Unraveling the threads of hatred, sewn into a Confederate icon
Sally Jenkins is a sports columnist for The Post and co-author with John Stauffer of The State of Jones, about Unionists in Mississippi during the Civil War. They are writing a biography of Charles Sumner.
This blighted boy with red hate in his eyes but otherwise colorless curdled milk skin this boy is a failure. It takes more than a weak stick like him to start a race war.
Personally, I pray that the lives of nine Charleston, S.C., martyrs serve this purpose: Instead of hammering and whispering on racism, we finally reach a tone of agreement based in simple self-truth. Surely we all can shake on the idea that the murder of preachers, teachers and librarians in the name of color demands that we examine how such an old, infectious poison got into the veins of a newborn American boy. And that requires admitting that we
we have been teaching fiction instead of American history. We have romanticized the roots of hate with crinoline and celluloid.
If you went to Germany and saw a war memorial with a Nazi flag flying over it, what would you think of those people? You might think they were unrepentant. You might think they were in a lingering state of denial about their national atrocities. The Confederate battle flag is an American swastika, the relic of traitors and totalitarians, symbol of a brutal regime, not a republic. The Confederacy was treason in defense of a still deeper crime against humanity: slavery. If weaklings find racial hatred to be a romantic expression of American strength and purity, make no mistake that it begins by unwinding a red thread from that flag.
Yet it is easier for the governor of South Carolina to call for the execution of this milkweed boy than it is for her to call for the lowering of that banner. Why?
This lack of political will and failure of self-recognition is not hers alone. It has repeated itself, on a large scale and small, generation by generation for 150 years, a self-lying sentimental tide. It seems inconceivable, Stanley Turkel wrote in Heroes of the American Reconstruction, that the losers of the bloodiest war in history were allowed to wrap their traitorous acts in the description of their so-called noble cause. Yet in 1957, John F. Kennedy won the Pulitzer Prize for Profiles in Courage , in which he distorted and maligned the character of Union Medal of Honor winner Adelbert Ames, chased from the Mississippi governors office during Reconstruction by White Line terrorists, while instead lauding L.Q.C. Lamar as the more heroic figure. Lamar drafted Mississippis ordinance of secession and raised the 19th Mississippi Infantry Regiment.
Maybe it wouldnt have done any good for Charleston shooting suspect Dylann Roof, who were told repeated the ninth grade , but he and his classmates should have been required to read The Bloody Shirt by Stephen Budiansky, which describes in vivid detail how between 1867 and 1877 the defeated South was permitted to overthrow new state governments representing black citizens, killing more than 3,000 of them with terrorism. Roof should have been required to read Redemption by Nicholas Lemann, who documents how President Ulysses S. Grant effectively gave back everything he had won in the war when he lacked the will to enforce the 14th and 15th amendments with troops, instead abandoning Ames to the White Line terrorists.
All wars are romanticized by those who have never felt bullets fly through their coats. But there is something deeply pernicious in the continued attempts to soft-focus the causes of the Confederacy, its aftermath and its lingering effects. South Carolinas part of the Declaration of Causes of Seceding States , also signed by Mississippi, Georgia, Virginia and Texas, stated that secession was the direct result of an increasing hostility on the part of the non-slaveholding states to the institution of slavery.
We will have truthfully reckoned with our racial history when high school and college students quit going to Heritage Balls wearing butternut military tunics and sashes and understand that Jeff Davis and Bobby Lee should have spent the rest of their natural lives in work camps, breaking rocks with shovels, instead of on their verandas and the fact that they didnt was a profound miscarriage. And when they understand that the South was in fact deeply divided along class as well as racial lines. Enforced conscription and edicts such as the Twenty Negro Law allowed the wealthiest slaveowners to sit out the fight. Something else Roof should have been required to read is Mark A. Weitzs book More Damning than Slaughter , which shows that dissension from within and the desertion of well over 103,000 disillusioned Confederate soldiers defeated the South as much as any battles.
In 1872, another much-maligned patriot, Sen.Charles Sumner of Massachusetts, introduced a resolution that would have forbidden placing the names of Civil War battles on regimental colors of the U.S. Army. Sumner felt that conflicts in which Americans killed Americans should not be romanticized or celebrated. He was shouted down and censured.
Maybe Dylann Roofs alleged acts have killed the impulse to romanticize atrocity anymore. Maybe instead of provoking a race war, he has provoked the wish to clean out this brutal wound once and for all with the astringent of truth. We are all unutterably weary of bloody internal estrangements. Can we not agree to run up the same flagpole? And to lower those crossed and starred banners, the bloody shirts with their inverse reds and blues? Personally, I would like to burn them and bury the ashes in an unmarked grave, keeping just a few for the museums.

