╌>

The national security threat that Republicans are ignoring

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  randy2  •  11 years ago  •  7 comments

The national security threat that Republicans are ignoring

rampellc.jpg?ts=1402668098006&w=80&h=80

Opinion writer

When it comes to the 2016 Republican presidential primary, the candidates have found two big, fertile policy arenas in which to stake out territory: climate change and national security.

Specifically, presidential hopefuls are scrambling to show who is most aggressive on national security and who is most passive on climate change. The ideal candidate would, presumably, be able to claim both superlatives

But this set of stances is incoherent as a policy platform. Actually its worse than incoherent. Its an oxymoron.

Thats because climate change is a national security issue. You cant credibly claim to be tough on national security and terrorism while simultaneously boasting how unconcerned you are about global warming.

A scientific consensus has found that climate change is real. Its also man-made, and while it cant be unmade, per se, it can be at least minimized. You wouldnt know this from the GOP presidential hopefuls, for whom climate denialism or something close enough to it to amount to the same thing is sadly considered a prerequisite for the nomination. Ted Cruz said that people who are concerned about global warming are the equivalent of the flat-Earthers; Ben Carson argued climate change is fake and also irrelevant . Jeb Bush , Rick Santorum , Marco Rubio and Rand Paul have, at best, equivocated, saying climate change is probably real but maybe not anthropogenic. So, you know, nothing to be done. (In millennial-speak: \_()_/.) Scott Walker has largely avoided the issue, but his record on other environmental policies (including proposed cuts to recycling ) isnt encouraging.

Meanwhile these same candidates including the once-isolationalist Paul have been offering tough, if vague, platitudes about everything they would do to neutralize any security threat to the United States.

But extreme weather high temperatures, droughts, storms, floods is politically destabilizing. It can lead to food and water shortages, mass migrations, destruction of infrastructure, disputes over refugees, pandemics. Sure, it doesnt directly create armed conflict or militia groups, but it can generate the conditions under which these threats are more likely to emerge and thrive. Such prospects are scarier when you consider that many of the parts of the world most vulnerable to climate change are also areas with weak governance and civil unrest. Global warming is, if nothing else, a threat multiplier .

Dont take my word for it; that term threat multiplier comes directly from a recent Defense Department report about climate change. Americas military and intelligence branches and their scientific partners have been analyzing environmental data for decades, under both Democratic and Republican administrations. In 2004 , for example, the Pentagon developed a blueprint to imagine the unthinkable: how a sudden change in the worlds climate might affect national security. Many military reports , task forces , advisory boards and conferences since then have looked at the consequences of more gradual warming and warned in no uncertain terms of the severe threats it poses to the countrys strategic interests around the globe.

And yet, lately, hawkish Republicans have been undermining efforts to assess and confront these risks. Hundreds of state and federal elected officials including Rubio, Paul, Cruz and Walker have signed a No Climate Tax Pledge, modeled after Grover Norquists stultifying anti-tax pledge . Many of their compatriots on Capitol Hill have been hacking away at funding for NASAs earth-science program, the National Science Foundations geosciences program and Energy Department initiatives that support research into new energy sources. Last year, in a party-line vote, the House even passed an amendment prohibiting the Defense Department from using any funds to conduct its anti-fossil fuel climate change agenda, as the summary of the amendment, introduced by Rep.David B. McKinley (R-W.Va.), reads.

This amendment is about prioritizing our national security over ideology, McKinley said, apparently without irony. The amendment died in conference committee.

President Obama underscored why such attitudes are dangerous in his recent commencement address at the U.S. Coast Guard Academy . He also came startlingly close to characterizing climate denialism as treasonous, noting that in other contexts being aware of a security threat and doing nothing would be negligence and a dereliction of duty. The same is true, he said, of climate change. Denying it or refusing to deal with it endangers our national security. It undermines the readiness of our forces, Obama said.

The speech, disappointingly but not surprisingly, was met with mockery by conservatives , particularly those who usually present themselves as tough on national security. Little do these hawks realize that sometimes it helps to have a little green in your feathers.

Source Link


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

The extremes in weather are undeniable and indescribably as normal. Massive, record breaking rain and floods in Texas and Oklahoma. A drought in the entire American Southwest not just California) that shows no sign of letting up and is on it's way to breaking every record since human have been here.

We can argue and argue about what is causing it, but that's just rearranging he deck chairs on the Titanic. The Defense Department knows it's real, that it IS happening and is taking steps to meet this National Security Threat and so should the rest of us.

If you are looking at any of the candidates for President and the ones you look at are climate change deniers, then forget them immediately. Look at ones who know it is happening, not those candidates with their head up their ass or are owned by he big energy companies.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

But extreme weather high temperatures, droughts, storms, floods is politically destabilizing. It can lead to food and water shortages

This is of course alarmist propaganda . In the state of California they can't even admit they are causing their own drought :

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

We are not the only state that produces meat. In fact it is a very minor part of our agriculture. We are a produce state, not a meat state. Look to Texas and Oklahoma, Colorado, Kansas and such for beef production and it seems they have received plenty of water to do it lately. Not California. Here we are about beans and grapes and tomatoes and cabbage and lettuce, etc. There is no way you can point to us with that article.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Sure I can . The problem is excessive in California because the state is a liberal stronghold of greed . They can't accept the limitations that they have and scale back their excessive use of water . That is especially true for beef production [which they should abandon completely ] but also for growing almonds . Not accepting the limits of the environment is the worst kind of greed . Gov J. Brown should be apologizing to the rest of the country for bitching about CO2 when the real problem in that state is greed .

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

That entire post is right wing bullshit. We are scaling back and doing everything we can to conserve water, but it doesn't happen overnight, so back off!

The anti-California movement has no basis to it. They just plain don't like California no matter what. They have no rational reason for it, but many of them wish California was not part of the US or that it was broken up to try to weaken it. I think that most of the anti-California people have never spent any real amount of time here (a year or more) and haven't the slightest idea of what they say about Californian. Move here. Live here. Become part of it. Then I'll listen to your criticism, but without that, what you say is taken with a huge grain of salt because we know most of it is "I hate California for....(pick your hate)" bullshit.

We have become used to the envy.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Climate change most definitely a national security issue or the DOD wouldn't be studying it as much as they have for the last 30 years.

As I have pointed out before, salinity, water temperature, conductivity are all critical elements to be measured and taken into account with respect to underwater sound propagation as has to be applied to submarine and anti-submarine warfare. Even with the best of computer and software systems, underwater detection and tracking is a bitch as subs get evermore quiet. Changes in the worlds oceans due to climate change is very much an issue of national defense.

The effects of climate change in association with aviation is every bit as worrisome when you take into account stealth technology and weapons targeting and tracking. Even the simplest of minds should grasp that aircraft take longer to get off the ground with lower payloads when the air temperature and humidity levels are higher, and lasers are diffused by moisture laden air.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

80% of the states water goes to that produce. Regardless of what the water is being used to produce, a balance must be made. I think it is ironic that CA is telling residents to "tighten their water belt" so to speak while the real water hogs are unaffected.

 
 

Who is online

Dismayed Patriot
Igknorantzruls


93 visitors