SACRAMENTO — Two leaders of the successful referendum to remove Britain from the European Union were recently in California, where they said favorable things about the newest version of a plan to split the state in pieces. As Arron Banks told a British newspaper , “It’s the world’s sixth largest economy, and it’s very badly run.” He isn’t the only person to believe that a breakup may be the best way to solve California’s intractable problems.
Some news reports about the Yes California independence campaign used the term “Calexit,” which makes for good headlines because it sounds like “Brexit,” but it’s confusing. Some left-leaning activists indeed are pushing a far-fetched “Calexit” idea to create a new California nation , something that has gained publicity after Donald Trump’s victory shocked Democratic-dominant California. This Yes California campaign has a ballpark-zero chance of gaining traction. It’s mostly about venting.
While creating a new nation would tear the United States asunder, redrawing state boundaries is nowhere near as unthinkable — or as dangerous — as some suggest.
“We should explore creating more states so we have a democracy that’s closer to the people,” said Scott Baugh, a former Republican assemblyman who met with Mr. Banks and Nigel Farage when they were in Orange County to receive an award. California has nearly 40 million people and is growing. At what point is the population too large for a single state? he wondered in a recent interview. That’s a question Californians have been asking since the early days of the state’s existence.
When a motley crew of American settlers, native-born “Californios” and European immigrants assembled in Monterey in 1849 for a constitutional conventio n, there was wide disagreement about where to put the eastern boundary for the proposed state of California. Some wanted an enormous state that would have encompassed a lot of modern-day Utah.
Since California achieved statehood in 1850, residents have floated dozens of plans to break it up. A proposed 2016 measure to carve it into six states, which did not make it onto the ballot, was initiated by a Silicon Valley entrepreneur, Tim Draper , who also is behind the effort that Mr. Banks and Mr. Farage recommended. News reports suggest his latest plan is to largely split the state east to west, but Mr. Draper told me his idea has no specific boundaries yet.
“We are doing deep research on everything from infrastructure to higher education to safety to water to the electric grid to politics to income levels to health care,” Mr. Draper said.
I’ve flown the State of Jefferson flag at my little ranch, a reminder of a continuing partition movement dating to World War II. Residents of California’s northern counties and Oregon’s southern counties complain that their tiny populations’ concerns get short shrift here in Sacramento and in Salem, Ore. It’s now mainly a California movement to create one separate state in the far north. Some Jefferson backers say it’s basically a cry for help from a region suffering joblessness and an eroding tax base.
As an example, a group of elected sheriffs met in Yreka, Calif., a few years ago, where they vowed to defy rules limiting public access within publicly owned lands. It was an astounding act of frustration at federal and state land-use policies that didn’t consider the concerns of local residents. But their meeting never gained attention in either state capital. These rural areas in the “north state” have watched their timber, fishing and mining industries dry up, and many officials in that region blame environmental policies that are drafted with dense urban areas in mind.
Yreka is the county seat of Siskiyou, which is physically larger than Los Angeles County , but its population of 44,000 is dwarfed by the latter’s 10 million residents. How do residents of a small-population county get their voices heard in a state where one of 58 counties is more populous than 41 other states? For additional perspective, San Bernardino County is larger geographically than New Jersey, Connecticut, Delaware and Rhode Island combined.
And it’s not just a problem in California’s desolate regions. Even Democratic officials in the blue-collar San Joaquin Valley , a four-million-population region where oil-drilling and agriculture are major industries, are often at odds with their party’s priorities. Hard-pressed industrial cities in California such as Fresno and Bakersfield are world’s away from Santa Barbara and Napa Valley. Residents of Orange, San Diego and Riverside counties are often frustrated by the outsize influence of nearby Los Angeles.
Like many Californians, I haven’t embraced any particular proposal, but there’s no reason current boundaries can’t be adjusted to meet the needs of a changing population. Residents of Chico could still visit San Francisco on the weekend, just as I can now travel to Reno, Nev., to play the slots. But a partitioned California — or Texas or Florida, for that matter — could improve millions of people’s chances at self-government. It would also make sense on a federal level given that nearly 40 million Californians are represented by two senators — the same number that represent Wyoming, which has fewer than 600,000 residents.
