╌>

A quick and easy guide to the planned parenthood videos

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sean-treacy  •  11 years ago  •  21 comments

A quick and easy guide to the planned parenthood videos

On July 14, the Center for Medical Progress began releasing a series of videos about the Planned Parenthood abortion clinics. Reporting for the video project was done undercover and took place over the course of several years. The videos feature executives and staffers at Planned Parenthood and affiliated businesses discussing and demonstrating human organ harvesting and the fetal body part trade. Some of the discussions and footage taken inside abortion clinics is quite graphic.

The journalism project immediately went viral, with millions of people watching the videos. But the media have largely struggled to even mention the videos and what they show. When presidential candidate Carly Fiorina mentioned the videos during the 2nd GOP presidential debate, the media claimed to have no idea what she was talking about. The weak media coverage has left many Americans in the dark about the content of the videos. And sloppy reporting has led to misinformation about the videos.

Heres a quick and easy guide to the 10 videos that have been released thus far and what they show.

1) Planned Parenthood Uses Partial-Birth Abortions to Sell Baby Parts

This 9-minute-video with more than 3 million views on YouTube features Dr. Deborah Nucatola, Planned Parenthoods senior director for medical services, munching on a salad and sipping wine while she admits to altering abortion procedures in such a way that baby body parts can later be sold to human organ buyers. Laws prohibit altering abortion procedures for organ procurement .

Weve been very good at getting heart, lung, liver, because we know that, so Im not gonna crush that part, Nucatola tells actors posing as organ traffickers. Im gonna basically crush below, Im gonna crush above, and Im gonna see if I can get it all intact.

See also: Full footage of the 3-hour meeting. Flyer from Planned Parenthood partner StemExpress, which purchases aborted baby parts, promising clinics financial profits , financial benefits , and fiscal rewards . An official from Planned Parenthood is directly quoted in the advertisement praising StemExpress.

2) Second Planned Parenthood Senior Executive Haggles Over Baby Parts Prices, Changes Abortion Methods

This video features Dr. Mary Gatter, who at the time the video was filmed was serving as the president of the Planned Parenthood Medical Directors Council. In this video, she haggles over the payment for human body parts from aborted fetuses. While negotiating a price, she says she doesnt want to be the first person to name a price, because the person who throws out the figure first is at a loss.

What would you expect for intact tissue? the undercover journalist asks.

Why dont you start by telling me what youre used to paying? Gatter replies.

At the end of the video, she jokes that shed like to get a Lamborghini out of the deal. Planned Parenthood, contra the video, claims to only recoup fixed costs in sale of human organs. Theyve never explained why negotiations would be taking place if that were true. Gatter also defends the practice of altering abortion procedures to procure intact organs.

See also: Full footage of the meeting.

3) Human Capital Episode 1: Planned Parenthoods Black Market in Baby Parts

This video features Holly ODonnell, a former StemExpress technician who harvested the parts from the aborted babies at a Planned Parenthood clinic. This is the first video to really explore how the organs are procured.

We were asked to procure certain tissues like brain, livers, thymus, pancreas, heart, lungs, and pretty much anything on the fetus. Its basically a huge trafficking of fetal tissues, she explained. StemExpress is a company that hires procurement techs to draw blood and dissect dead fetuses and sell the parts to researchers.

The video also features Dr. Savita Ginde, Vice President and Medical Director of Planned Parenthood of the Rocky Mountains, talking about how to get the most money out of an aborted 11-week old .

See also: 4 Shocking Moments from the video (NSFW). On using digoxin to induce fetal demise vs. crushing fetuses while still alive in the womb.

4) Planned Parenthood VP Says Fetuses May Come Out Intact, Agrees Payments Specific to the Specimen

This video features Planned Parenthood Rocky Mountains VP & Medical Director Savita Ginde discussing the practice of procuring baby parts as well as how to avoid media scrutiny of their organ harvesting.

Toward the end of the video, the cameras get inside the abortion clinics pathological laboratory. Medical assistants are heard and seen cracking skulls, and extracting brains. Heres some organs for you, a Planned Parenthood employee said. Heres a stomach, kidney, heart. A medical assistant exclaims: And another boy!

See also: Full footage . Eight shocking moments from 4th Planned Parenthood video.

5) Intact Fetuses Just a Matter of Line Items for Planned Parenthood TX Mega-Center

This video features Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast Research Director Melissa Farrell trying to negotiate a business agreement with investigators posing as organ buyers. She also tells them that some abortionists harvest body parts for their own research. They discuss how they could defend increased payments for more valuable organs even though the law only permits payment for costs. Its all just a matter of line items, she says.

This video also features employees of a Gulf Coast clinic pulling a 20-week-old twin baby out of the freezer, and graphically sifting through second trimester body parts. An employee holds up a liver and lungs as the technician gushes over how intact the organs are. A large severed limb is also pulled out of the dish where the other mangled remains lay. It is in this section of the video that we hear about the Planned Parenthood Federations encouragement of fetal organ harvesting.

See also: Full footage . Supplement to the full footage. Seven most important takeaways from the 5th Planned Parenthood expos.

6) Human Capital Episode 2: Inside the Planned Parenthood Supply Site

This video once again features former StemExpress procurement technician Holly ODonnell. ODonnell worked in Planned Parenthood clinics in California. In this video she explains how the procurement works and the cooperation between Planned Parenthood and Stem Express. Planned Parenthood provides the organ buyers with a list of what operations are being performed. Women are supposed to give consent for donating the body parts of their children. But, ODonnell says, their organs were regularly harvested without the informed consent of the mothers.

There were times they would just take what they wanted, said Holly ODonnell, a former StemExpress procurement technician. And these mothers dont know. And theres no way they would know.

ODonnell talks about one doctor who seemed to enjoy aborting children and who rushed through procedures. We also learn how the dead baby parts are shipped.

