╌>

The Exxon Shakedown

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  10 years ago  •  14 comments

The Exxon Shakedown
Liberal attorneys general from 17 states have put a big red bull's-eye on the chest of Big Oil.

Their bizarre claim is that for years energy companies fraudulently covered up their knowledge that greenhouse gases from fossil fuels cause catastrophic climate change. The most recent chapter of this witch hunt is a remarkable subpoena filed by Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey, which would require ExxonMobil to turn over 40 years of internal company documents. It also demands that ExxonMobil produce all its internal communication with conservative-leaning think tanks.


This is nothing more than an old-fashioned, political mob shakedown of a deep-pocketed industry for money. The AGs are hoping for a repeat of the multibillion-dollar tobacco company settlement in the 1990s. The big and obvious difference here is that tobacco companies sell a product that is dangerous to one's health. The oil and gas companies sell energy that makes all modern industrial life possible.

Worse, they want to use the steel-heeled boot of government to get energy companies to stop giving money to free-market institutions that the left doesn't agree with. But they are permitted to donate to the Sierra Club, the Wildlife Federation and the Center for American Progress. The goal is to silence any opposition on the right to the climate-change industrial complex. The way to create a scientific consensus on an issue is to muzzle anyone who dares disagree with the scientific consensus. If these science police had been around several hundred years ago, we'd all be forced to believe that the Earth is flat.


To enforce the global warming consensus, the AGs want more than money -- they want to figuratively hang the oil and gas company CEOs in effigy in the public square. New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman hinted that he'd like to see criminal prosecution and jail time for the energy company executives, saying "financial damages alone may be insufficient.…The First Amendment does not give you the right to commit fraud."

Get instant access to exclusive stock lists and powerful tools on Investors.com. Try us free for 4 weeks.
Get instant access to exclusive stock lists and powerful tools on Investors.com. Try us free for 4 weeks.
The end game here could hardly be more sinister. The AGs are following the example set by the Obama administration and the EPA to bleed and "bankrupt" oil- and gas-producers in America as they are doing now to the domestic coal industry.

All the while, there has been no factual basis for these allegations, just conjecture and speculation. First, there is no evidence that the companies produced global-warming research; second, there's no evidence that they covered it up; third, there is no evidence whatever that this research (if it happened) confirmed or denied global warming; and fourth, there is no consensus among leading scientists about whether global warming is happening, why it is happening, or what its effect might be (positive or negative) on the planet.

Moreover, unlike the tobacco company litigation, which concerned smokers who got cancer and heart disease, who is the victim here of the purported fraud by the energy companies?

While these AGs are using their positions of power to intimidate Big Oil, ExxonMobil, Chevron, BP and others have been busy creating millions of energy-related jobs, helping the USA become the largest energy producer in the world, driving down the cost of energy, and adding to U.S. growth. Without the energy companies and the shale oil and gas boom of the last decade, the U.S. would not have escaped the Great Recession of 2008-09.

But in Washington, no good deed goes unpunished.

Now for the ultimate irony of these AG witch hunts. The oil and gas companies are reducing their greenhouse gas emissions already. In part, because of fracking, and the new boom in natural gas, carbon emissions have rapidly declined over the past decade. So where is the fraud?

EXXONWhat's more, because natural gas burns clean, and because of its availability, affordability and abundance, it is more and more the fuel that powers the engine that drives our economy. The more we burn, the more emissions trends are declining (see chart). ExxonMobil and all the other energy producers should be honored and given medals for environmental cleanup, not demonized.

So fracking is reducing greenhouse gases, and yet the state AGs who say global warming is an imminent crisis threatening the future of the planet are trying to stop the energy companies that they are suing from fracking. States like New York, California, and Maryland have banned fracking, thus depriving themselves and the rest of the market of greater access to clean energy.

‎All of this suggests that maybe it is the AGs who should be sued for fraud. We're pleased to report that ExxonMobil is indeed fighting back. The company has admirably called the bluff of these AGs, and filed a lawsuit against Massachusetts' attorney general and the U.S. Virgin Island's attorney general, charging that the AGs are guilty of harassment. In recent days, the Virgin Islands AG ran for cover and dropped the subpoena. ‎ http://www.investors.com/politics/commentary/the-exxon-shakedown/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    10 years ago

Leaving a comment so I can come back...  Computer wants to update...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    10 years ago

So much for the 1st amendment ... and maybe some other amendments as well .

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    10 years ago

OK, I'm back.  I rescheduled the update for 3:30 am this morning...  My response may surprise you, and then again, you may wish to brain me...

Just because I have cleaned up so many messes from the oil industry, (over 50 projects), I have a hard time feeling too sorry for them.  However, I feel that these AGs are going after the wrong thing.  They need to go after the oil companies to make them clean up their messes-- not this.