Some readers may scoff at this seemingly pie-in-the-sky notion, but state boundaries have long been fluid and even illogical . People also thought Brexit was an impossible idea. But state boundaries aren’t sacrosanct. Maybe it’s time to reduce political division by adjusting the political lines.
-----------------------------------
RED RULES apply:
Be polite No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
Be smart and stay on-topic Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic and will be deleted.
-----------------------------------
The topics are: - The advantages and disadvantages in breaking up large states into smaller ones. - The impact on the nation as a whole of moving to "flexible" state boundaries.
- Be polite. No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None! - Be smart and stay on topic. Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic, and will be deleted.
Lots of trees and some good places to grow pot. Also a lot of water. Some of the reasons the State legislature will never vote to let it go and they need that (I believe 3/4ths votes) to happen plus approval from the U.S. Congress. It's not going to happen.
Actually we here get our water from five deep wells owned by the Myoma Water Company which basically just serves Bermuda Dunes. The rest of the desert communities make deals for water sharing and leased land (a large part of Palm Springs is leased Indian land and the lease is going to be up in 2020) with The Morongo Band of Mission Indians and The Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians. We're sort of on the sidelines watching.
Ifind the notion of "water wells belonging to" very distressing. I'm glad no one has figured out how to take possession possession of the air we breathe.
Well, water is a finite resource, and a utility gets a free pass, sort of, as they provide the water for everyone else. Maybe we can all be glad that we don't have to rely on wells on our own property.... What bugs me more is that private companies, like Nestle, wants to supply water for homes. The cost will be astronomical!
I don't mind a collectivity - city or county or whatever - managing water distribution. Butthe idea of a private company owning groundwater is... disgusting.
I don't understand riparian rights, as they apply out west, which is different than it is applied to here in the Midwest.
Basically, here, you "own" the rights to the water beneath your property. If a utility or business dewaters your well, they are bound by law to replace it. It seems to work fairly well here, even though there are times when it has to be enforced.
I once worked for a coal company to investigate a private well that had been drilled by the coal company as a replacement of the supply. The house was on a pad of dirt, sort of a cliff, surrounded on three sides by a coal mine. The 4th side, which was left as a cliff and ridge of land with a road on it, was perched above the strip mine. Because the strip mine had dewatered the well-- removing all the coal removed the formation that supplied the well, the coal company had drilled them a new, much deeper well, but the water in the well was AWFUL. Very high in salt and sodium bicarbonate, (baking soda). It was literally not fit to drink.
The coal company, acknowledging that the water was awful, had given the home owner an osmosis machine that purified 4 quarts of water, every day, for drinking water. But, of course, the water was so bad, the membrane of the machine didn't last beyond a couple of weeks, so the family was trying to use the undrinkable water as their source... It all ended up that the coal mine had to install a cistern and provide them with drinking water, to replace their well. Fortunately, more than 4 quarts of water per day.
I know that out west, the utilities do not want you to contain rain water that falls on your roof and/or driveway, etc., because they need every drop to recharge the aquifer and provide water for everyone. I have a hard time with that, too, but can understand that they are absolutely desperate for additional water. They have been mining the groundwater out there for years, and the time will come when they run out. Water levels in the aquifers are becoming dangerously low-- so it is of critical importance that every drop of rainwater goes to recharge the aquifer.
Fortunately, here, we have plenty of rainwater, even though we may not have the formations that can transmit the water to a well, OR to recharge a deeper aquifer. My advice: Move. If you live in a spot on this earth without water, find another spot. It's only going to get worse.
What bugs me more is that private companies, like Nestle, wants to supply water for homes.
Well out here in the desert the Morongo Band of Mission Indians and the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians have most of the water rights rights and the Morongo Band makes extra money by leasing some of it's water rights to Nestles to bottle water for sale pretty much anywhere Nestles wants to sell it.
There is a difference between a private company and a public utility. Nestle can bottle water without having to meet the federal standards for drinking water, because it is regulated by the FDA, not the EPA. A public utility must follow the standards by the EPA, which are much more stringent, and require a lot of treatment to be pure enough to pipe to homes. Plus, they must add chlorine in order to maintain a (I think) 3 ppm level to all homes.
A public utility has to meet these stringent standards, AND has all the added expenses of maintaining treatment plants, the distribution system, the federal requirements for testing, etc. A public utility is monitored very closely, while a private company is not. Nestle can charge whatever they want for their water, while a public utility has to submit water rates to a watch-dog organization, the Utility Regulatory Commission, who caps the amount they can charge, based on their costs.