7) Human Capital Episode 3: Planned Parenthoods Custom Abortions for Superior Product

This is the video that the media claim doesnt exist. Its absolutely horrifying. It combines clips from previous videos weve already seen, such as some of the statements of Planned Parenthood officials, with the claims of others in the baby organ procurement business. But the centerpiece is the first-person testimony of ODonnell explaining how a late-term baby boy was aborted, how she didnt know if he was technically alive or not since the heart was beating. She says she harvested his brain by cutting his head open beginning at the chin. She describes how afterwards she had difficulty shoving him into a container because he was so big. She says it was the hardest experience she ever had. ODonnell describes harvesting the boys body parts with her colleague:

its nose was very pronounced, it had eyelids, and its mouth was pronounced. And then since the fetus was still intact, she said, okay, well, this is a really good fetus, and it looks like we can procure a lot from it. Were going to procure brains.

While shes talking about this, footage of another aborted later-term baby kicking his legs in a dish is shown. Later we see a picture of yet another boy who was born premature and died in his parents arms.

See also: Carly Fiorina discusses brain harvesting at debate. Misinformation about the video.

8) Planned Parenthood Baby Parts Buyer StemExpress Wants Another 50 Livers/Week

This video features Planned Parenthood organ buyer StemExpresss CEO Cate Dyer talking about consistent growth in the industry. She says, Planned Parenthood has volume because theyre a volume institution. Asked what would make her happy, she says another 50 livers a week. She says they work with almost triple digit numbers of clinics. They discuss intact cases, though the company later claimed it was just referring to intact organs, not entire bodies.

Dyer also discusses the lack of sanitary conditions at some clinics, which makes it difficult to get human organs that are not contaminated.

Ive seen really rampant, rampant problems with bacteria in certain clinics, Dyer said. Ive seen staph come out of clinics. I mean, Ive seen all sorts of things come out of clinics.

9) Planned Parenthood Baby Parts Vendor ABR Pays Off Clinics, Intact Fetuses Just Fell Out

This video features Perrin Larton, the procurement director for Advanced Bioscience Resources (ABR), a California-based non-profit organ middleman. She tells an undercover journalist that pro-lifers are making business difficult for baby organ traffickers.

Larton notes that while there have been federal limits on embryonic stem cell lines, taxpayer-funded research on aborted baby parts has gone on for decades.

Fetal got lost in the mix, she said. She said that they sent fetal tissue to the National Institutes of Health even though the tissue was gleaned from abortion.

This video features graphic discussions of how abortionists shred body parts and tear the baby apart in the womb.

10) Top Planned Parenthood Exec: Baby Parts Sales A Valid Exchange, Can Make A Fair Amount of Income

Though this video featuring discussions with a wide range of Planned Parenthood executives isnt graphic, it is in some ways the most troublesome for Planned Parenthood. Thats because this video shows that Planned Parenthood encourages the fetal organ trade at the very highest levels. They discuss how exchanging money for tissue is valid. Deb VanDerhei, the national director of the Consortium of Planned Parenthood Abortion Providers claims that some colleagues generate a great deal of income on the sale of human organs from aborted babies. Dr. Carolyn Westhoff, senior medical advisor for Planned Parenthood Federation of America, doesnt shy away from specific discussions of the human organ trade, specifying which human organs buyers are interested in, such as eyes, brains and gonads. Certainly everything we provide, she says.

Dr. Vanessa Cullins, VP for external medical affairs for Planned Parenthood, shares her worry that exposure of Planned Parenthoods participation in human organ harvesting could destroy it. VanDerhei talks about how the entire industry is trying to figure out how to handle payment for unborn baby parts, as it would be a public relations disaster if it came out what Planned Parenthood was selling. Both VanDerhei and Nucatola talk about how the lack of formal guidelines is intentional. They talk about avoiding a paper trail by not discussing things over email. Executives worry about congressional oversight and how that would affect their business. To sum up, Planned Parenthood clearly sells human organs (that is, exchanges them for money), this discussion goes well beyond cost recuperation, they are terrified of media scrutiny of their human organ harvesting trade, and they are terrified of congressional interest in human organ harvesting from aborted children.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I understand those invested in propagating planned parenthood propaganda will deny what's on these videos and pretend they don't contain what they do, just like people deny the holocaust. No matter how many times you show them the tapes they will act like the proverbial ostrich and refuse to deal with their contents.

Keep in mind, analysts with a long history of working for the Democratic Party and paid for by Planned Parenthood confirmed that every statement contained in these videos made by a Planned Parenthood employee was accurately recorded and not edited.

I look forward to numerous posts regurgitating already debunked talking points. Have it at, but please watch the relevant videos on the topic you say isn't there, before making silly claims that it doesn't exist.

The videos are embedded on the linked site.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Im gonna basically crush below, Im gonna crush above, and Im gonna see if I can get it all intact.

That's how you harverst fetal organs, straight from Dr. Deborah Nucatola, Planned Parenthoods senior director for medical services

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
I think I get it now - you're upset because they aren't crushing the middle?
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Hey, Congrats on authoring comment where you don't write god doesn't exist. You deserve a parade.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Baby steps. Now, back to your drama - isn't it clear that you are just plain against abortion, and that you and your ilk are using "harvesting" as a means to an end that you have no hope of achieving otherwise?
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Are you against informed choice?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
No, but I'm fairly certain we have different visions of what informed choice should mean. A woman's decision to terminate a pregnancy is hers to contemplate, not some shrill harpy standing guard outside of a provider's medical practice.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Such people are not interested in facts.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

A NOT SO QUICK BUT SPECIFICALLY DETAILED GUIDE TO THE FACTS!

The videos are edited and manipulated and this seeded article is a "GUIDE" to the edited and manipulated "information". A guided tour to a fraudulent presentation.

Anti-ChoiceGroupReleasedAnotherDeceptively EditedVideo Purport...

DECEPTIVE EDIT:Center For Medical ProgressCherry Picks Quotes To...

DECEPTIVE EDIT:VideoCrops GatterTo Claim Planned Parenthood Modi...

Planned Parenthood Receives"No Financial Benefit" From Legal Donat...

