News Analysis: Bernie Sanders Can Take Heart From a Broadway Champ
IF you want to support Senator Bernie Sanders for president but worry that he doesnt have a shot against Hillary Rodham Clinton for the Democratic nomination, take heart from the Broadway show Fun Home, which won the Tony Award for best musical last week.
Fun Home was the decided underdog: a nominee with little money, bold themes, no frills and a small team on the payroll. (Sound familiar, Sanders-ites?) The story of a lesbian cartoonist and her relationship with her closeted gay father, Fun Home is about facing difficult truths and the tragic consequences when we dont the very message, as it happens, that the Sanders campaign is offering to America about income inequality and climate change. Compared with the flashy big-budget musical An American in Paris, which was the safe bet to win the Tony, Fun Home looked like a fringe contender, too dark and offbeat to have wide appeal, not unlike certain politicians who are easily dismissed as quixotic nonfactors.
In other words, Fun Home isnt the sort of musical you imagine on Broadway just as Mr. Sanders isnt the sort of politician you imagine in the White House. (He would be the first socialist president, after all.)
What does it take for an underdog to succeed? In politics and on Broadway, two worlds Ive covered as a reporter, some of the factors are similar. Message and perseverance are crucial. Money not a fortune, but at least enough is essential. And authenticity matters most of all.
Underdog candidates like Harry S. Truman in 1948 and Barack Obama in the 2008 primary contest struck many voters as authentic leaders who were willing to speak truth to power (Truman railing against a do-nothing Congress, Mr. Obama opposing the American invasion of Iraq) and who did not try to be all things to all voters. Truman was quintessentially Midwestern and didnt shy away from his roots, no matter what coastal elites thought of him. Mr. Obama was the first black presidential nominee and didnt shy away from his race, giving an eloquent speech in the face of controversy over his Chicago pastor. Many Americans came to see both men as the real deal.
Underdogs succeed when the voters are in a certain zone I call it the voter zone where they are looking for something, and the underdog candidate taps into that something, said Tad Devine, a veteran Democratic consultant who is advising Mr. Sanders. It can be a set of issues, attitudes or beliefs that voters feel are being overlooked by the front-running candidates. If the underdog can get into the voter zone with the voters by themselves, and if they are credible, they can win despite the odds.
Both Fun Home and An American in Paris had plenty of credibility in the run-up to the Tony Awards : They were winning over critics and filling seats with paying customers, two meaningful measures in the eyes of the 844 Tony voters eligible to cast ballots for best musical. But Fun Home had a freshness that appealed to many liberals among the Tony electorate: Shows about lesbians are rare on Broadway. Its producers, meanwhile, had shown perseverance by developing the musical for years and raising enough money ($5.2 million) to transfer it from the Public Theater, Off Broadway, to Broadway.
A lot of people loved Fun Home, but they also believed in what it was about and wanted to see it win, said Scott Sanders, a veteran Broadway producer (who is not related to the senator).
Underdog victories can be fleeting, of course. The musical Nine beat Dreamgirls for the Tony in 1982, but Dreamgirls has become the more cherished title. Another upset win came in 2004 when Avenue Q triumphed over Wicked yet Wicked is the one about to hit $4 billion in global ticket sales. In politics, former Gov. Howard Dean of Vermont also Mr. Sanderss home state had the antiwar message and political authenticity (Im here to represent the Democratic wing of the Democratic Party) that pleased many party members in the 2004 presidential primaries, but came up short to the establishment candidate, Senator John Kerry. And Senator Sanders may be attracting attention to his message by drawing large crowds, like the thousand people who turned out for him this month in Keene, N.H., but Mrs. Clinton is sure to attract a sea of fans to her rallies on Roosevelt Island on Saturday and in Des Moines on Sunday.
Like Eugene McCarthy in 1968, Sanders will offer a way to cast a protest vote in a primary against Hillary Clinton, but I dont expect him to register much support beyond that, said Douglas E. Schoen, a Democratic strategist who was an adviser to President Bill Clinton.
Dare to dream, the underdogs reply. Take the fight for same-sex marriage : It was a long-shot movement for years, but perseverance (through legal and political fights) and authenticity (the love and commitment of same-sex couples) have helped changed policies and attitudes across the country.
Its the underdogs who dare to push the envelope, who dare to take risks, and who dare to be different, said Chad Griffin, president of the Human Rights Campaign, a gay rights group. In doing so, its the underdogs who prove the pessimists wrong and push the world forward.
Among those rooting for Senator Sanders is Alison Bechdel, who wrote the graphic memoir Fun Home, which was adapted into the musical. Like Mr. Sanders, Ms. Bechdel lives near Burlington, Vt., and she has been a political supporter of his for years. And if an underdog like Fun Home can win, she said, maybe he can surprise people, too.
People kept saying that we were too small and challenging to beat something big and comforting like American in Paris, Ms. Bechdel said. This is where the analogy between Fun Home and presidential politics is interesting. People say they wont support a candidate who they think is unelectable. But if enough people vote for the candidate, what happens? They will get elected. You just need enough voters to go with their heart.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/14/opinion/bernie-sanders-can-take-heart-from-a-broadway-champ.html

Bernie Sanders is a different kind of presidential candidate in many ways - whether that is a good thing or a bad thing is a matter of opinion and considerable debate. Can Sanders win? Doubtful I the eyes of the experts, but it is always interesting to watch and hope that an underdog does better than expected. I do not agree with Sen Sanders on many policy issues, but I admire his forthrightness and feel that he would (to the best of his ability) do exactly what he says he would do if elected.
He is largely being ignored in the early days of his campaign and perhaps that will persist, I for one hope that he at least advances the dialogue of both parties in the run up to the 2016 elections.
I won't be voting for Sen Sanders, but I am very interested to see how many people do.
As usual your crudeness overshadows the point (a valid one) that Sen Sanders appeals (At this point) to a very select group of voters.
Irrelevant
Sen Sanders has never held state-wide office in Vermont and thus is not responsible for state government policies and programs.
I like Bernie and many of his ideas. I can't support his level of isolation though and it's one one of the reasons he doesn't stand a change at becoming President. Yes, I would love Medicare for all or just free healthcare for all Americans, like many countries do for their citizen, but with the gerrymandered republican House staying in their control at least until the new census at the end of the decade it's simply now going to happen. Let's keep working on Obamacare and making it more liberal until we retake the House. There is a good chance for us to retake the Senate the next election and holding onto it through the 2018 election. But it still won't be enough to talk the rich financed (bought) republican shills into voting for something the rest of the westernized countries have.
Hillary is going to be the the nominee and I hear Jeb Bush doesn't want to be called by his last name anymore. Just Jeb, without the Bush. I wonder how his father and brother feel about him saying fuck you to them both? I don't think anyone will forget his last name. Hillary beats him fairly easily.
The Democrats drove the plan and by his own admission he is not a Democrat.
Would you care to discuss the article topic which is not the PPACA or the Vermont single payer healthcare system?
M M
Thanks for the perspective
I do not agree with most of his positions, but have great respect for his honesty and unwavering in those positions
I think he is a what you see is what you get politicians - unlike the leaders in the two major party at this point who are empty of sincerity.