╌>

Anarchy in the House

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  feronia  •  11 years ago  •  23 comments

Anarchy in the House

SEPT. 29, 2015

REPUBLICANS arent big fans of Karl Marx, but perhaps they should ponder his observation that history repeats itself first as tragedy, then as farce. As preposterous presidential candidates dominate the polls and extremists topple congressional leaders, the Republican Party is headed for a replay of the catastrophic Goldwater revolt of the early 1960s. It may be an entertaining spectacle, but its dangerous.

The Republican Party has long been divided into comparatively moderate and conservative factions, but historically the conservatives were realists, too. Senator Robert Taft of Ohio, the great conservative leader of the mid-20 th century, understood that his side had to make incremental steps toward its goals. It had to devise detailed policy alternatives to Democratic proposals, work with party leadership and build coalitions both within the party and across party lines.

But the early 1960s witnessed an overthrow of Taftian realism. The radicals who coalesced around Senator Barry Goldwaters insurgent presidential campaign were zealots. They had no interest in developing a governing agenda. Their program consisted mainly of getting rid of the New Deal and every other government effort to promote the general welfare. As Goldwater famously wrote: My aim is not to pass laws, but to repeal them. It is not to inaugurate new programs, but to cancel old ones.

Goldwaters followers viewed any Republicans who wanted to govern as traitors to be stamped out. They accused their own leadership of conspiring with Democrats to thwart conservatives; the theme of betrayal from within had been the essence of Senator Joseph R. McCarthys populist appeal. They had no strategy other than taking over the party and nominating Goldwater. He would win the 1964 election, they believed, because a hidden majority would flock to the polls when presented with a candidate who wasnt what we would now call politically correct.

Years ago, I wrote a history of the Republican civil war between the moderates and radicals of the Goldwater era. Im sufficiently alarmed, watching history repeat itself, that I now work as a research consultant for the Main Street Partnership, an organization of over 70 members of Congress who represent the moderate-conservative wing of the Republican Party. Their rivals are members of the Freedom Caucus, who would rather close the government than compromise.

Once again, the battle is between Republicans who want to govern and those who dont. The radicals have no realistic alternative solutions of their own. Even to contemplate the negotiations and compromises such policies entail would sully their ideological purity.

Senator Goldwater, despite his brave talk of repeal, was an isolated, powerless legislator. The extremists who opposed John A. Boehner as speaker are likewise a small faction without the ability to accomplish any positive program. InsideGov, a government watchdog site, recently came up with a list of the least effective members of Congress , as determined by the percentage of bills they sponsored that went on to pass committee. Ideological extremism correlates closely with legislative impotence.

Thats unsurprising, since many members of the Freedom Caucus put a higher priority on scoring purity points than on carrying out the nations business. Its chairman, Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio, is, by this accounting, the second-least effective member of Congress. The only one whos even less effective is another longtime critic of Mr. Boehner, Representative Steve King of Iowa, not one of whose 94 sponsored bills has passed the committee stage. Most of Mr. Boehners harshest critics lurk at the bottom of the Lugar Centers Bipartisanship Index . Representative Tim Huelskamp of Kansas, who triumphantly tweeted Today the establishment lost after Mr. Boehners resignation, is ranked last.

The Republican Partys unhappy ideological adventure in the early 60s ended in disaster. Goldwater not only lost the election in a landslide, but he dragged down the entire Republican ticket. The main result of conservative overreach was to hand President Lyndon B. Johnson the liberal supermajority he needed to pass Medicare and Medicaid.

The present resurgence of anti-governing conservatism is also likely to end badly for Republicans. The extremists have the ability to disrupt the Congress, but not to lead it. Their belief that shutdowns will secure real concessions is magical thinking, not legislative realism. And the more power they gain, the less likely it becomes that a Republican-controlled Congress can pass conservative legislation, or indeed any legislation at all.

Its true that sometimes no legislation is better than bad legislation. But the United States faces real problems, including stagnant wages, family instability, infrastructure collapse and long-term indebtedness. If Republicans cant advance their own solutions, theyll have to deal with what Democrats or harsh realities impose on them. Paralysis is not a plan.

