╌>

And now let us remember the worst economic prediction ever

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  11 years ago  •  1 comments

And now let us remember the worst economic prediction ever

Tinfoil-Hat.jpg

( laurelrusswurm /Flickr)

Everybody makes mistakes, but not all mistakes are created equal. Take writerMichael Kinsley's 2010 warning that hyperinflation was "our biggest economic threat" that could be "a disaster story on the level of Hurricane Katrina, if not 9/11 itself."

Now, the craziest part is that Kinsley admitted this was, well, kind of crazy. "Every economist I admire," he wrote, "is convinced that inflation will remain low for as long as we can predict. But, he added, "I can't help feeling that the gold bugs are right," whileconcedingthat this "fear is not the result of economic analysis" but rather comes from "the realm of psychology."

"Am I crazy," he wondered, or was everybody else for ignoring the inflation bogeyman under the bed? Well, two years later, he concludedthat it had to be everybody else."Barring a miracle," he predicted, "there will be a fierce storm of inflation in the next few years."

So I guess we got a miracle.Inflation has gone from 2 percent when Kinsley first sounded the alarm in 2010to2.6 percent when he did againin 2012to 0.3 percent today. Wheelbarrows full of cash that is not. Wallets will still suffice.

Like I said, everyone makes mistakes, and Kinsley told me he made one here. But, at the same time, he remains worried that "memories are short" and "many liberals have moved on to the view that more inflation would actually be a good thing." He was, hesaid in an e-mail, "bewildered recently by a New York Times headline declaring that Stanley Fischer, Vice Chairman of the Fed, was 'Optimistic About Inflation,'" where 'optimistic' referred to the fact that Fischer"saw 'good reason' to expect that inflation would rebound to a healthier pace."

"Do we want polio to rebound to a healthier pace," he asked me, "or Donald Trump?" The very idea, he said, "sounds insane."

Well, it's not. You can have too little inflation just like you can have too much inflation. That, after all, is why the Federal Reserve doesn't try to keep prices completely stable, but rather growing 2 percent a year. The problem with zero inflation, as a Fed Governor named Janet Yellen pointedout in 1996, is that it makes it harder for the economy to recover from a recession. That's because companies need a little inflation to "grease the wheels," as Yellen put it, of pay cuts.

Think about it like this. Any time a shock hits the economy, businesses that aren't as profitable as they thought they'd be need to cut costswhich means wages. Now, they could do that by cutting everybody's paychecks, but they don't. It turns out that companies don't like paying people less , because, get this, people don't like being paid less. Corporate bosses would rather preserve whatever morale they can by giving some people a pink slip rather than by giving everybody a pay cut. But they might nothave to do either if there was enoughinflation. Higher prices would do the job of cutting people's inflation-adjusted wages, so that companies could cut wagesby keeping them the sameand not firing anyone. A little inflation, in other words, can mean a little less unemployment.

The other important thing to remember is it's not how much the Fed cuts interest rates that matters to the economy, but how much it cuts inflation-adjusted interest rates. If inflation is zero, that means the lowest inflation-adjusted rates can go is also zero, and so a weakeconomy might not get the stimulus it needs. (Although, as we've found out, it might not with 2 percent inflation either, at least not after a once-in-three-generations financial crisis.) That's why economists agree that the economy is better off with a small amount of inflation, but not on how much that is. Before the recession, there was a consensus, for no particular reason, that 2 percent was the right number, but the recession has made economists like Paul Krugman , Olivier Blanchard , and Laurence Ball argue that it should be a little higher, say, 4 percent, to try to get things going and prevent something like this from happening again. But in any case, the idea that the economy could use more inflation than the 0.3 percent it has now isn't a crackpot one. It's a mainstream one.

What was odd, though, was worrying about high inflation at the same time that unemployment was so high. Now, that did happen in the 1970s, but it's hard to see how it could happen today. Workers don't have the cost-of-living-adjustment contracts they used to, which means that price spirals won't turn into wage spirals that become even bigger price spirals.Not only that, but the Fed monitors people's inflation expectations as a double check against that ever happening again. Before, people might have thought inflation was going to be 3 percent, and so asked for a 5 percent raise, which would then turn inflation into 7 percentand then make people expect 9 percent inflation. It was a self-reinforcing process. So that's why the Fed makes sure that people expect 2 percent inflation and only 2 percent inflation today.

But Kinsley ignored all that, and argued that the government's deficit determines inflation.It doesn't.At least not outside of a few extreme examples, like Zimbabwe, where the government spends so much more than it can even borrow that it has to print the rest.That is how hyperinflation works, but not how the U.S. economy does. Our government actually borrows the money it needs. That's why our inflation rate depends on what the Fed wants it to be, and not what the budget deficit forces it to be. Indeed, there is zero relationship between the twoan R-squared of 0.006since the Fed started de facto targeting inflation in 1988.

Even if you don't love the national debt, you can at least stop worrying that it's going to set off an inflation bomb.

But, as Kinsley asked me, if "government deficits never lead to inflation and a bit of inflation is a good thing anyway," does that mean that "we can just print money to pay for" whatever we want?Well, not generallyexcept for right now. What this misses is that the rules change when interest rates are zero. Banks are content to just sit on newly-printed money when rock-bottom lending rates mean the cost of doing so is nil.Especially when the Fed says it will un-print enough of this money to keep inflation from rising much at all. Why do anything with your money if you won't make any from lending it, and you won't lose any from inflation? You won't. So none of this money makes its way into the economy and inflation stays in hibernation, even as the Fed retires trillions of dollars of debt with all the money it has printed. (When the Fed buys bonds, it remits interest payments back to the Treasury, so the government starts paying itself instead of paying the banks that used to own them). That's as free as lunch gets.

But what if banks start lending all this money out? Won't the economy overheat, spark massive inflation and turn into 1970s America, if not 1920s Germany? In a word, no. The Fed has plenty of tools, with mind-numbing names like reverse repos and interest on reserves, to vacuumup as much of that money as it wantsand, if history is any guide, it's going to want to vacuum it all up. That's because the Fed takes its 2 percent inflation target quite seriously. If anything, it takes it too seriously, getting ready to raise rates even though there isn't any inflation to speak of. This is not a central bank that is going to fall asleep at the inflationary wheel.

Sometimes the obvious answer is the correct one.Today's Fed isn't going to let low inflation turn into hyperinflation. Today's government isn't going to force the Fed to do so.And Paul Krugman knows more about economics than Glenn Beck.

----------

And now let us remember the worst economic prediction ever

by Matt O'Brien

Wonkblog


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Excellent recap of the current situation, and what may be happening in the near future.

 
 

Who is online





Thomas


97 visitors