╌>

Questions For Christians - N° 1

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  9 years ago  •  23 comments

Questions For Christians - N° 1

shutterstock_261199148
1. Are you feeling okay?

For real– are you ok? Because I’m not sure you’re thinking clearly.

It’s one thing for Christians to have a disagreement on political policy, but I can find no plausible path towards supporting Donald Trump without betraying the Christian faith.

While I want to be charitable with my assumptions, in this case that means I’m just going to have to assume that something must be wrong, and that you’re just not thinking clearly. Because all the other options? Well, those options would far less charitable.

…

I’ve tried to reconcile this idea of being a Christian and supporting Trump, but to me, it just doesn’t seem possible– not unless one just completely redefines the word Christian. So help me out: if you claim to be a Christian and a Trump supporter, how do you reconcile those two things? I’d be impressed if it could be done.

** this post originally included some good-natured sarcasm that I have since removed so as to not be a stumbling block to some readers. However, call me crazy, but I think we as Christians really need to lighten up.

Image credits:
5 and 4. Gage Skidmore via Flickr, CC 2.0
3. Donkey Hotey based on Gage Skidmore original via Flickr, CC 2.0
2. Roger H. Goun via Flicker, CC 2.0
1. Shutterstock

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Continued from yesterday  ,  original article  by  Benjamin Corey


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    9 years ago

The topic of Dr Corey's article is the incompatibility of Christian faith and support for Donald Trump.

Hillary Clinton is not mentioned in the article. A significant portion of Comments has been about Hillary Clinton. Being charitably Christian, I'm guessing that not all of these were derails. (Some obviously were!)

In the past, I have attempted to elicit "conservative policy propositions" from NT conservatives, without success. All I ever got were attacks on liberal policies. I have drawn the conclusion that "conservatism" in America has no actual content, but is simply rejection of... whatever. 

The Comments here are in the same vein: Trump supporters have not -- not one single Comment over the last four days -- attempted to demonstrate that Donald Trump is a good Christian. Not one. This seems to confirm that present-day "conservatives" have nothing to say other than "tear it down!" ... which isn't very Christian...  confused

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    9 years ago

"I used to consider myself a person of at least average intelligence, but I’ve been trying to wrap my head around the idea of Christians supporting Donald Trump, and I just can’t do it.

I tried, but I have failed miserably."

I think Benjamin learned a valuable lesson. Hopefully their answers to his questions helped him to better understand his failure. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Dean Moriarty   9 years ago

I used to consider myself a person of at least average intelligence, but I’ve been trying to wrap my head around the idea of Christians supporting Donald Trump, and I just can’t do it.

Liberals ignored Hillary's many many many shortcomings because they thought Trump was a threat to the peace of the galaxy. To them, Hillary was the lesser of two evils. Christians saw Trump's personal values as less than ideal but considered a continuation of government enforced political correctness an actual threat to their faith. So they picked the lesser of two evils from their perspective. Both used the same "lesser of two evils" approach but arrived at different conclusions. Maybe if liberals smoked less dope, they could understand (not necessarily agree with) something other than their own point of view. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    9 years ago

Trump is a loud-mouthed, vulgar, thrice-married, greedy casino operator, who sees women as walking goody bags and whose lack of familiarity with the bible is obvious. As such, nobody thinks he is a good example of Christian virtues. Yet Christians voted for him anyway. Why? Because liberals have targeted certain Christian beliefs as bigoted and/or inconsistent with the political correctness that they see as enlightened. XX posted an interesting article on the subject. So basically, Christians could choose to continue being pressured to replace their faith with political correctness or they could pick Trump (who is anything but politically correct). Many chose the latter and I'm not at all surprised.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  1ofmany   9 years ago

Because liberals have targeted certain Christian beliefs as bigoted and/or inconsistent with the political correctness that they see as enlightened.

 

And liberals are still clueless.   Go figure.   Like i said before hopefully they will lose several more elections before they pull their heads out of their butts.   Articles like this give me hope that is exactly the case.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  1ofmany   9 years ago

Christians could choose to continue being pressured to replace their faith with political correctness or they could pick Trump

I assume you're referring to how society is so accepting of those icky gays.  Unfortunately for you and your argument, discriminating against the LGBT community is very low on Trump's agenda.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   9 years ago

I assume you're referring to how society is so accepting of those icky gays.  Unfortunately for you and your argument, discriminating against the LGBT community is very low on Trump's agenda.

But viewing Christian values as discrimination is obviously very high on the agenda of the Democratic Party. You simply make my point.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  1ofmany   9 years ago

I guess you're saying that it's discriminatory to not tolerate discrimination.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   9 years ago

I guess you're saying that it's discriminatory to not tolerate discrimination.

And I guess what you're saying is that political correctness should govern what people can believe. The author is similarly confused.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  1ofmany   9 years ago

1ofmany,

Because liberals have targeted certain Christian beliefs as bigoted and/or inconsistent with the political correctness that they see as enlightened.

Could you be more explicit than "certain Christian beliefs"? I know of none.

I hope you are not thinking of abortion, because the current "hard-anti" stance of many fundamentalists is anything but "Christian". Christ said nothing at all on the topic. If we look at the "political history" of the topic, anti-abortion is a relatively recent litmus. Fifty years ago, only the Catholics were staunchly anti-abortion, while Protestants had no particular position. Social conservatives borged the evangelicals a few decades ago; not the other way around.

