Texas Court Refuses To Lift Hold On Obama's Immigration Executive Action
A federal appeals court refused Tuesday to lift a temporary hold on President Barack Obama's executive action that could shield as many as 5 million immigrants illegally living in the U.S. from deportation.
Posted: May 26,2015 2:45 PM EDT
The U.S. Justice Department had asked the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to reverse a Texas judge who agreed to temporarily block the president's plan in February, after 26 states filed a lawsuit alleging Obama's action was unconstitutional. But two out of three judges on a court panel voted to deny the government's request .
It wasn't immediately clear if the government would appeal, either to the full appeals court in New Orleans or to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The states suing to block the plan, led by Texas, argue that Obama acted outside his authority and that the changes would force them to invest more in law enforcement, health care and education. But the White House has said the president acted within his powers to fix a "broken immigration system."
U.S. District Judge Andrew Hanen sided with the states and, from his court in Brownsville, Texas, issued a temporary injunction on Feb. 16 to block the plan from taking effect while the lawsuit works its way through the courts.
Justice Department lawyers sought a stay while they appealed the injunction. They argued that keeping the temporary hold interfered with the Homeland Security Department's ability to protect the U.S. and secure the nation's borders. They also said immigration policy is a domain of the federal government, not the states.
But, in Tuesday's ruling, 5th Circuit judges Jerry Smith and Jennifer Walker Elrod denied the stay, saying in an opinion written by Smith, that the federal government lawyers are unlikely to succeed on the merits of that appeal. Judge Stephen Higginson dissented.
Obama announced the executive action in November, saying lack of action by Congress forced him to make sweeping changes to immigration rules on his own. Republicans said Obama overstepped his presidential authority.
The first of Obama's orders to expand a program that protects young immigrants from deportation if they were brought to the U.S. illegally as children was set to take effect Feb. 18. The other major part, extending deportation protections to parents of U.S. citizens and permanent residents who have been in the country for some years, had been scheduled to begin May 19.
Hanen issued his injunction believing that neither action had taken effect. But the Justice Department later told Hanen that more than 108,000 people had already received three-year reprieves from deportation as well as work permits. Hanen said the federal government had been "misleading," but he declined to sanction the government's attorneys.
The Justice Department has also asked the 5th Circuit to reverse Hanen's overall ruling that sided with the states. A decision on that appeal, which will be argued before the court in July, could take months.
Along with Texas, the states seeking to block Obama's action are Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Kansas, Louisiana, Maine, Michigan, Mississippi, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah, West Virginia and Wisconsin.

The US Circuit Court of Appeals for the Fifth District is not a "Texas court." It's a federal court that sits in Louisiana and its appellate jurisdiction includes Texas.
This case was going to SCOTUS no matter which way the 5th court ruled.
I know the Right Wing folks want Obamas' EA overruled, and I realized they may have grounds to see that happen. But my concern is for the kids that have made their lives here and have grown up as citizens of the USA, IMO, it's totally unfair to uproot them, because they had no choice but to come here with their parents, so they should not be made to suffer.
I just read the court's decision. As the Court pointed out, it might have reached a different decision if this were simply a matter of the Obama administration exercising its discretion to determine which cases to prosecute. But the Obama administration has gone beyond that and conferred "legal presence" status on an entire class of aliens here illegally. Legal presence status, in turn, allows these illegal aliens to obtain benefits at the expense of the states. This is a significant immigration issue and, to me, it would be better to hold off on conferring anything this questionable rather than confer it now and create a lot of confusion later if the court determines that Obama acted illegally. So I agree with both the District judge and appellate court.
I agree. We'll see what the SCOTUS has to say. I have patience and I'm willing to wait.
Of course all of this would be a moot point if Congress got off it's do nothing ass and passed real Immigration Reform. For the last 5 years this has been the most do nothing Congress in modern American history and it looks like they plan to stay that way and just say no, without coming up with any real, serious answers themselves. Instead they just sit on the sidelines and bitch and cry and whine.
And what was to have prevented them from "legally" applying for citizenship like the millions and millions and millions before them who were also illegals and decided not to rely on "others" to do what they should do for themselves?
How they got here is already a moot point. They are already here. They are not going to leave. It is physically impossible to deport them all. What do you suggest doing with them? Mass executions? Genocide?