I believe that more and more people are rejecting the very idea of the Confederate Flag and that the momentum is growing. More an more people have come to realize that it represents slavery, racism, hate and terrorism and not heritage or tribute to the men who fought in the Civil War then the Swastika represents heritage and tribute to the Germans who had fought and died in WWII. It's well past time to consign the Confederate Flag to the museum, just as we have done with the Nazi Flag. It is, rightly or not, now a symbol of hate and racism.
Excellent article. MM.
Great article, Randy. Maybe it's time for all of the people who don't mind the flag that much, or who wish to fly it, to think of what it represents to others-- a symbol of racism!
Thanks to all for the "good find" It is IMHO, less and less and less possible to defend the Confederate Battle Flag any longer with calls of heritage and honoring their forefathers who made the sacrifices during the Civil War. However that argument simply does not work any longer, as much as some people are still in denial about it.
I am sure there are still some old Nazis who get misty eyed at memories of what they saw as service for their country (at the time) and the sacrifices they made together in what for many of them was just doing their duties and I am sure they have passed some of these memories on down to their children. So at what point do we put the Swastika flag into the museum once for all? Well, considering the evil of the Nazi empire that time as already come and past and there are still former Nazi's still alive. The flag represents and symbolizes hate and racism and slavery to millions and the fond memories of a few are not justification for the pubic display of the that flag.
Well, the same time as come and passed for the Battle Flag. Yes there may be some who still look at it as a piece of their history and heritage, but their voices have been loudly drown out by those who use it to express their hatred, their racism and their desire to return to a state of slavery, that those who look upon it favorably once have been co opted by those who have used it to represent their naked desire to kill and main and otherwise terrorize people of color, mostly Blacks. If they like it or not it is as much a symbol of hate and racism as the Swastika has become and it's far past the time to confine it to museums and to those who really are bigoted racists.
The usual blurred lines crap . Obviously it represents both .
I doubt it.
i think it may have a major impact of some people, and woken them up. But I don't think it will make any significant change in the overall picture.
A related topic; After each major mass shooting, polls indicate a rise in support for more (sensible) gun control measures. I remember this was very true after Sandy Hook. But little by little support for gun control decreases. And nothing really gets down.
Ironically, one thing that might help is Hillary! Recently she seems to have changed from a sort of moderate poodle of Wall St. to a progressive (Undoubtedly thanks at least in part to Bernie Sanders & perhaps Elizabeth Warren.). And, apparently she's coming out fighting on the issue of guns. Will it be just talk-- or will she really press the issue? Only time will tell.
And racism per se-- that's a tough thing to change.
How idiotic are you to suggest that anyone with a grain of intelligence wants to return to a state of slavery? Or that even if they wanted to, would be stupid enough to think they could?
You don't mind if protesters trying to shut down legitimate American businesses fly the flag of Hamas, a terrorist organization. You don't mind if the Haitian flag flies at the home of Haitians here, and half the population of Haiti are children who are SLAVES, sold and bartered into slavery by their own parents who turn around and have another baby to sell.
You have an opinion about what the Confederate flag means to you, but you don't get to tell everyone else what YOUR opinion of the flag means to THEM. You and John both have a problem with wanting to tell others what THEY think.
It's not just the opinion of John and myself though. If you like it or not once being able to be proud of the Battle Flag has been dirtied by racists and White Supremacists. You may believe what you want to about it, but others have brought it down into the muck of their world and there is no way any longer to wash the hatred, bigotry, racism and terrorism from what it now represents.
People such as John and myself are not the ones you should be angry with. Who you should really be mad it is all of the White Supremacist hate groups who have taken it on as THEIR symbol and made it into something evil. I didn't do that, neither did John and neither did anyone else except them. Point your anger where it belongs. At the ones who corrupted it, not those who are just pointing the corruption out.
It is, rightly or not, now a symbol of hate and racism.
Shabazz 7X Badfish is right about that.
But little by little support for gun control decreases. And nothing really gets down.
It'll be seriously talked about and considered, until a war breaks ut somewhere or a revolutuion takes place or another act of terrorism (like this one was) happens somewhere else in the Western world and then all of the talk of gun control here will go away again. If the slaughter of so many innocent children like at Sandy Hook won't change the black heart of the leadership of the NRA, who own a lot of politicians and are nothing more then the gun manufacturers lobby, nothing will.
It'll take the slaughter by gun of thousands of children before there is a serious look at gun control, because the only thing the the gun people say now is to buy more guns. Big shock considering they're are just doing a sales pitch for the people who make the guns. That's it. Gun owners are nothing more then salesmen for gun manufactures. That's it. That's all. That is all most of the more fanatical gun owners are, is gun salesmen. They are their patsies. Everytime a bunch of people are slaughtered, their answer is more guns, which is raw stupidity, but makes the manufacturesmuch richer, on the blood of innocent Americans. Sold by people too ignorant to understand that they are being used and had.