╌>

The Graying of the U.S. Middle Class

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  11 years ago  •  15 comments

The Graying of the U.S. Middle Class

Margaret and Charles Kozlovsky in their 1957 Chevrolet after working out at the senior center in Waxahachie. Mr. Kozlovsky retired from a job driving an 18-wheeler in 2009, but he works as a school bus driver and volunteers at the senior center. Credit Brandon Thibodeaux for The New York Times

Most Americans suffered serious losses during and after the recession, knocked off balance by layoffs, stagnant pay and the collapse of home values. But apart from the superrich, one groups fortunes appears to have held remarkably steady: seniors.

Supported by income from Social Security , pensions and investments, as well as an increasing number of paychecks from delaying retirement, older people not only weathered the economic downturn that began in 2007 but made significant gains, a New York Times analysis of government data has found.

As a result, Americas middle class is graying.

People on the leading edge of the baby boom and those born during World War II the 25 million Americans now between the ages of 65 and 74 have emerged as particularly well positioned in the nations economic timeline. While there are plenty of individual exceptions, as a group they are better off financially than past generations and may well enjoy a more successful old age than future ones, even those merely a decade younger.

These are people who have been blessed with good economic circumstances, especially those who were able to ride the wave of postwar economic growth, said Gary V. Engelhardt, an economist at Syracuse. Theyre definitely in a sweet spot.

Older Americans ability to rise during the postrecession years when most households were falling reflects a broader trend that has unfolded in recent decades.

In the past, the elderly were usually poorer than other age groups. Now, they are the last generation to widely enjoy a traditional pension, and are prime beneficiaries of a government safety net targeted at older Americans. They also have profited from the long rise in real estate prices that preceeded the recession. As a result, more seniors now fall into the middle class defined in this case between the 40th and 80th income percentile than ever before.

Median income for people 75 years and older has also risen, but not as much as it has for people in the 65-to-74 age group.

One big reason seniors income is higher than before is that more seniors are deferring retirement.

The increase in income is also reflected in spending growth among seniors outpaces other age groups.

One of this relatively fortunate group is Monette Berryhill, 72. Six days a week she descends from her second-floor apartment for a treadmill workout in the poolside fitness room of her gated complex here in Waxahachie, south of Dallas.

A widow who says she enjoys her freedom too much to date, Ms. Berryhill dines out with friends from time to time and recently took in a country music concert. Her yearly vacation is a San Diego trip to see grandchildren, but this year she expects to splurge on an Alaskan cruise.

Ms. Berryhills past career in customer service at two banks did not make her rich. But her retirement is comfortable.

I feel like Im doing all right, said Ms. Berryhill, whose red-framed glasses offset her snowy, spiked hair. I really enjoy it.

Some researchers have found that the economic success of seniors is masking an even deeper gulf in income inequality between the upper tier and everyone else than what is evident in the overall statistics.

Nearly half of seniors ages 65 and up consider themselves in excellent or good shape financially, according to a Pew survey last month, in contrast to younger baby boomers, who view their circumstances less favorably.

More secure in their finances, many older Americans have congregated in traditional retirement communities. The Villages a central Florida haven for seniors with its low crime and dozens of golf courses has been the fastest-growing American metropolitan area for the last two years. Millions of other elderly people have settled in middle-income suburban and exurban areas like Waxahachie.

Photo

Mike Leath, a retired chiropractor, leading an exercise class at the senior center in Waxahachie. Credit Brandon Thibodeaux for The New York Times

With its muggy weather and neighborhoods of classic gingerbread houses, most seniors here are thriving, riding an overall population boom. But the current crop reflects some different choices from those who lived in the area three decades ago. For one thing, many more of them are working to supplement their income.

The whole meaning of retirement is changing, said Gary Koenig, vice president for economic and consumer security at the AARP Public Policy Institute. People are living longer; they have to fund more years of retirement.