Payment For Fetal Tissue May Be AcceptedOnly To Offset"Reasonable...

Previous Video From Center For Medical Progress Was Deceptively Edited

The Center For Medical Progress Has Almost No Internet Footprint

CMP's Founder, David Daleiden, Has A Long History With Discredited ...

A Center For Medical Progress Board Member Called Murder Of Abortio...

Center For Medical Progress Is Also Connected To A Disreputable Ant...

Center For Medical Progress Cherry Picks Quotes To Claim Video Shows Planned Parenthood Was Paid For Fetal Donations

Edited Video: Gatter Admitt ed "Planned Parenthood Received Payment In Spite Of Incurring No Costs." The Center for Medical Progress' press releaseclaims thatthe deceptively cut video showsGatter admittedthat Planned Parenthood receives payment for fetal tissue donation "in spite of incurring no costs,"pointing tothe 8-minute long videowhereGatter saying the process "was logistically very easy for us, we didn't have to do anything. So there was compensation for this":

Gatter also admits that in prior fetal tissue deals, Planned Parenthood received payment in spite of incurring no cost: "It was logistically very easy for us, we didn't have to do anything. So there was compensation for this." She accepts a higher price of $100 per specimen understanding that it will be only for high-quality fetal organs: "Now, this is for tissue that you actually take, not just tissue that someone volunteers and you can't find anything, right?" [The Center For Medical Progress, 7/21/15 ]

Full Video Shows Gatter Was Discussing Process Of Obtaining Consent And Sorting Donations. The Center for Medical Progress' transcript of the full-video revealsthat whenGattersaid"It was very easy for us, we didn't have to do anything. There was compensation for this," she was discussingthe process of working with a companytoobtain consent for the donations and decidewhich donations could be used, citinghow itwas "logistically ... very easy"because arepresentative was there to help make the decision(emphasis added):

GATTER: So Novogenix was our partner in PPLA and they would send us- you know, big volume. They would send their staff to the site, and our staff, our medical assistants were used to discussing with the patients, do you want to consent? And they would say yes or no, and a lot of them said yes. Maybe it wasn't entirely sixty, and then once the patients have signed the consent form, the patients did not receive digoxin, and Heather would look at the tissue- that's probably Laura- she would take the pieces that she wanted and it worked out well for everyone. She was unobtrusive, she was helpful, she did all that kind of stuff.

LAUREL [Gatter's Colleague]: Oh, my apologies. Hi.

GATTER: So we just started the conversation.

GATTER: They're a start up, they've have been about a year in business. They are for profit company connecting researchers with people willing to donate tissue. We just started talking- they were a little bit concerned about the fact that they're in Long Beach, but they understand that every California affiliate is paired up in a tissue donation program, except for Pasadena. Volume, that you for getting it to me is eight hundred a year. We were just starting to talk about the process worked with Novogenix down in Los Angeles when I was there. To back up a little bit, PPFA, our parent body, is on board with tissue donation, but we have to ask for a waiver to do it, and we have to lay out for them what our program's gonna be like. And it's absolutely a requirement that we use only the official, federal government form for tissue donation, that we don't modify it in any way. Novogenix was working on a concept that California has slightly different requirements, and so it's different, and so they wanted to very reasonably insert the California requirements into the consent form, the federal form, PPFA said no, you have to have two separate forms, so it just added to the burden of consent issues. But I was also explaining to them, back when I was in Los Angeles maybe sixty to seventy percent of people said yes to tissue donation.

So Heather, a Novogenix person would come to the site, and our staff would sign the patients up, and get consent. Heather would look at the tissue and take what she required, so logistically it was very easy for us, we didn't have to do anything. There was compensation for this, and there was discussion if that was legal, they have been paying by the case, and there was some discussion about do we, in a different way, or I don't know what you're used to doing, how you're used to doing compensation. Patients don't care what we do, of course, but-[The Center For Medical Progress, 7/21/15 ]

Video Shows Gattner Was Talking About "Costs Associated With The Use Of Our Space" -- Compensation For Which Is Legal According To Federal Law. Even in the 8-minute video, Gattner's full comments reveal that the compensation being discussed was to offset clinic costs such as "costs associated with the use of our space," a legal industry standard for fetal tissue donation.

GATTER: And we don't want to be in the position of being accused of selling tissue and stuff like that. On the other hand, there are costs associated with the use of our space, and all that kind of stuff.

ACTOR: Exactly. Yes, right. [The Center for Medical Progress, 7/21/15 ]

Video Crops Gatter To Claim Planned Parenthood Modifie s Abortion Procedures "To Get More Intact Fetuses"

Edited Video: Gatter "Suggests Modifying Abortion Procedure To Get More Intact Fetuses." According to CMP's press release, the 8-minuteversion ofitsvideo shows Gatter "suggest[ing] modifying the abortion procedure to get more intact fetuses.":

BUYER [ACTOR]: You know, 10 to 12 week, end of the first trimester, if those are pretty intact specimens then that's something we can work with.

GATTER: So that's an interesting concept. Let me explain to you a little bit of a problem which may not be a big problem. If our usual technique is suction, at 10 to 12 weeks and we switch to using IPAS or something with less suction or to increase the odds that it will come out as an intact specimen, then we're kind of violating the protocol that says to the patient we're not doing anything different in our care of you. Now to me, that's kind of a specious little argument and I wouldn't object to asking Ian, who's our surgeon who does the cases, to use IPAS at that gestational age in order to increase the odds that he's going to get an intact specimen. But I do need to throw it out there as a concern. Because the patient is signing to something and we're signing to something that we're not changing anything with the way we're managing you just because you agreed to give tissue. You've heard that before.

BUYER [ACTOR]: Yes, it's difficult. It's touchy. How do you feel about that?

GATTER : I think they're both totally appropriate techniques, there's no difference in pain involved. I don't think the patients would care one iota. So I'm not making a fuss about that.

