Paul's Flat Tax Indicts Bankrupt Idea Of Progressive Taxation
IBD EditorialsPaul's Flat Tax Indicts Bankrupt Idea Of Progressive Taxation07:09 PM ETSen. Rand Paul announces the start of his presidential campaign in Louisville, Ky., on April 7, 2015. APSen. Rand Paul announces the start of his presidential campaign in Louisville, Ky., on April 7, 2015. AP View Enlarged ImageTax Reform: It's been a long time since a major presidential candidate proposed a flat tax. Rand Paul's new plan will be vigorously debated, but the flat tax idea isn't dying because progressive taxation is so destructive.In the Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx places "a heavy progressive or graduated income tax" second in his 10-item to-do list for establishing a communist society. Bracketing it are, at No. 1, "abolition of property in land and application of all rents of land to public purposes" and, at No. 3, "abolition of all rights of inheritance."How can American society, the world's supposed bastion of capitalism, be so tied to the core Marxist principle of progressive taxation?Ronald Reagan's first-term tax-rate cuts and his 1986 tax reform improved things tremendously, bringing the top marginal income tax rate to below 30%, down from 70% during the Carter years. In the 1950s, there was a 92% top rate.But it was no time before it crept up again. Today, the top tax rate is less than a half-point under 40%, while the less successful are hit by much lower rates, like 15% and 25%. At higher income levels, most of the money that the government takes would otherwise go into private investments, generating jobs for those in the middle and lower incomes.Progressive taxation might as well have been devised by Invidia, the personification of envy, of whom the ancient Roman poet Ovid wrote, "Gnawing at others, and being gnawed, she was herself her own torment."Indeed, envy-based progressive taxation is its own torment, as divided sectors of the community gnaw at each other's successes and stifle society's potential.As IBD's John Merline found in a Congressional Budget Office report last November, the top 1%, making 15% of all income, "paid 35% of all federal income taxes. The bottom 20% accounted for 5.3% of income, but they got more in refundable tax credits, on average, than they paid in income taxes."Even when you include payroll and other federal taxes, the bottom 20% carried just 0.6% of the total tax burden."Nothing fair or equitable in a system like that.The plan that Sen. Paul, R-Ky., unveiled this week would "blow up the tax code and start over," with a single broad-based rate of 14.5% on individuals and corporations, accompanied by elimination of nearly all deductions. Other seekers of the White House will no doubt soon present their own flat, or near-flat, tax reforms.The code's monstrous 70,000-plus pages currently give the Internal Revenue Service massive powers to seize Americans' bank accounts simply on suspicion, without a judge's warrant. With that power, the IRS has in recent years harassed and weakened the effectiveness of political organizations, elements of the populist tea party movement in particular. Ending progressive taxation with a single low rate applicable to all would mean little if any need for a national confiscatory police force like the IRS, since noncompliance would be largely unheard of under such a simple system no longer dedicated to serving government greed.Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/061815-758020-flat-tax-cures-damaging-progressive-income-tax.htm#ixzz3dScAYD00 Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook

A flat tax is regressive, it hurts those who make less more than it hurts those who make more.