The U.S. might be better off without Congress — and a president

(iStock)
If we could start from scratch, how would we design the U.S. government? Would we preserve the electoral college, the 18th-century creation that is so controversial today? Would we keep the Senate or the Supreme Court?
According to Parag Khanna, an author known for pushing boundaries, the answer is no. In a new book, “ Technocracy in America: Rise of the Info-State ,” Khanna takes on the task of radically redesigning the U.S. government for the 21st century.
It’s an apt time to undertake such a project. Trust in U.S. institutions has fallen to an all-time low, with 65 percent of Americans saying they are dissatisfied with their government, according to Gallup.
Khanna considers systems from around the world, from Switzerland to China, to suggest an ideal form of government that would reflect the will of the people, as well as the wisdom of experts and data. Khanna argues that the United States needs to evolve into what he calls an “info state,” in which experts use data to guide the country toward long-term goals — otherwise the country will be surpassed by countries that do.
This interview has been edited for length and clarity.
In many ways, the 2016 election represented a backlash against elites and experts. How do you reconcile that with your vision that technocrats should be leading the government?
What I derisively call ‘Martha’s Vineyard millionaires’ are not technocrats. Just because you’re an elite or expert, it doesn’t mean you’re a technocrat. A technocrat is a meritocratic, utilitarian civil service personnel.
In a country like Singapore, the civil service runs the entire country. You could decapitate the regime, and not even replace it for five years, and the country would run fine. You can do that in Switzerland, and maybe in Germany, but you can’t do that in America, because we have very few utilitarian-minded civil service elites who transcend administrations and have a lot of influence.
Why is it that Donald Trump has to appoint 4,000 federal appointees? It’s because, clearly, members of the civil service don’t occupy those 4,000 top jobs. In a technocracy, they would occupy 3,999 of them. So the U.S. is not a technocracy, it is an elitist clique that is rotating in and out of power.
So yes, there is an anti-elite backlash, and I’m totally in support of it. Occupy Wall Street, the Arab Spring, Brexit and Trump all fall into this pattern. The last 10 years have given us year after year, revolution after revolution, of anti-elite backlash. I think that’s a wonderful thing, because we’re holding people’s feet to the fire. But we’re not replacing them with the kind of regime the public deserves. That’s only going to be done if we replace elitism with technocracy.
By the way, just because Barack Obama is a law professor, it also doesn’t mean he’s a technocrat. You need to know how to run something to be a technocrat. Having a bunch of smart people around who happen to be Martha’s Vineyard millionaires does not make you a technocracy. We are so far from it, it’s pathetic.
Do you think the backlash in the U.S. election exposed certain faults with the government that were there all along?
The weaknesses have been there prior to this election.
After my first book, “ Second World ,” I got lambasted for arguing that America’s infrastructure, education and quality of life were deteriorating. I was looking at the publicly available information about where we rank internationally in a list of areas. People thought this was over the top, but I don’t think they appreciated how much we were falling behind. I’m pointing to the same data here, to say that if the data shows the government is not improving the state of the nation, it’s doing something wrong!
What did the election have to do with that? Almost nothing. Because the election is just one more chronological event that shows us not improving. I’m looking for all the institutional modifications, all of the evolution that would indicate that we are improving. And I’m not seeing that. No one is.
I take a strong view in the book that political systems should evolve over time. It represents almost indoctrinated willingness not to learn from other systems, or from your own history. No one would expect a football team today to still be wearing leather helmets. No one expects tennis players to play with wooden rackets. And I feel like our government is still a wooden tennis racket in a world where other countries are using graphite Kevlar.
In the book, I look at how the best executive branches, legislatures, judicial branches and civil services around the world are run. I tried to document as objectively as possible where the best institutions correlate to the best outcomes. It’s not by accident that I force you to read 70 pages about other countries before you’re allowed to read about America. Only by forcing you to read that do you see, oh, my god, it’s been done in all these other countries. It’s been done for so long, so smoothly and cost effectively. You need to be pulling your hair out. And then you might be willing to do something.
I’m a technocrat in my heart of hearts. I’m much more interested in institutions and policies than in specific people. I just don’t care who is president. I really don’t. I just want to see a better structure. There’s this line we use in other fields: Bad process, bad outcome. When you have a bad process, surprise, surprise, you get a bad outcome. So I want to see a better process, as I have in all these other countries.
