Filabuster This: Democrats Pay A Huge Price For Gutting The Senate's Supermajority Rule
Rules: You have to laugh at the Democrats' current plight. They have almost no leverage to block anyone Donald Trump decides to select for judgeships or cabinet posts. They can't stop Republicans from repealing most of ObamaCare. And they only have themselves to blame.
On CNN this week, Senate Minority Leader Charles Schumer was lamenting the fact that Democrats wouldn't be able to use the filibuster to stop Trump's nominees.
There should, he said, be "60 votes because on such important positions there should be some degree of bipartisanship."
And who, exactly, is to blame for this? Schumer's predecessor in the Senate's leadership ranks, Harry Reid, who in 2013 eliminated the filibuster for presidential appointments, except to Supreme Court.
Reid did it for short-term political reasons — he wanted to let Obama quickly pack the lower courts with liberal judges. The left-wing media cheered the move, with The New York Times heralding it in an editorial titled "Democracy Returns to the Senate." (We wrote in opposition to Reid's action on several occasions: see below for a sampling.)
Reid's ploy worked. Democrats were able to usher through nearly 100 judges before they lost control of the Senate in the 2014 midterm elections.
But when Republicans regained control of the Senate, they blocked Obama's judicial appointments, leaving roughly 100 vacancies to be filled. Now, thanks to Reid, it's Trump who will be able to get conservative judges appointed — and reshape the courts — without having to win over a single Democrat.
Democrats also face the prospect that, if they try to block Trump's nominee to the Supreme Court, Republicans might eliminate the filibuster for that, too.
Not surprisingly, the left is now lamenting the loss of the filibuster, with The New York Times running an Op-Ed saying it made the Senate "the cradle of compromise."
In the same vein, Senate Democrats used a clever parliamentary trick known as "reconciliation" — which lets the Senate pass certain budget bills without the threat of a filibuster — to get ObamaCare over the finish line. Obama fulsomely praised the Senate for doing so, as did everyone else who wanted the bill passed, no matter what precedent this maneuver set.
Now, Republicans are planning to use the same parliamentary trick to gut ObamaCare, and Democrats can't do anything to stop them.
"Budget resolutions can't be filibustered, so if Republicans vote to include reconciliation instructions for ObamaCare repeal, there's nothing the opposition can do about it," explains the liberal Vox.com whose founder, Ezra Klein, championed ObamaCare while at the Washington Post.
Had Democrats made any serious attempt to win Republican buy-in on health care reform, they wouldn't have needed reconciliation to get it passed. And Republicans, who've won successive elections promising to repeal ObamaCare, wouldn't be using reconciliation today to do so.
What this all boils down to is that Democrats are now suffering the consequences of their own shortsighted hubris. When they didn't need GOP support in Obama's first two years in office, they didn't lift a finger to get it. And when they did need GOP support, they changed the Senate rules so they no longer would.
Apparently it never occurred to Senate Democrats that they might someday lose control of that chamber, as well as the White House, leaving them largely unable to stop Republicans from undoing what they thought they'd achieved.
Queue the world's smallest violin.
On CNN this week, Senate Minority Leader Charles Schumer was lamenting the fact that Democrats wouldn't be able to use the filibuster to stop Trump's nominees.
There should, he said, be "60 votes because on such important positions there should be some degree of bipartisanship."
And who, exactly, is to blame for this? Schumer's predecessor in the Senate's leadership ranks, Harry Reid, who in 2013 eliminated the filibuster for presidential appointments, except to Supreme Court.
Reid did it for short-term political reasons — he wanted to let Obama quickly pack the lower courts with liberal judges. The left-wing media cheered the move, with The New York Times heralding it in an editorial titled "Democracy Returns to the Senate." (We wrote in opposition to Reid's action on several occasions: see below for a sampling.)
Reid's ploy worked. Democrats were able to usher through nearly 100 judges before they lost control of the Senate in the 2014 midterm elections.
But when Republicans regained control of the Senate, they blocked Obama's judicial appointments, leaving roughly 100 vacancies to be filled. Now, thanks to Reid, it's Trump who will be able to get conservative judges appointed — and reshape the courts — without having to win over a single Democrat.
Democrats also face the prospect that, if they try to block Trump's nominee to the Supreme Court, Republicans might eliminate the filibuster for that, too.
Not surprisingly, the left is now lamenting the loss of the filibuster, with The New York Times running an Op-Ed saying it made the Senate "the cradle of compromise."
In the same vein, Senate Democrats used a clever parliamentary trick known as "reconciliation" — which lets the Senate pass certain budget bills without the threat of a filibuster — to get ObamaCare over the finish line. Obama fulsomely praised the Senate for doing so, as did everyone else who wanted the bill passed, no matter what precedent this maneuver set.
Now, Republicans are planning to use the same parliamentary trick to gut ObamaCare, and Democrats can't do anything to stop them.
"Budget resolutions can't be filibustered, so if Republicans vote to include reconciliation instructions for ObamaCare repeal, there's nothing the opposition can do about it," explains the liberal Vox.com whose founder, Ezra Klein, championed ObamaCare while at the Washington Post.
Had Democrats made any serious attempt to win Republican buy-in on health care reform, they wouldn't have needed reconciliation to get it passed. And Republicans, who've won successive elections promising to repeal ObamaCare, wouldn't be using reconciliation today to do so.
What this all boils down to is that Democrats are now suffering the consequences of their own shortsighted hubris. When they didn't need GOP support in Obama's first two years in office, they didn't lift a finger to get it. And when they did need GOP support, they changed the Senate rules so they no longer would.
Apparently it never occurred to Senate Democrats that they might someday lose control of that chamber, as well as the White House, leaving them largely unable to stop Republicans from undoing what they thought they'd achieved.
Queue the world's smallest violin.

I believe I called them on this, on this very site, the day after they did this very short-sighted move saying it would come back and bite them in the ass someday. Well, here we are.......I wonder where our 'Alt-Left' friends are to defend the defenseless in the senate?
I believe I called them on this, on this very site, the day after they did this very short-sighted move saying it would come back and bite them in the ass someday.
You weren't the only one Spike, nor were all the Democrats as short sighted as Reid. On the very day that Reid gutted the filibuster, Senator Carl Levin D-MI publicly stated that it was stupid for much the same reasons that you gave. I think that he was the only Democrat who voted against the rule change. He also stated that he was not running for re-election in 2014 (gee, I wonder why). He is now enjoying being around his great-grandchildren while Reid is twisting slowly in the wind.
Reid was a typical Democrat; a cancer on our Republic. The left will now suffer the consequences of his bad decisions. Good.
A filibuster is only useful to the party out of power. Once it's completely eliminated, the party in power may never have an incentive to recreate it, especially under hyper partisan politics. The democrats excerised the nuclear option on the filibuster and blew themselves up. What a bunch of dopes.
Until then, Reid and the Democrats can be blamed for the consequences of their stupidity.