Charles Kozlovsky, 73, retired from his job driving an 18-wheeler in 2009. Two years later he went to work as a school bus driver. The job keeps him busy but the work can be stressful; on a recent day a student was suspended from his bus for bad behavior.

In between routes, Mr. Kozlovsky goes to the senior center, a popular hangout for its 1,350 members that offers everything from poker games to Zumba for anyone 50 and up. For holidays, he and his wife play host to grandchildren who live nearby, setting up tables in the garage and back porch to squeeze everyone in.

The couple tend their backyard lemon and peach trees; sometimes they take trips to Branson, Mo., to see musical shows. Mr. Kozlovsky particularly enjoys his meticulously restored, shiny red 1957 Chevy, which he shows off in the parade at the annual National Polka Festival in nearby Ennis.

Things got a little bit better when I started driving a school bus, Mr. Kozlovsky said.

As recently as the late 1990s, only one in five Americans in their late 60s had a job. Now, that number has jumped to almost one in three. And unlike in their parents generation, more women are earning paychecks than in the past, contributing to household income.

Researchers say these factors are in large part responsible for the substantial rise in median household income that seniors in their late 60s and early 70s have experienced since 1989, even as Americans in their prime working years have mostly treaded water or lost ground.

Not everyone, of course, can work later in life. Health problems and age discrimination present major hurdles. And many of those who find jobs consider them barely adequate.

Pat Cherry, 72, has been earning minimum wage at a job in the library of the city-run Waxahachie Senior Center. Ms. Cherry, who is divorced, had to retire early from a bookkeeping job after an autoimmune disease caused her to miss too much work. She could barely pay her bills until she found the part-time job through a government-sponsored work program, but it expired last month.

Ms. Cherry is worried no one will hire her again. I need the money desperately, she said.

Still, for those seniors who manage to work longer, the benefits can be significant, providing a much-needed enhancement to retirement income. And for those with enough money from a job to postpone receiving their monthly checks from the government, the value of future Social Security payments rises by about 8 percent for each year of waiting, up to age 70.

Social Security benefits make up more than half the total income for a majority of the nations elderly 52 percent of married people and 74 percent of unmarried people, according to the federal government.

Kathleen McGarry, an economist at the University of California, Los Angeles whose research focuses on the well-being of seniors, calls Social Security the single most important tool in combating poverty among the elderly.

For Jim Engel, 72, his government benefit offered a lifeline after he lost his bakery business during the recession. The checks let him put off the sale of his nest egg, a Tennessee Walking Horse barn, allowing time for property values to recover.

I feel blessed, he said.

Photo

Monette Berryhill at a local department store in Waxahachie. Ms. Berryhill worked at a bank in Dallas for 25 years before retiring. Credit Brandon Thibodeaux for The New York Times

To be sure, many older people have trouble making ends meet and some are saddled with responsibilities that exceed the reaches of the safety net. Mary Walker, 74, who fled New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina with no more than an extra pair of underwear in her purse, is now raising two young great-grandchildren on her own not far from Waxahachie. At this age I shouldnt be struggling, she said.

But older Americans in general are significantly wealthier compared to previous generations.

The median assets of people ages 65 to 74 doubled between 1989 and 2013, a far greater gain than other age groups experienced. And while there has been a decline from the peak since 2007, largely because of the real estate bust, this age group lost less than others.

Ms. Berryhill, the widow in the gated complex, had no debt on her home on three acres when real estate prices were plummeting. By the time she put her house on the market in 2011, it sold in one week, at a significant profit. Besides that cushion, she gets about $1,600 a month in Social Security and has proceeds from retirement accounts.

She pays nearly $900 a month for a spacious, one-bedroom apartment decorated in red the sofas, the computer mouse, the plates and even the napkins carefully folded into wine glasses are all red. On a recent day she bought an inflatable palm tree for her granddaughters luau-themed birthday party.

