Lies, Carly Fiorina and Abortion
There has been an impressiveamount of angry liberal commentary, which has spilled over into the mainstream press coverage (or do I repeat myself?) of the issue, about how in the last Republican presidential debate Carly Fiorina allegedly citedan entirely imaginary video in order to make a crazy claim about Planned Parenthoods brain-harvesting ghoulishness thats totally unsupported by the facts.Heres Slates Dahlia Lithwick , in a representative rant, attackingFiorinas big fib, the sheer enormity of which has shaken Lithwicks faith in honesty in politics and journalism:
Nobodynot even Fiorinas staunchest defenderscan say that these videos that clearly dont exist are real. Even one of the most brazen defenders of the imaginary videos, Jonah Goldberg , opens with this concession to the petty, mewling fact-checkers: [T]hey have a point. The exact scene, exactly as Fiorina describes it, is not on the videos. (The article could felicitously end there, but Goldberg goes on to defend the statement under the theory that since [m]ost Americans are morally appalled by late-term abortions, Fiorina might as well supply them with pretend images to go with their preconceptions.)
Not even the most robust defenders of Fiorinas defense can say much more than that some of the images grafted onto the sound bite might not be completely false . And yet there is still no word from Fiorina, her campaign, or her super-PAC to indicate that she misspoke, or misremembered, or confused some other video with a video about Planned Parenthood. There seems to be no place in the middle for Fiorina to just put out a statement saying, Hey, I misspoke. Sorry.
This is an extraordinary moment in the annals of political deception. No walk-back, no clarification, just a persistent insistence that a video that doesnt exist and cant even be manufactured in the underground labs of political deception is really out there but, like the Emperors new clothes, only the virtuous can see it. In Fiorinas world and the world posited by Goldberg, if people want to believe the big lie about the kicking fetus and the brain harvesting badly enough, who are we to tell them it couldnt have happened?
Okay, before I risk becoming a brazen defender of blatant fabrication,let me attempt to a neutral descriptionof the underlying evidence thats in dispute.
Lets start with what Fiorina said on stage:
As regards Planned Parenthood, anyone who has watched this videotape, I dare Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama to watch these tapes. Watch a fully formed fetus on the table, its heart beating, its legs kicking while someone says we have to keep it alive to harvest its brain.
Now its very clear what scene shes referencing: Its asection of this Center for Medical Progress film , the relevant portion of which you can find right here (warning: tough-to-watch content), that weaves together interviews, graphic footage, and excerpts from the CMPs sting videos of Planned Parenthood officials to tell an anti-PP story.The specific clip in question features a former technician for Stem Express, Planned Parenthoods ( erstwhile ) partner in fetal-tissue procurement, describing her work at a Planned Parenthood clinic; this interview is intercut with video footage of a fetus twitching while it expires in a metal bowl, which is not from the abortion/procurementbeing described, but taken from a different undercover video at an unidentified clinic. Here is my transcript of what the technician issaying, while the video plays and after, about her experience with an intact fetus and a Planned Parenthood worker:
its nose was very pronounced, it had eyelids, its mouth was pronounced. And since the fetus was still intact, she said, okay, well, this is a really good fetus, and it looks like we can procure a lot from it. Were going to procure brains.'
Then if you watch the full film, youll see that the situationthe technician is describing involves the worker showing her how she can tap the heart of the just-aborted fetus theyre looking at and make it start beating again, just before they jointly cut open the fetuss face in order to actually acquirethe brains. Again, we dont see the tapping or cutting happen; the footage of the fetus that we see is from a different case, anundercovervideo obtained by a different pro-life group. And then the film as a whole is using the technicians anecdote and the footage as part of an argument buttressed by footage of interviews with Planned Parenthood higher-ups and others that because fetal tissue harvesting is much easier when the fetus comes out intact,abortionists have incentives to perform later-term abortions in ways that sometimes/often endwith fetuses alive in the airbefore they die.
So thats a (no doubt partial) attempt at a summary of the film and footage thatsat issue. And having completed it, Im a little bit confused about whats being debated here.On the one hand, I think Fiorinas critics are correct that shemisdescribed the video, in two ways: She implied that the footage of the fetus was part ofthe scene being described (maybe because she thought it was; the documentary doesnt make it clear that its a different fetus), and she has thePlanned Parenthood worker saying we have to keep it alive to harvest its brain, as opposed to look at this, I can make its heart beat; okay now lets harvest its brain. Neither of these misdescriptions strike me as lies, per se, in their original form: If you watch the film as a whole its easy to see how you could misremember the scene the way Fiorina describes it rather than the way it actually plays out. (Just as lots of people think they remember the lineplay it again, Sam, which is never actually uttered in Casablanca.) But I agree with Lithwick that it would have been, and still would be, appropriate for Fiorina to correct herself,to say that she misremembered some of the details, instead of standing by her original words in their entirety.
