╌>

THE GENIUS OF THE GOP HEALTH PLAN

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  10 years ago  •  9 comments

THE GENIUS OF THE  GOP HEALTH PLAN
House Republicans led by Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wisc.) on Wednesday released the most comprehensive GOP health plan to date. The plan is the fifth of six agenda items that comprise the House GOP’s “A Better Way” agenda for 2017 and beyond. Evan Smith of Opportunity Lives and Avik Roy at Forbes have good summaries of the plan.

The proposal repeals and replaces Obamacare, but it does more than that. It is an ambitious effort to reform our health system more broadly by updating laws that are quite literally stuck in the 1940s and 1960s. The proposed changes to our $3 trillion healthcare economy (which is one-fifth of our entire economy) will have profound impacts on patients’ lives, jobs, wages, the future of American politics and the character and direction of the Republican Party.

The plan is significant for many reasons. One reason expressed by Rep. Tom Price (R-Ga.) at the House GOP’s rollout event hosted by the American Enterprise Institute (AEI) is that it “finally put[s] to rest the notion that Republicans don’t have a health care plan.” Rep. John Kline (R-Minn.) echoed this point saying, “Now we’re saying we’re going to do this.”

For years, Democrats argued Republicans didn’t have any healthcare ideas, which was patently false. Republicans have launched an armada of around 400 healthcare bills including a handful of flagship Obamacare replacement plans. As an aide to then-Senator Tom Coburn (R-Okla.) I worked on some of those flagship plans. Sadly, they were sunk in battle (losing is a great teaching tool).

I remember sitting in Sen. John McCain’s (R-Ariz.) campaign headquarters in 2008 listening to Coburn describe consumer-directed health care to McCain before Obama savagely demagogued McCain’s health reform plan. I also recall Coburn teaming up with Ryan on the first Obamacare alternative, the Patients’ Choice Act, before Obamacare passed. Those plans were all improved on in the intervening years but Democrats did have a point. Republicans were reluctant to rally around a particular plan. Until now.

From left, House Budget Committee Chairman Rep. Tom Price, R-Ga., House Education and the Workforce Committee Chairman Rep. John Kline, R-Minn., House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Rep. Fred Upton, R-Mich., House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Rep. Kevin Brady, R-Texas and moderator James Capretta participate in a panel discussion at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI) in Washington, Wednesday, June 22, 2016, on the Republican health care plan. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)From left: Reps. Tom Price, John Kline, Fred Upton, Kevin Brady and AEI health expert James Capretta discuss the House GOP health plan. | Photo: AP
House Republicans have wisely built upon those lessons learned and put forward a plan that clearly addresses the complexity of — and seeks to resolve the confusion around — America’s health care system. Ryan has long emphasized the need to earn a mandate for change by offering specific proposals. The release of this plan represents the triumph of that perspective over other perspectives that would seek to capitalize politically from Obamacare’s failures without doing the hard — and politically risky — work of describing what Republicans are for. This plan settles that debate.

It does so by dealing honestly and directly with the competing perspectives about how to improve our healthcare system.

In the 2016 presidential campaign, Democratic candidate Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) did the nation a service by asking the right question about healthcare. The healthcare debate boils down to a question of trust. Who do you trust to create the most efficient, effective and compassionate system possible — yourself or the government? Sanders enthusiastically said, “the government.” He asked throughout his campaign why can’t we have a “Medicare for All” plan administered by the federal government?

He argues on his site:

“It has been the goal of Democrats since Franklin D. Roosevelt to create a universal health care system guaranteeing health care to all people. It is time for this country to join them and fulfill the legacy of Franklin D. Roosevelt, Harry Truman, Lyndon B. Johnson and other great Democrats. The Affordable Care Act was a critically important step towards the goal of universal health care … as we move forward, we must build upon the success of the ACA to achieve the goal of universal health care.”

The House GOP plan, on the other hand, takes a markedly different approach:

“[Our plan] recognizes that health care today is a wholly integrated system, consisting of providers, insurers, researchers, entrepreneurs, and others working to deliver the best quality care. Our proposal embraces this reality but also recognizes that people must come first. A health care system is only as good as its service of the patients who rely on it.”

In other words, the House GOP plan elevates people over programs, and values outcomes and results over inputs and good intentions.

The House GOP plan elevates people over programs, and values outcomes and results over inputs and good intentions
For the past six years, Americans have been able to see these competing visions in action. Obamacare proves the axiom that the best way to make something expensive is for government to make it affordable. As the House plan explains:

“President Obama promised that premiums would decline by $2,500 per year; instead, average premiums in job-based coverage increased by $3,775. The average premiums for families enrolled in employer sponsored coverage have increased more than $17,000 annually since 2010, a growth of over 27 percent.”