Government data on consumer spending reflects the new reality. Adjusted for inflation, older Americans spent 18 percent more per household in 2013 than in the late 1980s, while spending for other age groups remained relatively flat. Higher health care costs, which fall more heavily on the elderly, accounted for a portion of the difference, but seniors spent 57 percent more on entertainment, and significantly more on a wide range of items, including homes, rental cars and alcoholic beverages.

We thought it would give us more money to retire on when we did retire, Ms. Berryhill said.

Ms. Berryhill is much better off than her parents, who grew up during the Depression. Her father, who was a gasoline truck driver, had to retire at age 61 because of a heart ailment. Her mother did not work outside the home. They were always able to pay their bills, but Ms. Berryhill said they never took a vacation trip, let alone left Texas.

We werent rich but we didnt hurt for being hungry or anything like that, Ms. Berryhill said.

She worries how her two children will fare. Their paychecks are bigger, but Social Security payouts, she fears, could be smaller when her children reach retirement age. They might have to take out loans to help pay for their childrens college educations. They have 401(k) savings plans at work but those are not as generous as her employer-sponsored pension.

But she always taught her children to save, and she cannot do much more now, she says, than hope for the best.

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/15/business/economy/american-seniors-enjoy-the-middle-class-life.html?partner=rss&emc=rss&_r=0


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

The seniors of the U.S. as an increasingly larger earner and spender in the economy.

Follow the link to the article for a couple of interesting and informative charts

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

As the U.S. economy continues its sluggish recovery from the recession and global economic crisis, more seniors and fewer young adults are in the workforce now compared with 2010. There has been a three-point increase since 2010 in the percentage of Americans aged 65 and older who are in the workforce -- employed full time through an employer, self-employed, working part time, or unemployed but actively searching for work. At the same time, there has been a two-point decrease in the percentage of Americans aged 18 to 29 who are in the workforce.

Percentage of Americans in Workforce, by Age, 2010-2013

The recession contributed to significant household wealth reductions that Americans are still trying to recoup. Older Americans' desire to replenish their retirement savings may partly explain the three-point increase in the percentage of seniors in the workforce, as more postpone retirement or former retirees re-enter it. In addition, Gallup's employment data show that 12% of those 65 and older are employed full time for an employer or are self-employed full time in 2013 versus 9% in 2010, suggesting that older Americans may be keeping their full-time jobs.

Those aged 65 and older experienced workforce increases among all levels of educational attainment. This includes four-point increases among those with undergraduate degrees and those with postgraduate education. Workforce participation among seniors who have a high school education or less remained relatively stable, at 18% in 2013 versus 17% in 2010.

Change in U.S. Workforce Population, by Education Level, 2010 vs. 2013

Bottom Line

There are more seniors and fewer 18- to 29-year-olds in the workforce now compared with 2010. The sluggish recovery from the Great Recession may explain some of these changes in workforce composition.

Americans' biggest financial concern is funding their retirement, with 61% worried about having enough money for that. This worry has been exacerbated by the recession's aftermath, which has perhaps caused more seniors and baby boomers near retirement age to remain in the workforce and postpone retirement until they have replenished their nest eggs. However, some of these seniors are likely remaining in or even entering the workforce out of personal choice, not necessity. A recent survey suggests that half of U.S. adult employees earning at least $75,000 say they will continue working after retirement by choice, while pluralities of lower-income workers intend to remain in the workforce more out of necessity.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Very interesting article Robert. I fall right in the middle of this'graying middle class' (which according to my avatar slogan, "Trying to stay in the middle of the issues", is exactly where I should be.

It's true us 'greybeards' are doing better than most past retirees, however I see many of the younger middle class people struggling to make ends meet regardless of their hard work in trying to get ahead, and this is a concern to me.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago
We're going to miss you old geezers when you're gone. These are the people that really made this country a great place to live, work and play. Kids today are soft and lazy compared to you old farts.
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Jerry

I am in the same sector of the graying band that you find yourself and we are by no means wealthy, but we are comfortable in our retirement and very happy.