So what is that structure? You call for a “direct technocracy” — what is that?
The term combines direct democracy and technocracy, which are two terms that rarely feature in the same conversation — other than in places where they’re already happening, which happen to be these two totally opposite countries of Switzerland and Singapore.
I certainly believe in direct democracy, and there is no higher symbol of democracy than directly electing your executive. And it should be done in a way that combines not only electing a leader at the federal level, but electing powerful leaders at the local level.
Then there’s the technocracy part. There are hugely technocratic aspects to the most successful countries in the world, as well as to countries like China, where we don’t respect their political systems but they have accomplished incredible things for their populations.
This new technocracy has to be meritocratic, and it has to be utilitarian. Maybe there’s no more important word that needs to be reintroduced into the American political conversation than utilitarianism. It’s a quantitative measure of how fair and decent leaders are.
There are a lot of interesting ideas in this book. But if you had to pick one that we could apply in the U.S., what would it be?
I’m really big on this assembly of governors — that instead of 100 senators, you should have 100 governors, two per state. One goes to Washington, and the other stays in the state capital, and they coordinate and rotate after a period of time.
If this book has one thesis, it’s that America suffers from a surfeit of representation, and a deficit of administration. And governors are administrators, they know how to run things. Their job is to run one state, but paradoxically governors think a lot about what will help all states. They are most supportive about national programs around infrastructural connectivity, because they know that any connection helps both states. But they’re not in Washington. They just have this National Governors Association that might as well be an NGO. So governors should have far, far more power in the political system.
Most senators used to be governors, but now most are former congressmen. Their only job, it seems, it either to get reelected or to seek funding for their own state. It’s no surprise that the Senate is basically just a more elitist version of [the House], which is to say utterly dysfunctional and not doing [anything]. When I stumbled upon that, it convinced me like never before that the Senate serves no useful purpose, and that we should replace it with the 50 states that actually do something.
You also talk about a collective presidency. What does that mean?
This is another example that I’ve seen it in practice in other countries, especially Switzerland. I firmly believe that there’s no reason in a complex world for one individual to coordinate everything in a government. How can one man actually juggle all the domestic and foreign challenges at the same time and come to a coherent, comprehensive decision about it? He can’t.
So I argue for creating an executive committee, where the president is more like the chairman of the board. We should structure this executive committee such that responsibilities overlap, and everyone is accountable for the overall success of the system, not just the president.

Parag Khanna's design for a “cabinet executive committee,” to replace the modern presidency. From “Technocracy in America”
There are a few benefits. I don’t need to tell you about all the social psychology research that tells us it’s important to have a diversity of opinions to make decisions. It’s also a way of de-egotizing the presidency, since the president is just the first among equals. If six of your advisers disagree with you, there has to be some publicly defensible reason why you want to go it on your own. You can’t just shoot from the hip.
Another thing you’ve stressed in America’s ability to compete is infrastructure, and that’s something that more politicians these days seem to be recognizing as well, right?
It tells you something that infrastructure is the only thing that both Hillary and Trump agreed on. They talked all the time about roads, tunnels and bridges. They should have also included fiber broadband and so forth. And I propose Cabinet-level integration of various agencies around infrastructure.
There’s a lot of cynicism about how Trump would implement a big infrastructure plan. But looking at the countries that have good infrastructure, you don’t need to make it up as you go along. The road maps are all out there. Other countries show us the right and wrong way to do it.
----------------------------------------
Original article by Ana Swanson in Wonkblog

I was deeply perturbed many, many years ago by an interview with Lee Kuan Yew, the long-time Prime Minister of Singapore. (Singapore is a beautiful, modern, clean, etc city... a short ferry ride from Indonesia, which is primitive, poor and dirty. PM Lee guided Singapore during the decades after independence in 1959, generating these differences.)
Roughly speaking, Lee's discourse was:
You Occidentals are fixated by "democracy"... despite all the evidence since ancient Greece that "democracy" simply does not work. In every instance, it has broken down sooner or later. Meanwhile, Confucianism governed China efficiently for millennia.
It is absurd to imagine that "the people" can be competent to run a modern government. The web of objectives and constraints surrounding a modern society is so complex that it can only be understood by very smart people who have spent many years preparing themselves.