If Nestle can find a semi-pure source of supply and doesn't have to run the water through a treatment plant, just bottle it, they have an unfair advantage over a public utility. Which they do anyway, because they don't have maintain the chlorine dose, or meet federal purity standards.
Another thing we're all overlooking, is that water boundaries have absolutely nothing to do with arbitrary political boundaries. Here, at home, Louisville is in at least 4 different watersheds, but politically, it's one county. So, say this one county has a piece of a watershed, and the formations are wonderful-- the county can pump the aquifer and manage to dewater the watershed. So, one county can take all the water from that piece of a good watershed, leaving the rest, which is in another county, without an adequate supply.
Just the water rights and uses, which California somehow manages, would have the state legislature/etc. ding donging around for years. In fact, I could see this one issue, which would destroy a state-wide management plan, as having the capability of stopping anyone from leaving California.
Basically, here, you "own" the rights to the water beneath your property.
That's how it worked when I lived in rural Michigan. Of course in Michigan the water table was so high that most of the state was really sort of floating on fresh water. When I bought my first home about 20 miles inland from Lake Michigan my well was only 20ft deep. I had to have the point pulled because it clogged, so while it was up I had the pipes going into my pump replaced (they were 30 years old, like the house) and told the well man to drop the point down another ten feet just in case because I'd heard there had been an old gas station about two miles away from where I lived. The idea of actually "buying" water was foreign to me. Of course there were expenses like a water softener (and the salt) and a septic tank to worry about, but I knew people who could always help me out with those at costs, just like David the well guy did.
I live in Yuma Arizona, where the Colorado River comes to die.
The mighty Colorado, author of the Grand Canyon, no longer flows to the sea. It irrigates the farms of the Southwest... and the fountains of Las Vegas.
The topics are: - The advantages and disadvantages in breaking up large states into smaller ones. - The impact on the nation as a whole of moving to "flexible" state boundaries.
I think we could probably look to the issues that gerrymandering has caused and maybe apply it to your question. If we break up the larger States we are just dividing ourselves further into areas and people we mostly relate with.
I think maybe it's time should abolish the Country as a whole and divide it up based on party preference.
Gerrymandering. Surely a related topic. OTOH, if we imagine that the whole country was divided equitably, I don't see a resolution to the problem of populated counties and empty counties. Either Los Angeles gets representation that "weighs" 200 times Yreka, or "one man, one vote" is violated.
There's no way that Yreka and Los Angeles can be in the same polity - state or nation - without Yreka getting drowned.
So should we break up the USA? The question is not idle...
Yes, break up the Country. The system currently in place gives too much power to the minority. Now I'm forced to have a president that engages in sexual assault, skipping out on his financial obligations and colluding with the Russians.
- The advantages and disadvantages in breaking up large states into smaller ones.
I believe that chipping away states into smaller entities exposes needs that are not as apparent as the advantages that they create. It kind of reminds me of the difficulties that the EU had during the financial crisis, where the more wealthy countries were demonstrating a bit of reticence when it came time to support their troubled counterparts. The US is more homogeneous an entity. Breaking a state like California apart might create additional bitterness and division in our country.
- The impact on the nation as a whole of moving to "flexible" state boundaries.
Again, we are all Americans, subject to the same set of laws. I understand that state laws vary from state to state, but there is no restriction on moving out of a state that you feel you are disadvantaged in.
I believe that chipping away states into smaller entities exposes needs that are not as apparent as the advantages that they create.
That is undoubtedly true. Yreka county cannot be heard when drowned out by Los Angeles, 200 times more populous. But once they have been heard... should they necessarily be followed? If the rule is "the greatest good for the greatest number"... we will often nod understandingly to Yreka... and then dowhat is needed for Los Angeles.
Breaking a state like California apart might create additional bitterness and division in our country.
I wonder. The divisions within our nation run deep. the will to compromise is almost absent. Is it perhaps time to break the system?
... there is no restriction on moving out of a state that you feel you are disadvantaged in.
True. But people are not really all that mobile. Most people make only one big move in their lives...
Let's imagine the territory of the fifty states, after the next census, divided by a computer program into a thousand compactest-possible districts of equal population. No gerrymandering... on the contrary!
