'I forgive you': Suspect stone-faced as relatives of church massacre victims offer compassion
The suspect in the Charleston church massacre stood stone-faced from jail Friday, two heavily armed guards behind him as he heard relatives of his nine victims bare their grief and offer forgiveness in a video court appearance where he was ordered held without bail.
"You have killed some of the most beautifulest people that I know," Felecia Sanders, mother of victim Tywanza Sanders, told Dylann Roof, speaking from the courtroom. "Every fiber in my body hurts ... May God have mercy on you."
The daughter of Ethel Lance, another of the nine victims in the Wednesday night attack at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church, had a similar message for the 21-year-old alleged killer, who police believe attended a Bible study meeting at the church, where he was embraced by strangers only to open fire on them for no apparent reason.
"You hurt a lot of people," she said, "But I forgive you."
"Repent. Confess. Give your life to the one who matters the most, Christ, so he can change your ways no matter what happens to you and you'll be OK," said Anthony Thompson, who represented the family of victim Myra Thompson .

This is what is going to keep me out of heaven!
That's exactly what I expected them to do. And exactly what they were supposed to do. I may be an atheist, but I have worlds of respect for the Christian faith they have.
It's same as when that man shot up that Amish school , killing several young children before he (I believe) killed himself. The Amish community immediately sent people over to be with his wife and family, to help them as much as they could and to grieve with them. They also attended the man's funeral with his widow. That's what you're supposed to do and the fact that so few who call themselves Christians do it, is one of the reasons I know there is no God. They talk the talk, but so very, very, very few of them walk the walk. Not enough of them.
I know, but like I said I'm not ready to forgive for several reasons, although I know this thug definitely has more problems than just racism.
I have strong doubts about that unless evidence is presented otherwise. I think he is just a plain garden variety racist killer. A White Terrorist. I think that 50 years ago he would have just been a typical Klan member.
I am an atheist and if some of my immediate family members had been killed, I would have forgiven him too. Not to get in good with a god I know doesn't exist, but because it is simply what you are supposed to do. It's the human thing to do. It's the moral thing to do. I still want to see him charged with capital murder and if convicted given the death sentence, but I still would forgive him.
IMHO every racist is a mental case no matter who he or she is.
The DSM-V doesn't recognize Racism as a mental illness. It is learned belief and behaviour and therefore can be unlearned. If we allow people to use Racism as a legal defense of it being a Mental Illness, then every person who kills a person of another race would be able to get away with it, based on temporary insanity of Racism. Or even being in a permanent state of Racism. Racism is not a Mental Illness. It is learned Hate. People are not born Racist. It has to be taught to them. Therefore it is not a Mental Illness.
Extreme obsession can be a symptom of a mental disease and he certainly qualified for that. It would not surprise me if he isn't diagnosed as schizophrenic. You don't have to succumb to becoming a racist by being subjected to it. Haven't you been subjected to things you didn't accept as a belief?
All I can say this is terrible for a number of reasons and I admire the people who can forgive. I don't think I could be so forgiving, especially so soon.
HISlawyers paid for expert Psychiatrists can claim any mental illness they want, but it has to be proved that he had it and that he knowingly had it before has commited the murders if thedefense diagnoses is schizophrenia. That's very hard to do. Besides, schizophrenics very, very rarely are violent. So proving that he is a violent schizophrenic is as close to being as being impossibleas beingimpossible is. The defense may try an insanity plea, but it'll be laughed out of the jury room. He is sane, he just is a regular, run of the mill racist who hates and wants to kill Black people. What I am REALLY curious about is who taught it to him? Generally it is a father or grandfather, but I'm betting he learned it at home.
Sad, he is a really messed up kid.
Who says that's what we're supposed to do? Why treat him, or any violent criminal, with respect or dignity?
I already have forgiven him, not that the families of the people killed will ever know it. I would forgive someone who murdered a member of my family too. I have done it because that's what is inside of me. It's what my morals tell me is the right thing to do. It's what most people would refer to as my heart and soul tell me to do. Just because I'm an atheist, doesn't mean I live with no morals or sense of right and wrong. These feelings I have just stated are not owned by any church of any mythical god. They are human feelings. Morality is a human concept, not a religious one, though most of them believe in them too. Believe it or not, even atheists have human feelings that are put into them mostly by their parents, but mostly through life experiences too. Not to cheat. Not to lie. Not to steal. And to forgive. Atheists are human beings too. We just know there is no god.
After a fair and impartial trial, at which he is almost certainly going to be found guilty as he has confessed and has no viable defense, he will be sentenced to death and die by Lethal Injection or the Electric Chair. I assume his appeals path will be fairly short considering his confession. That's good enough for me.
I am not sure who Wilson is, however as for Zimmerman I have forgiven his murder of Trayvon, but still look forward to his eventual punishment. Death.
Yes, I forgive him for the murder he committed, however like Zimmerman I still look forward to his punishment. Death.
What a cool idea! Forgiving people for their actions-- and then wanting to see them killed for their actions!
(Very creative indeed...!)
Just because you forgive someone for the crimes they have committed, doesn't mean they should not still be punished for the crimes they have committed. The two are completely separate. Forgiveness is not a get out of jail free card. There is a very big difference between forgiving and pardoning.
Wonderful