No. because almost all of them are working and hospital ER's, by law, can not turn anyone away. The idea that they have come here to just use our benefits, such as welfare, is a myth. They come here to work and everyone of them that I know are and are not collecting any taxpayer paid benefits. No welfare. No food stamps. And many of them have been here quite a long time. Many own their own business (with a legal license) and hire other people. They are ingrained in our society and economy. If we managed to magically make them all leave (and that is not going to happen no matter what benefits you cut off, because most of them are not using them anway) our economy would take a major, major hit. It would immediately collapse into a recession that would make 2008 look like a minor correction. Besides many of them have America children who have the right to live here.
Oh and yes, they do do jobs Americans will not do. You'll never get White or Black Americans picking beans or tomatoes or anything like that.
They are not going anywhere, so back to the question, what would you realistically do with them?
The only answer he knows. Why? Because he won't do any work, therefore no one else will.
"Oh and yes, they do do jobs Americans will not do. You'll never get White or Black Americans picking beans or tomatoes or anything like that."
They also cook, make beds and there are a whole lot more crops that need picking across the countries. And as I've said many of them have been here for many years and have children and even grandchildren here who are natural born Americans. With English as there first language and are college graduates doing jobs that Americans would do, like managing banks, practicing medicine and practicing law and even helping to fight our wars. Many of the ones who were naturally born here and are citizens are even going into politics.
And the other ones are not going to leave because this is where many of them grew up after coming across the border as very young children. Saying "show the other eleven million to the door." is easy to say, but they don't want to leave and a mass deportation would be a bloodbath. Tens of thousands (if we were incredibly lucky it would be that small of numbers) on both sides would die. Our troops would be required to kill men, even Americans, who would fight back. Women and children, many of them born Americans would die. It would take the U.S. Military to try (and fail to do) and lay waste to entire sections of major cites and even small towns. The plain and simple fact is that they intend on staying and there is no realistic way to make them leave. Without killing many that don't have the proper papers because we have no places, no jails or prisons to hold them in. And the only way we could afford to build a facility that big, would be to use undocumented workers to do. Then, under the Constitution every one of them have a right to their day in court and force the federal government to prove that they are here illegally. Then there is feeding them, guarding them and healthcare (which we would legally have to provide since they have not been convicted of anything and are presumed innocent.) Besides, we just don't have the manpower to check all of their papers and it would be stopped by the SCOTUS as unfair and a violation of the civil rights of Hispanics whose families have been here since before there was an America. And the many more who are also here legally.
Getting rid of them is physically impossible. The only answer is to tighten up the border even more (even though it is more secure then at anytime in our history). Yes there are plenty of holes, but we would have to build a wall with electrified barbed wire on the top and the would cost hundreds of millions of dollars. And yes, could only be afforded if we hire undocumented workers to build it.
Besides, most of them don't cross the border. They get travel Visas to the US, fly in and then just don't leave. Then, while securing the border using illegal aliens as labor, give them a realistic path to a green card and citizenship and make them taxpaying Americans. We might as well get used to it, because in about 20 years White people will be a minority and not long after that this will be a Hispanic controlled America, even if another one never get's across the border.
I was gonna' make my own original paintings of these and do the dollar amounts in Roman numerals but then I decided to just copy and paste it so that I didn't get accused of making it all up.
Can't win some days.
Just take a look at California. Here's what the President's actions can mean for the Golden State:
According to recent findings from the President's Council of Economic Advisers, these executive actions would grow the U.S. economy by $90 billion to $210 billion over the next ten years. For California, that means:
Check out Texas. Here's what the President's actions can mean for the Lone Star State:
According to recent findings from the President's Council of Economic Advisers, these executive actions would grow the U.S. economy by $90 billion to $210 billion over the next ten years. For Texas, that means:
And Illinois! Here's what the President's actions can mean for the Prairie State:
According to recent findings from the President's Council of Economic Advisers, these executive actions would grow the U.S. economy by $90 billion to $210 billion over the next ten years. For Illinois, that means:
Over the next several months, we will profile one state a week to highlight the local economic benefits of the Presidents immigration actions and to share what this means for local communities in your state. Stay tuned for the other states with the largest populations of children or parents that are eligible temporary relief under the President's actions.
You can learn more about the actions the President took last year and what they mean for America's future here: www.whitehouse.gov/immigration-action
Once located, deport them.
100% impossible. Forget it. Can not be done. Drop it as an idea. It can not happen. I explained why above. It is a fantasy of some, but it is impossible to do. Not without involving the army involved if you want to do it as fast as you can. And do it illegally.
You can't just deport them, they getto have their day in court and the government must PROVE that they are here illegally. That would have to be done 11 million times. It would break our economy to try. And according to the SCOTUS you can not hold onto them for as long as you want. Since they have not be convicted of anything, they have the same rights as any American. 99.9% of them will be given a court date and be released in a few days on their own recognizance. Since there are so many already clogging the courts now, the court date will be years in the future.