Then let's imagine a unicameral Congress -- one representative per district.
Let's keep it at 50 (a 1000 is too many new state flags and songs and animals and birds, etc., to keep coming up with) and just break the country up into 50 equal population states every ten years. That way they all get 2 Senators and an equal number of Representatives in the House.
Why two Houses? That just dilutes responsibility. If we do fifty districts, then that should mean fifty representatives to a single House. Let's leave no doubt about who is responsible for a given district!
I wouldn't argue about the number of representatives, except to say that these people would have to keep up with an awful lot of topics, so maybe more of them could split the load.
We have to have an upper and lower chamber otherwise the country would be strictly majority rule and that way lies chaos. That's why the turning of the Senate into the House that is happening now is so bad for our country.
simple answer is Bob , each house has different duties and different responsabilities as dictated by the Constitution, the Senate represents the states interests in government , and the house , the peoples interests , and as I have pointed out before , sometimes what is good for one is not good for the other, hense the bi-carmal congress to balance the needs of the people with the needs of the state and it is suppose to foster fruitful compromise , not that there is any lately.
people need to remember what each houses duties , and to whom they are responsible to , the 17th amendment didn't change a senators duties , just how they were placed in office , and people seem to forget that senators do not represent the people in our government , but because its the populous that elects them they think they represent the people , when they don't. once that is understood , its easy to see why there is 2 chambers of congress.
want it changed? it has to be done with a constitutional amendment , that would not pass ratification.
Questioning it is fine, but I'll be damned if I can think of a better way to do it. If I could change one thing I would make the so-called nuclear option in the Senate, not an option on anything. Anything at all. I think even budget reconciliation should require at least a 60% majority. The Senate needs to be the "great cooling saucer" it was intended to be. I wish it was possible to get through a Constitutional Amendment ordering that. We have slipped away from part of what it was intended to be and we will all suffer for it. And no finger pointing please! BOTH parties are guilty in this!
In selecting an appropriate visual symbol of the Senate in its founding period, one might consider an anchor, a fence, or a saucer. Writing to Thomas Jefferson , who had been out of the country during the Constitutional Convention, James Madison explained that the Constitution's framers considered the Senate to be the great "anchor" of the government. To the framers themselves, Madison explained that the Senate would be a "necessary fence" against the "fickleness and passion" that tended to influence the attitudes of the general public and members of the House of Representatives. George Washington is said to have told Jefferson that the framers had created the Senate to "cool" House legislation just as a saucer was used to cool hot tea.
Well the House is where ideas from the people through their Representatives are first debated and voted by popular vote. A simple majority. It is in the Senate, a much smaller body, where these ideas that were sorted through the House come to be more seriously considered. To see if they are, in the opinion of these older people (you have to be older to run for the Senate then for the House) who are serving longer terms and therefore are less driven by re-election and represent the entire state where they come from so they have the whole state as a constituency, more in the best interest of the whole of the nation or not. Then, if the Senate agrees, but that they have made changes they are sent to committee made up of members of both bodies to hammer out any differences. If the Senate passes what comes from the House with no changes then it's on to the President for signature. Having two houses in intended to make it much harder to change laws or implement new ones so they won't be changed or implemented on a whim or just by a simple majority of one House too quickly. The goal is to make it difficult.
You are describing the current system as it (supposedly) works. I'm talking about a more ideal system. Originally, the Senate was imagined as a second Cabinet, giving "advice annd consent" to the President. (There were only twenty-six Senators.)
The current system could hobble along as long as most Congresspersons made an effort to make it work. Now, with a significant portion purposefully sabotaging everything, the system's frailties are flagrant.
Op-Ed by Steven Greenhut - The Opinion Pages / NYT
-------------------------------------
Mark Ralston
Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
SACRAMENTO — Two leaders of the successful referendum to remove Britain from the European Union were recently in California, where they said favorable things about the newest version of a plan to split the state in pieces. As Arron Banks told a British newspaper , “It’s the world’s sixth largest economy, and it’s very badly run.” He isn’t the only person to believe that a breakup may be the best way to solve California’s intractable problems.
Some news reports about the Yes California independence campaign used the term “Calexit,” which makes for good headlines because it sounds like “Brexit,” but it’s confusing. Some left-leaning activists indeed are pushing a far-fetched “Calexit” idea to create a new California nation , something that has gained publicity after Donald Trump’s victory shocked Democratic-dominant California. This Yes California campaign has a ballpark-zero chance of gaining traction. It’s mostly about venting.