[TIMESTAMPS JUMP FROM12:38:25 TO 13:09:41, REMOVING NEARLY 8 MINUTES]

GATTER: Now you have my email address right?Here is my suggestion. Write me a three of four paragraph proposal, which I will then take to Laurel and the organization to see if we want to proceedwith this. And then, if we want to pursue this, mutually, I talk to Ian and see how he feels about using a "less crunchy" technique to get more whole specimens.[The Center for Medical Progress, 7/21/15 , 7/21/15 ]

Full Video Shows Gatter Reiterating That She Cannot Modify Procedure Herself And It Won't Heighten Patient Risk. Left out of the edited video isGatterand her colleague explaining that there are at least two different ways to perform the type of abortion in question, but the "slight variation" of IPAS (manual suction) does not put the patient at any more risk. Because some have argued that the consent forms patients sign would not allow doctors to perform a potentially longer procedure, even if the longer procedure were just as safe,before Gatter can endorse onetype ofprocedure over the other shespecifically tells the CMP actor she will have to consult with the surgeon she works with(emphasis added):

ACTOR: You're not putting the patient at any more risk, right? As you said.

GATTER: No. Just slight variation of the technique.

ACTOR: Okay.

LAUREL: Which, the consent they're signing is for suction aspiration, it doesn't describe what kind it is.

GATTER: Yes, but I have heard people argue that for the tissue donation, it says we're not doing anything different, so.

ACTOR: That's what I need to understand, because what I'm seeing it as, of course, I'm looking for intact specimens. You know from a medical perspective, the patient is receiving just as good of care. So help me understand the problem.

GATTER: Well, there are people who would argue that by using the IPAS instead of the machine, you're slightly increasing the length of the procedure, you're increasing the pain of the procedure, is it local anesthesia or conscious sedation, so they're technical arguments having to do with one technique versus another.

ACTOR: So it's technicalities, is what I'm hearing.

GATTER: It's something that I need to discuss with Ian, before we agree to do that. [The Center For Medical Progress, 7/21/15 ]

Abortion Methods Described By Gatter Are The Most Common Methods Of Abortion During First Twelve Weeks Of Pregnancy. The methods of abortion Gattner identified as most common at her clinic are two variations ofwhat is known as"aspiration" abortion, one variation ofwhich usesamanualpump. According towomen's health group Our Bodies Ourselves, the procedure is the most common method "during the first twelve weeks of pregnancy" and is "a safe medical procedure" with small risk of complications:

Although the number of women in the United States choosing medication abortion (abortion with pills) is increasing each year, aspiration abortion (also called surgical or suction abortion) is the currently the most common method used for abortions during the first twelve weeks of pregnancy. In 2010, about 72% of all first trimester abortions were aspiration abortions.

Some of the reasons women choose aspiration abortion over medication abortion are easier access and higher success rates. In addition, a surgical abortion is shorter and completed in a predictable period and fewer office visits are needed.

In aspiration abortion, the uterine contents are removed by suction (aspiration), which is applied through a cannula, a thin tube that is inserted into the uterus and connected to a source of suction, either an electric pump or a handheld syringe. (If no electric pump is used, the abortion is a manual vacuum aspiration, or MVA.)

SAFETY

Aspiration abortion is a safe medical procedure. Fewer than 1 in 200 women who have an aspiration abortion in the first 12 weeks of pregnancy experience a complication that requires hospitalization. The risk of death from abortion is always lower than the risk of death involved in carrying a pregnancy to term. [Our Bodies Ourselves, 4/2/15 ]

Association Of Reproductive Health Professionals: "Overall Effectiveness, Patient Satisfaction, And Complication Rates Are Comparable" For Both Types Of Aspiration Abortion. In a 2008 reference guide for clinicians, ARHP confirmed that both electric or manual vacuum aspiration "are safe and can easily be performed." Additionally, "in patients who are less than 50 days of gestation, [manual vacuum aspiration] results in less patient perception of pain":

Vacuum uterine aspiration allows for the simple evacuation of the uterus through a cannula attached to either an electric or manual vacuum source. Both methods of evacuation are safe and can easily be performed in any setting, including an office, emergency room, or the operating room. When conducted in the outpatient setting rather than operating room, vacuum uterine aspiration can result in substantial cost savings and significantly reduce patient waiting periods for services.

Overall effectiveness, patient satisfaction, and complication rates are comparable for EVA and MVA. MVA is highly portable, virtually silent, reusable, and available at a low cost. In patients who are less than 50 days of gestation, MVA results in less patient perception of pain as compared to EVA, but takes longer to complete. Additionally, pregnancy tissue may be easier to identify after MVA than EVA. Clinicians also report high satisfaction in the use of MVA. [Association of Reproductive Health Professionals, "Manual Vacuum Aspiration," June 2008 ]

Federal Statute 42 U.S.C. 289g-1: The "Research On Transplantation Of Fetal Tissue" Law Does Not Ban Alterations In Medical Procedure. In its explanation that "federal law requires that no alteration in the timing or method of abortion be done for the purposes of fetal tissue collection," the CMP press release incompletely described the statute governing fetal tissue donation. In fact, 42 U.S.C. 289g-1onlyregulates alterations to the procedure that are done "solely" for obtaining the tissue; alterations for other reasons are permitted:

In research carried out under subsection (a) of this section, human fetal tissue may be used only if the attending physician with respect to obtaining the tissue from the woman involved makes a statement, made in writing and signed by the physician, declaring that--

(A)in the case of tissue obtained pursuant to an induced abortion--

(i)the consent of the woman for the abortion was obtained prior to requesting or obtaining consent for a donation of the tissue for use in such research;

(ii)no alteration of the timing, method, or procedures used to terminate the pregnancy was made solely for the purposes of obtaining the tissue [42 U.S.C. 289g-1, Accessed 7/21/15 ]

Planned Parenthood Receives "No Financial Benefit" From Legal Donations Of Tissue

Planned Parenthood Statement: Fetal Donations Were Done "Under The Highest Ethical And Legal Standards," And Provide Them "No Financial Benefit." In a July 17 statement responding to the first video, Eric Ferrero, Planned Parenthood's Vice President of Communications, explained that the organization's clinics "help patients who want to donate tissue for scientific research" with "the highest ethical and legal standards." Ferrero noted that the organization received "no financial benefit" from the arrangement aside from reimbursement of "actual costs, such as the cost to transport tissue" -- consistent with industry standards:

"In health care, patients sometimes want to donate tissue to scientific research that can help lead to medical breakthroughs, such as treatments and cures for serious diseases. Women at Planned Parenthood who have abortions are no different. At several of our health centers, we help patients who want to donate tissue for scientific research, and we do this just like every other high-quality health care provider does -- with full, appropriate consent from patients and under the highest ethical and legal standards. There is no financial benefit for tissue donation for either the patient or for Planned Parenthood. In some instances, actual costs, such as the cost to transport tissue to leading research centers, are reimbursed, which is standard across the medical field.