We've had several companies that frack in KY frequently, inject highly radioactive materials into the Mississippian formations that are 'deep' in spots, at the surface in other spots.  The state is trying to develop a safe level for injection of radioactive waste.  So far, I think they are settling on 50 pico curies/liter.  I think.

This is what I see as a huge problem with fracking-- and I speak from the point of view that I spent nearly 40 years protecting our drinking water supply.  So, yes, I'm biased.  But then, few people have seen the messes I've seen.  

Injection of toxic materials into "deep" formations is just putting the problem off for a few years.  Maybe even a few centuries, but still.  We'll end up dealing with all of this eventually, so why not deal with it now, and NOT contaminate water supplies?

There is NO guarantee that the casings of these injection wells will hold up for a long time.  In fact, they usually don't.  We have huge problems in the state with brine and salt water, (connate water, or water that was there when the rock formed), from being water flooded to drive the oil into a pocket, so that it is more profitable to extract.  These wells have failed, and the open casings have allowed salt water to reach the levels that even a dug well will intersect it.  Meaning:  in many places, huge swaths of areas, if you drill down, or dig down, 50', you're in salty water, and that pretty much ruins a water supply well.  

Secondly, the oil companies do not perform any kind of a fracture trace analysis.  A fracture trace is a long, linear feature, where the rock is naturally broken up.  They are caused by uneven hardening of the rock when it lithifies or becomes rock, changes in lithology, and a host of other structural things-- like uneven settling...  Sort of like a crack in your basement.  

Fracture traces may be thousands of feet long, and I know that some reach up to 4,000' deep.  (I know because I've drilled into them, looking for oil, and the effects are measurable to 4,000'.)  That means that anything down there, can migrate upward, if put under enough pressure.  Which is exactly what they do, pressurize the system, so the rocks will take the fluids they are trying to dispose of.  If you want to think of a fracture trace like a stress crack, that may help explain it.  Fractures are everywhere, in all kinds of rock.  They intersect each other, and they are relatively easy to find on satellite, U2, and other kinds of aerial photography.  When you find them, you ground truth them, because they are seen on the surface of the earth.  If you don't see it on the ground, then it's not there...

Have you ever driven along a road cut, and the rock is pretty even, then you get to a section where the rock is all broken up and knarly?  That's a fracture.  They cause huge problems with tunnels, excavations, mines, etc.  They are a godsend to the water hydrogeologist, because they act as a natural way for water to travel through rock to a well.  By drilling into a fracture, you can increase the production by 1800%.  (I've done this.)  Same for oil or any other fluid that might be present.  But, they present a huge problem to underground gas storage facilities, etc.  And, unless you look for them, they present a HUGE danger to the safe storage of fracking materials.

Third, oil companies are a careless lot.  They don't really care what they contaminate, or what they spill-- it's not a part of their bottom line to be careful, or to prevent accidental spills of this fracking stuff, because they aren't required to do it.  So, they lose a few thousand gallons of benzene, kerosene, or whatever along the highway, when they're trucking it out of there...  It has happened here-- a lot!  We call it 'spreading the wealth'.

There are over 1500 spills per year on the Arctic North Slope.  That stuff doesn't go away.  The volatiles evaporate out, leaving the heavier components that eventually seep into the ground.  Oil companies have a hard time getting clean water supplies up there for their people to drink...

So, I don't agree with how they're going about it, but something needs to be done.  I personally recommend removing the "Haliburton Loophole".  Put them back under the Clean Water Act.  Make them clean up whatever messes they make.

Oh, and that "deep" Mississippian formation?  It is a water supply for many places.  The rocks just naturally bend upward until they are at the surface.  I don't want that garbage boiling up out of the ground, and I would bet you wouldn't, either.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

I just now saw your comment, and I guess my comment is way off what you were looking for.  I'm sorry!  But I felt I had to explain why I feel the way I do.

I think they're going about it all wrong.  On both sides.  

Note:  I am happy to explain fracking, water flooding, fractures, etc., if you want...  I tried to keep this brief.  (HA)

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

Thank you Lady Dowser.  Your explanation and examples were great in helping my comprehend some of the practices and procedures.  :o)

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

I worked a long time in the industry...  I'm happy to help explain some of the terms and what happens in practice.

They have done fracking sine the 1940s, but it was just a matter of throwing dynamite down into a well...  When it blew, it opened up the rocks in the immediate vicinity, which helped with production-- that is, unless it was drilled into a fracture, and then the "fracking" made the rock settle even tighter around the casing-- or into the open hole.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

http://img.wonkette.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/sanders-clinton-oil-statement.jpg

 

Hillary Clinton’s Biggest Campaign Bundlers Are Fossil Fuel Lobbyists

Clinton’s top campaign financiers are linked to Big Oil, natural gas and the Keystone pipeline.

Hillary the check is on the way.jpg

 

 
 

Who is online

Igknorantzruls


157 visitors