hate and Racism.

Makes sense to me.Smile.gif

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  pat wilson    11 years ago

I like your response, concise, logical and to the point. Regardless other members here want to flog that dead horse until it turns into a saddle !

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Remember, they hate Native Americans as much as Black Americans.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    11 years ago

I have to ask myself, If the flag had never been used or flown would we have racism? If we ban the flag from ever being displayed will racism end?

The flag, much like a gun is blamed for the problem of other people. It is people who cause racism and kill other people NOT gins or flags.....

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  pat wilson    11 years ago

I'll bet "gins" DO have something to do with "the problem of other people".

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I love gin! It's tastes like what I would expect a pine tree to taste like if it tasted the way it smells!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

randy this I had to chuckle at and I will relate why. I live on the reservation here, and the only ones flying the battle flag are the natives , the FBI ( full blooded Indians) and they do so I am told because I asked , as a fuck you to the US government. see why I chuckled ?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

racism is a learned behavior someone has to teach it , and someone has to perpetuate it . no article or items removal is ever going to end it , it doesn't need those things to remain. thing people have to ask themselves is , are they part of the problem , or the solution and go from there.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  pat wilson    11 years ago

no article or items removal is ever going to end it ,

By the same token we don't need to fly symbols from our ramparts that are known to offend certain members of our communities.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

can you show me in the constitution, bill of rights where ANYONE has the right to be unoffended? many things offend me , but they are covered under the protections of freedom of speech , they have the right to speak their mind , they don't have the right to make anyone agree or to even listen if they choose not to. what your suggesting is political correctness and we have seen where that has led.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  pat wilson    11 years ago

many things offend me , but they are covered under the protections of freedom of speech ,

I'm just glad I'm old and won't have to deal with this shit for long !!

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

no article or items removal is ever going to end it

And some people will still fly the Swastika too. Which is their right and they have to be prepared for the right that people will have to hate them for it. That is THEIR right to freedom of expression.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Racists hate Natives and the Natives think that is funny? That's a rather odd sense of humor.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

randy I never claimed to be a native though I do have native blood as does most of the population in this country, only that I live on a reservation , and my point is that flag means whatever the person flying it wants it to mean , not nessisarily what you think it means .

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I disagree. Not with that flag. Not anymore then with the Nazi flag.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

part of the problem or part of the solution , see what I was getting at?

you hate the Nazi flag , that was taught because of the atrocities they committed , but the swatstika is much older than the 1933-1945 reich and had an entirely different meaning before it was bastardized .

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

And so did the Confederate battle flag before it was bastardized by the White Supremacist Movement, beginning with Strom Thurmond, and there is no way to wash it clean again any more then the Nazi flag can be.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

on that we can agree , the bastardization has consequences , what im finding out as I get older , the more I think I know , the less im finding out I actually know , and there is always another part of the story, it is up to me to accept , that as simple as something seems , it gets complicated no matter what. so do I accept the 4 thousand years of what the crooked cross meant , or the 13 years it was bastardized? same for the battle flag its original intent or what its been bastardized to mean. that is for me to decide I think not for someone else to tell me what to think.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

The 4 thousand years of the Swastika were wiped out completely by the 13 years of it's Nazi use. That symbol will never again be clean in history, it has been soaked in far too much blood, bigotry, hate, racism and mud. It is the same with the Confederate battle flag. There is far too much hate, too much blood, too much racism, too much bigotry and too much filth for it to ever be clean in history again. It is permanently destroyed. It is permanently stained. Permanently a sign of White Supremacy, of Hate, of Terror, of Lynchings, of Torture, of Rape, of Murder and or of Racism to ever be clean again. Ever! No matter who views it, they can pretend and even convince themselves that it means something different, but it does not and never will again in history. It has become as much pure hate as the Swastika has.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

I will humbly disagree randy , because I still see the swastika used in native beadwork here , and have seen it still in use in buddist and hindu temples. sometimes the alignment is different , sometimes its the same but it is still in use with no thought given to who or how it was used before.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

That is your right. And my opinion, all that I have said, is my right and I will believe history will find it so.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

randy I can respect your opinion , and I agree both will be sullied by the bastardization, the reason I disagree is just as history has shown one was used for years before to mean something totally opposite what it was used for 70+ years ago it still has its original meaning attatched to it and is still in use for that meaning its bastardization is understood, it just depends on who presents it on how it is taken, the battle flag , you might be right , but there will always be those that see more than what it was used for in the civil rights era and has come to mean to many , what has to be remembered , is that it does hold other meaning to different people and the only time one will know what it means is if they ask what it means to the person flying it which is another form of bastardization.