The true contribution of Occidental political history is not "democracy", but "human rights"; the codification of individuals' recourse against the state. Occidentals always presume that "human rights" and "democracy" are necessarily bound together. That is false.
The ideal government is Confucian-style life-long leaders, trained from childhood to their mission; within the limits of a human rights charter.
Over the last decades, Lee's thesis has proven itself. America has flailed about, electing "leaders" like Nixon, Carter and Bush II (I'm suspending judgment on Mr Trump), starting wars but never ending them, .... While China surges ahead...
Right, kind of a socialist, loving, kind, king for life.
Just the thought of such makes me want to take up my gun.
I don't want anyone or any system that places one person over everyone else. In any manner way shape or form.
And, since he is commenting about Democracy, it is plain he doesn't know what he is talking about. cause we are NOT a democracy. why, cause he is correct, ALL democracies in history have failed after a short time. As Jefferson opined in his letters, less than 100 years from conception to failure on average.
This is why the founders outright rejected democracy as a form of government. Even more so than they rejected monarchy no matter how benevolent a king.
So the man is claiming that a monarchy, (single ultimate ruler trained from birth) under mandated rules of benevolence, is the best solution to governance.
And you guys agree with this.
You are aware of what Hitler did for Germany? turned it from a broken nation into a world power in less than 20 years under his benevolent leadership. (one heck of a monarchy)
Lets not even start with the Soviet Unions benevolent rulers for life...... (successive monarchies)
What about the Mao period of China's history? (he was one hell of a monarch wasn't he?)
You can keep it.
I will fight for my freedom, and rather die trying to keep it than submit to any single lifetime ruler.
I would discuss the topic, NWM... but I won't trade insults and bumper-sticker slogans. Have a nice day.
Then you have a nice day discussing the topic Bob.
IF you can call it a discussion, it is your seed.
(and your echo chamber)
I really don't see any personal insults in your comment NWM. All I see is your opinion and it is completely contrary to Bob's opinion.
As far as I'm concerned and as it was stated, I don't think most Americans would go for Confucianism.
The fact is some people won't the government to run the show and some people don't.
I don't think Libertarians could ever adopt the concept of a "technocrat", because they all think that they have the answers to everything all by themselves. Reminding them that that's not true only impels them to reach for their guns.
You are aware that if we do not know everything, you do not either.
There is one constant about humans.....
NO ONE KNOWS EVERYTHING!
So what your advocating for is that we submit our free will to someone who knows as little as we do under the premise that more education means more intelligence.
And that the more intelligent would be more benevolent.
The definition of elitism.
No thank you.
Also, since we have a constitution, we don't have to reach for our guns everytime. (as demonstrated in the recently past election)
But the creators of our government very wisely left that option open for us if we ever need to again.
So true NWM. I only need to reach for a gun if somebody tells me that they're taking over for my own good.
My argument about infrastructure is bullet proof. You yahoos in the sticks can rail on all you want about how y'all's the ones doing the heavy lifting, but you don't know dick about what it takes to connect the country with the infrastructure you take for granted every single day.
NWM,
So what your advocating for is that we submit our free will to someone who knows as little as we do under the premise that more education means more intelligence.
No.
I am proposing that we (demos, the people) choose the experts we need to do the jobs that need doing, and that we are, ourselves, are incapable of doing.
If you need an appendectomy, you won't trust me, and I wouldn't try. We have the same problem, in color, with most of the problems facing the nation. We are not competent. If we try, we'll fumble. We need experts.
The question is how to choose our experts. Not if.
sixpick,
The fact is some people won't the government to run the show and some people don't.
That's exactly what I said.
I added that "what people want" may not be a very efficient way of facing the problems of the modern world. We (myself included) are not competent to make the right decisions.
It's funny, really... We accept that we don't know how to fix our car... but we think we can fix all the problems of the world. Very few of us can do higher math, but we all have very firm ideas about climate.
It's all well and good to say, "I don't want the government messing with the world..." but the alternative is Big Oil, with no constraints and Deepwater Horizon every day. Cars and trucks with no anti-pollution at all. No standards for drinking water... anywhere...
And that's just a few of the consequences that come quickly to mind.
No constraints on Comcast. No constraints on ... anything.
I fear we are headed for a dystopia of "liberty"...
I fear we are headed for a dystopia of "liberty"...