But for her words to rise to the level of an extraordinary big lie, a vicious slander of abortion providers everywhere, it seems to me that something more than this kind of misdescription would need to be in play. If thescene in question literally did not exist, which is what the language of her critics consistently suggests if Fiorina had conjured up a vision of an intact fetus with a working heart and twitching limbs having its brains harvested out of her hyperactivepro-life imagination well, that would merit liberal shock and outrage. But she didnt conjure or invent it: Its very easy to figure out what scene shes talking about, and the discrepancies between whats in the documentary and her description arent wild or incredible or weird. Theres no outright fabrication here, in other words, and what Lithwick calls the big lie about the kicking fetus and the brain harvesting is a roughly-accurate summaryof what the film actually shows. (A twitching, dyingfetus? Check. A firsthand description of harvesting a brain from an intact fetus? Check again.)
So for Fiorina to actually be proven as wildly misleading and fundamentally dishonest as her critics keep suggesting, they would need to marshal evidence beyond just a parsing of her words, and demonstrate that the thing shes describing is an inaccurate depiction of what happens inside abortion clinics that double as tissue procurement centers. They would need to prove that, for instance, the technician in the video is lying about what she saw and did, or that the footage of the twitching fetus in the bowl is fake, or that abortionists never approach the procedure with an eye toward making sure the fetal body comes out intact, or that the idea that this leads to born alive cases is just a myth and all testimony (including, implicitly, Planned Parenthoods own )to the contrary is false or misleading.
Evidence on any of those counts would actually rebutFiorinas essentialclaim, which is that the processof acquiring organs from the unborninvolves practices and habits that wouldshock the squeamishly pro-choice if they ever had to confront the reality and that they ought to confront it, politicians very much included included, ideally by watching the videos the Center for Medical Progress has produced.
But I dont see that kind of counter-evidence being offered in Lithwicks piece, or in any other similar fact check. I see a lot of talk about selective editing, but mostly the claim is just that the CMP exaggerated Planned Parenthoods eagerness to turn a profit on these practices, rather than that their videos mischaracterized the practices themselves. So Ill put it to Fiorinas critics: Is what shes describing actually a pure fantasy? Is it entirely false to suggest thatbrains and other organs are regularly harvested from fetuses whose limbs can still twitch and whose hearts can still beat, and that abortion procedures are sometimes chosen with that harvesting in mind?
Because if it is false, that seems like an important point to press. But if not, Im not sure that their case against Carly Fiorina, alleged prevaricator, is all that strong a rebuttal to her case against Planned Parenthood, publicly-funded dismemberer of tiny, still-twitching human lives.
http://douthat.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/09/28/lies-carly-fiorina-and-abortion/

Now its very clear what scene shes referencing: Its asection of this Center for Medical Progress film , the relevant portion of which you can find right here (warning: tough-to-watch content), that weaves together interviews, graphic footage, and excerpts from the CMPs sting videos of Planned Parenthood officials to tell an anti-PP story.The specific clip in question features a former technician for Stem Express, Planned Parenthoods ( erstwhile ) partner in fetal-tissue procurement, describing her work at a Planned Parenthood clinic; this interview is intercut with video footage of a fetus twitching while it expires in a metal bowl, which is not from the abortion/procurementbeing described, but taken from a different undercover video at an unidentified clinic. Here is my transcript of what the technician issaying, while the video plays and after, about her experience with an intact fetus and a Planned Parenthood worker:
Then if you watch the full film, youll see that the situationthe technician is describing involves the worker showing her how she can tap the heart of the just-aborted fetus theyre looking at and make it start beating again, just before they jointly cut open the fetuss face in order to actually acquirethe brains. Again, we dont see the tapping or cutting happen; the footage of the fetus that we see is from a different case, anundercovervideo obtained by a different pro-life group. And then the film as a whole is using the technicians anecdote and the footage as part of an argument buttressed by footage of interviews with Planned Parenthood higher-ups and others that because fetal tissue harvesting is much easier when the fetus comes out intact,abortionists have incentives to perform later-term abortions in ways that sometimes/often endwith fetuses alive in the airbefore they die.
How do they find the evolutionary throwbacks to do this stuff? Even a crocodile takes care of its young.
No one kills a fetus to harvest its organs!
But I will consider a specific, detailed explanation with a viable citation as to how this is done and who is doing it.
As I often recall, at least eight times as many "babies" (fertilized eggs) "die" for not implanting, as "die" of abortion. I have not heard one single word from the "pro-life" contingent, proposing urgent legislation to "save these millions of precious lives".
Not one word.
So... Their spiel is bullshit. They don't give a flying F about the "babies". They want control of women's lives.
Then men, too, of course.
That's nonsensical.
It's the equivalent of arguing that because people die of cancer, there's no point in worrying about murder.
Scary these monsters walk among us.
So... Their spiel is bullshit. They don't give a flying F about the "babies". They want control of women's lives.
Yep.
I have never heard of and no one has ever shown any credible proof of any kind that that any fetus in America has been killed with the intention of harvesting it's organs. It has never happened to my knowledge and the so-called "Planned Parenthood" videos do not show it in any manner. It's just not on any of the tapes at all. Period.
Before debating whether an action is "right" or "wrong," it's significant to determine whether or not, if in fact, such an act as alleged and described is actually taking place.
