Trump says FBI records on Clinton reveal 'criminal act,' State Dept. official should resign
Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump said Monday night at a campaign rally in Wisconsin that newly released FBI records reveal "a criminal act" he claims is worse than Watergate while calling for a senior State Department official to resign.
"This is one of the great miscarriages of justice in the history of our country," he said.
Newly released FBI documents revealed Monday that a senior State Department official proposed a “quid pro quo” to convince the FBI to strip the classification on an email from Hillary Clinton’s server – and repeatedly tried to “influence” the bureau’s decision when his offer was denied, even taking his plea up the chain of command.
Fox News first reported Saturday that the FBI interview summaries and notes, known as 302s, contained allegations of a quid pro quo. Republican Rep. Jason Chaffetz, who initially told Fox News of the claim, called it a “flashing red light of potential criminality.”
Documents published Monday morning confirm the account. Notes from an interview with an unnamed FBI official reveal the State Department Undersecretary for Management Patrick Kennedy tried to horse-trade with the FBI, offering additional slots for the bureau overseas if they would de-classify a particular email marked “SECRET.”
Trump accused the State Department Monday night of "trying to cover up Hillary's crimes of sending classified information on a server our enemies could easily access."
He also blasted Kennedy, saying his actions were a sign of a "cover-up."
"The FBI documents show that Under-Secretary of State Patrick Kennedy made the request for altering classification as part of a 'quid pro quo,' in other words a deal," Trump told supporters. "This is felony corruption. Under-Secretary Kennedy needs to resign."
Before his rally, Trump described the actions by the State Department to Fox News' Carl Cameron as "a criminal act," while also hurling criticisms at fellow Republicans.
"It's a crime, and I hear the Republicans are going to hold hearings after the election, why would you hold them after the election? We want to hold those hearings before the election," Trump said. "It's a criminal act and it's incredible that they can do this and get away with it."
When asked if he was taking shots at Republicans again, Trump pushed back as to why hearings should be held sooner.
"I mean, you'd think you'd hold these hearings frankly immediately, this is serious stuff," Trump told Fox News. "This is big stuff. This is Watergate."
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2016/10/18/trump-says-fbi-records-on-clinton-reveal-criminal-act-state-dept-official-should-resign.html
"This is one of the great miscarriages of justice in the history of our country," he said.
Newly released FBI documents revealed Monday that a senior State Department official proposed a “quid pro quo” to convince the FBI to strip the classification on an email from Hillary Clinton’s server – and repeatedly tried to “influence” the bureau’s decision when his offer was denied, even taking his plea up the chain of command.
Fox News first reported Saturday that the FBI interview summaries and notes, known as 302s, contained allegations of a quid pro quo. Republican Rep. Jason Chaffetz, who initially told Fox News of the claim, called it a “flashing red light of potential criminality.”
Documents published Monday morning confirm the account. Notes from an interview with an unnamed FBI official reveal the State Department Undersecretary for Management Patrick Kennedy tried to horse-trade with the FBI, offering additional slots for the bureau overseas if they would de-classify a particular email marked “SECRET.”
Trump accused the State Department Monday night of "trying to cover up Hillary's crimes of sending classified information on a server our enemies could easily access."
He also blasted Kennedy, saying his actions were a sign of a "cover-up."
"The FBI documents show that Under-Secretary of State Patrick Kennedy made the request for altering classification as part of a 'quid pro quo,' in other words a deal," Trump told supporters. "This is felony corruption. Under-Secretary Kennedy needs to resign."
Before his rally, Trump described the actions by the State Department to Fox News' Carl Cameron as "a criminal act," while also hurling criticisms at fellow Republicans.
"It's a crime, and I hear the Republicans are going to hold hearings after the election, why would you hold them after the election? We want to hold those hearings before the election," Trump said. "It's a criminal act and it's incredible that they can do this and get away with it."
When asked if he was taking shots at Republicans again, Trump pushed back as to why hearings should be held sooner.
"I mean, you'd think you'd hold these hearings frankly immediately, this is serious stuff," Trump told Fox News. "This is big stuff. This is Watergate."
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2016/10/18/trump-says-fbi-records-on-clinton-reveal-criminal-act-state-dept-official-should-resign.html

Rather than just blurt out that a quid pro quo is illegal, Trump needs to explain why it benefits Hillary. He doesn't make the connection and comes off as half cocked (at least to me). To many people this could sound like "Hillary . . . blah blah blah . . . emails . . . State department . . . blah blah blah . . . Illegal . . . blah blah blah".
Washington Post fact checker Glenn Kessler debunked claims from Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump and right-wing media that the FBI and State Department engaged in a “quid pro quo” in order for Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton to face less scrutiny for her use of a private email server as secretary of state. Kessler asserted “there is no evidence” of any alleged “collusion” between the two agencies.
Trump and his campaign baselessly claimed that transcripts released by the FBI relating to their investigation into Clinton’s email use show that a top State Department official proposed a “quid pro quo” wherein the FBI would agree to lower the classification level of one of Clinton’s emails if the State Department would agree to allow the posting of more FBI officals in Iraq .
Right-wing media asserted that the FBI documents “bolster Donald Trump’s criticism of corruption.” The same flawed analysis made its way to mainstream media and GOP lawmakers , who are using it to call for a State Department official to be fired. But as NBC’s Andrea Mitchell pointed out ,
there “was no quid pro quo, there was no linkage” and “there was nothing at all nefarious” that happened between the two agencies. Even the FBI official involved in the alleged collusion disputed the pejorative characterization of the interaction, telling The Washington Post it is “a reach.”