The rebranding of Republicanism as a force for anarchy has spilled into the presidential contest and threatens the general election chances of the eventual nominee. The Republican establishment, and the partys governing majority, have the power to quell this insurgency, whether by abandoning the so-called Hastert rule, which requires a majority of the majority to approve of legislation before it can come up for a vote, or by mounting primary challenges of their own. Its too late for Mr. Boehner to face down the radicals, but his successor will have to if the Republican Party is to have a meaningful future.

~~Link~~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Good article. I was around when Goldwater was running, talk about the right almost destroying themselves, that was the time.

It's interesting to note, that the Tea Party members are taking credit for getting Boehner to resign. Yet, not one of them has stepped forward to take his position and lead the party. That, in itself,is indicative of their lack of leadership or a plan.

Talk about ''leading from behind''..Smile.gif

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

LOL! Them claiming that they drove Boehner out of office is like Al Qaeda taking claim for a tornado that hits Kansas.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Good seed. (I almost posted it... but I did the other one about the crazies, instead.)

We're beginning to see the "reality is whatever I wish" wing, which has been nourished by the Big Business wing for forty years... turn on its master. Frankenstein.

The genie is out of the bottle, and everyone knows that you can't put it back.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

He lost to Johnson by one of the largest margins in history. Popular vote 61% to 38%. Goldwater won only 5 or 6 states.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

This over-the-top political attack ad against the Goldwater campaign still lives in infamy :

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

He hinted that he wanted to use nuclear weapons on North Vietnam. Which is what resulted in the Daisy ad from Johnson, which was so powerful it was only shown ONCE on TV. Every other time it has been seen has been during discussions where it comes up.

Johnson was right in the ad. Those were the stakes.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I think McConnell will be around for awhile. Or at least until the GOP loses control of the Senate again (coming up in 2016), because there are not that many Tea Party nuts in the Senate as there are in the House. It's easier to elect a lunatic from one single congressional district, then it is to elect a lunatic statewide or nationwide. The real question is when the Democrats take the Senate back who is going to be the Majority Leader with Reid leaving.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I would agree he is there for the cookies, but as his senility sets in he is also there to scream war at the top of hs lungs at the slightest provocation. John never met a war he didn't love and that's what he loves about the Tea Party. They'd rather spend our taxpayer money fighting unnecessary wars rather then helping our own country's needs. They rather spend our money on the other side of the world while our own infrastructure falls apart.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Yeah! Why are the media ignoring all the high drama of the Martin O'Malley campaign?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

The tea party wishes to control the government but, as mentioned above, they need leadership. They have absolutely no leader.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I couldn't agree more. There is no one person who is a guiding force for that movement. Ted Cruz would like to be and is trying to be, but he is...well...Ted Cruz and couldn't guide his way across a 1 foot wide brook.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    11 years ago

The tea party wishes to control the government

And there in lies such a strange dichotomy.

Tea Party, sure the first rally cry was about taxes but those getting elected under tea party mantel these days have a generally philosophy loosely based on "Government Bad, Government Doesn't Work", so they get a job in Government then do everything they can to make their beliefs become reality.

Or toborrow from John Boehner, "FalseProphets doing every thingpossible in hopes of crating a self fulfilling prophecy, Government bad, Government doesn't work and taxes are too dam high".

Generally just destructive putz's.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Thanks, Petey, for showing the ad.

I did not see it at the time, (that I remember), but it was certainly a powerful ad-- especially since we had those awful drop and cringe drills in school.

In my mind, I've been comparing those days of anarchy with today-- when there was rioting in the streets, and assassinations every time you turned around. What a horror! I was hoping that my son wouldn't have to see them come again.

Great article, Feronia!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

1st,

The tea party wishes to control the government...

That depends on what you mean.. The crazies do indeed want to control the people who are trying to govern... but they most definitely do not want to govern themselves. They are back-seat drivers, heckling the driver but taking no responsibility themselves.

 
 

Who is online





Thomas


97 visitors