If you are referring to acceptance of homosexuality... Once again, Christ didn't mention the subject. But since His message was often about tolerance (the good Samaritan, the Centurion's servant, ...) and never about exclusion, I feel pretty safe in saying the "love your fellows" applies to gays, too...

 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

I hope you are not thinking of abortion, because the current "hard-anti" stance of many fundamentalists is anything but "Christian". Christ said nothing at all on the topic. If we look at the "political history" of the topic, anti-abortion is a relatively recent litmus. Fifty years ago, only the Catholics were staunchly anti-abortion, while Protestants had no particular position. Social conservatives borged the evangelicals a few decades ago; not the other way around.

I am talking about abortion. Christ didn't need to say anything about the topic other than to say that he follows the word of God. Christians believe that God, in the Ten Commandments, said "Thou Shalt Not Kill." Many believe this applies to abortion no matter what different groups thought about it at different times.

If you are referring to acceptance of homosexuality... Once again, Christ didn't mention the subject. But since His message was often about tolerance (the good Samaritan, the Centurion's servant, ...) and never about exclusion, I feel pretty safe in saying the "love your fellows" applies to gays, too...

Christ didn't have to mention it because he said he follows the law of the prophets before him. Homosexuality was, in Leviticus, regarded as so sinful that it rose to the level of an abomination before God and its practice warranted the destruction of sodom (after which sodomy is named). Jesus never preached the tolerance of homosexuality or sin. What he meant is love the sinner and repent the sin, not love the sinner and embrace the sin. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  1ofmany   9 years ago

The commandment is against murder, not against killing. To constitute murder, the victim must be a person. I have never seen a convincing secular argument for considering a fetus to be a person. The Bible is silent about abortion, but the Old Testament, in several instances, clearly does not consider a fetus (or even a newborn) to be a person. People are free to believe whatever they like, but they are not free to ascribe their beliefs to Christ or the Bible without proving it. 

 

Leviticus is Old Testament. Christ stated very clearly that "love your fellows" superseded any previous contrary scripture. His message is inclusive: "Love your fellows". He did not make exceptions. On the contrary, he insisted that even the despised Samaritans were included. 

John said that anything that distracts from Jesus's message "is a lie". Using a superseded OT text to exclude someone from "love your fellows" is a distraction... a lie. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

The commandment is against murder, not against killing. To constitute murder, the victim must be a person. I have never seen a convincing secular argument for considering a fetus to be a person. The Bible is silent about abortion, but the Old Testament, in several instances, clearly does not consider a fetus (or even a newborn) to be a person. People are free to believe whatever they like, but they are not free to ascribe their beliefs to Christ or the Bible without proving it. 

Anybody can believe that a fetus is a person (and there is no "proof" that it isn't) and they can believe that the biblical prohibition against killing or murder applies to abortion whether you think so or not. That grounds it in both the new and old testaments as I pointed out earlier. All you are doing is giving your opinion, acting like it's a fact, and then telling others that any contrary opinion needs to be proven when you haven't "proven" anything yourself. People don't need you to interpret the Bible for them because they can do it themselves. 

Leviticus is Old Testament. Christ stated very clearly that "love your fellows" superseded any previous contrary scripture. His message is inclusive: "Love your fellows". He did not make exceptions. On the contrary, he insisted that even the despised Samaritans were included. 

John said that anything that distracts from Jesus's message "is a lie". Using a superseded OT text to exclude someone from "love your fellows" is a distraction... a lie. 

You can think as you like but, to me, this is utter nonsense. What you have done is twist love of the sinner into acceptance of sin. Nowhere did Jesus remotely suggest any such thing. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  1ofmany   9 years ago

Anybody can believe that a fetus is a person... 

Of course. But they may not claim a Christian grounding for that belief without scripture and verse. Which does not exist. 

 

If you wish to follow the Old Testament rather than Christ, that is your right. 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  1ofmany   9 years ago

Christians believe that God, in the Ten Commandments, said "Thou Shalt Not Kill." Many believe this applies to abortion no matter what different groups thought about it at different times.

"Many Believe". So its not what God (Peace Be Upon Him) actually said-- but rather how some people interpret it.

Some many people could also believe that "Thou Shalt Not Kill" might mean the death penalty for murder is verboten.

And not killing could also be believed by many to mean thou shalt not kill any animals.

Perhaps some people (but probably not many) believe "that thou shalt not kill" means thou shalt not kill plants.

 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

...Perhaps some people (but probably not many) believe "that thou shalt not kill" means thou shalt not kill plants.

When you see God, ask him what he meant and get back to me. 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    9 years ago

Unfortunately Bob, I've been reviewing your five questions for Christians, trying to come up with some rational for them that makes sense other than the obvious one.

And I find none.

This whole series of "Questions" are very craftily worded and posted hit pieces to make people question the validity of their faith.

And as such, they should be treated with the prejudice they so adroitly represent.

Not worth responding to.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

Unfortunately Bob, I've been reviewing your five questions for Christians, trying to come up with some rational for them that makes sense other than the obvious one. And I find none.

Maybe he's starting the church of Bob. 

 
 

Who is online

Hallux


123 visitors