Moreover, Obamacare itself has become a pre-existing condition for millions of Americans who have lost access to their doctor because of the law’s provisions.

Sanders’ answer is to fix Obamacare by expanding government’s role. He argues the U.S. has fallen behind other industrialized countries that offer universal health care. But his comparison is misguided and misleading.

First, many developed counties are far smaller than the U.S. and are not a good basis for comparison. For instance, in terms of population, Sweden is the size of Chicago, Denmark is the size of Atlanta, and Norway is the size of Boston. The only place where “universal health care” has been tried on a comparable scale is the Soviet Union. That experiment didn’t end well. It showed that socialized medicine is a prescription for shared misery.

Second, many developed counties, such as Switzerland and Singapore, don’t have pure government-run or “Medicare for All” type systems but instead have hybrid public-private systems.

In fact, the U.S. already has a public-private system. The two largest government-funded programs, Medicare and Medicaid, include 55 million and 65 million enrollees respectively. Medicare is often described as the 800-pound gorilla in the room (during the rollout Kline said it was an 8,000-pound gorilla) because the program effectively sets prices across the entire health care market. (Consider a sports metaphor — because one can never use too many sports metaphors: Medicare is like the Yankees, Red Sox and Dodgers pooling their payrolls and forming one team. Sound fair?).

Still, think of it another way. We have a monolithic government system that casts a huge shadow on the private market. Patients operate in the dark with no sense of price transparency. We can’t see what things cost, which is the most basic market force that drives down cost while increasing quality. Therefore, everything costs too much while there are few incentives to improve quality. Health care sucks, and is confusing.

In short, the problem in our healthcare system is that we get the worst of both worlds (bloated government and distorted markets) when we could be getting the best of both worlds (competitive markets and a sustainable safety net).

The problem in our healthcare system is that we get the worst of both worlds (bloated government and distorted markets) when we could be getting the best of both worlds (competitive markets and a sustainable safety net)
The House plan aims to achieve a “best of both worlds” outcome by updating our health laws. As Apple CEO Tim Cook has explained, we have a tax code written for the industrial age but we’re living in the information age, which is incredibly stupid and destructive. The same is true of our health laws.

When millions of Americans returned home after World War II, Congress created a tax structure that rewarded employers who offered health coverage to their employees. This “employer-based” insurance model is still vital (150 million people rely on it) but it doesn’t take into account changes in our economy. Employees rarely stay in the same job for their entire working lives. Therefore, our tax treatment of health care should reflect these changes and not punish people who don’t have a 1940s or 1950s-style career, even if Bernie Sanders, Hillary Clinton and Elizabeth Warren think they should.

Republicans have suggested capping the employer deduction to help Americans without access to employer-based coverage buy health insurance with the help of a tax credit. The tax credit model isn’t unlike the Swiss system leading conservative reformers Doug Holtz-Eakin (former CBO director and McCain adviser) and Avik Roy (former Mitt Romney adviser) lift up as an example of a market-based system that delivers near-universal coverage. In hindsight, then-candidate Obama’s decision to ridicule McCain for bringing a Swiss idea into the campaign was a cynical near-term success but long-term blunder that facilitated the progressive movement’s quixotic crusade for universal coverage utopia. By declaring the Swiss model as too conservative, Obama chose an approach that has failed catastrophically for patients and his party.

A second critical update from the House plan is to apply a competitive model to the 1960’s Medicare program beginning in 2024. Retirees could chose from a host of plans that would compete alongside traditional Medicare. This is how the current Federal Employee Health Benefits program and Medicare Part D (the prescription drug benefit) already work. This approach is called “premium support.” According to the House plan this means, “Medicare would provide a premium support payment either to pay for or offset the premium of the plan chosen by the beneficiary, depending on the plan’s cost.” Welcome to the Age of Actuarial Aquarius, Bernie (p.s. please let the sunshine in to fee-for-service).

This reform would be transformational because it would turn the 800- (or 8,000-) pound gorilla into something more manageable. Perhaps a person, who can use words.

Therein lies the genius of the House plan. http://opportunitylives.com/the-genius-of-the-house-gop-health-plan/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    10 years ago

Consider a sports metaphor — because one can never use too many sports metaphors: Medicare is like the Yankees, Red Sox and Dodgers pooling their payrolls and forming one team. Sound fair?

The author was very honest to use a sports metaphor.  Baseball and Insurance companies are very much alike. They both exist for two main reasons - to WIN and to bring in lots and lots of MONEY.  Neither are going to change their business plan unless they are made to or until dying is no longer profitable because it doesn't benefit them.    

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Unfortunately insurance companies don't typically make a lot of money. There profit margin is only about six to eight percent. 

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

Dean - I think your % may be off a little.  Even if we use 6% the Insurers are doing just fine in the profit department.  

 

 
 

Who is online