While creating a new nation would tear the United States asunder, redrawing state boundaries is nowhere near as unthinkable — or as dangerous — as some suggest.
“We should explore creating more states so we have a democracy that’s closer to the people,” said Scott Baugh, a former Republican assemblyman who met with Mr. Banks and Nigel Farage when they were in Orange County to receive an award. California has nearly 40 million people and is growing. At what point is the population too large for a single state? he wondered in a recent interview. That’s a question Californians have been asking since the early days of the state’s existence.
When a motley crew of American settlers, native-born “Californios” and European immigrants assembled in Monterey in 1849 for a constitutional conventio n, there was wide disagreement about where to put the eastern boundary for the proposed state of California. Some wanted an enormous state that would have encompassed a lot of modern-day Utah.
Since California achieved statehood in 1850, residents have floated dozens of plans to break it up. A proposed 2016 measure to carve it into six states, which did not make it onto the ballot, was initiated by a Silicon Valley entrepreneur, Tim Draper , who also is behind the effort that Mr. Banks and Mr. Farage recommended. News reports suggest his latest plan is to largely split the state east to west, but Mr. Draper told me his idea has no specific boundaries yet.
“We are doing deep research on everything from infrastructure to higher education to safety to water to the electric grid to politics to income levels to health care,” Mr. Draper said.
I’ve flown the State of Jefferson flag at my little ranch, a reminder of a continuing partition movement dating to World War II. Residents of California’s northern counties and Oregon’s southern counties complain that their tiny populations’ concerns get short shrift here in Sacramento and in Salem, Ore. It’s now mainly a California movement to create one separate state in the far north. Some Jefferson backers say it’s basically a cry for help from a region suffering joblessness and an eroding tax base.
As an example, a group of elected sheriffs met in Yreka, Calif., a few years ago, where they vowed to defy rules limiting public access within publicly owned lands. It was an astounding act of frustration at federal and state land-use policies that didn’t consider the concerns of local residents. But their meeting never gained attention in either state capital. These rural areas in the “north state” have watched their timber, fishing and mining industries dry up, and many officials in that region blame environmental policies that are drafted with dense urban areas in mind.
Yreka is the county seat of Siskiyou, which is physically larger than Los Angeles County , but its population of 44,000 is dwarfed by the latter’s 10 million residents. How do residents of a small-population county get their voices heard in a state where one of 58 counties is more populous than 41 other states? For additional perspective, San Bernardino County is larger geographically than New Jersey, Connecticut, Delaware and Rhode Island combined.
And it’s not just a problem in California’s desolate regions. Even Democratic officials in the blue-collar San Joaquin Valley , a four-million-population region where oil-drilling and agriculture are major industries, are often at odds with their party’s priorities. Hard-pressed industrial cities in California such as Fresno and Bakersfield are world’s away from Santa Barbara and Napa Valley. Residents of Orange, San Diego and Riverside counties are often frustrated by the outsize influence of nearby Los Angeles.
Like many Californians, I haven’t embraced any particular proposal, but there’s no reason current boundaries can’t be adjusted to meet the needs of a changing population. Residents of Chico could still visit San Francisco on the weekend, just as I can now travel to Reno, Nev., to play the slots. But a partitioned California — or Texas or Florida, for that matter — could improve millions of people’s chances at self-government. It would also make sense on a federal level given that nearly 40 million Californians are represented by two senators — the same number that represent Wyoming, which has fewer than 600,000 residents.
Some readers may scoff at this seemingly pie-in-the-sky notion, but state boundaries have long been fluid and even illogical . People also thought Brexit was an impossible idea. But state boundaries aren’t sacrosanct. Maybe it’s time to reduce political division by adjusting the political lines.
-----------------------------------
RED RULES apply:
Be polite
No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
Be smart and stay on-topic
Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning.
One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic and will be deleted.
-----------------------------------
The topics are:
- The advantages and disadvantages in breaking up large states into smaller ones.
- The impact on the nation as a whole of moving to "flexible" state boundaries.
RED RULES apply:
- Be polite. No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
- Be smart and stay on topic. Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic, and will be deleted.
Special seed, for XX!