In the October 19 fact-check, Kessler explained that “‘quid pro quo’ was a secondhand description of a conversation — and both people who engaged in the conversation insist there was no collusion. Moreover, there is no evidence that anything happened as a result of the conversation.” Kessler added that summaries of the exchanges between the officials show “that whatever was said in the conversation, nothing happened to change the classification of the emails,” which “certainly undercuts Trump’s claim of ‘collusion.’” From the fact-check:
Trump rushed out a video statement to supporters claiming that there was “collusion” between the State Department, FBI and the Justice Department “to make Hillary Clinton look less guilty” after news reports that an FBI official spoke of a “quid pro quo” between the FBI and State regarding the classification status of some of Clinton’s emails.
“Quid pro quo” certainly sounds bad. But as more information has come in, there’s much less to the story than Trump claims.
[...]
The statement about “quid pro quo” comes from an FBI summary of an interview (known as a 302) with a third, unidentified FBI official during the criminal investigation of Clinton’s private email account. But there are other interviews as well, including with [then-FBI director for international operations Brian] McCauley and [then-State Department undersecretary of state for administration Patrick] Kennedy. Moreover, even the summaries with the unnamed official shows that whatever was said in the conversation, nothing happened to change the classification of the emails.
That certainly undercuts Trump’s claim of “collusion.”
[...]
To sum up, “quid pro quo” was a secondhand description of a conversation — and both people who engaged in the conversation insist there was no collusion. Moreover, there is no evidence that anything happened as a result of the conversation. The FBI did not back down from its contention that the email should to labeled as classified.
_____________________________________________________
Save yourself the trouble of the "copy and paste" stuff … you seed an article verbatim, I respond with similar.
Trump says a lot of thing, mostly false. This is not the exception to the rule.
The media may see no problem here but I do. Here's what happened.
Patrick Kennedy works in the State Department and both the FBI and the State department were grappling with the classification of emails discovered on Hillary's secret server. The FBI had not yet launched a criminal investigation into Hillary's email shenanigans but had determined that a particular email should be considered classified. Kennedy started calling around trying to get the FBI to change its determination that the email contained classified information. Although Kennedy's motive is not stated, it's obvious that Hillary would likely have avoided any FBI criminal investigation if her secret server contained no classified information.
According to a Washington Post interview with McCauley, who worked in the FBI, Kennedy called him and said "Brian. Pat Kennedy, I need a favor." McCauley responded "Good, I need a favor. I need our people back in Baghdad." When McCauley informed a colleague of what transpired, that colleague construed it as Kennedy offering a quid pro quo. The characterization ended up in summaries and those summaries became public (not through Wikileaks).
McCauley said that he really didn't interpret the conversation as a quid pro quo. According to him, Kennedy didn't fully explain what he wanted at the time and, when Kennedy did explain it, McCauley simply said that he couldn't do it . . . and that was that.
But Kennedy still seemingly offered a quid pro quo whether McCauley accepted it or not and that's the problem here. The fact that McCauley denies doing anything wrong simply means that the quid pro quo deal was not consummated. It was still offered and Kennedy, like most people, can be expected to spin what happened to his benefit to avoid being charged with misconduct or a criminal offense.
But Kennedy still seemingly offered a quid pro quo whether
Some background;
THE FBI '302 FORM' INTERVIEWThe purpose of interviews during criminal or civil investigations is to objectively determine everything the person interviewed knows - and doesn't know - about the matter and properly document it in the best possible way to avoid any later dispute about exactly what was said by the person interviewed and the person(s) conducting the interview.
The best way to do that is to conduct the inteview at the earliest possible time and record the interview in its entirety. The fairest way to do it is to use 2 or more recorders, keeping in mind that opposing counsel has the right to listen to the tape, have it examined for possible tape tampering and to a transcript in the event a duplicate original isn't made for that purpose during the interview. An added benefit to duplicate recordings arises when one of the tapes becomes damaged, as sometimes happens. Keep in mind that the investigator's job is to expertly gather evidence - and preserve it.
The FBI 302 Form Interview Procedure
Routinely, two agents conduct the interview, usually one asking the questions while the other takes notes on a pocket pad and sometime later dictates a summary of the interview which dictation is sometime later transcribed on a 302 form which is eventually returned to the agent for review and signature (or any corrections, additions or deletions he might consider appropriate).
The purpose of interviews during criminal or civil investigations is to objectively determine everything the person interviewed knows - and doesn't know . . .
The issue for me is Kennedy's intent at the time he made contact with McCauley, not the process by which investigators take statements. I would never rely exclusively on a statement given by a witness who has a motive to lie. If that became the standard by which employee misconduct was judged, then I doubt any employee could be disciplined without a confession or a video tape.
If I offered someone a bribe, it's relevant that the other person didn't take it (when he tries to get himself off the hook) but offering the bribe is still a criminal offense. I can try and wiggle out of it by saying that this was not an exchange of favors but two unrelated favors standing alone. A prosecutor, however, will attempt to connect them as a quid pro quo i.e. I offered to grant your favor if you granted mine. No matter what Kennedy says now, this looks like a quid pro quo that warrants investigation.