Freedom can be messy but I'm not trading it for life as a team of dogs under one whip.
1ofmany,
I fear we are headed for a dystopia of "liberty"...
Freedom can be messy but I'm not trading it for life as a team of dogs under one whip.
My point is that the whip is coming. Period.
Your only "freedom" is a teeny-tiny bit of latitude in choosing the holder of the whip. Right now, it looks like it will be the CEO of Exxon-Mobil.
. . . Your only "freedom" is a teeny-tiny bit of latitude in choosing the holder of the whip. Right now, it looks like it will be the CEO of Exxon-Mobil.
Even if you were right (a point I don't concede), it's that "teeny-tiny" bit of latitude I want to preserve, along with the ultimate power to take the whip back and determine our destiny.
1ofmany,
... along with the ultimate power to take the whip back and determine our destiny.
That's the problem. You won't have that power.
Holding on to your 30.06 isn't going to help you. That is a fantasy. I'd even go so far as to say it is a dangerous fantasy. As long as you imagine that you and the other good ol' boys will be able to hitch a .50 cal up into the pickup's bed, and go take down the Bad Guys... you'll do nothing today.
Mr Tillerson will have Blackwater , not handguns or even that .50.
... along with the ultimate power to take the whip back and determine our destiny.
That's the problem. You won't have that power . . .
No Bob, we do have that power and I'm not giving it up. If we retain control of the government and don't give it up to big brother in some Orwellian fantasy, then it will never be the good ole boys against blackwater . . . It's either the corporations follow the law established by the people or suffer the consequences. A corporation is an entity created by law, bob. We can dissolve it, if necessary, and it will cease to exist.
1ofmany,
It's either the corporations follow the law established by the people or suffer the consequences. A corporation is an entity created by law, bob. We can dissolve it, if necessary, and it will cease to exist.
Who establishes the law in Mr Tillerson's world? And who can dissolve Exxon-Mobil?
Fantasies...
1ofmany,
It's either the corporations follow the law established by the people or suffer the consequences. A corporation is an entity created by law, bob. We can dissolve it, if necessary, and it will cease to exist.
Who establishes the law in Mr Tillerson's world? And who can dissolve Exxon-Mobil?
The answer to both: We the people.
Fantasies...
Reality. Your Orwellian world of government "by our betters" is the fantasy.
That's funny, didn't we just reject Mr Tillerson at the ballot box?
Yeah we did. probably cause we got a good dose of what he had in store for us from 2008-2010.
Been rejecting him ever since.
NWM,
I don't know who you are talking about. I am talking about Rex Tillerson , CEO of ExxonMobil and Mr Trump's nominee for Secretary of State.
I was directing my comment at the overriding point of this travesty of an article.
You saying that Mr Tillerson is indicative of the ideal that smart people should dictate. indirectly trying to claim that the Trump administration is going to be a dictatorship on the basis of who he's nominated.
WHY in god's green earth would Trump nominate someone just like those we have been voting out of office for the last 6 years?
This is an example of the ingenuousness of your postings. The long way around the barn so to speak. Using rhetoric to fool people into agreeing with you then Voila! you pronounce that you agree with me. When in reality, you have just manipulated the respondent into agreeing with something they despise.
That is what I'm talking about.
And no we are all not so stupid or ignorant to see what the point actually is.
Have a nice day.
NWM,
You saying that...
Please do not put words in my mouth. Absolutely nothing that follows "You saying that..." corresponds to my thinking.
I abhor Mr Tillerson. He Is the CEO of my nightmares.
NWM,
Your last post bothers me. Your understanding of what I have said is so very, very far from what I meant...
We may have a situation that I have encountered elsewhere: You may be so convinced that you already know my thinking that you don't pay much attention to what I actually say.
Please. Please make an effort to not presume that you know what I think. Read my words. Take them at face value. Do not add or subtract anything. Then you may learn what I think.
Thank you.
Actually Bob,
I'm not convinced of anything, so do me the respect of not judging what I am saying or doing by your preconceived notions of what I may be thinking.
Fair enough?
The article is attempting to explore the ideal that the United states would be better served by having someone appointed into a position that is specifically trained to handle said position and to decide the issues that might arise in that position. Someone that knows which way to do or what to do without consultation or committee discussion.
