Al-Qaida fighter turned MI6 spy urges effort to 'confuse' Islamic State
It will take years to beat Isis extremists whose ignorance protects them against doubts about the justice of their cause, warns reformed jihadi
Aimen Dean is an unusual example of a poacher turned gamekeeper. The talkative Bahraini is sought after for his understanding of the Islamic State , now expanding across Syria and Iraq in a campaign the US has warned could take decades to defeat. Deans insights are based on his own experience as an al-Qaida terrorist but one who underwent a crisis of conscience and changed tack to spy for British intelligence.
With his neat haircut, dark suit and gold-rimmed glasses, Dean not his real name - looked at ease amongst the academics and security policy wonks debating strategies for countering violent extremism at a conference in Qatar this week. But his years in the jihadi world and his extraordinary journey out of it inform his view of how to combat Isis, which is attracting thousands of young Muslims from across the world to its Caliphate in the heart of the Middle East.
The first thing is to realise the magnitude of the problem, he says. It is deep and difficult. The idea that there a magic solution to convince these people just to turn around and come back and be good citizens is almost impossible. It is ludicrous. Sowing doubt is the key. Al Qaida and Isis say on Twitter and YouTube that the shortest path to heaven is jihad and martyrdom. New recruits to Isis went to nightclubs, took drugs, were members of gangs and had sexual relations out of wedlock. They want absolution, forgiveness. The thirst for redemption is there. And Isis is catering to that need.

I wonder how many of the ''terrorism experts'' have ever been a terrorist. He might be on to something, than again, he isn't a ''expert'', just a reformed terrorist.
People in such organizations don't understand the big picture of what it does . It is about extortion and violence to get their way . if they have never known a world where such things are rare events then they don't understand that an alternative is possible .
It seems that people are disagreeing as to whether he's right or not.
I think that there is not just one reason people become violent jihadis. There are probably several-- i.e., different people do it for different reasons.