Remember, they don't have to prove that they are here legally, the government must prove that they are here illegally. Until it dies in a court, they have the same rights as American citizens in every manner. That's the U.S. Constitution for you.
I know, I saw the "Texas Court" thing and thought, "WTF?". Your're right, it is a Fed Court, I think the reporter wanted to point out the court was in a Texas jurisdiction, because most judges in the south have anti Obama leanings no matter what court they sit on or where the court is located.
Not always!
They (at least many of them) can't stand the fact we have a black president, and they don't want to give Obama any wins.
It's complicated, and at this point it doesn't make any difference. They're here, we let them be here, and we have to figure out a fair and equitable way to deal with them.
Stop thinking they're all accepting benefits and concentrate on finding a fair resolution to the problem.
What' up with that 1st?
Do you head the cheerleader squad, or are you in charge of the peanut gallery?
No bias there ... LMAO !
When an individual or entity GOES ON THE RECORD, THEY SUBJECT THEMSELVES TO SCRUTINY GOING FORWARD.
Righties post any bullshit that floats their boat but not "on the record". And when the bullshit is refuted, righties ignore it and often repeat the same bullshit!
BINGO!!!
It always looks great when you only look at one side of the coin. Do you happen to have the statistics on how much this will strain and affect the entitlement system?
"A boost in productivity from people who COULD pay taxes" The word COULD in this sentence should be your first clue that these statistics are a fairytale.
The second clue is that the "projected" stats came from the same clowns that are pushing the agenda in the first place.
One more time
They're ON THE RECORD They're putting it out there so, if it fails, you can kick their butts!
But to say be a nay-sayer without any corresponding specifics as a counter argument -- all you've got is the Limbaugh-line, "I hope he fails."
Don't just say/hope it won't work put up your numbers and then, down the road, when both sides are on the record, we'll know who was correct or nearly so.
Go for it!
Just take a look at California. Here's what the President's actions can mean for the Golden State:
According to recent findings from the President's Council of Economic Advisers, these executive actions would grow the U.S. economy by $90 billion to $210 billion over the next ten years. For California, that means:
Check out Texas. Here's what the President's actions can mean for the Lone Star State:
According to recent findings from the President's Council of Economic Advisers, these executive actions would grow the U.S. economy by $90 billion to $210 billion over the next ten years. For Texas, that means:
And Illinois! Here's what the President's actions can mean for the Prairie State:
According to recent findings from the President's Council of Economic Advisers, these executive actions would grow the U.S. economy by $90 billion to $210 billion over the next ten years. For Illinois, that means:
Over the next several months, we will profile one state a week to highlight the local economic benefits of the Presidents immigration actions and to share what this means for local communities in your state. Stay tuned for the other states with the largest populations of children or parents that are eligible temporary relief under the President's actions.
You can learn more about the actions the President took last year and what they mean for America's future here: www.whitehouse.gov/immigration-action
Actually
Is the most important part of his post. If we quit attracting them in this manner we wouldn't have this huge Illegal Immigrant/deportation problem in the first place.
The Republicans and their shills lie to you and whip up your xenophobia, etc., and laugh at those who run with the lies.
FULL QUESTION
Is this true?
FULLANSWER
I'll find a more recent article but the facts haven't changed!
And
10 Myths About Immigration
Yeah copied and pasted no one is obligated to read it. Those who do will have some facts.
Oh PLEASE!!!! You know as well as I do that when it turns out these stats are pure BS the asshats that spewed them out will be LONG gone and the little or no repercussions will come of it.
THEY ARE GUESSING. So are you saying if I or someone else throw out some wild ass numbers you will believe them LMAO!
Sorry AMac bout no RESPONSIBLE entity would provide numbers on something that is virtually impossible to provide numbers on. What I CAN do is give you a little bit to chew on as to how this will in-fact stress and affect the entitlement system. Ponder this.
...
________________________________________________________________________
The Fiscal Consequences of Executive Amnesty
President Obamas executive order granting legal status to millions of current illegal immigrants will encourage increased illegal immigration in the future, imposing further costs on taxpayers.
Assuming that 3.97 million illegal immigrants apply for and receive legal status under DAPA, the following fiscal consequences would be likely.
DAPA beneficiaries would immediately receive Social Security numbers and, in most cases, the eventual ability to obtain Social Security and Medicare benefits. The lifetime costs of Social Security and Medicare benefits to DAPA recipients are likely to be around $1.3 trillion (in constant 2010 dollars).