"A well funded group established for the purpose of damaging Planned Parenthood's mission and services has promoted a heavily edited, secretly recorded videotape that falsely portrays Planned Parenthood's participation in tissue donation programs that support lifesaving scientific research. Similar false accusations have been put forth by opponents of abortion services for decades. These groups have been widely discredited and their claims fall apart on closer examination, just as they do in this case." [Planned Parenthood Federation of America, 7/14/15 ]

Payment For Fetal Tissue May Be Accepted Only To Offset "Reasonable Expenses"

Federal LawAllows ForDonations Of Fetal Tissue With Consent. Federal law regarding the use of human fetal tissue does not prohibit the use of donated materials. [Title 42 U.S. Code 289g-2, Accessed 7/14/15 ]

Health And Human Services Independent Review Board: Providers May Accept Payment "For Reasonable Expenses" With "Informed Consent." The set of standards outlined by the Health And Human Services Independent Review Board guidebook, the industry standard for medical research, explains that payment for fetal tissue may be obtained "for reasonable expenses occasioned by the actual retrieval, storage, preparation, and transportation of the tissues" (emphasis added):

Prohibiting Payments and Other Inducements

Payments and other forms of remuneration and compensation associated with the procurement of fetal tissue should be prohibited, except payment for reasonable expenses occasioned by the actual retrieval, storage, preparation, and transportation of the tissues.

Informed Consent

Potential recipients of such tissues, as well as research and health care participants, should be properly informed about the source of the tissues in question.

The decision and consent to abort must precede discussion of the possible use of the fetal tissue and any request for such consent that might be required for that use.

Fetal tissue from induced abortions should not be used in medical research without the prior consent of the pregnant woman. Her decision to donate fetal remains is sufficient for the use of tissue, unless the father objects (except in cases of incest or rape).

Consent should be obtained in compliance with state law and with the Uniform Anatomical Gift Act. [Health and Human Services Institutional Review Board Guidebook, Accessed 7/14/15 ]

Previous Video From Center For Medical Progress Was Deceptively Edited

FirstFull Video Released By GroupRevealed ThatCrucial Portions Were Edited Out. This video is the second in a series released by TheCenter for Medical Progress (CMP). The first was a July 14 video, which also relied on deceptive edits to falsely claimPlanned Parenthood Federation of America's Senior Director of Medical Services Dr. Deborah Nucatola had discussed how the organization "sells the body parts of aborted fetuses." The nearly nine-minute video and an accompanying press release also claimed that Planned Parenthood was in violation of 42 U.S.C. 289g-2, a federal law regulating the use and sale of fetal tissue. Yet the entire, unedited, nearly three-hour version of the first video that CMP released contains several sections that were edited outof the shorter video, whichcontradict the group's assertions. For example, as the unedited transcript shows, Dr. Nucatola says, "Nobody should be 'selling' tissue," and she repeatedly referred to "tissue donation" during the conversation. The edited video also jumps ahead nearly eight minutes in the middle of a discussion about money in an attempt to falsely frame Nucatola's comments as having to do with the sale price of tissue, but the unedited version reveals that she was actually discussing reimbursementcosts for legal donation during those missing minutes. [ Media Matters for America , 7/14/15 ]

The Center For Medical Progress Has Almost No Internet Footprint

Center For Medical Progress Describes Itself As A Non-Profit "Group Of Citizen Journalists." According to the organization's website description of itself:

The Center for Medical Progress is a group of citizen journalists dedicated to monitoring and reporting on medical ethics and advances. We are concerned about contemporary bioethical issues that impact human dignity, and we oppose any interventions, procedures, and experiments that exploit the unequal legal status of any class of human beings. We envision a world in which medical practice and biotechnology ally with and serve the goods of human nature and do not destroy, disfigure, or work against them.

The Center for Medical Progress is a 501(c)3 non-profit organization. [Center for Medical Progress, Accessed 7/15/15 ]

Center For Medical Progress Has A Small And Recent Internet Footprint. CMP's presence online was nearly non-existent until several weeks ago. The group's Facebook page shows no posts beforeMay 24of this year and the organization didn't join Twitter until May 30. No videos other than the deceptively edited Planned Parenthood clips appear on the group's YouTube site. The website address listed on their Facebook page leads to a Postal Annex in Irvine, CA instead of real organization. [Facebook.com, accessed 7/15/15 ; Twitter.com, accessed 7/15/15 , YouTube.com, accessed 7/15/15 ; Yelp.com, accessed 7/15/15 ]

CMP's Founder, David Daleiden, Has A Long History With Discredited Conservative Groups

Center For Medical Progress: Daleiden Is "Founder" And Project Lead For The "Human Capital" Investigation. According to the Center for Medical Progress' website, Daleiden not only spearheaded the "Human Capital" investigation that produced the deceptively edited video attacking Planned Parenthood, he also founded the organization. Daleiden's bio also describes his past work at conservative news outlet The Weekly Standard :

David Daleiden is a citizen journalist with nearly a decade of experience in conducting investigative research on the abortion industry. In 2013, David started The Center for Medical Progress as a vehicle through which to pursue sophisticated, in-depth, and scintillating investigative journalism projects pertaining to contemporary bioethical issues.

