Blame for the Yemen raid going terribly wrong is now being placed squarely on the desk of the new president. Reports surfaced on Thursday night to say that President Trump had authorized the raid in Yemen, which targeted Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula without sufficient intelligence and backup planning. Some critics of the president immediately cited the story as a sign that Trump said “yes” without a full appreciation for the life-and-death stakes of this kind of combat operation.
I have written against Trump’s immigrant ban, arguing that it places U.S. allies in Iraq, Syria, and beyond at risk and leaves America less safe, not more. But in the case of the Yemen raid, critics seem to be misunderstanding just how these missions work.
Voices may have been missing from the room, as some say, from the State Department and intel community. That is not yet fully clear. But a lack of perspectives and a deferral to judgment of others, including Defense Secretary Mattis, is not the same as sending U.S. troops willy-nilly into a special operations mission.
The entire incident highlights the tensions inherent in planning, approving, and carrying out these missions. Over the past two years, I have heard from special operators who said the Obama White House was taking too long to approve (or reject) some life-or-death missions. And now the Trump administration is facing a barrel of questions about whether it moved too quickly and without enough information.
The bloody civil war continues to claim lives in Yemen. The United States is not directly involved in the war, but working with UAE special operations forces to pursue Al Qaeda targets. This special operations mission began as a “short-term” one and was extended “indefinitely” last July.
Right now, special operations forces are facing extremely high demands on both their time and their skill set. In December, a report from the Center for Strategic and International Studies noted that as these specialized troops “became increasingly involved in counter-terror operations, the demands on special operations forces created historically high rates of deployment. During any single year, SOF are deployed to nearly 75 countries around the globe, with some operations requiring up to a dozen raids each evening.”
The pace only escalated under the Obama administration. Indeed, planning for last week’s Yemen mission began during its final months.
Under Obama, the State Department and the intel community both helped to decide whether to approve strikes, a process that frequently, but not always, required White House approval.
“The Obama White House tended to approach this from a perspective of ‘Let’s make sure we don’t get this wrong, even if we miss an opportunity,’” says Luke Hartig, who served as Senior Director for Counterterrorism at the National Security Council under Obama. “There are merits and downsides to that.”
As it happens, Obama White House officials reviewed the operation, but deferred the ultimate decision until local conditions allowed for it.
The mission — approved by President Trump — began badly and ended tragically, starting with the crash of the Osprey — which is now becoming known as a “hard landing.” And that was just the start of a raid that went terribly wrong, killing at least 10 civilians, including an eight-year-old American girl, and taking the life of Navy SEAL William “Ryan” Owens.
But what the narrative of this mission gone awry misses is that special operations had long chafed under the Obama White House. I spent months last year talking to people inside the special operations community and the Pentagon. Many said the administration micromanaged operations, down to the helicopter used. Some who took part in daring raids to rescue hostages and find Al Qaeda and ISIS leaders told me the White House moved too slowly in life-and-death situations.
So with the arrival of a new president, there was some sense among those in the community that up-or-down decisions would arrive more quickly. And when conditions were right, the Yemen operation was briefed to and approved by Trump in relatively short order. But what was not foreseen was how well prepared the enemy would be when U.S. forces arrived, and just how wrong things would go.
As one special operations source told me this week, “The enemy always has a say.”
Now the question is: what happens next? Will the White House continue to defer and say yes when its approvals are sought for these kinds of special operations missions? And what, exactly, is the U.S. mission in Yemen?
The answers are, as yet, unknown. But what is certain is that more of these missions lie ahead.

Interesting perspective from the people who actually fight wars as opposed to the desk jockeys who report on it. A lot goes into mission planning, and we, the military, ever since Vietnam, has said trust us to know how to plan for and execute the mission. Can't really blame the president for doing what the military has been asking for 50 years or more.
How did all the planning, trust in our leaders, and congressional millions of dollars work out for Vietnam? I'll tell those who care, 55,000 Americans dead and missing. That was the price. WAS IT WORTH IT? Get the fuck out of Iraqnam and Veitghanistan now.
Military Leaders did not run the Vietnam campaign. The White House and various appointees did, having no knowledge of boots on the ground experience, Military planning and tactics, etc. They thought they were smarter than the folks with practical experience. That's why it was such a catastrophe. As to the reasons for being there? Doesn't mean much when your country has dropped you there to do a job and then hamstrings you.
Spike IMO the senior military leaderships was as inept as the civilian leaderships during the Vietnam war.