I have come to the decision , that when I finally pass , there will not be a US flag drapped on my casket( I have earned that by service) but instead the flag of my state of residence at the time of my demise ( long in the future I hope, 20 to 30 yrs should do) because by then the flag I served in my youth will have come to represent an even more disunited states than it is already .

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I still disagree. I think the damage to both is and always will be permanent. However you and I will long be gone to dust (well, me sooner since I am to be cremated) before anyone will know. That has not changed my conviction in my feelings that too much damage, too both, has been done to be whipped out 10,000 years from now.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Good article, Pat! Thanks for sharing it with us!

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

If you are willing to see history clearly, you can clearly see the symbolic problem with the Confederate battle flag, and why it should only be used on the personal level, and to commemorate the dead who fought under it.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

randy , I too when I finally go will be creamated and ashes spread to the 4 winds to land wherever they choose, cant see taking up space reserved for the living. it is good such civil discussions such as this can be had and differences recognized and respected. Future generations should have both opposing sides in order to make a truly informed choice , something that I find is truly lacking in this modern world where things are cherry picked to make a point or persuade an argument. and it goes beyond this subject as well.

Fly , I whole heartedly agree with your post, one has to look at history clearly and be able to acknowledge both sides if not all sides of it, the good , and the bad, and be able to recognize the differences, the subject matter of this discussion is a part of history and the whole history should and must be told before anyone decides what they think of it on a personal level, and I can agree that there are very limited proper use of, and display of this ensign, but others have and will disagree with any display because of what it means to them and their personal perceptions.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

What facts have been ignored John , has it not been acknowledged that the ensign was and has been and will continue to be bastardized by those that choose to do so for their own reasons? has it not been agreed that slavery was indeed a cause of the war in question , but it was not the sole and only reason for that conflict, which you in your cherry picking mind seems to think . Lincoln , son of Illinois that he is , was racist , he was a man of his time , if he could save the union without freeing the slave he would have , if he had to free them,he would have done that as well, which is what inevitably what happened . and by interjecting in this civil discussion where there has been agreements to disagree but respect is still being given by all parties , you have proven a post of mine that your whistling like an under filled and over boiling teapot that's showing the crack in your bottom , I do look forward to the day someone shoves a cork up your backside and vapor locks your cherry picking mouth , it wont be me because you have been weighed , measured and found sorely wanting in intelligence , respect , and presenting all the facts. which is the main reason I do not engage with you, and if I do , it is briefly, good day to you .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     11 years ago

yes it is his actions , as well as his words that define him as a racist John . His actions against natives as well as the colored people , he was as well a consummate politician and played to what worked to keep the union in place. just as there was a southern aristocracy , there was a northern aristocracy, that didn't and still don't view minorities as equals or on the same levels of themselves.

if states rights is established as a cause? I think that is pretty much already established , because I don't think you can convince people that for every 100 people that fought in that conflict on the side of the confederacy they did so for the 3 that owned slaves . that's what the numbers break down to , only 3% of the southern population owned slaves . I have asked this before, what would convince the other 97 people of that 100 to enter a conflict such as that?

COULD it be that those that had no interest in slavery by virtue of not even owning a single slave , were fed up with federal tariffs that were confiscatory and favored northern industrialist where it came to the argragarian souths products or raw materials? or COULD some of those 97 have seen the presence of federal troops as an invasion of their states and homes and a threat to their families?

So here is the real kahuna , which makes more sense? that the north went to war to free slaves ? or preserve the union? thus securing a raw material needed for civilized advancement (based on the standards of that time , and not the hindsight of today).

and which makes more sense ? that person from the south would fight for the enslavement of an entire race , even though they didn't own a single slave? or that they would fightagainst confiscatory taxes( said tariffs) and an invasion ? or the federal governments ability to remove posessions and property?

OR can it be as I believe, a culmination and combination of it all. all it really comes down to is to what degrees they all actually played and contributed.

The fire of rebellion flows through and is the birthright of EVERY American citizen its what created this nation in the forges of war, irregardless of their race , creed, color gender or origin, and are you not with your diatrabes , ranting , cherrypicking and racebaitingexpressing your own little fanatical form of rebellion?

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  pat wilson    11 years ago

Thank you, RW.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I like your response, concise, logical and to the point.

I forgot to thank you!

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

randy , I too when I finally go will be creamated and ashes spread to the 4 winds to land wherever they choose, cant see taking up space reserved for the living.

I have decided to have my ashes interned in a National Cemetery. I would say at Arlington, but having never seen combat and even though I am qualified to be in the columbarium, I'm still not sure. I would have liked to be buried at the National Cemetery in Los Angeles (I fell in love with that city), but all of the plots are accounted for (though not yet used and they don't have a columbarium). Perhaps I'll leave it up to my wife.

 
 

Who is online

Snuffy
MrFrost
evilone


69 visitors