Never happen.
We agree. Not a chance.
I'm heading to CA tomorrow! Maybe I'll slip over to Jefferson and see what it has to offer......
Lots of trees and some good places to grow pot. Also a lot of water. Some of the reasons the State legislature will never vote to let it go and they need that (I believe 3/4ths votes) to happen plus approval from the U.S. Congress. It's not going to happen.
I don't believe California will ever let the northern part of the state leave, if only because they have water-- and the rest of the state is so dry.
Good enough reason for me.
the rest of the state is so dry
You could always take a little bit more from the Colorado River.
...
...
oh, wait
Actually we here get our water from five deep wells owned by the Myoma Water Company which basically just serves Bermuda Dunes. The rest of the desert communities make deals for water sharing and leased land (a large part of Palm Springs is leased Indian land and the lease is going to be up in 2020) with The Morongo Band of Mission Indians and The Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians. We're sort of on the sidelines watching.
Ifind the notion of "water wells belonging to" very distressing. I'm glad no one has figured out how to take possession possession of the air we breathe.
Well, water is a finite resource, and a utility gets a free pass, sort of, as they provide the water for everyone else. Maybe we can all be glad that we don't have to rely on wells on our own property.... What bugs me more is that private companies, like Nestle, wants to supply water for homes. The cost will be astronomical!
I don't mind a collectivity - city or county or whatever - managing water distribution. Butthe idea of a private company owning groundwater is... disgusting.
I don't understand riparian rights, as they apply out west, which is different than it is applied to here in the Midwest.
Basically, here, you "own" the rights to the water beneath your property. If a utility or business dewaters your well, they are bound by law to replace it. It seems to work fairly well here, even though there are times when it has to be enforced.
I once worked for a coal company to investigate a private well that had been drilled by the coal company as a replacement of the supply. The house was on a pad of dirt, sort of a cliff, surrounded on three sides by a coal mine. The 4th side, which was left as a cliff and ridge of land with a road on it, was perched above the strip mine. Because the strip mine had dewatered the well-- removing all the coal removed the formation that supplied the well, the coal company had drilled them a new, much deeper well, but the water in the well was AWFUL. Very high in salt and sodium bicarbonate, (baking soda). It was literally not fit to drink.
The coal company, acknowledging that the water was awful, had given the home owner an osmosis machine that purified 4 quarts of water, every day, for drinking water. But, of course, the water was so bad, the membrane of the machine didn't last beyond a couple of weeks, so the family was trying to use the undrinkable water as their source... It all ended up that the coal mine had to install a cistern and provide them with drinking water, to replace their well. Fortunately, more than 4 quarts of water per day.
I know that out west, the utilities do not want you to contain rain water that falls on your roof and/or driveway, etc., because they need every drop to recharge the aquifer and provide water for everyone. I have a hard time with that, too, but can understand that they are absolutely desperate for additional water. They have been mining the groundwater out there for years, and the time will come when they run out. Water levels in the aquifers are becoming dangerously low-- so it is of critical importance that every drop of rainwater goes to recharge the aquifer.
Fortunately, here, we have plenty of rainwater, even though we may not have the formations that can transmit the water to a well, OR to recharge a deeper aquifer. My advice: Move. If you live in a spot on this earth without water, find another spot. It's only going to get worse.
What bugs me more is that private companies, like Nestle, wants to supply water for homes.
Well out here in the desert the Morongo Band of Mission Indians and the Agua Caliente Band of Cahuilla Indians have most of the water rights rights and the Morongo Band makes extra money by leasing some of it's water rights to Nestles to bottle water for sale pretty much anywhere Nestles wants to sell it.
There is a difference between a private company and a public utility. Nestle can bottle water without having to meet the federal standards for drinking water, because it is regulated by the FDA, not the EPA. A public utility must follow the standards by the EPA, which are much more stringent, and require a lot of treatment to be pure enough to pipe to homes. Plus, they must add chlorine in order to maintain a (I think) 3 ppm level to all homes.
A public utility has to meet these stringent standards, AND has all the added expenses of maintaining treatment plants, the distribution system, the federal requirements for testing, etc. A public utility is monitored very closely, while a private company is not. Nestle can charge whatever they want for their water, while a public utility has to submit water rates to a watch-dog organization, the Utility Regulatory Commission, who caps the amount they can charge, based on their costs.
