╌>

The Boehner Shock

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  11 years ago  •  7 comments

The Boehner Shock

ee675f5df2e1f1be9bd38d86fcc6b616.square.png Ever since the financial crisis erupted in 2008, media outlets and specialists alike have devoted much attention to anticipating negative shocks to the global economy. Today the focus is on the state of the Chinese economy, the timing of the US Federal Reserves normalization of interest rates, and the various policies under discussion in the United States presidential election campaign.

But the most damaging shocks often hide in plain sight and then hit precisely when and where almost everyone thought stability would prevail. One such risk is that political partisanship will cause another disruption to the US federal governments finances, weakening the American economy and roiling world financial markets.

This warning may seem strange. After all, the last big partisan fight ( in 2013 ) over funding the government and raising the debt limit gained little for the Republicans who instigated it other than significant damage to their reputation for responsibility . And the current Republican leadership, eager to strengthen their partys electoral chances in 2016, very much wants to project an image of sober good sense.

Yet a major and destabilizing confrontation over public finance now seems unavoidable, particularly following House Speaker John Boehners surprise announcement that he will resign his position and his seat in Congress at the end of October. To see why, one need look no further than the House Ways and Means Committee, whose current chairman, Paul Ryan, is a leader of the hardline Republican insurgents who had scorned Boehner for being too willing to compromise with President Barack Obama and House Democrats.

Ryans committee plays an important role in setting Americas fiscal agenda, reflecting both the constitutional requirement that revenue bills originate in the House of Representatives and political realities (the House is traditionally less fractious than the Senate). Unlike in 2013, the strategy of Ryan and his allies this time around is unlikely to include a threat to default directly on federal government debt. And Republicans on the committee claim that social security payments will be made on time. So what other bills do they plan not to pay as part of a showdown over legislation to keep the government funded?

In fact, it is difficult to say exactly what the threat is and that is part of the problem. Uncertainty about government contracts and various kinds of payments can have a broad impact on the economy. The difficulty of working through the full economic implications is precisely what discourages consumers from making purchases and causes firms to postpone investment.

The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) published a helpful report in July that spelled out some of the consequences of the 2013 confrontation over the debt ceiling including how it pushed up the governments borrowing costs and the negative impact this had on the economy. But the Republican majority in Congress simply ignores this type of sensible analysis.

As a result, a partial government shutdown is entirely possible, with the Republicans imposing a form of prioritization on government payments: some people will be paid what they are owed, and others will not. This will fuel uncertainty, sap economic confidence, and almost certainly hurt the Republicans at the polls in 2016. So why is it likely to happen?

One reason is to be found in the decentralized nature of American politics, which leaves elected officials relatively unbeholden to party leaders. Some Republican supporters and donors have obviously moved to the right in recent decades. But, as James Kwak and I explained in our book on US fiscal policy, White House Burning , the time when the Republican right favored responsible budgets and financial stability has long since passed. Now the right increasingly catering to a Southern, rural, and white constituency cares much more about shrinking the federal government, and in recent years has viewed shutting it down or threatening nonpayment of debts as a way to starve the beast.

Moreover, the Republicans uncompromising stance has been reinforced by the extreme position taken by many within its congressional delegation that Planned Parenthood a health-care provider that primarily serves women must be defunded as a condition of any budget deal. Boehners resignation, though viewed by some as clearing the way for a short-term deal to fund the government, merely underscores the limited ability of any responsible Republican leader to control the partys increasingly fundamentalist caucus.

In the US, as elsewhere, debates about fiscal policy should be open, with clear statements of alternative goals and balanced assessments of how best to pay for what government does. Unfortunately, a debate and the compromises that follow are not what the Republicans have in mind. Boehners forced departure makes it likelier than ever that the US and the world will soon face the prospect of another self-inflicted economic shock, caused entirely by the Republicans scorched-earth budget tactics.

----------------------

The Boehner Shock

by Simon Johnson

Project Synd icate


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Planned Parenthood is the most important provider of health care services to low income women.

Planned Parenthood does not receive a single penny of Federal funding for its abortion services.

The Republican Party will shut down the Federal government unless all funding for women's health services is stripped from the budget.

We saw considerable impact on the economy during the 2013 shutdown.

This time the world economy is fragile.

Let's blow it all up!

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

I don't want my earnings stolen from me and given to Planned Parenthood. I'd rather have it pay down the debt or returned to my pocket. The poor women now get their healthcare payed for by the government through Obamacare. Nobody is buying into the fear mongering that poor women will no longer have healthcare if the government doesn't steal your earnings and hand it over to them.

The baloney about the shutdown raising the cost of borrowing is another bullshit lie. Treasuries actually paid less interest and had more demand after the shutdown. If the government is really concerned about the interest on debt stop raising the debt ceiling.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

You know all about women's health care, do you?

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

I know the government is stealing my money and giving it to them. I =kinw they don't lose their Obamacare if PP is defunded.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

The repubs lazar focus on jobs seems to have taken a detour.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Jeez, Woodie!

First... Obamacare is insurance. It pays for health care, using many many providers, including Planned Parenthood.

Second, Planned Parenthood does not receive a single penny of Federal funding for abortion services, via Obamacare or otherwise.

You make two points... both of them based on errors.

 
 

Who is online

Hal A. Lujah
Thomas


104 visitors