Westmoreland and that group blew smoke up the presidents ass and he inhaled every bit of it.
From body counts to changing tactics on a regular basis created a total FUBAR for the grunts on the line.
The military was a frickin mess due much in part to the piss poor senior military leadership as we'll as the civilian
An excellent book to read is ''A Bright and Shining Lie,'' John Paul Vann, an American in Vietnam.
Derelection of Duty by McMaster is also a great book about the war.
I'll defer to your knowledge (I'm way too young compared to you.....LOL).
The old saying ''The buck stops here'' is what this is about. You break it, you bought it. Simple as that. Right or wrong that's the way it is.
Intel can and is wrong numerous times. That also is a fact, and the ones that pay the price are the front line participants in the mission.
One only has to review some of the FUBARS of Vietnam...They don't call it the ''Fog of War'' for nothing. If it can go wrong it will.
No one should want to return to the days of the President is picking out bombing targets from the toilet like LBJ did. Unless the President's name is Eisenhower, he shouldn't have any involvement in the tactics of an operation.
Another article that puts a spin on the issue for the purpose of criticizing the former President while giving the new President a pass. The last President took too long to make decisions......boo hoo hoo. I can't believe he actually wanted to make sure things were done right with minimal threat to life. What a complete asshole.
Let's all cheer President Trump for saying yes quickly. It's not his fault that things went bad. I'm just glad he was able to have a nice hot meal and could relax with minimal interruptions from those pesky intelligent briefings.
No sarcasm tag need here. Thanks Pj. I agree.
Don,
I'm surprised at your comment. There are people here who want our President to fail (or seem like he fails) at everything. It's sad to see people choosing partisanship over country.
It's sad to see people choosing partisanship over country.
You are aware of how hypocritical that sounds, correct? This whole false pretense of country first if a load of BS especially when you and your right wing buddies have been putting your party before country starting on the night former President Obama was inaugurated. Save it for the choir. I always love hearing from ex-military. How horrible the Democrats are to them. It's the Democrats who fight to take care of the Vets when they return from serving the country. The Republicans fuck you guys over every single time except when it comes to defense spending and even then it doesn't go to the men and women that serve but to the friends of Republicans in the form of contracts.
All hail President Trump for not choking on his fucking meal after saying yes to the mission.
As this article was written by folks in the Defense Industry, I tend to trust their knowledge level much more than I trust your ability to objectively look at anything, especially things you have no qualifications to judge.
I'm fully qualified to judge them. I have a brain and I have common sense. I don't blindly follow orders without questioning it. Whereas you've been taught to tow the line rather than think for yourself. Let me just say that you tow the line and vomit the talking points very nicely.
Well, you're allowed to think what ever you want about other people, that's the great part about America, no one forces you to stop blathering stupidly. Your comments are a continual reminder of that truth. It's pretty obvious you know virtually nothing of the military, the branches of service (possibly with the exception of noting they were different colored dress uniforms).
Everyone is born with a brain and generally have a modicum of common sense, that doesn't not make them qualified to judge on areas where they have little to no expertise. I suppose you'd be happy to comment and judge a doctor on how he/she repairs an intracranial Hemorrhage. Because you have an opinion, doesn't make it right, especially from a virtual zero knowledge level.
I'm not surprised you would use the doctor analogy. It's the simplest one to throw out there for the simplest of minds. Do you know how many errors doctor's make?
Some of these could be avoided if the patient didn't BLINDLY accept everything the doctor told them. Many times the patient KNOWS the doctor is WRONG but won't say anything.
I believe this is your problem also. You accept what the brass tells you because you're a good little soldier. Don't question authority and don't buck the system. You are part of the problem why so many people accept what our military tells us.
As Gunny said, my father is ex marine so your little BS statements don't worry me in the least and I'll continue to blather as you put it because I'm not fucking brainless. It doesn't matter what fucking color their uniforms are (BTW thanks for the sexist comment) I'm proud of them no matter what they wear.
You don't know enough about me to diagnose anything. Let's see, I'm not a soldier. I never was a soldier. I was an Airman, I served for over 21 years before retiring honorably. In the Air Force, we are taught from Basic Training on to manage at the lowest possible level, which involved thinking for ourselves and figuring out the best way to proceed. This also involves continuing education throughout your career. In the Air Force, you simply cannot become a Senior NCO or an officer without a college degree. You know the military from sitting on your daddy's knee. I know it form actually serving.