DAPA recipients will be given immediate access to two major cash welfare programs: the refundable Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and the refundable Additional Child Tax Credit (ACTC). Increased EITC and ACTC cash payments to DAPA recipients would be $7.8 billion per year.
DAPA recipients will also be permitted to apply for EITC and ACTC cash benefits retroactively for the last three years. The cost of retroactive benefits could be as much as $23.5 billion.
DAPA-eligible families already receive many means-tested welfare benefits from programs such as Medicaid, the Women Infants and Children (WIC) food program and Food Stamps prior to the Obama executive order. (These benefits
are typically given to illegal immigrant parents on behalf of their U.S. born children.) The average DAPA-eligible family already receives around $6,600 per year in means-tested welfare benefits, prior to Obamas executive action. (The aggregate cost is around $13.4 billion per year.)
The executive order does not make DAPA recipients eligible for Obamacare. However, if DAPA beneficiaries remain legally in the country for the indefinite future, it is likely that subsequent legislation would make them eligible for Obamacare or other federal medical programs. The cost of providing Obamacare to all DAPA-eligible families who lack current insurance would be at least $14 billion per year.
On average, the combined cost of means-tested welfare benefits currently received, the EITC and ACTC cash, and potential Obamacare benefits would come to $17,800 per year per DAPA family. The aggregate cost would be over $35 billion per year.
On the other hand, Obama executive action would encourage DAPA-eligible illegal immigrants to shift from informal off the books employment to formal on the books employment; this would result in an increase in tax payments. Most experts believe that about half of illegal immigrants work off the books. If, instead, all DAPA-eligible individuals were employed on the books, Federal Insurance Contribution Act (FICA) and federal income tax revenues would increase by about $7.2 billion per year.
Nonetheless, the increase in tax revenue would be equaled or outweighed by the increase in EITC and ACTC cash payments. The value of total means-tested welfare benefits received by DAPA-eligible families exceeded the value of FICA and federal income tax payments made by those families before the executive action and will continue to do so after the action as well.
According to my analysis at least 3.97 million current illegal immigrants will be covered by DAPA and eligible for provisional legal status. The actual number could be higher.
The Fiscal Impacts of the Executive Order for the DAPA Population
The executive order creates three immediate fiscal impacts.
1. The 3.97 million illegal immigrants covered by DAPA will be immediately eligible for work authorization and Social Security numbers. Upon receiving a Social Security number, the individual can earn entitlement to future Social Security and Medicare benefits by completing 40 quarters (10 years) of work.
2. The DAPA parents will also become eligible for the refundable EITC and refundable ACTC. These are means-tested welfare programs which provide cash benefits to parents who have no federal income tax liability. The EITC is the largest cash welfare program in the country. Together, the EITC and ACTC can provide up to $7,460 in cash welfare benefits each year for a lower income family with two children.
3. Most experts believe that roughly half of illegal immigrants work on the books and pay Federal Insurance Contribution Act or FICA and income taxes; the other half work off the books and do not pay those taxes. The executive action makes it easier for DAPA recipients to obtain normal on-the-books employment; it also creates an incentive for greater on-the-books employment since such employment will create credit for future Social Security benefits.
Earned Income Tax Credit and Additional Child Tax Credit
The Earned Income Tax Credit is the nations largest means-tested cash welfare program. Although the EITC in some cases reduces federal income taxes owed, its major function is to provide refundable tax credits to low income individuals. A refundable tax credit is simply a cash welfare grant to individuals who have no federal income tax liability. About 15 percent of the total expense of the EITC goes to tax reduction, while 85 percent goes to refundable cash credits. In 2012, 24.3 million individuals received such cash payments from the EITC at a cost of $56.2 billion to the taxpayer.
The structure of the EITC is complex. A married couple with two children receives a cash payment equaling 40 percent of their earned income for earnings up to $13,430. For
earnings between roughly $13,500 and $23,300, the cash payment is fixed at a maximum value of $5,460. As earned income rises above $23,300, the credit is phased down.
Another common misconception is that legal immigrants rarely receive welfare. In reality, legal immigrants receive very high levels of welfare aid. In fact, the highest level of welfare aid of all is received by households headed by legal immigrants without a high school degree. The DAPA population consists of families with children headed by parents with very low average education levels. If DAPA families were given full access to welfare system, receipt of benefits would undoubtedly be very high.
As noted, the average DAPA-eligible family already received some $6,600 means-tested aid before the Presidents executive action. The executive order would give DAPA families access to the refundable EITC and ACTC at an average cost of $3,900 per family. If DAPA families were subsequently given access to Obamacare the added cost would be around $7,300 per family. The total annual benefit package of existing welfare, ACTC, EITC, and Obamacare would come to $17,800 per family. The aggregate annual costs would be over $35 billion. Beyond this there are many other means-tested welfare programs; if DAPA benefiaries become long-term legalized
residents, they are very likely to be given access to these programs through future legislation.