Our generation was very focused on saving and putting away for a rainy day and that is not as strong in the current generation, partly for economic reasons and partly because of an I want it now attitude.

I think the our children will be in a similar situation to ours in retirement, but following generations are still a question in my mind.

Thanks for the feedback

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Dean

I detect a little respect and kindness in the terms " old geezers" and "old farts" and for that say thank you very much.

When I think of my generation and my father's generation I see them as ding all the hard stuff that made things easier for me, but my boys say that my generation in many ways did the same for theirs.

I guess it is a matter of perspective.

My generation worked hard, but I think the current working generation works incredibly hard as well

I thank you for your perspective on this issue and for the feedback

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Well, my wife and I are certainly getting greyer (though she'll continue to color hers to hide it) in our retirement. However I would consider us to be more lower middle-class, then really middle-class. As long as there are no problems (like my almost $600 red-light ticket last month...damn it!) we live fairly comfortably in a nice house (bought when the housing market bottomed out and got a great deal on it) on my SS Disability, her SS (she retired at 70) and a small pension, on a month to month basis. We have our Medicare (which a lot of un-retired people don't realize you do actually have to pay for ($108 a month right now, I believe)) and free Medigap insurance from United Healthcare, so we can afford to get sick, which helps a lot with my medical expenses and medications.

Getting by OK, sure. Comfortable, but I would say only lower middle-class, not really middle-class. Typical for our area which has a lot of retired people living here.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

M M

Thanks for the feedback and perspective

Middle class, lower middle class or upper middle class is all a matter of perception in my view.

So long as you are comfortable in your situation you are dong fine in retirement.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Our generation was very focused on saving and putting away for a rainy day and that is not as strong in the current generation, partly for economic reasons and partly because of an I want it now attitude.

Yes.

And many Millenials feel so very "entitled". So,among other things, they may leave a job if they feel they aren't getting what they "deserve". They may be in fr a rude awaening later in life....

Many would also rather live with mommy and daddy.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

In other words as long as we are happy spending most of our time laying around watching TV and DVDs or even VHS tapes just about everyday (which we are) we are doing fine. You always see those ads on TV for this product or another aimed at retired people and they're always riding motorcycles or motor-homes or hiking or constantly on a cruise (OK so we do go on a cruise every year or so), but we think retirement means doing as little as we can get away with. I guess retirement is different things to different people. For us it's getting to do nothing all day, most days, if we feel like it. We love that.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

M M

The wife and I decided early on in retirement that it was going to be doing what we wanted, when we wanted and not doing anything at all if that was how the day played itself out.

We like to travel to see the kids occasionally and we do a lot one and two day trips to national parks, museums, or just to se the sights in a city we have not been to but mostly we enjoy our time together or with friends and family

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

We go into LA every once in awhile, usually on day trip buses that take you to some spots there (The Grove, Santa Monica (and Venice Beach), Long Beach, etc) and pick you up there later. We go just to get the feel of the place again. The truth is that if we could have afforded it we would of retired there. We lived there for more the 11 years. We both LOVE Los Angeles and miss it a lot, but it's just too expensive to retire there unless you are very, very well to do.

Maybe we'll be buried there. At the Hollywood Forever Cemetery . We lived a few blocks from it in the old studio district of Hollywood for about 4 years.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

We do have a swimming pool though, which is a great help on hot days (our highs won't be below 110 for the foreseeable future), but it's not really some sort of luxury item. We told our real estate agent not to bother to show us any house without one because it's so hot out here in the summer and most homes have them anyway. Still not really middle-class.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Krish

The feeling of entitled is by no means only in the millenials...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

We saw the same thing hen we lived in Ft Lauderdale for a while, the pool was as common as the air conditioner in most areas of the suburbs.

 
 

Who is online


CB
MrFrost


80 visitors