As Project Lead at CMP, David recently completed the organization's first long-term project, the 30-month-long "Human Capital" investigation documenting Planned Parenthood's illegal sale of body parts from aborted fetuses. Prior to CMP, David worked as Director of Research for a national new media education and advocacy organization. David is a graduate of Claremont McKenna College with a B.A. in Government, and his writing has been published in The Weekly Standard and The Human Life Review . [Center for Medical Progress, Accessed 7/15/15 ]

Life Legal Defense Fund Credits Daleiden As Director Of CMP's Project. In a press release discussing CMP's first video, the Life Legal Defense Fund credited David Daleiden as the director of the "Human Capital" project behind the deceptively edited video, thanking him specifically "for bringing these shocking practices to light":

The "Human Capital" project was a nearly 3-year-long undertaking produced by The Center for Medical Progress (CMP). Directed by CMP Project Lead David Daleiden, the effort secured audio and video recordings of Planned Parenthood administrators and abortionists casually agreeing to sell freshly-extracted parts from their abortions. CMP's devastating expose of PP's trade in body parts may be seen atcenterformedicalprogress.org.

Life Legal gives the credit for bringing these shocking practices to light to David Daleiden. But Daleiden gives a lot of credit to Life Legal: "The Center for Medical Progress thanks Life Legal Defense Foundation for their initiative and foresight in consulting on and helping to develop this project." [Christian News Wire, 7/14/15 ]

Daleiden Was Formerly The Director of Research At Live Action. In 2009, Daleiden was the director of research for the discredited anti-abortion group Live Action, which has been criticized before for deceptively editing undercover footage of abortion clinics in an attempt to smear Planned Parenthood. According to Daleiden's bio from the time on Live Action's website, he assumed his role in 2008 and was later banned from Pomona College's campus after "videotaping a Planned Parenthood of Los Angeles speaker denying Planned Parenthood's responsibility for the cover-up of statutory rape":

David Daleiden has a passion for promoting the culture of life in communities and campuses across the country. He is proud to be a part of the Live Action team.

A native of the Sacramento area, David first became involved with the pro-life movement at age 15, working with local college pro-life groups and learning from veteran activists in his community. He founded a pro-life club at his high school, helped bring pro-life debater Scott Klusendorf to his hometown, and has participated in the "Genocide Awareness Project" to show abortion images to the public. David points to such images as the original impetus for his work in the pro-life movement.

During high school, David was also heavily involved in speech and debate. He first met Lila Rose in the Junior State of America (JSA) organization, and over the years became more and more involved in Live Action.

In 2007, David began his studies at Claremont McKenna College (CMC) in Claremont, California. David currently runs a Live Action chapter in Claremont, which routinely conducts sidewalk counseling efforts, community education, and campus activism.

David took on his current role as Director of Research for Live Action in 2008 during the early stages of the Mona Lisa Project. In March 2009, David and a fellow student were banned from sister campus Pomona College after videotaping a Planned Parenthood of Los Angeles speaker denying Planned Parenthood's responsibility for the cover-up of statutory rape. The ban was soon lifted after intense public scrutiny. [Live Action, 8/17/09 ; Media Matters for America , 2/4/11 ; Media Matters for America , 5/31/12 ]

Snopes: Daleiden Is Reportedly Friends With Conservative Figure Best Known For "Severely Edited" Videos. A Snopes.com takedown of CMP's video noted that Daleiden is reportedly a friend of James O'Keefe -- another conservative figure notrious for using "severely edited" videos to target liberal organizations:

An individual named David Daleiden has been widely credited as the "leader" of the Center for Medical Progress. While Daleiden's online footprint is minimal, a 2009 Claremont University article (penned by fellow conservative activist Chuck Johnson) reported:

James O'Keefe is a friend of David Daleiden's. O'Keefe and Hannah Giles have been going coast to coast documenting instances of ACORN employees willingly giving advice on how to avoid paying taxes and shielding a would be pimp (running for congress) and a prostitutent from the watchful eye of the law. They've brought their investigation to New York City, Washington D.C., and Baltimore.

O'Keefe came to prominence in 2009 after he produced "egregiously misleading" and "severely edited" videos targeting agencies such as ACORN." [Snopes.com, 7/14/15 ]

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

CONTINUED

A Center For Medical Progress Board Member Called Murder Of Abortion Doctor "Justified"

Troy Newman, President of Operation Rescue, Serves On Board of Directors. "Operation Rescue President Troy Newman serves on the Board of Daleiden's Center for Medical Progress. During this investigation, Newman advised Daleiden, providing consultation services and material support." [Christian Newswire, 7/14/15 ]

Newman Called Murder Of Abortion Clinic Doctor A "Justifiable Defensive Action." In a 2003 press release, Newman defended Paul Jennings Hill, who was executed by lethal injection for murdering abortion doctor John Britton in Pensacola, FL. Newman argued that Hill should have been able to defend himself by classifying the murder as justifiable.

Today's scheduled execution of Paul Hill is not justice, but is another example of the judicial tyranny that is gripping our nation. A Florida judge denied Rev. Hill his right to present a defense that claimed that the killing of the abortionist was necessary to save the lives of the pre-born babies that were scheduled to be killed by abortion that day. Our system of justice is based upon 'innocent until proven guilty,' but in Rev. Hill's case, there was no justice because the court prevented him from presenting the legal defense that his conduct was justifiable defensive action.