SO let's see...
1.3 TRILLION for SS & medicare
23.5 BILLION for DAPA
7.8 BILLION in EITC and ACTC
23.5 billion for retroactive benefits of EICT and ACTC
13.4 Billion PER YEAR for WIC and SNAP
14 Billion per year for Obamacare
Now let's add this up and put against the BO fairytale stats.
BUT Don't forget to cut the fairytale stats on taxes in half as Most experts believe that roughly half of illegal immigrants work on the books and pay Federal Insurance Contribution Act or FICA and income taxes; the other half work off the books and do not pay those taxes.
All in all this adds up to aprx. TWO TRILLION PER YEAR!!!
LINK
another link
The rest of the story
Where did the bottom part of your post come from? I didn't see it in the linked article did I miss it?
The northern part of the Western Hemisphere is where the jobs and the food and the better living is at. People ARE going to migrate here and there really is nothing anyone can do about it. There have been mass migrations to where the food and better living was throughout human history and there always will be. If humans survive on this earth another 500 years (I strongly doubt it) there will still be mass migrations happening then, though I don't know where (and don't really care because I'll be dead).
If living conditions were better in Central or South American then here, the mass migration would be in that direction and the people already there would not be able to do anything about it either. Humans migrate in huge numbers to where things are better. They always have and they always will and there is no way to stop it.
Alternatively , stop the force of the drug industry cartels in Mexico and people might want to stay in Mexico .
The bottom part was from "So let's see" on down is mine. Full disclosure. My stats are a worst case scenario against your and BO's best case scenario. (and make no mistake that's what your/BO's stats are) The point I am trying to make here goes back to my first comment:
IMO your stats are a BS fairytale and I am trying to show you the dirty side of BO's coin because BO certainly won't. Truth is neither are accurate. Like I said this is best and worse case scenario. That being said if the margin of error is the same in both cases BO's is a losing proposition.
This is where most the stats came from BTW I accidentally closed the page and had a very hard time finding it again. Probably where the "bottom part" came from that you are talking about.
...
Actually the problem is it does not nearly contain enough facts for anyone to form an educated opinion. IT IGNORES ALL NEGATIVE ASPECTS. If you are silly enough to only look at one side of the coin and take it as a win that is your own problem/silliness.
Just out of curiosity, if all the numbers on both sides of the coin came true and it actually ended up costing the country 250+ Billion a year would you still only look at the positive aspects and take it as a win? Again?
Totally agree, Petey; in addition, lock up the Americans who keep those cartels in business as the buyers of their wares!
Or, legalize and tax the drugs -- that of course will hurt the politicians who look the other way while repudiating the sellers and users.
It's one of a number of rigged games.
From Robert Rector Senior Research Fellow The Heritage Foundation.
Check this
That's almost funny!
Like I said. My example is a worse case scenario. The numbers do add up regardless of the source...and let's not forget your source is the one trying as hard as possible to push this through...which would make it at least as biased as mine, if not more. Wouldn't you agree?
This is very true, and the people that already occupy the fertile land always resent the new people, thinking the new people are going to take some of they have, when they should really be seeing that the new people are willing to pitch in and help develop the fertile land so there willactuallybe more for everybody.
Humans will survive, we are a very intelligent and adaptable species, well most of us are intelligent, there are some of you that aren't too bright, but we have to take the good with the bad.
That is true and would be a good thing to do, but the problem is ....How? We can't go into Mexico and Columbia to shut down the cartels, that's the responsibility of those countries governments. But they're not inclined to destroy the cartels because the drug traffic actually contributes the the economy of those countries ...... (not to mention the government officials are paid off.)
So it comes back to .... How?
I say, legalize the drugs and tax the sale and distribution, that will, 1)contributeto our economy aswell as the countries that produce the shit. 2) It will release law enforcement from the responsibility of tracking down the dealers and allow them to concentrate their efforts on other criminal activity, 3) It will reduce the enormous cost of investigating, arresting, processing and incarcerating thousands of non-violent drug dealers.
We have the highest per capita rate if incarceration of all the developed nations in the world. Americans represent roughly only 5% of the worlds population, yet we have 25% of all the worlds incarcerated population. Something is wrong with that picture!
(Btw, it'sencouraging to see Petey Coober post a comment that makes sense and is related to the topic. Thanks Petey.)