Now the one assumption I did make is that Mr Tillerson IS someone you would intensely dislike. (thank you for confirming this)
But then you use Mr Tillerson as an example of someone in such a position when clearly he isn't.
That's the conundrum I'm looking at.
It's why I made the statement I made.
Clarification is needed.
Why bring up Tillerson as an example of the article point if he is someone you abhor so much?
That is where the reference to the long way around the barn comes from. It appears deceptive.
Trying to reconcile such reference to the point of the article, and it makes absolutely no sense.
Mt Tillerson is removable at a moments notice if the situation required it. And he has no real power or, better put, his real power is filtered by the man that put him in that position.
He will never be the man trained to hold the office for life. or the man to set policy since,
"We the people" are no longer competent to decide policy
That is not his role.
So I hope you see the conundrum here.
And if anything I am direct.
Oh and BTW, I've been told by some on the board that I suffer from the same problem as you state you do, I sometimes come across as obtuse. (blowhard is the term that comes to mind) So I try very hard to make myself plainly understandable. Even if you might not like what I have to say.
Peace.
NWM
NWM,
Good post! Let's go through it carefully.
I'm not convinced of anything, so do me the respect of not judging what I am saying or doing by your preconceived notions of what I may be thinking.
Fair enough! I could be me as well as you. I was trying to understand how one intelligent person (you) could, from the words of another intelligent person (me), draw conclusions that seemed top be 180° from my intent.
The article is attempting to explore the ideal that the United states would be better served by having someone appointed into a position that is specifically trained to handle said position and to decide the issues that might arise in that position. Someone that knows which way to do or what to do without consultation or committee discussion.
That's close, but IMHO not exactly right. The devil may be in the details, so let's check. One of the less perfect aspects of the article, IMHO, is that Mr Khanna does not stipulate, precisely, how his ideal government would be designated. Are all the Cabinet-level persons elected? By whom and by what process? Appointed? By whom and by what process? (Mr Khanna probably doesn't want to be too precise in an interview... He wants to entice readers to buy his book!) The designation process is important, because a person always works for the person who can assure that they keep their job, get promoted, ...
Personally, I would like to see the "economics" jobs (Fed, Treasury, ...) go through a filter at some point to ensure that they are considered competent by their peers . Likewise for the "science" jobs, to be filtered by their peers, and so on. This could be in a nomination process, or the final choice. I read a lot of economics, probably more than most Congresspeople, but I would not be competent to act in the process of selecting a Fed chairperson. On the other hand, there is an association of economists, which could elect a "select committee for the designation of Fed Presidents". They would be entirely competent. More importantly, they would be competent to judge the performance of the persons actually installed. The role of a Fed chairperson is very important, but hardly omnipotent. The Fed operates within a considerable number of constraints, so the chairperson's performance must be judged within those constraints. I wouldn't have the foggiest idea!
The same basic idea of selection by peers would apply to all the senior technocratic posts. Roughly, those that now require the advice and consent of the Senate.
Clarification for Mr Tillerson: He was CEO of the biggest of Big Oil, a personal acquaintance / business partner of heads of state, in particular, Russia. He is now intended to manage America's relations with those countries. The risks of conflict of interests in the case of Mr Tillerson are s-o-o-o blatant... Mr Tillerson is not a "technocrat" in the sense of the article, in that he has neither training nor experience in diplomacy. He is surely a good negotiator because that is necessary for rising to the top of any bureaucracy, including ExxonMobil, but if the choice of Secretary of State were being made by a "select committee of career diplomats", I very much doubt that Mr Tillerson would be in the running.
I think my first mention of Mr Tillerson was to 1ofmany .
We will either move toward a mix of Confucius and the European Council (which are not democratic institutions)... or become serfs to Rex Tillerson.
This was Mr Tillerson in his role as CEO of the wealthiest corporation in the history of the world. (And not incidentally, one of the most government-subsidized.)
There are interesting sub-threads here, if you're interested. Is Mr Tillerson a technocrat in the oil business, or something else?
Mt Tillerson is removable at a moments notice if the situation required it.
This is strictly true... but so unlikely that I don't see it as useful.
And he has no real power or, better put, his real power is filtered by the man that put him in that position.
IMHO, a Secretary of State has an enormous amount of power. We do not yet know how Mr Trump will behave once in power. Will he be hands-on, or easily distracted? Or both? Or... dunno!