"There are many examples where taking the life in defense of innocent human beings is legally justified and permissible under the law. Paul Hill should have been given the opportunity to defend himself with the defense of his choosing in a court of law. [Operation Rescue West press release, 9/3/03 ]

Newman Stalked Clinic Workers. A 2004 Los Angeles Times story detailed Newman's anti-abortion activism:

Newman will pick through clinic workers' trash to figure out where they do business; he'll trail them at a distance to learn their routines. His goal is not just to make their lives uncomfortable. He wants to unsettle and disgust their friends and associates, so their hairstylists and their pharmacists, even their neighbors, make it clear they're not welcome in Wichita. [ Los Angeles Times , 2/17/04 ]

Center For Medical Progress Is Also Connected To A Disreputable Anti-Choice Organization

Vox: Center For Medical Progress "Appears To Be Associated" With Life Legal Defense Foundation. In a July 14 post detailing the controversy around the deceptively edited video released by CMP, Vox noted that the Life Legal Defense Foundation "appears to be associated with" the organization, linking to a series of materials on Life Legal's website from the Center For Medical Progress. [Vox, 7/14/15 ]

Life Legal Defense Foundation Has Been With The Center For Medical Progress "From The Very Start." In a press release discussing CMP's video, the Life Legal Defense Fund said it had been working with CMP "from the very start":

Life Legal Defense Foundation was finally able today to reveal its support of an undercover operation proving that Planned Parenthood routinely peddles the organs and tissues of babies aborted in its "health centers." This systematic profiteering is known about and approved by officers at the abortion giant's highest levels of authority. Planned Parenthood's abortionists will even alter the abortion procedure in order to guarantee the tissues most sought after--regardless of what might be best for the aborting mother.

[...]

Life Legal gives the credit for bringing these shocking practices to light to David Daleiden. But Daleiden gives a lot of credit to Life Legal: "The Center for Medical Progress thanks Life Legal Defense Foundation for their initiative and foresight in consulting on and helping to develop this project."

Familiar as we are with the contract killer's practices, Life Legal can't claim to be surprised by Planned Parenthood's utter disregard for medical ethics. But we are delighted that it has been so ably and thoroughly documented by David Daleiden.

Life Legal is proud to have taken an active, essential role in exposing Planned Parenthood's "Dr. Frankenstein" wrongdoing. Katie Short, Life Legal's Vice-President for Legal Affairs, remarked, "Planned Parenthood's unconscionable acts are recorded and proven. But it will take a lot of pressure to bring consequences to bear. After these revelations, the first thing every public official should be asked is why a penny of taxpayer money is going to fund any part of Planned Parenthood's work."

Having been with the project from its inception, Life Legal is committed to following through. Planned Parenthood will not lightly escape the judgment it has merited by trafficking in babies' eyes, hearts, livers, muscles, and other organs and tissues. [Life Legal Defense Fund, 7/14/15 ]

Life Legal Defense Foundation Does Not Meet Standards Of Better Business Bureau's Wise Giving Alliance. According to the BBB's Wise Giving Alliance, which "helps donors make informed giving decisions and promotes high standards of conduct among organizations that solicit contributions from the public," the Life Legal Defense Foundation does not meet their standards for charity accountability. Citing the organization's indirect compensation of board member's sibling as well as inaccurate "presentation of LLDF's fund raising and program service expenses. [Give.org, Accessed 7/15/15 ]

Right Wing Watch: Life Legal Defense Foundation Espoused Conspiracy Theory That National Defense Authorization Act Was "Really A Way .. . To Round Up Anti-Abortion Activists And Imprison Them Indefinitely Without Trial." In a January 2012 post, Right Wing Watch called out members of the "Religious Right" -- including the Life Legal Defense Foundation -- who forwarded the fringe conspiracy theory that the Obama Administration's National Defense Authorization Act for 2012 would allow the government to permanently imprison pro-life activists without a trial. Speaking to LifeSiteNews.com at the time, Dana Cody, the president and executive director of the Life Legal Defense Foundation, said her organization was studying the NDAA because it says "enemy territory could be anywhere," and added, "If it's within the discretion of the government under the National Defense Authorization Act, of course it will be used by the government to intimidate and silence pro-life people, especially those who are in the public forum." [Right Wing Watch, 1/4/12 ]

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

My apologies; in the interest of short attention spans everywhere, I should have allowed the seeded lies about the video lies to stand unchallenged.

It's just that liars hope the calling out of, and the specific repudiation and debunking of their lies. will bore the average "mind."

It appears that liars have a point and a viable strategy.

The truth is always an insult or a joke, lies are generally tastier. We love them. The nature of lies is to please. Truth has no concern for anyone's comfort
Katherine Dunn ,

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Your post should warn readers they are about to be crushed in an avalanche of logical fallacies. Seriously, the amount of straw men you flail against and ad hominem attacks you unleash is truly staggering.

Seriously, how can you think the fact that CMP doesn't have a "significant internet footprint" invalidates the statements made by Planned Parenthood personnel on the videos? If you want to throw every piece of shit you can find against the wall to try and obfuscate the issue, go right ahead. But don't be surprised if no one wants to take the time to rebut irrelevant "fact" after irrelevant "fact."

If you want to pick a specific statement contained in the summary and rebut with specific information relative to that statement, I'll be happy to discuss it with you. But please be specific, this avalanche of irrelevance doesn't help anyone.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

All the lies and/or the sources of the lies/videos are there for all to see; you pick a statement and we'll go from there.

For starters

Seriously, how can you think the fact that CMP doesn't have a "significant internet footprint" invalidates the statements made by Planned Parenthood personnel on the videos?

It's a "witness/source credibility" facet, Sean. The "statements" you refer to are from edited sequences.

Your post should warn readers they are about to be crushed in an avalanche of logical fallacies.

Every so-called "fallacy" is explained.

But don't be surprised if no one wants to take the time to rebut irrelevant "fact" after irrelevant "fact."

I'll be surprised if they try they won't likely do so because my post repudiates yours. The only responses won't be rebuttals, they'll be the usual doubling down on the lies along with some personal attacks.

Why don't YOU pick a "fallacy" and show why it's not relevant (why it's not accurate)? Go for it!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

t's a "witness/source credibility" facet, Sean. The "statements" you refer to are from edited sequences

Except Planned Parenthood's own analysis confirmed that the statements were not edited. Go check it. Those conversations were put forth unedited and planned parenthood'sanalystconfirmed it.

hy don't YOU pick a "fallacy" and show why it's not relevant

I did. Whether or not CMP has a "large" internetpresenceis totally irrelevant to rebutting Dr. Mary Gatter haggling over fetal organ prices so she can get aLamborghini.