If Nestle can find a semi-pure source of supply and doesn't have to run the water through a treatment plant, just bottle it, they have an unfair advantage over a public utility. Which they do anyway, because they don't have maintain the chlorine dose, or meet federal purity standards.
Another thing we're all overlooking, is that water boundaries have absolutely nothing to do with arbitrary political boundaries. Here, at home, Louisville is in at least 4 different watersheds, but politically, it's one county. So, say this one county has a piece of a watershed, and the formations are wonderful-- the county can pump the aquifer and manage to dewater the watershed. So, one county can take all the water from that piece of a good watershed, leaving the rest, which is in another county, without an adequate supply.
Just the water rights and uses, which California somehow manages, would have the state legislature/etc. ding donging around for years. In fact, I could see this one issue, which would destroy a state-wide management plan, as having the capability of stopping anyone from leaving California.
And Nestlé is selling our children's water...
Basically, here, you "own" the rights to the water beneath your property.
That's how it worked when I lived in rural Michigan. Of course in Michigan the water table was so high that most of the state was really sort of floating on fresh water. When I bought my first home about 20 miles inland from Lake Michigan my well was only 20ft deep. I had to have the point pulled because it clogged, so while it was up I had the pipes going into my pump replaced (they were 30 years old, like the house) and told the well man to drop the point down another ten feet just in case because I'd heard there had been an old gas station about two miles away from where I lived. The idea of actually "buying" water was foreign to me. Of course there were expenses like a water softener (and the salt) and a septic tank to worry about, but I knew people who could always help me out with those at costs, just like David the well guy did.
I live in Yuma Arizona, where the Colorado River comes to die.
The mighty Colorado, author of the Grand Canyon, no longer flows to the sea. It irrigates the farms of the Southwest... and the fountains of Las Vegas.
Hey people!
The topics are:
- The advantages and disadvantages in breaking up large states into smaller ones.
- The impact on the nation as a whole of moving to "flexible" state boundaries.
I see no advantage to the state of breaking California up into smaller states and I think it would have an overall negative impact on the U.S.
Sorry Bob
I think we could probably look to the issues that gerrymandering has caused and maybe apply it to your question. If we break up the larger States we are just dividing ourselves further into areas and people we mostly relate with.
I think maybe it's time should abolish the Country as a whole and divide it up based on party preference.
Jeez, PJ...
That's a lot of ideas!
Gerrymandering. Surely a related topic. OTOH, if we imagine that the whole country was divided equitably, I don't see a resolution to the problem of populated counties and empty counties. Either Los Angeles gets representation that "weighs" 200 times Yreka, or "one man, one vote" is violated.
There's no way that Yreka and Los Angeles can be in the same polity - state or nation - without Yreka getting drowned.
So should we break up the USA? The question is not idle...
Yes, break up the Country. The system currently in place gives too much power to the minority. Now I'm forced to have a president that engages in sexual assault, skipping out on his financial obligations and colluding with the Russians.
I felt much the same way about Bill.
I wasn't over joyed about Bill either. What does that have to do with the criminal, crook, liar, misogynist, racists currently in office?
- The advantages and disadvantages in breaking up large states into smaller ones.
I believe that chipping away states into smaller entities exposes needs that are not as apparent as the advantages that they create. It kind of reminds me of the difficulties that the EU had during the financial crisis, where the more wealthy countries were demonstrating a bit of reticence when it came time to support their troubled counterparts. The US is more homogeneous an entity. Breaking a state like California apart might create additional bitterness and division in our country.
- The impact on the nation as a whole of moving to "flexible" state boundaries.
Again, we are all Americans, subject to the same set of laws. I understand that state laws vary from state to state, but there is no restriction on moving out of a state that you feel you are disadvantaged in.
I believe that chipping away states into smaller entities exposes needs that are not as apparent as the advantages that they create.
That is undoubtedly true. Yreka county cannot be heard when drowned out by Los Angeles, 200 times more populous. But once they have been heard... should they necessarily be followed? If the rule is "the greatest good for the greatest number"... we will often nod understandingly to Yreka... and then do what is needed for Los Angeles.
Breaking a state like California apart might create additional bitterness and division in our country.
I wonder. The divisions within our nation run deep. the will to compromise is almost absent. Is it perhaps time to break the system?