He will never be the man trained to hold the office for life. or the man to set policy since,
"We the people" are no longer competent to decide policy
That is not his role.
So I hope you see the conundrum here.
I think I see what you are trying to say, but if I go off into the weeds, please reformulate. We're at the crux, here, so it's important.
We are talking about "Secretary of State", which is a particularly interesting case. I have contended for a long time that American diplomacy is so dysfunctional that we might as well consider that it does not exist. IMNAAHO, the US has had no coherent foreign policy since George C Marshall defined "containment" at the end of WWII. That was "foreign policy" . It was a clear, publicly enunciated strategy , in the interest of the nation, and it was followed by all administrations, regardless of party, all the way to its success with the collapse of the USSR. There were some very bumpy patches (Vietnam!) but ultimately, "containment" was brilliantly successful.
There has been no other "foreign policy" since WWII. Each President has done as he pleased, without reference to any overarching long-term strategy. This is unreasonable... and the observed results are only what one would expect: chaos. We have been at war in the Middle East for nearly half a century, now... we have gone through four Presidents... and we still do not have a publicly known, consensual strategy. Is this any way to run a railroad???
But in our strictly Presidential regime, this is almost inevitable. All power rests with the President, including foreign affairs. Each new President tends to do the opposite of his predecessor (regardless of the topic), so other nations just hunker down, and wait for a more favorable President.
Other nations, UK and France notably, have professional diplomatic corps that manage their foreign policy, with fairly little interference from the current PM/President. They have "policies" that persist over decades.
So... getting back to our topic... the "technocrat" in diplomacy should be... a diplomat. Promotion through the corps, all the way to the top. "Foreign policy" would be in the long-term custody of a Cabinet subcommittee including Defense and Intelligence, but chaired/dominated by State.
Obviously, a President would always have the possibility of animating a public conversation on long-term foreign policy, and the whole diplomatic corps would be wise to listen... but then the diplomatic corps would have the responsibility of deciding whether a modification of long-term strategy is required.
Four years is not very long. Even eight. Most national policy needs more continuity than that. America's on-again-off-again health-care nonsense is shameful.
I sometimes come across as obtuse. (blowhard is the term that comes to mind)
I sure am glad that no one has ever said anything so harsh about me...
Speak for yourself. I can fix damn near anything on a car.
Disagreement is an insult?
1ofmany,
Disagreement is an insult?
Of course not. Why do you ask?
If you are referring to my Reply to NWM's post then you must not have noticed
You are aware of what Hitler did for Germany?
Implying that I am unaware of what Hitler did is both an insult and a lack of simple good manners. I'm not interested in pursuing...
If you are referring to my Reply to NWM's post then you must not have noticed
You are aware of what Hitler did for Germany?
Implying that I am unaware of what Hitler did is both an insult and a lack of simple good manners. I'm not interested in pursuing...
He was posing a question as a reminder of what Hitler did not suggesting that you're ignorant of it. If that's an insult, then it strikes me that you may have intended some of your own queries to be insults but I didn't take them that way at the time.
1ofmany,
We have different standards for "good manners", perhaps.
We have different standards for "good manners", perhaps.
No Bob, that's not my problem. I'm wondering whether you apply your standard of "good manners" differently depending on whether someone is agreeeing or disagreeing with you. You have posed questions and set up articles that, under your standard, would seem to be intended as an insult.
Perhaps.
I don't think it's a useful debate. Each of us participates in a conversation according to whatever rules of good manners we desire. If I decide that X has overstepped then I break off.
If X feels that I have overstepped, she has the same option.
I am not imposing anything on anyone except myself.
The liberals are so upset over their loss many would willingly give it to even more of a dictator than BO. Why are you surprised? They have shown their shortsightedness over and over the last decade. (just wait until Trump uses the new powers BO and the Democrats have given him as I warned would eventually happen) Of course, if the dictator they love decided not to push their agenda we would probably have to turn half the country into a "safe space".
A good thought provoking article.
Having spent quite a bit of time in Singapore over the years, I did get a good look at their system of governance. We had a larger operation there with a couple of hundred employees, Chinese, Malay and western, both US and European.
What I found is that the natives of Singapore had a wonderful work ethic and were content in the system of government that they had. Although it would be somewhat restrictive in the American sense, it surely worked for them.