No one is arguing that CMPdoesn'topposes abortion. It's biased. We get it. That doesn'tmean the video is any way false though.Pretty much all that laundry list you posted does is demonstrate the bias, which no one is disputing in the first place.

If theSouthernPoverty & Law center sendsactiviststo videotape a Klan meeting in whichaprominentpolitician is caught on video making racist statements, would you beleading the charge to discredit the veracity of the videoon the grounds that the video wascaptured by a group with a political agenda? Of course you wouldn't.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Except Planned Parenthood's own analysis confirmed that the statements were not edited.

Sean, when a statement in a video is taken out of sequence, and/or clipped and re-positioned in that video so as to appear to be addressing something other than it addressed in the un-edited sequence, the "words" may be "confirmed," but the meaning is deceptive.

Here's an example pay close attention, Sean it's an edited fake AND TELLS THE VIEWER THAT UP-FRONT unlike the videos you defend.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   seeder  Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Except that the full videos were released at the same time as the abridged version so any "editing" that takes things out of sequence and or clipped would be pointless.

Planned Parenthood's own expert couldn't find any evidence of statements being clipped or re-positioned in the full videos.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Planned Parenthood's own expert couldn't find any evidence of statements being clipped or re-positioned in the full videos.

I don't know where you're getting that, Sean, but it is contradictory to this

WASHINGTON Planned Parenthood on Thursday gave congressional leaders and a committee that is investigating allegations of criminality at its clinics an analysis it commissioned concluding that manipulation of undercover videos by abortion opponents make those recordings unreliable for any official inquiry.

A thorough review of these videos in consultation with qualified experts found that they do not present a complete or accurate record of the events they purport to depict, the analysis of a private research company said.

Cecile Richards, the president of Planned Parenthood , underscored that in a cover letter to the Senate majority leader, Mitch McConnell, and House Speaker John A. Boehner, both Republicans, and to Senator Harry Reid and Representative Nancy Pelosi, the Democratic leaders.

Shortly after the release of the analysis, the anti-abortion group responsible for the videos dismissed the attempted debunking as a complete failure and attributed gaps identified in the videos to bathroom breaks and waiting periods.

With Mr. Boehners urging, Republicans on the House Energy and Commerce Committee opened an investigation of Planned Parenthood in July after the Center for Medical Progress, an anti-abortion group, began posting online secretly recorded videos . The center claims the videos show that Planned Parenthood affiliates illegally profit from selling tissue from aborted fetuses to researchers and, in some late-term abortions, prevent a possible live birth.

Planned Parenthood denies the charges and says that the videos were deceptively and misleadingly edited.

The analysis was by Fusion GPS, a Washington-based research and corporate intelligence company, and its co-founder Glenn Simpson, a former investigative reporter for The Wall Street Journal.

The videos, recorded by two activists posing as representatives of a biotechnology firm procuring tissue for researchers and universities, continue to be released online about once a week.

One of the activists, David Daleiden of California, told The New York Times last month that his thousands of hours of videotape was enough to release videos into the fall. That will coincide with Congresss final budget debate, and the videos have stoked growing Republican threats of a government shutdown unless Planned Parenthood is stripped of about $500 million it gets annually, mostly to care for low-income Medicaid patients. By law, public funds cannot pay for abortions.

The analysis commissioned by Planned Parenthood covers the first four videos and transcripts from the Center for Medical Progress, which were recorded in California, Colorado and Texas. Several have been released since with footage repeated from earlier videos, though the most recent ones focus not on Planned Parenthood but on a company, StemExpress, that procures fetal and human tissue globally for research.

The reviewers looked both at edited videos that are about eight minutes to 15 minutes long and at what Mr. Daleiden said were full-length recordings, some more than two hours long, that he released simultaneously.

A transcription service was hired to transcribe the videos, without being told that Planned Parenthood was the client, to compare with transcripts publicized by the anti-abortion group. That comparison, the analysis said, showed substantive omissions in the groups version. Mr. Simpson was assisted in the analysis by several others, including a video forensics expert, Grant Fredericks, and a television producer, Scott Goldie.

According to the investigation, the reviewers could not determine the extent to which C.M.P.s undisclosed edits and cuts distort the meaning of the encounters the videos purport to document.

But, it said, the manipulation of the videos does mean they have no evidentiary value in a legal context and cannot be relied upon for any official inquiries unless C.M.P. provides investigators with its original material, and that material is independently authenticated as unaltered.

For example, Mr. Fredericks said r ecordings in Houston and Denver were each missing about 30 minutes of video, judging from time stamps and frame counters on the recordings.

The analysis also supported Planned Parenthoods objection to two allegations that have elicited some of the most outrage from anti-abortion forces, disputing that Planned Parenthood staffers at one point say of fetal remains, Its a baby, and in a second instance, Another boy.

Mr. Daleiden, in a statement posted on the Center for Medical Progresss website, said, Planned Parenthoods desperate, 11th-hour attempt to pay their hand-picked experts to distract from the crimes documented on video is a complete failure.

He added, The absence of bathroom breaks and waiting periods between meetings does not change the hours of dialogue with top-level Planned Parenthood executives eager to manipulate abortion procedures to get high-quality baby parts for financially profitable sale.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

After reading this "article" and some of the responses it all comes down to two questions. Has Sean been lied to or is Sean lying himself. It's obvious from all of the investigations that answer to one of the questions will be the truth. Either the people who took the videos, heavily edited them to try to make planned Parenthood look bad lied and Sean believes them. Or Sean is lying. It has to be one or the other. There are no other options.

So Sean. Is the Center for Medical Progress lying and you're just one of their dupes or are you lying yourself?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Mark Twain admonished [tongue in cheek] that we be sparing with the truth since it is such a valuable commodity . But I would add that certain subjects be exempt from that restriction ... mostly the hard sciences .

 
 

Who is online





Thomas


97 visitors