╌>

2 Trials and No Convictions Put Top Baltimore Prosecutor in a Bind

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pj  •  10 years ago  •  2 comments

2 Trials and No Convictions Put Top Baltimore Prosecutor in a Bind

2 Trials and No Convictions Put Top Baltimore Prosecutor in a Bind

The New York Times

By SHERYL GAY STOLBERG 5 hrs ago

256

© Jose Luis Magana/Associated Press Marilyn J. Mosby, Baltimore’s state’s attorney, outside the Maryland Court of Appeals in Annapolis in March.

BALTIMORE — In the wrenching drama that has engulfed this city since the death of Freddie Gray , one figure seems caught in the middle: Marilyn J. Mosby.

Ms. Mosby, as Americans learned when riots broke out after Mr. Gray, a 25-year-old black man, was fatally injured in police custody, is Baltimore’s state’s attorney, its top prosecutor. Her impassioned speech announcing charges — including murder — against six Baltimore officers was widely credited with helping to keep the peace, as armored National Guard trucks still rumbled through the streets.

But when a judge acquitted Officer Edward M. Nero of all charges against him on Monday, it was Ms. Mosby’s second trial without a conviction. And that puts the prosecutor, a 36-year-old daughter and granddaughter of police officers who once so captivated the national imagination that she was featured in Vogue , in a tough spot.

In a majority black city where race is often a proxy for residents’ feelings about the police, Ms. Mosby — who was notably absent from the courtroom when Officer Nero was acquitted — has emerged as a kind of Rorschach test.

Her critics, many of them white, say the acquittal on Monday, coming on the heels of a hung jury in the case of Officer William G. Porter last year, is proof that she had no business bringing charges in the first place. Her supporters, many of them fellow African-Americans, give her an E for effort, but are growing impatient.

Hal Riedl, who is white, worked as an investigator for Ms. Mosby’s predecessor, and has been deeply critical of her. “I’d say it’s a new low in her career,” he said after the verdict. “In my judgment, it was a totally political prosecution. I don’t know why she was persuaded that she needed to bring the disorders to an end by charging the police.”

Tawanda Jones, an African-American preschool teacher whose brother, Tyrone West, died after a 2013 encounter with the police in Baltimore, worked to help elect Ms. Mosby in 2014. “It doesn’t change my feeling,” Ms. Jones said of the acquittal on Monday. “At the end of the day, I just look at the fact that she did something.”

Yet in the next breath, Ms. Jones also made clear that she and other critics of the police wanted more from Ms. Mosby. They accuse her of not being aggressive enough in prosecuting police misconduct in cases that have not gripped the city as Mr. Gray’s has. Ms. Mosby’s office drew the ire of activists recently when it announced it would not reopen Mr. West’s case. Ms. Jones, who said she was having her brother’s body exhumed to gather more evidence, is unsatisfied.

“I don’t want to hear none of her foolishness,” Ms. Jones said. “I want her to go forward and do her job and at the end of the day, if she don’t do her job, I’m going to be very upset.”

Ms. Mosby, barred by a judge’s order from talking to the news media, did not respond to a request for an interview, and her office said she had no public appearances planned this week.

The spotlight has had its challenges.

Ms. Mosby is married to City Councilman Nick Mosby, who ran for mayor this year. He withdrew after failing to gain traction; many said Baltimore did not need two Mosbys in such high office. Their home has been picketed by protesters, who recently shouted Ms. Mosby down at a public meeting.

“As a mother of a 5- and a 7-year-old, I would appeal to them to stop coming to my house, because it’s scaring my children,” The Baltimore Sun quoted her as saying at the meeting.

Ms. Mosby’s supporters note that there are five trials to go (Officer Porter will be retried), and say it is unfair to render judgment on her until they have all concluded. “Time will tell whether folks were overcharged, undercharged, whatever,” said City Councilman Brandon M. Scott, one of her supporters.

The trial of Officer Caesar R. Goodson Jr., who faces charges of second-degree depraved-heart murder — in essence, murder with willful indifference — is scheduled next, in early June. Officer Goodson faces the most serious charges. “That’s the one everyone is going to be looking at,” Mr. Scott said.

It is an open question here whether Ms. Mosby will seek re-election in 2018. Billy Murphy, a lawyer for the Gray family and a donor to Ms. Mosby, said he had “every expectation” that she would, and predicted that she would wind up in the State Legislature one day.

Yet in pursuing police officers so aggressively, Ms. Mosby has also risked her relationship with an important constituency: the Police Department itself, whose cooperation she needs to win convictions in every case her office tries.

David Jaros, a law professor at the University of Baltimore who has followed the trials, said there was a “significant moment” in the Nero trial when the prosecutor, Jan Bledsoe, spoke of officers’ “jacking up citizens” — a provocative comment for a representative of the state’s attorney office to make. Mr. Jaros noted that there were “multiple publics” Ms. Mosby had to satisfy.

“So we have to ask,” Mr. Jaros said, “what does this mean for her relationship with the police?”

He continued: “What does it mean for her relationship with a more privileged, perhaps wealthier white Baltimore? And what does it mean for her relationship with poor African-American communities?”

http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/2-trials-and-no-convictions-put-top-baltimore-prosecutor-in-a-bind/ar-BBtqkhW?li=BBnb7Kz


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   seeder  PJ    10 years ago

It appears so far that Ms. Mosby was perhaps a bit too aggressive in her attempt to make a name for herself.   Next time she should probably review the facts.    

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

"Her critics, many of them white..."

A clear demonstration that the protestors put racism ahead of justice.

 
 

Who is online