It should be considered that Singapore wasn't a country until the early 1960's. From that time to today, the growth, prosperity and freedoms have become enormous.
Yes, we can learn from their successes, although I don't see Americans willing to ''give up'' whatever it is that each consider sacred, but not looking outward is a good sign that soon the ability to comprehend the world will be lost.
JMHO.
A big part of these questions is "what is our yardstick for measuring the 'success' of government?"
For some, the purpose of government is to improve the lives of the people. For others, it is to stay out of the lives of the people. The two visions are incompatible, and have torn the US in two.
I think there's a political consequence of our modern "knowledge explosion" that has yet to be widely recognized. That lack of recognition may have very grave consequences.
The founders of our "Modern Occidental World" -- France's philosophes, Great Britain's "Members of the Royal Academy", America's Founding Fathers -- were men (and a very few particularly enterprising women) who "knew everything". If you Google "the last man who knew everything" you'll find several candidates... but none are modern. Even such wide-ranging intellects as Hawking and Sagan never pretended to "know everything".
Human knowledge has vastly outstripped the capacity of any single human mind.
That seems like an obvious statement... but it is in fact quite a recent situation. The men who wrote the Constitution of the United States of America "knew everything". As a group, they held all human knowledge: economics, physics, medicine, geology, ... everything!
When those men decided policy, they could -- by themselves -- take account of all human knowledge.
Back then, any (fairly intelligent) person who was determined enough, could collect all the knowledge needed to competently understand the policy decisions that the Founding Fathers were making.
(Not incidentally, human population and human technology were still such that the Earth could digest any negative consequences of erroneous decisions.)
Democracy was possible, because demos could in fact be competent.
This is no longer true. Demos has absolutely no chance of being competent on the complex and interlocking topics of today's world. If an incompetent demos tries to run the world, the inevitable result is erratic, erroneous policy with no basis in fact: Tea Party America.
"We the people" are no longer competent to decide policy; but no political organization has yet had the courage to say, "We propose to choose the experts who must decide and manage policies on such-and-such criteria"... which would be the best that demos could hope to decide with any degree of competence.
I fear that democracy is a zombie. Walking dead. And we have yet to even begin to discuss its replacement.
i would never trade American freedom for the authoritarianism of Singapore under the Big Brother government created by the late Lee Kuan Yew. Nor do I want a technocracy run by people who think they're smarter than everybody else and born to rule like the Council of Krypton. I have no doubt that you can accomplish a lot with one party rule that puts the population to work like an ant colony to achieve one goal (Hitler proved that) but I do not want to live in a system that is fundamentally undemocractic. The advancement in society was precisely the realization that people should control their government not that the government should control them for their own good.
Government is infrastructure, and yes - there are people who are way smarter than you when it comes to building it. Sorry to burst your bubble.
And when they don't, we the people of the states will get rid of them unless we're unable to do so, which would be the situation in this case.
Six -- This is why the second amendment is important. When some people get too big for their britches and seize government from the people, the people need to be able to take it back.
Six, when I say infrastructure I'm talking about the vast physical network that connects us all - roads, bridges, communications, sewers, water systems, power plants, etc. You didn't build those networks, and likely have little to no knowledge of what it takes to design or build them. Let those who do understand it make the decisions regarding it. That's just common sense.
LOL sure Hal,
While the need for a replacement of the original structure became acute soon after it was completed, [3] the construction of the current structure was also plagued with difficulties.
Construction began in 1979 with an expected completion date three years later; however the bridge would not be available for traffic for nine years. The initial budget of $79 million was exceeded by $48 million. In 1982, with the bridge two-thirds complete, a 150-foot (46 m) long, 6,700-ton (6,070 metric tonnes) segment was not properly counterbalanced and sank five feet (1.5 m) out of alignment while rising 3.5 feet (1.1 m) on the other end, cracking a pier footing in the process. Once repairs were made, a new contractor was hired to complete the bridge once the initial contractor (Stevin Construction) and the state agreed to terminate their contract in exchange for both sides dropping their lawsuits over the accident. The new contractor developed a method of heating the concrete to allow construction during the winter. However, on some cold days these new sections could not be properly sealed against water infiltration, eventually leading to spalling as the water froze and expanded. Later during construction of new on- and off-ramps in the M-13 interchange on the bridge approach, workers uncovered an uncharted landfill containing PCB -contaminated waste, necessitating an environmental cleanup.