As to my comment on the colors of uniforms being sexist? That's one of the sillier things you've said in a while. We all have brains, You might try using yours before the diarrhea of ideas pours out your fingers.
You don't know enough about me to diagnose anything
Vice Versa
I served for over 21 years before retiring honorably
Thank you for your service
I don't blame Trump for this fiasco, I blame his advisors... But then, Trump picked 'em, didn't he? I'm sure he feels terrible about what happened, and had no idea it could go so badly as it did.
I still say that history teaches us that new, incoming presidents should perhaps, ignore all military advisors on their first military operation-- they always seem to go wrong. If someone on the staff is all gung ho, maybe they should listen to their better judgement and just say, "no".
Still, we're lucky we only lost two people-- even though one of them was a child. It could have been a lot worse, I guess. I'm outraged that we lost the two people, ESPECIALLY as one of them was a child. But glad it wasn't worse.
If they were expecting us, who tipped them off? Could Trump have said something to Putin, who put the bug in someone's ear that it was going down? Sheer speculation on my part, but I've always heard that Loose Lips Sink Ships. In his Bro-mance with Putin, could Trump have compromised the operation? That's my question, and that I would be furious about...
Well, intel is good, when it's good, but intel can be a crapshoot also. When intelligence types analyze stuff, they might infer some things because indicators point them that way. Intel goes wrong. Japan's Intel told them our aircraft carriers would be in Port in December of 1941. Thank God they weren't.
False intel is a huge advantage to us, at times... Like the time we leaked that the Island of Midway was having troubles with their desalinization plant, and it wasn't... Or that we were crossing the Channel at Calais, when we weren't... I'm sure the planners did the best they could, but a long-term plan like this is sure to leak, somehow.
And sometimes things go sideways. I don't believe it's Trump's or Obama's advisors. Some times things just turn bad. Things change by the minute, Intel is generally a snapshot in time.
I think some people here have a huge misconception of the Special Operations Community, and how they work. Let me give you some insight.
Forget everything you've seen on TV or at the movies about Spec Ops and their missions, and how they carry them out. There are only one or two movies I have seen in the past 30 years that comes even close to what actually happens in Spec Ops.
There are two incidents in history that define how JSOC operates today. The botched raid to free the hostages in Iran in the 70's, and the invasion of Grenada.
Google Desert One to learn all you need to know about the first incident. What you need to take away from that failed raid is that it was the defining point in the ultimate formation of JSOC. In other words, dedicated resources to Special Operations. Dedicated helicopters, dedicated support staff, dedicated equipment, etc. JSOC is ALMOST it's own branch of the military.
Google Seals and Urgent Fury to learn about the second incident. What you need to take away from that incident is the loss of 4 Seals when they were dropped into the wrong area and drowned. You will also learn that the Seals operations in this conflict was riddled with misinformation, delays, more equipment failures, and command and control problems that contributed to the deaths of these 4 men. What you will learn if you dig deep enough is that JSOC learned from this episode, and now allows for more direct control of missions down to the individual team members. If an operation looks fucked up, the players have a say, and can make changes or even cancel an op if they have serious concerns of the mission.
This was borne out in the raid to kill Bin Ladin. If you read the many books written on the raid, you will learn that there was a serious amount of micro-management from the political side into this mission. And in several cases, the operators called bullshit, and refused several of the plans included in the mission.
JSOC missions are planed mid level, and refined at the operator level. Not at the Pentagon or Secretary or even Presidential level. The planed mission is presented to the chain of command, and it passes up to the level of approval. Questions can be asked, suggestions made. But ultimately, it is the boots on the ground that really have the final say on a mission. If they are not comfortable with the current intel, or conditions, they can postpone, or even cancel an operation.
The armchair generals who want to use this raid to somehow place blame on Trump need to understand that the Operators had the final say. They planned the operation, and could have made changes if the intel was not to their liking. These details will never be known to the public. BUt an understanding of how JSOC operates is paramount to understanding how this mission could have failed.
And Bruce, add the one final part to this political charade.
If the mission had succeeded, no one would have ever heard of it.
The only reason it is a story is cause it failed.
The basic rule of military operations, once the first bullet is fired chuck the written plan out the window. All you have left is objectives and the men and equipment to accomplish your mission. If enough missions are successfully concluded, you might be able to claim the plan worked.
That is entirely the purview of the man on the ground. NOT the man in the office.
The way it has to be.
That is entirely the purview of the man on the ground. NOT the man in the office.
I certainly agree with that!