Criminal immigrants reoffend at higher rates than ICE has suggested
hey were among the nation’s top priorities for deportation, criminals who were supposed to be sent back to their home countries. But instead they were released, one by one, in secret across the United States. Federal officials said that many of the criminals posed little threat to the public, but did little to verify whether that was true.
It wasn’t.
A Globe review of 323 criminals released in New England from 2008 to 2012 found that as many as 30 percent committed new offenses, including rape, attempted murder, and child molestation — a rate that is markedly higher than Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials have suggested to Congress in the past.
The names of these criminals have never before been made public and are coming to light now only because the Globe sued the federal government for the list of criminals immigration authorities returned to neighborhoods across the country. A judge ordered the names released in 2013, and the Globe then undertook the work that the federal government didn’t, scouring court records to find out how many released criminals reoffended.
The Globe has also published, in conjunction with this story, a searchable database of the thousands of names that were disclosed to the news organization, so that crime victims, law enforcement officials, and managers of sex offender registries — who are often unaware of these releases — can find out if the criminals may still be in the United States.
The review does not indicate that immigrants are any more likely to commit crimes than native-born Americans — and in fact studies have shown that not to be the case. But the review reveals the damage inflicted on victims by criminals who were ordered to be deported when their sentences were complete, and were not, and it raises questions about how the government handled their cases.
The public rarely learns about ICE’s decisions to release criminals until something goes wrong — because immigration is the only law enforcement system in the United States that keeps such records secret.
ICE maintains that immigration records are generally private, and therefore exempt from disclosure under federal law. But others say the public should know who is making these decisions and why.
“There’s a serious question of who ICE represents. Who do they work for?” said Chester Fairlie, a lawyer for the mother of Casey Chadwick, a Connecticut woman murdered last year by a released criminal — a case that is intensifying calls for reform in ICE. “Public safety should trump any claim of privilege or confidentiality. It doesn’t come from statute. It doesn’t come from law. It comes from ICE deciding that that’s how it’s going to do things.”
Immigration officials have long insisted that the decision to release criminals — some of whom initially came to this country legally — is often out of their hands because the Supreme Court ruled in 2001 that the government cannot jail immigrants indefinitely. If immigration officials cannot deport them after six months, the court said, they should generally set them free.
“So to sit there and say that the proud women and men of law enforcement in ICE are choosing to release criminals is absolutely unforgivable,” ICE Director Sarah Saldaña told the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform

"For example, ICE had insisted in court records that reoffenders were “isolated examples.” To Congress, ICE officials suggested that reoffenders were rare, less than 10 percent.
But the reoffender rate among the immigrants on the Globe’s list is clearly much higher, at 30 percent."
The Obama administration lies about everything.
How many victims has Obama's "transparency" created?
Excellent article, outlining the various problems within our ICE system. Unfortunately, these problems have been there for years and I've yet to see the will of Congress to address ANY of them. Hearings occur on the Hill come after a heinous crime has been perpetrated by an illegal immigrant, a few hands wring, a couple committees discuss and life goes on with no change in sight.
Cochise2 - surely you hit the wrong thumb
Are you ill?
For the life of me I don't understand why these criminals cannot be deported. Congress should not have to intervene to make ice do their job. We should have no obligation to keep these criminals within our borders.
Jennilee,
One of the major obstacles is the country where the illegal came from refuses to repatriate them. I don't believe we have a law that allows ICE to pack them up, fly them home and leave them on their home soil. Our Supreme Court has said our justice system cannot keep them imprisoned forever after serving their sentence...hence they're on the streets.
Like I said, the system is fraught with problems that no party has been willing to address. These are but a few of the systematic issues.
Recidivism for ALL released criminals is way, way higher than the number for immigrants stated in this article. This article implies criminal immigrants are much more law abiding that criminals in general.
Career criminals of all races and nationalities are all still career criminals. My mother was married to one when she was screwed up in the head herself. He was on parole from Jackson State Prison in Michigan for beating a guard to death in a juvenile facility and he was Irish/German. He was a very violent man who was not interested in doing one day's worth of honest work in his life. When he needed to get somewhere, he stole a car. When he needed money, he robbed gas stations. He went back to prison two more times and died, as he should have, by freezing to death in a Grand Rapids alleyway while being a heroin junkie. Most of his friends were career criminals also and most of them were in and out of prison constantly.