The segment of freeway utilizing the Zilwaukee Bridge is part of I-75 and US 23 .
So as soon as the first one was done they were like oh shz this won't cut it...tore down a 40 million structure that ws supposed to last 25+ years after less than 6 years then the new one went 48 million over on a budget that was nearly DOUBLE the budget of the first.
You know how many stories like this there are? Would you like to wager if more infrastructure projects went a minimum of 25% over budget compared to those completed within the budget in the last DECADE? How about a wager that DOUBLE the amount went over than were completed within budget?
I will concede Infrastructure to those who know what they are doing just as soon as you can show me those who know what they are doing...
What a moronic comment - engineers are embarassed for you. When constructing anything with a deep foundation you won't know what your working with untill you dig down deep to build it. The best you can do is make educated guesses in the design stage. Sometimes you end up going back to the drawing board in the middle of construction because of what has been unearthed. If Libertarians were in charge, every structure would be a leaning tower of Pisa.
What a moronic comment indeed. So what is your excuse for them building something that was totally inadequate in the first place that cost the state about 45 million and had to be scrapped?
Who does that make embarrassed for you?
Why don't you ask them? As you are a libertarian I'll have to explain this to you: the engineering and construction process is extremely complex, and only a fool would answer your question based on a blurb from a Wikipedia page.
It could be that the client was the problem, changing their mind every other day about what they want, thinking that such changes are minor when they are actually extremely complicated. I work for a developer, and I deal with that every day. It's not the engineer's fault when a project is grossly mismanaged, and we generally protect ourselves from this with detailed proposals and contract documents. If the fee was way over budget and got paid anyways, it's a good indication that there was no engineering negligence, just bad project management. Clients don't pay bills they aren't obligated to pay.
In the example you've referred to, it appears that the problem was primarily a construction issue, not an engineering issue.
Government is infrastructure, and yes - there are people who are way smarter than you when it comes to building it. Sorry to burst your bubble.
Government is "we the people" and you're not "smarter" than the rest of us. Sorry to pull your balloon back to earth.
I'm certain that in your profession, there are things that you yourself are smarter than me about. See how easy that is? Now you try it. Or is it that you can do anything no matter what? Design me a bridge, you genius you.
I'm certain that in your profession, there are things that you yourself are smarter than me about. See how easy that is? Now you try it. Or is it that you can do anything no matter what? Design me a bridge, you genius you.
I deal with engineers, accountants, economists and lawyers all the time. They are just fine in their respective disciplines but I am routinely struck by how dense they can be outside of them. Just because someone can build a bridge doesn't remotely mean that better governance would result if that same person could approach every problem in government like a construction project. Every problem is not a nail just because some "expert" has a hammer. So no, building bridges does not make you any more able to govern than the rest of us.
1ofmany,
i would never trade American freedom for the authoritarianism of Singapore under the Big Brother government created by the late Lee Kuan Yew.
Your description is a straw-man travesty... but basically I agree with the choice you express. We will either move toward a mix of Confucius and the European Council (which are not democratic institutions)... or become serfs to Rex Tillerson.
There's no third choice. Democracy is a zombie, shuffling on, but already dead.
1ofmany,
Your description of what has been said is a straw-man travesty... but basically I agree with the choice you express. We will either move toward a mix of Confucius and the European Council... or become serfs to Rex Tillerson.
There's no third choice.
These are your two choices, not mine, and I reject both of them. To be clear, I don't characterize our current situation as reducing us to corporate serfdom nor do I see the alternative as a government mix of "confusion" (no I didn't misspell it). Ultimate power should rest with the people whether or not you think they're too stupid to see that they are controlled anyway . . . so they should be controlled by big brother rather than a corporation.
1ofmany,
OK. I understand your position. I disagree fundamentally, but I see no way of "proving" anything today.
Thank you for the conversation.
1ofmany,
OK. I understand your position. I disagree fundamentally, but I see no way of "proving" anything today.
Thank you for the conversation.
It's ok to disagree. The fundamental purpose of free speech is to be able to say something that other people don't like. That's the beauty of being free. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
1ofmany,
Wow!
We reached a conclusion... of disagreement... without any nastiness.
I feel like celebrating!