Lawmakers vote down LGBT rights measure
Shouts of "Shame, shame, shame," erupted in the U.S. House of Representatives on Thursday as Republican lawmakers narrowly defeated legislation to protect the civil rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender employees of government contractors.
The measure, an amendment to a veterans and military construction spending bill introduced by New York Democrat Sean Maloney, initially had enough "yes" votes to pass, according to the count in the House chamber.
But House Republican leaders extended the time allowed for the vote as they urged enough party members to change their positions to defeat it by a vote of 213 to 212.
All 183 Democrats who voted backed the amendment, joined by 29 Republicans. All 213 "no" votes were from Republicans. Eight House members - three Republicans and five Democrats - did not vote. Lawmakers are allowed to change their vote in the few minutes between voting and the result being declared.
LGBT rights have been a hot-button issue during the 2016 election season. National politics have featured debate over whether making cakes for same-sex couples violates bakers' religious freedom or whether the government should decide which public bathrooms are used by transgender people.
Democrats chanted "Shame, shame, shame," at Republicans. "House Republicans are so committed to discriminating against LGBT Americans, that they broke regular order to force their members to reverse their votes and support Republicans' bigotry," Nancy Pelosi, the House Democratic leader, said in a statement.
Republicans who backed the provision said it was necessary to protect the religious rights of military contractors and not intended to be discriminatory.
Thursday's emotionally-charged vote came hours after the House late on Wednesday passed a $602 billion defense authorization bill that included "religious freedom" language that critics said would allow contractors to discriminate against LGBT individuals.
The House Rules committee had angered Democrats by voting along party lines late on Tuesday not to allow a vote on an amendment to the National Defense Authorization Act that would have eliminated that language.
The House also backed by 265-159 a separate Democratic amendment to the spending bill that limits the display of the Confederate battle flag on flagpoles at federal veterans' cemeteries.
The measure angered some conservative Republicans from southern states, who argue that the flag is a symbol of their heritage.
Some lawmakers have been seeking to limit displays of the Confederate banner since a racially motivated murder of nine black parishioners at a church in Charleston, S.C. last year.
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-defense-lgbt-idUSKCN0YA2II

Most of the recent polls I have seen indicate that roughly 7 in 10 Americans believe that the passage of laws that would protect the LGBT crowd from discrimination are needed.
Yet, members of the GOP don't seem to want to side with what the largest proportion of what Americans want, but rather to pander to their minority base.
Yet, members of the GOP don't seem to want to side with what the largest proportion of what Americans want, but rather to pander to their minority base.
As usual. It's a knee Jerk reaction of theirs. It's one of the reasons they're going to have a bad time on November 8th this year.
"....... based upon comments made in another posting* that polls are not to be believed anymore, they can be twisted to say anything the pollster or party paying for the poll wants them to."
That is not usually the case, it all depends on the source of the poll. Independent polling companies, like the Pew Research Center, depend on the accuracy of their polls in order to maintain their reputation for providing reliable information.
Whenever a poll (any poll) produces results not consistent with the opinion of the reader, accusations of bias are made. However I agree, when a private pollster has an agenda, the way the questions are framed and the cross section of those polled can, and usually do, produce biased results.
Whenever NEWSMAX for instance, takes a poll, you can be sure the results will favor a strong Right Wing position, because 99.99% of NEWSMAX readers are conservatives.
That's not my personal opinion, just that of other more educated people.
Well, .........,
(* Link?)
LINK?
I was hoping you would chime in here. I agree with your take.
Well this is the thing Jerry, you know as well as I do there is a whole industry devoted to polling and research in how to make them more accurate.
I've been receiving such data now for thirty years cause some people think I have a modicum of analyzing skills. But that is opinions of others. I've made a great deal of money consulting on that basis to various parties over the decades so for me to claim that polls have no validity is an oxymoron. (I'm not that dense my friend)
It was just a point to illustrate the recent onsite thinking on poll validity and that it is a viable rebuttal to anyone using a poll to back a position. That the poll can be challenged on the veracity side by attacking it's sources and methodology. Particularly by those opposed to the conclusion the poll represents.
My usage here was to illustrate that since this is an accepted norm around here, there is no point discussing an issue on the basis of polling.
Such attitude reduces the ability to talk about a subject, thereby shutting down dialogue.
I thought it was an interesting take on the issue. A person can disagree with his point simply cause they refuse to accept the polling data supporting his argument, hence his argument is not worth discussion.
(by the way I agree with his point notwithstanding the polling data)
In the name of religious freedom, the radical God-fearing people of this country have discriminated against people and sadly the tradition continues. Just waiting for the signs to appear in storefronts...
Is this what we want for America?
Just waiting for the signs to appear in storefronts...
Is this what we want for America?
We may not want America to be that way, but right now the only difference the sign would make is the sign.
What exactly is the legislation?
Simply saying is "protects the rights " is meaningless. It's just buzz words to get the usual fanatics to start foaming at the mouth without any actual information about what the bill allows or disallows.
I thought this was a veteran's bill. How did the LGBT stuff get put into it? And why are republicans vetoing a veteran's bill?
Dowser,
The bill is the National Defense Authorization Act for 2016 to provide appropriations and policies regarding military activities, it's massive with tentacles reaching far and wide. This amendment specifically dealt with prohibiting military contractors from discriminating against LGBT employees due to their sexual orientation.
The bill should have passed with this amendment intact.
Totally agree Fly, the amendment put forth by Maloney should have passed. Hell it had the votes before it didn't! If the Russell amendment wasn't already approved into the bill we'd not be having a conversation.
One sure has to take the time to connect the dots - kind of like, "pay no attention to the man behind the curtain".
Thanks, Lynne. It should have passed!! More political posturing...
I agree completely. This Bill should have included this amendment. There is no reasonable excuse for it not to be a requirement.