This is characteristic of the "straw-man"
I'll go so far as to state opposition in principle if you can show definitive proof that "killing a fetus to harvest its organs/tissues" is being systematically done by any known entity.
It is insidious to allege a horror-in-fact as opposed to repudiating it in principle.
It is incumbent upon those bringing allegations to satisfy the burden of proof. So far, we have manipulated, edited videos and those who accept them as genuine because it suits their political/ideological/religionist agenda.
Proof!
FYI: At least half-dozen (probably more) states have conducted investigations of PPH AND IN EVERY CASE FOUND NO WRONG DOING AS THE KIND ALLEGED IN THE VIDEOS AND BY REPUBLICANS (LIKE THOSE HERE ON NT)!
September 29, 2015 8:00 a.m.Missouri Joins Growing List of States Unable to Pin Anything on Planned Parenthood
By Nathan PembertonUmmm... Sean...
Do you think before you hit the "Add Reply" button?
I am saying that if fertilized egg is a person... then non-implantation is a far greater killer than abortion. If "save the babies" is the imperative, then anti-abortion should take second priority, far behind ensuring implantation for all.
Would you chase murderers, and abandon all medical research until there are no more? Of course not. So... What the F are you saying?
There's no way around it, Sean. Vastly more "babies" die of non-implantation than of abortion. But the "pro-life" folks never say a word about this perfectly well-known hecatomb.
The pro-life folks don't care about the "babies". They want to control the women.
do you think before making specious arguments? Frankly, this argument is so ludicrous that I find it impossible to believe anyone finds its compelling.
then non-implantation is a far greater killer than abortion.
So what? non-implementation occurs naturally.
Abortion is intentional. Is the difference that hard to grasp?
Ihey want to control the women.
yeah, all those pro-life women just want to control women! You figured it out!
Jeez, Dean...
Ummm... Dean? ... ... Disease occurs naturally. Are you suggesting an end to all medical treatment?
As for women pro-lifers... You have brilliantly demonstrated that most pro-lifers are ignorant of the realities of their movement.
It's admitted on the videos that planned parenthood will try to kill a baby in such a way to best harvest its organs. It's all there for you.
Where? All of the released tapes have been seen and they have been reviewed by dozens of non-partisan organizations and what you and Carly say is there, just is not. You have posted a video that supposedly proves that you and Carly are right, when it shows nothing of the kind and in fact makes Carly out to be proven to be even more of a complete liar. You have never, ever shown any evidence that backs up your claim. You just have not. Not even close.
If you say it's there, prove it, because no one else except you and Carly seem to be able to see it. I think you both suffer from magical thinking.
The videos are edited and manipulated.
THE ALLEGATIONS IN THE VIDEOS WERE INVESTIGATED BY 11 STATES
I am not sure what you suggest is even possible with today's medicine. Regardless, trying to compare not trying to save a fetus nature didn't intend to survive to killing a healthy one on purpose is ridiculous.
Wow. Nature has will? Nature decides stuff? And nature tells you what he/she/it intends?
Gosh...
Are you sure you don't mean God, rather than nature?
God talks to lots of people, but I've never heard of nature talking to anyone...
How about "that had no chance of survival". Is that better? Either way it doesn't change the fact that your comparison is ridiculous.
No, it isn't better. Your previous formulation was much more genuine, revealing the "sacred" side of the "pro-life" movement. Preacher-driven... since God doesn't talk to commoners.
But let's look at your new formulation... Two hundred years ago, most illnesses gave "no chance of survival". But society believed that it was important to work on medical practices, to improve "chances of survival".
Should we cease research on the remaining diseases that give "no chance of survival"?
You confirm my point, when you dismiss all those millions of non-implanted "babies". Your indifference to their fate is precisely what I want to spotlight. There are millions of "babies" dying every year... and you don't care the slightest bit. You find excuses to justify your indifference to their deaths.
You don't care about the "baby". You care about control over the woman.
Now its very clear what scene shes referencing: Its asection of this Center for Medical Progress film , the relevant portion of which you can find right here (warning: tough-to-watch content), that weaves together interviews, graphic footage, and excerpts from the CMPs sting videos of Planned Parenthood officials to tell an anti-PP story.
It is a very heavily edited video that was pieced together from several other videos to show something that is not there. It is as phony as little green men from Mars. It is a lie.
Extremely disturbing is the fact that no matter who is doing this or why, we can be debating on whether it is right or wrong to kill a fetus and harvest his/her organs.
No one or organization in America has ever killed a fetus to harvest it's organs. It simply never has happened. If someone told you it has, then they are lying to you. If they believe it, then someone lied to them. There has never been any evidence that it has ever happened at all. Those who claim it has have never once been able to show an proof at all of it happening. None.
Carly Fiorinas despicable Planned Parenthood lies have gotten even worse
The GOP upstart made news with her absurd claims about reproductive health at the last GOP debate. It gets worse
NOTE:
The world is not fair, and often fools, cowards, liars and the selfish hide in high places .
Bryant McGill ,