... there is no restriction on moving out of a state that you feel you are disadvantaged in.
True. But people are not really all that mobile. Most people make only one big move in their lives...
Let's imagine the territory of the fifty states, after the next census, divided by a computer program into a thousand compactest-possible districts of equal population. No gerrymandering... on the contrary!
Then let's imagine a unicameral Congress -- one representative per district.
Let's keep it at 50 (a 1000 is too many new state flags and songs and animals and birds, etc., to keep coming up with) and just break the country up into 50 equal population states every ten years. That way they all get 2 Senators and an equal number of Representatives in the House.
Why two Houses? That just dilutes responsibility. If we do fifty districts, then that should mean fifty representatives to a single House. Let's leave no doubt about who is responsible for a given district!
I wouldn't argue about the number of representatives, except to say that these people would have to keep up with an awful lot of topics, so maybe more of them could split the load.
We have to have an upper and lower chamber otherwise the country would be strictly majority rule and that way lies chaos. That's why the turning of the Senate into the House that is happening now is so bad for our country.
that way lies chaos
Why?
IMNAAHO, the safeguard against mob stupidity is in maximizing individual and collective rights, not in diminishing democracy.
simple answer is Bob , each house has different duties and different responsabilities as dictated by the Constitution, the Senate represents the states interests in government , and the house , the peoples interests , and as I have pointed out before , sometimes what is good for one is not good for the other, hense the bi-carmal congress to balance the needs of the people with the needs of the state and it is suppose to foster fruitful compromise , not that there is any lately.
people need to remember what each houses duties , and to whom they are responsible to , the 17th amendment didn't change a senators duties , just how they were placed in office , and people seem to forget that senators do not represent the people in our government , but because its the populous that elects them they think they represent the people , when they don't. once that is understood , its easy to see why there is 2 chambers of congress.
want it changed? it has to be done with a constitutional amendment , that would not pass ratification.
I understand all that, Mark.
It isn't a very democratic system.
Its existence was justifiable as long as the system worked effectively. Now, it is no longer effective. I think it is time to question the system...
Questioning it is fine, but I'll be damned if I can think of a better way to do it. If I could change one thing I would make the so-called nuclear option in the Senate, not an option on anything. Anything at all. I think even budget reconciliation should require at least a 60% majority. The Senate needs to be the "great cooling saucer" it was intended to be. I wish it was possible to get through a Constitutional Amendment ordering that. We have slipped away from part of what it was intended to be and we will all suffer for it. And no finger pointing please! BOTH parties are guilty in this!
In selecting an appropriate visual symbol of the Senate in its founding period, one might consider an anchor, a fence, or a saucer. Writing to Thomas Jefferson , who had been out of the country during the Constitutional Convention, James Madison explained that the Constitution's framers considered the Senate to be the great "anchor" of the government. To the framers themselves, Madison explained that the Senate would be a "necessary fence" against the "fickleness and passion" that tended to influence the attitudes of the general public and members of the House of Representatives. George Washington is said to have told Jefferson that the framers had created the Senate to "cool" House legislation just as a saucer was used to cool hot tea.
I agree on the idea of requiring supermajorities for some votes... but that doesn't imply two chambers.
Well the House is where ideas from the people through their Representatives are first debated and voted by popular vote. A simple majority. It is in the Senate, a much smaller body, where these ideas that were sorted through the House come to be more seriously considered. To see if they are, in the opinion of these older people (you have to be older to run for the Senate then for the House) who are serving longer terms and therefore are less driven by re-election and represent the entire state where they come from so they have the whole state as a constituency, more in the best interest of the whole of the nation or not. Then, if the Senate agrees, but that they have made changes they are sent to committee made up of members of both bodies to hammer out any differences. If the Senate passes what comes from the House with no changes then it's on to the President for signature. Having two houses in intended to make it much harder to change laws or implement new ones so they won't be changed or implemented on a whim or just by a simple majority of one House too quickly. The goal is to make it difficult.
You are describing the current system as it (supposedly) works. I'm talking about a more ideal system. Originally, the Senate was imagined as a second Cabinet, giving "advice annd consent" to the President. (There were only twenty-six Senators.)
The current system could hobble along as long as most Congresspersons made an effort to make it work. Now, with a significant portion purposefully sabotaging everything, the system's frailties are flagrant.